PTP3 - Pikachu's Revenge - Page 2

On August 22 2012 02:08 kitaman27 wrote:
Bah I had forgotten that the deadlines this game were so early. I should have caught up with the thread this morning, rather than saving it for my 20 minute lunch. Unforutnately I won't be back by the deadline.

Something I meant to mention earlier is that we should strongly consider taking role claims once a lynch is almost certainly decided. Unlike normal games, fake claims are much less likely due to the fact that someone else has submitted it. A role claim may allow a scum player to live an extra night, if we aren't careful, but if a town aligned player about to be lynched is offering up a confirmable role that shows they have the town's best interest in mind, we should consider following through with it.

The post bugs had pointed out about imallinson being wishy-washy was something that I had noticed as well. Hopefully bugs isn't taking advantage of a poorly constructed newbie post, but I don't have someone better to put forward right now. I wish I had more time to look into people who aren't attracting much attention like bum, mattchew or chezinu, but unfortunately I don't. Also, I'm concerned that draz has dropped off activity.

VE is still a head case (<3).

On August 27 2012 09:03 HiroPro wrote:


I haven't really read much since Toad died, so fresh look and all lol.

Dirkzor I think is town. His early play I think was mostly just because of how much pressure he was under from BC and I think he's actually trying to contribute.

I think VE is scum now for a couple of reasons.

First, the thing with grush still strikes me as really uncharacteristic of town VE. VE is someone who throws out policy lynches as town, but it's almost always "if we have no strong scum reads, we should lynch a lurker". For him to push a policy lynch on a person for their play in other games is just mind-boggling. VE has always emphasized that there is no such thing as an "useless townie" because they're still a member of town to count against the mafia wincon, yet now his views have suddenly flipped. If you look at the LVI postgame (the last game with VE and grush in it), there's nothing to suggest that VE was unduly mad. Yes, I know he made some comment pregame about how grush would likely just lurk and troll, but at least before VE pushed the policy lynch, grush had seemed ok in activity and was at least responding to others.

Next looking at the whole Wiggles-BC feud: Beforehand VE had said that he thought Wiggles was scum. But then when the cases come out, literally the only thing VE has to say about those two cases is a mild dislike of one of BC's points. Otherwise he just says afterward " BC died trying to get Wiggles lynched" and "Then he's absent for half of today, only to build a case against one of town's stronger scumhunters and disappear again.". That doesn't look like VE analyzing someone's play and reaching a conclusion based on that. It looks like him making a preconceived judgement and fitting what happens around it.









Then, the amount of times VE promises thoughts and reads but then when he comes back has pretty much nothing useful to say.

I know someone is going to bring up the shot done by Toad, but frankly I think it could just be separation. Toad knew it was only 0.5 KP and not going to pose a threat to VE actually dying.

Maybe I'm being an idiot right now in ignoring BC lol, but it's not like I've been doing anything this game for some time now.

##Vote VisceraEyes