EPTOn October 21 2012 23:35 marvellosity wrote:
If you weren't to lynch drazak, who would your top suspect be?
If you weren't to lynch drazak, who would your top suspect be?
V7
GSL Mini Mafia III - Page 12
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
V7 | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On October 21 2012 23:36 DarthPunk wrote: Really? I think voting for someone you think is town is a lynchable offense, The only reason that he is not getting lynched is that he is new and people are giving him the benefit of the doubt IMO. I think Drazak is scum. I am not sure Keir is. Right, but kush has done similar things as town, and drazak is just as 'new'. The point austin made was that why would scum, in the space of one post, say that he doesn't think someone is mafia and then vote for them (or affirm it, I forget which). Like, if you're going to avoid ONE thing as scum, it's shit like that. | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
On October 21 2012 23:40 marvellosity wrote: Right, but kush has done similar things as town, and drazak is just as 'new'. The point austin made was that why would scum, in the space of one post, say that he doesn't think someone is mafia and then vote for them (or affirm it, I forget which). Like, if you're going to avoid ONE thing as scum, it's shit like that. So it is too scummy to be scummy?I look at it this way. Would a townie be more likely to park a vote on someone he thinks he is town for 24 hours? Or would scum? Townie cares if there is a mislynch. Scum do not. At a basic level drazaks posting fits very well with the natural instincts fo scum. Arguments like Too scummy to be scummy. Too obvious etc. don't convince me all that much because a scum motive fits drazaks posting this game far better than a town motive. Like I don't see how a rational townie would have posted like that. But I can see a scum posting that stuff VERY easily. Also this is not the same as Kush because he is Blatantly townie even when he slips all the time as town. Drazak idoes not look clearly town despite his 'slips'. He is scummy as shit AND he 'slipped'. | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
| ||
|
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
The bit I'm referring you is last game you using the "omg you are scum trying to pull a mislynch" argument you were using as a defense On October 21 2012 23:33 DarthPunk wrote: Everyone is acting weird this game tho. Marv afk for two days. Hapa not really scumhunting and making mainly town reads that I am not sure are entirely rational based on the information available. Austin attacking logic rather than motive than finding everyone who did the same suspicious ZB looking alot closer to his scum meta thatn his town meta. Not enough yet for a real push on any of them. But this is a strange game. Yea, if it's because of activity, then refer to my first post. I was doing the same thing you were and taking a break, but I couldn't refuse a damn invite, so right now I'm trying to balance this out with RL. I'm pretty fucking townie though, so :/ Also, you still think drazak is scum despite what some people have said? Main reason you find him scum is: "he thinks I'm town and yet still voted for me, correct?" | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On October 21 2012 23:51 DarthPunk wrote: Like I don't see how a rational townie would have posted like that. But I can see a scum posting that stuff VERY easily. How does a rational scum post that he wants to kill someone who isn't mafia either? Sense makes not it does not sense make. If you want me to vote drazak, you're going to have to show me how what he's doing is speficically scummy and not just bad town. That voting thing is not it. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
| ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
On October 21 2012 23:56 Z-BosoN wrote: @DarthPunk The bit I'm referring you is last game you using the "omg you are scum trying to pull a mislynch" argument you were using as a defense Yea, if it's because of activity, then refer to my first post. I was doing the same thing you were and taking a break, but I couldn't refuse a damn invite, so right now I'm trying to balance this out with RL. I'm pretty fucking townie though, so :/ Also, you still think drazak is scum despite what some people have said? Main reason you find him scum is: "he thinks I'm town and yet still voted for me, correct?" Yeah. I was going to take a break too but Invite OP. It is like a less refined version of what I did to you last game. (god that was fun BTW) there is no main thing about draz there are a multitude of things that I find scummy. Which I have mentioned several times, I don't like to excuse him because it is 'too scummy' and he is new. Things are scummy because they are the natural inclinations of people with a scum mindset. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
| ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
 Just read through his filter and it seemed honest and sincere. I'm still leaning on the town side for him. | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
On October 22 2012 00:00 marvellosity wrote: DP, you realise drazak has a current TL Mafia record of being mislynched Day 1 twice out of 2? As a townie he clearly does not do a sterling job of being townie. How does a rational scum post that he wants to kill someone who isn't mafia either? Sense makes not it does not sense make. If you want me to vote drazak, you're going to have to show me how what he's doing is speficically scummy and not just bad town. That voting thing is not it. How does a rational townie post that? He doesn't. But it is a product of a scummy mindset. How about this. He fllip flopped on the actual reason for his vote depending on the climate of the thread. (clearly cared more about how his vote could be rationalised later than having a clear and consistent reason for making the vote in the first place) He expressed nervousness about voting for a scum read. (scum would be nervous, town are out for blood. If they are scum you want to lynch them) He stated that he wanted to stimulate discussion by pressuring me. Yet I was the most active at that stage and he has contributed very little. He has not contributed a scum read or scum hunted. Despite stating he was considering who to 'pressure' next. | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
On October 22 2012 00:05 marvellosity wrote: DP, is it your natural inclination, as scum, to say "let's lynch a townie!"? Or is your natural inclination to avoid saying anything like that at all costs? It is my natural inclination to want to lynch a townie because this ensures your survival for another day. VE knows this. That's why he looks at people who jump on a wagon like Draz did very closely. I even fell for it last game. | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
On October 22 2012 00:08 marvellosity wrote: Anyway, this whole conversation is boring Just read through his filter and it seemed honest and sincere. I'm still leaning on the town side for him. I have read it. It seemed the opposite to me. Weird. | ||
|
austinmcc
United States6737 Posts
On October 22 2012 00:13 DarthPunk wrote: It is my natural inclination to want to lynch a townie because this ensures your survival for another day. VE knows this. That's why he looks at people who jump on a wagon like Draz did very closely. I even fell for it last game. It's your natural inclination to want to lynch a townie. Yes. It is NOT normal for you to say "Let's lynch a townie." There's a huge difference. You say, "This guy (and I don't want to tell you this, but he's totes town) looks scummy for x and y, I think we should vote him." You do not go, "Attention town, I think this guy is townie, let's lynch him." The vote on someone you explicitly say doesn't feel scummy is NOT good townie play. But it's NOT good scum play. Again, look at it from both sides. It's not that the vote makes no sense from a townie, it's that the vote makes no sense from either alignment. Therefore, you can't get a read off it; it's null. | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
| ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
That said, I do want to hear more from drazak about who he thinks is scum today. I really wanna know where he's going and what he's thinking now so I can develop my read on him. | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
Please would you start being more obscure and absent. I wish to have my customary scumread on you. Sincerely, marvelbabe | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
On October 22 2012 00:17 austinmcc wrote: It's your natural inclination to want to lynch a townie. Yes. It is NOT normal for you to say "Let's lynch a townie." There's a huge difference. You say, "This guy (and I don't want to tell you this, but he's totes town) looks scummy for x and y, I think we should vote him." You do not go, "Attention town, I think this guy is townie, let's lynch him." The vote on someone you explicitly say doesn't feel scummy is NOT good townie play. But it's NOT good scum play. Again, look at it from both sides. It's not that the vote makes no sense from a townie, it's that the vote makes no sense from either alignment. Therefore, you can't get a read off it; it's null. LOL. do you think he meant to contradict say that in that post? I don;t think anyone in their right mind would mean to say that as either alignment. This is why I feel it speaks volumes of his mindset and that when you look at his mindset in light of that post it is only rational as scum. It makes no sense if you were Aware you were saying it as scum or town. But it makes perfect sense if it just came out subconsciously as scum. And don;t try and tell me that scum never leave subconscious tells like that. Especially newer scum. | ||
|
austinmcc
United States6737 Posts
On October 22 2012 00:21 marvellosity wrote: Dear austin, Please would you start being more obscure and absent. I wish to have my customary scumread on you. Sincerely, marvelbabe It's worrying me too. I had started to find you scummy in LC because you hadn't said I was scummy and disinterested, until you finally did later in the day. | ||
|
DarthPunk
Australia10857 Posts
| ||
| ||
