|
On October 10 2012 21:59 Mattchew wrote:
honestly? look at the last 3 days (i honestly thought i voted hapa) but theres been no real necessary discussion. lynch marv, hapa, kush. We aren't lynching off analysis or discussion, we are lynching off of roles and setup ish.
Are you trying to say you dont see the benefits of keeping the discussion active?
|
just because i am not concerned does this not make me a citizen?!
but srsly has anything posted other than ve's claim been useful?
and sloosh is clearly scum trying to earlier push the BC 3rd party lynch
|
You've responded to nothing I said, you're just trying to hide behind other factors. You get one more try.
|
On October 10 2012 22:38 Mattchew wrote:
just because i am not concerned does this not make me a citizen?!
but srsly has anything posted other than ve's claim been useful?
and sloosh is clearly scum trying to earlier push the BC 3rd party lynch
Then make a case on sloosh if it is so clearly there.
I thought you said there was nothing to discuss?
|
On October 10 2012 22:28 Kreb wrote:Show nested quote +On October 10 2012 21:59 Mattchew wrote:
honestly? look at the last 3 days (i honestly thought i voted hapa) but theres been no real necessary discussion. lynch marv, hapa, kush. We aren't lynching off analysis or discussion, we are lynching off of roles and setup ish. Are you trying to say you dont see the benefits of keeping the discussion active?
i see the benefits, i don't think you see how unrealistic and hard it is to get real discussion going when the biggest threat is the mighty feared FOS
|
On October 10 2012 22:47 Mattchew wrote:Show nested quote +On October 10 2012 22:28 Kreb wrote:On October 10 2012 21:59 Mattchew wrote:
honestly? look at the last 3 days (i honestly thought i voted hapa) but theres been no real necessary discussion. lynch marv, hapa, kush. We aren't lynching off analysis or discussion, we are lynching off of roles and setup ish. Are you trying to say you dont see the benefits of keeping the discussion active? i see the benefits, i don't think you see how unrealistic and hard it is to get real discussion going when the biggest threat is the mighty feared FOS
he is quite right. how about you don't lynch me and lynch someone else...that is a good option imo.
BTW why did VE reveal so early? he didn't even fight for the lynch to keep his roll a secret. Revealing this early, ad mattchew pointed out, stiffles discussion.
|
On October 10 2012 22:47 Mattchew wrote:Show nested quote +On October 10 2012 22:28 Kreb wrote:On October 10 2012 21:59 Mattchew wrote:
honestly? look at the last 3 days (i honestly thought i voted hapa) but theres been no real necessary discussion. lynch marv, hapa, kush. We aren't lynching off analysis or discussion, we are lynching off of roles and setup ish. Are you trying to say you dont see the benefits of keeping the discussion active? i see the benefits, i don't think you see how unrealistic and hard it is to get real discussion going when the biggest threat is the mighty feared FOS
lol
|
On October 11 2012 00:00 kushm4sta wrote:Show nested quote +On October 10 2012 22:47 Mattchew wrote:On October 10 2012 22:28 Kreb wrote:On October 10 2012 21:59 Mattchew wrote:
honestly? look at the last 3 days (i honestly thought i voted hapa) but theres been no real necessary discussion. lynch marv, hapa, kush. We aren't lynching off analysis or discussion, we are lynching off of roles and setup ish. Are you trying to say you dont see the benefits of keeping the discussion active? i see the benefits, i don't think you see how unrealistic and hard it is to get real discussion going when the biggest threat is the mighty feared FOS he is quite right. how about you don't lynch me and lynch someone else...that is a good option imo. BTW why did VE reveal so early? he didn't even fight for the lynch to keep his roll a secret. Revealing this early, ad mattchew pointed out, stiffles discussion.
Stiffles discussion? He's done nothing but promote discussion since his claim. He not only continued to push you and make sure you die, but hes also been jumping on z-boson. We have players calling out mattchew, we have people still commenting on me and sloosh. I would actually say his reveal has prompted MORE discussion given that till his claim near the only talk in thread was on me and sloosh.
Revealing as he did actually ensured the day wasn't wasted and he coming out in the last 12 hours and busting out a dt claim no one would believe as it would come off as him desperately trying to get you lynched and bsing reasons. By claiming when he did showed everyone exactly why he was gunning for you so hard when the concensus was you were retarded and not scum.
|
On October 10 2012 22:47 Mattchew wrote:Show nested quote +On October 10 2012 22:28 Kreb wrote:On October 10 2012 21:59 Mattchew wrote:
honestly? look at the last 3 days (i honestly thought i voted hapa) but theres been no real necessary discussion. lynch marv, hapa, kush. We aren't lynching off analysis or discussion, we are lynching off of roles and setup ish. Are you trying to say you dont see the benefits of keeping the discussion active? i see the benefits, i don't think you see how unrealistic and hard it is to get real discussion going when the biggest threat is the mighty feared FOS
You haven't done fuck all in 4 game days. You have been called out EACH DAY for said behavior and this is one of your reasonings for not doing shit? You are better then this.
|
VE has stifled other people's discussion i meant.
but yeah he has been pretty good recently.
|
Thanks BC for that I'll write a case before the end of the night
|
On October 10 2012 16:15 VisceraEyes wrote:
The point is that you jumped off of Node resulting in the lynch of your townread. He might have been lynched anyway based on the voting rules, but a vote for Node put Shady one step closer to safety rather than damning him inexorably to the noose. *shrug*
kushm4sta, ZBoson
I know I said the focus on the BC thing was a bad idea, but I've been thinking about it and the whole Mementoss/BC thing is...strange. On the one hand I can't understand Mementoss' assumption that BC is third party - I mean, we don't know if medic saves are informed (to my knowledge) so why would Mementoss assume BC was lying about thinking he was medic saved. On the other hand, I can't understand BC's assumption that Mementoss is scum based on a role not functioning the way he's used to in a closed setup game where the roles are obviously fucked with.
That's everyone's homework assignment for tomorrow (or today if your brain can take it). Go back over Mementoss and BC's filters. See if their play matches up with the claims. Is passive-ass BC really a veteran? Is Mementoss convenient claim of a flipped role just a bit TOO convenient? The truth is in this thread.
My assumption wasn't that he was scum before the role worked differently then I thought it did. It was that I had a huge scum read on mementoss before he claimed. He then claimed a role that had already flipped in thread, with information mafia could easily fake while only giving out that I was not medic protected. He then follows up his second check with getting nothing, and is roleblocked on the third.
I think the timing of his claim, and combined with how he claimed and the assumptions he made were really weird. It didn't seem normal to my eye thus I suspected him more given he was already one of my scum reads.
|
On October 11 2012 00:33 kushm4sta wrote:
VE has stifled other people's discussion i meant.
but yeah he has been pretty good recently.
Disagree. He wanted people to stop discussing third party shite. The thread has been more active today in general discussion then it has in awhile, and he is one of the core reasons for it.
|
What do you think of ZBos BC?
|
|
|
huh?
how can someone make up a claim like that?
|
Huh? Wha?
Oh, just wanted to see how you'd react seeing his name in red like that. Interesting that you took immediate issue with it.
Carry on bro.
|
On October 11 2012 00:55 VisceraEyes wrote:
What do you think of ZBos BC?
He is looking extremely bad at this moment in time. However I might be to much in tunnel vision but I see sloosh as red, and i see mattchew as red. Mementoss is likely as fuck there as well -_-
I can't see this many people still being scum so trying to sort out which are bad town and which are scum might be annoying.
I currently believe lynching him or mattchew tommorrow should be what we do as based on thread today and overall they seem most likely to net us scum. (mattchew only if he fails to provide the analysis he just promised).
|
Also
##unvote
##vote kushm4sta
|
@ VE and BC it's an honest question... how can scum make up a claim like that about BC and have it be corroborated by BCs story... it doesn't make sense to me that he isn't town.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
