I Can't Believe it's not Themed MiniMafia - Page 6

On July 20 2012 02:48 Keirathi wrote:

Err what?

I never claimed that I was rb'd? :o

On July 20 2012 03:14 Risen wrote:
##unvote
##vote gonzaw

If he's red I no longer want Matt lynched. I don't think he'd bus THIS hard. Also, I'm not being thick the message isn't the same bc you were just defending keir then swapped his name with miltons and said the message was the same. No it isn't, you're shady as fuck if Gonzaw flips green.

On July 20 2012 05:13 gonzaw wrote:


Also Mattchew, you don't need to post "what are your thoughts about my case?" 100 times, it only makes you seem like you are active when in fact you are just repeating the same thing over and over when people already fucking read your case since it was 1 post long and it's not that hard to find in your filter.

On July 20 2012 06:24 Miltonkram wrote:
Fuck it. I'm going for Mattchew.

Here's why:
- His reads haven't shifted much. I see this as scummy, not townie. I looked back and he was finding gonzaw scummy from, I believe, the middle of D2.
- His attempt to take credit for the tali lynch.
- He's avoided commenting on players outside of his tunnel-vision.

I can see scum motivation for all these things.

##Unvote
##Vote: Mattchew

On July 20 2012 06:46 gonzaw wrote:


This would be a good time to post who you think is my scumbuddy

On July 20 2012 06:50 gonzaw wrote:


Who is it? I don't see who is "pretty easy to find"
Keirathi? Dropbear? Milton?

On July 20 2012 06:57 Keirathi wrote:


I haven't really found gonzaw scummy all game until today, and most of that was because of his early play after Risen claimed cop.

I did, however, think Mattchew was scummy yesterday, and nothing he did today made him look more townie.

I still think you are tied in with him too hard because he's been buddying you and copied your reads.

On July 20 2012 06:58 Mattchew wrote:

Its called a numbers game

you die, flip scum 7-1, 7 town, 3 with risen, so therefore scum lay within 4 people, keirathi, drop, milton, scib.

scib is pretty obvious town, i shoulda known that
leaving 3 people

On July 20 2012 07:00 Risen wrote:

Guess you should have jumped on the Keir train then. GODSPEED MATTCHEW, AND MAY THE OBS QT THREAD BE WELCOMING TO YOU. I'll be there soon, brother.

On July 21 2012 07:47 NoSmurfHere wrote:
yeah I'm going to write up a more detailed postgame soon but the gist of it is this:

scum were lazy. They had 0 presence, 0 influence, and 0 will to play. I know Mattchew didn't even want to play scum. Given that 1/3 of the scum team doesn't want to be scum and the other 2 for the most part play at about the same level, the only factor left is town.

Because scum had no influence and town had confirming power roles (2 masons + cop) AND scum chose not to RB n1, the setup was very transparent. The lack of n1 RB forced the hand of mafia and it was a poor choice. Even if they wanted to (which I doubt they did) they could not fake a town RB or jailkeeper. In addition it was a race against the clock and scum lost because they were complacent. The townies who were "confirmed" were not at all confirmed (except for sciberbia, who didn't claim) but scum didn't take advantage of this. Scum didn't take advantage of Risen flip flopping. Scum didn't take advantage of the incorrectness of everyone who was not named austinmcc.

The game wasn't won on analysis. It was merely won on luck. It could've been lost (for town) by luck just as easily. All the players must remember that.

Kudos to austinmcc and marvellosity though. I would rate austin the best player of this game given that out of 4 scum reads on d1 he caught all 3 scum within them.

On July 21 2012 08:08 Risen wrote:


This brings to mind another possibility. I mean shit, matt could have pushed a lynch on me EASY. Then Keir is the next to go no questions asked in my mind. I just can't wrap my head around why matt buddied me. All it did was make me think he was scum.