Liquid City Mafia - Page 3
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
| ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
| ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
Fine, marv. You are a cute and snuggly wisp of life | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
On October 03 2012 08:10 marvellosity wrote: Had a quick peek at the playerlist out of curiosity. Seeing syllogism lynched day 2 was a bit of a shock to my system, heh Also, lol @ the irony Poor marv | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
| ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
I have trouble believing this. Why on earth would anyone protect you? | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
Here's to never taking him seriously ever again | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
On October 04 2012 00:59 Coagulation wrote: lol butt hurt townie detected. You will be ok big boy walk it off. How do you know I'm townie, sir? | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
On October 04 2012 01:07 Coagulation wrote: Is the bandwagon because of risen dropping a massive wifom bomb before he died? Like... really? When im scum I always shoot the stupid fucker saying "IF I DIE KILL THIS TOWNIE" cause of idiot bandwagons like this. throw all that out the window cause marv starts playing scummy as fuck in response to the pressure so whatever. lololololol there there On October 03 2012 22:24 marvellosity wrote: Risen protected me and his role is that if he protects mafia he dies | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
On October 04 2012 01:12 Coagulation wrote: RUKIDDING? you all bent out of shape and huffing and puffing over me like your holding a most fucking unbearable indignation and personal vandeta against me for calling you scum earlier. LOL I see this shit every game. A bit defensive are we? Visceraeyes once told me that scum got all defensive when called out. That must mean you are scum. Plus, marv told me to shhhhhh that must mean that he didn't want everyone to know you are scum. Sup scum | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
On October 04 2012 01:14 austinmcc wrote: Because I'm town? Because they think I'm town? Because I put a bunch of work into this game N1? Because they agreed with my reads? Because their role is austinmcc-protector? Because they loved the play I wrote? I dunno, ask them. Them, please tell me why austin would come even close to being a good medic save? No, but seriously. You were being pegged as scum. Hard to think scum would choose to shoot you over someone else. Even harder to think that a medic would have saved you. The only plausible reason someone could have "saved" you were if they jailed you. Are you sure you got hit or did you just get saved? Because if you got hit, the only plausible explanation is that a vig shot you AND a jk protected you. Other than that, scum is feeling super confident and deciding to eliminate the most scummy looking players. | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
| ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
On October 04 2012 05:02 BloodyC0bbler wrote: Given that no one has claimed any of the shots on the dead players, (ie no one is claiming vig) We know we have two dead vanilla's, shots on me and austin, and risen raped himself while giving us marv. We know we have mafia, and 1 third party based on setup, so 4 kp appearing isn't that unlikely I think. My issue is not the amount of kp. My issue is there being 3 medics. The claims all indicate that there is 3 medics, and not only that, but one of them decided to actually save austin, and not only that, but someone actually decided to shoot austin. Austin. Who was under some scrutiny on day 1. Austin. Seriously? Either that or he's lying. | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
On October 04 2012 06:06 kushm4sta wrote: austin has made some good posts IMO look at his filter. No, he's made long posts you were too lazy to read. Regardless, he was also a lynch candidate. | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
I mentioned Node because I agreed with him. Actually im jk. I mention all of my scum friends and agree with them. Go write plays, it suits you better. | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
I think he claimed RB because he did, in fact, get RB and doesn't want an angry roleblocker on his ass. So, we got 2 vigi shots, and 2 mafia shots accounted for? mafia on BC and ... austin? and vigis on kingjames01 and annul. If that's correct, probably all shots went through and my VE got roleblocked and thus didn't kill supposition is wrong. Unless... austin is lying just so the angry roleblocker doesn't push VE or whoever else might have gotten roleblock as well? Hm... Carry on | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
On October 04 2012 11:32 ToutEstChaos wrote: Extremely cool, because it means you're scum. ShiaoPi is an analytical player whose ability to post cases isn't great, but he thinks a lot about the game and reads the thread extensively. Even for a normal player, though, the kind of slip-up ShiaoPi made is unusual-- it means that at the time he made this post, he hadn't extensively read the thread since the day-post, or hadn't thought about it clearly. This is not useful to town and not what ShiaoPi or anyone does. His statement: isn't unusually stupid or anything-- but it doesn't follow a pattern of logic a townie would use. When he speculates about the night kills (showing a night-oriented mindset), he thinks mafia has 3 KP. Even if this is reasonable, it's set-up speculation on D2, and it's not pushing us in the right direction. I didn't get totally on him because I wanted to see what he'd do after the FoS, and that was this: Although I give ShiaoPi credit for writing something, overall this is bad. Assuming, for example, that because mkfuba07 and marvellosity posted similar things at similar times they are scum together, is like super bad. Sure, maybe they were talking about it in their scum QT together and happened to post at the same time, but that sort of interaction in scum QTs (in my experience) typically delineates explicitly who will say what. Townies (or a townie and a scum) often say shit at the same time that means the same thing. Think about it: how many times have you been "ninjaed" in a mafia game by someone and one of you was town? The next it of ShiaoPi's case rests on the fact that mkfuba changed his mind a few times without making a huge amount of sense. He said this is "confusing town", but really, anyone who's played with mkfuba (and similarly incompetent players) know that this is in fact "confused townie". One part of ShiaoPi's case does in fact point out scummy stuff that mkfuba does: his node read is inconsistent later on, and he pushes it half-heartedly. This is fair point, and also the right point to end a case on if the other points are weak, made up crap that scum use to fluff out their post count. Granted, it's also chronologically the last point so it makes sense to go there, but the fact of the matter is, it is what it is. This line in particular jumps out at me as poor reasoning: >fuba was more or less following marv during day 1 play, This is not what scum does to other scum. Come on, you've all played scum. This wasn't a scum fuba following scum marv. Look at Marv's previous scumgames. He wouldn't let shit like that happen. This is a scared town fuba in a big game deciding to attach his lips to the ass of the strongest, biggest, most familiar vet he could find: Marv. ShiaoPi, you continue to fail to impress, and since I've called you out you've posted even less. Unless you want to be vigied at best you should respond properly to this ##FoS This seems pretty legit. I've played with shiaopi in LVII and it was a totally different ball game. He was low and quiet during most of the game and finished it with brilliant dead-on reads. I agree with our french (smurf?) friend that his line of reasoning is extremely weak and forced compared to his LVII play. | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
On October 04 2012 11:54 BloodyC0bbler wrote: Er? Its scummy thing to recheck / review? I don't do that ever unless I am town making some epic post by post analysis. I think he could easily be mafia given his interactions with people, his odd post that he just made This may just be the living up in a household with a mother who is an english major, but using the word "so" as he did seems weird to me. However throwing ones thoughts into the thread mean near jackshit when you look at the last three pages of his filter have been basically none useful. I don't see solid reasoning for reads, I see summarizing of other peoples shit, spam, and the same. I honestly believe if someone is active like he has been this game there should be real content in his filter, and honestly I am not seeing it. That's him as townie, and that's him as scum. Unfortunately it's either vig or policy lynch for him. I think he fits his town meta a bit more then his scum meta, but I could be wrong here. Would be nice if someone who's played witih him, such as kreb (I think?) could attest to this. | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
On October 04 2012 12:09 DarthPunk wrote: Up to Page 48. I am pretty bummed marv decided to Troll/WIFOM/Shit up the thread so badly. It makes this much more arduous a task. Sup! It's like you are back from the dead. He's playing to his wincon =/ How's mkfuba looking compared to his XXIV? | ||
Z-BosoN
Brazil2590 Posts
I've noted some discrepancies in mr. Sloosh's play here. Let's do this. First thing he says: On October 01 2012 06:15 slOosh wrote: This is the most upsetting start to a game I've played. So I'm gonna lay some ground rules because people are playing in a way that they shirk responsibilities with their actions / words. Biggest thing is stop saying "I wanna lynch player X what do you think?". There is no back up analysis, and it allows people to toss out names at random. You think someone is scum, back it up. Don't say "seems scummy maybe". It lets people sow seeds of suspicion and it makes mislynches more untraceable. Shady's vote makes no sense as VE pointed out. In fact the whole thing doesn't make sense, including how he has already started making connective tells on Kush based on Z-Boson. But it seems just as explainable by a combination of poor play / leftover emotions from TL-LVII. I'd wait to see what he can produce (case wise or whatnot) since arguing whether acting like a troll to incite a mod warning isn't conclusive to determining alignment. VE I don't see your issue with annul - or are you doing one of those reaction things because its leaning on the destructive side right now. He seems rather confident in this post. He wants people to be assertive about their reads. However, this later comes out as an extremely fluffy "I care about town" post, because look at his next post. On October 02 2012 12:33 slOosh wrote: Guh didn't realize how much time I actually take to read. Between Node and Shady Sands I'm leaning Shady. With a total lack of follow through after his troll antics, he has disrupted early day discussion and dropped off. Not lynching him today on the basis of a potential modkill is stupid - he could easily trade his life for hurting day 2 discussion as well and he might not even be lynched. The nature of the Node lynch is really strange. Reason enough to lean the former. ##Vote: Shady Sands I see this as extremely dull, compared to the tone he set in the introduction post. I'd rather lynch him then him, this feels weird, etc... I don't buy his explanation. This goes on to repeat itself: On October 02 2012 12:49 slOosh wrote: Node is scummy. I think what you found about his post was valid. However we can only lynch 1 at a time and I find Shady a better target for the reasons I stated. The strangeness of Node's lynch was that there was a disconnect between the push and the votes - you tossed out a bunch of names and his was just picked up. It's enough to sway me to Shady. While he gives a brief description later in the post as to why he's agreeing, this seems like a pathetic excuse to lynch Shady. "Node's lynch was strange, he is scummy, and that makes me want to lynch Shady". I can just not be seeing it, but please clarify what the hell are your reasons for voting shady. Regardless, this is also a rather weak tone. The rest of his game, however, seems consistent with his original view. I just find this slight break in it rather weird. Especially when we contrast this to him in [url = http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=361826&user=53783]LVII[/url]. Even though he was 3rd party, he was a pretty freakin townie one. His reads were much more assertive and he didn't fret with "I feel this" or "I feel that". I've noted some differences in his play and his initial post seemed like an uncharacteristic fluff. For those of you who have played with him, how does his play so far compare? | ||
| ||