Have I not given my own reasons for wanting to lynch Zentor?

Have I not given my own reasons for wanting to lynch Sin?

Have you not agreed with at least some of them?

So what's the problem?

Did you ever fulfill my request of you to go look at the slOosh interactions? No? WHY GUY?!

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

July 10 2012 17:50 GMT

#688

You know what? No.

I've tried. I'm being lynched for not shitting up the thread and having a 17 page filter in a 35 page game. Fine, whatever...I've been lynched for worse reasons *sarcastic eyeroll*

Dangeresque77

United States65 Posts

July 10 2012 17:51 GMT

#689

the problem is that we have better reason for lynching you
and for the fact that still you arnt defending yourself your just trying to switch our target to mrzentor and sin

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

July 10 2012 17:53 GMT

#690

On July 11 2012 02:51 Dangeresque77 wrote:
the problem is that we have better reason for lynching you
and for the fact that still you arnt defending yourself your just trying to switch our target to mrzentor and sin

Look, you've never played with me, and your reasons for thinking I'm suspicious are fucking terrible.

I'm going to flip Dreamer and you're all going to be all "Oh VE, why play so terrible? Why so bad? Blah blah!"

slOosh

3291 Posts

July 10 2012 19:18 GMT

#691

On July 11 2012 01:05 marvellosity wrote:
slOosh, could you address the point made by prplhz/myself about Zentor's aggressiveness towards me?

It boils down to "hey scum won't be that scummy would they?" and the fact that you are asking that question shows that the strategy of "be scummy" a viable one. Remove the MrZentor tag off - would you lynch this guy? I would. You could argue that he plays like scum as town, but then if you make that consession how would you ever know if he is scum? If MrZentor rolls scum is town auto lose?

Honestly scum are in a situation where they have little to none thread control.
1) They were complacent D1 because we were lynching townies, and a drastic change in thread direction will surely be noted
2) We have a confirmed town that they have to go through, so manipulation is more difficult

So what are they going to do when one of their own gets caught? All they can do is bus for the town cred, or do subtle misdirections (such as bring up another lynch candidate). I didn't get any bad vibes from Zephirdd and so aside from us three I don't think scum have clout to do anything but pull out such cards as "passive aggressiveness" and "too scummy to be scum".

Or you could go the other way around. Three players must be scum, and conversely the remaining players must be town. Who looks towniest and whatever you have leftover is scum. Bluelightz is a ? for me, I think Zeph and danger are town, you are confirmed and therefore scum must be in the leftovers. If I had to pick out a town out of those 4, it wouldn't be MrZentor.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

July 10 2012 20:39 GMT

#692

slOosh your logic is backward and convoluted this game, like mine is every game. Any reason?

slOosh

3291 Posts

July 10 2012 21:00 GMT

#693

No thanks VE, we can talk post game.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

July 10 2012 21:02 GMT

#694

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

July 10 2012 21:04 GMT

#695

I'm not trying to "shit up the thread" or whatever your curt responses are insinuating. I'm trying to talk to you.

The question had bite, but you understand what I'm asking man. You don't typically hardline against people like this, as town you're always trying to see townie motivation. You're like, not even accepting that I might be town. You realize that by refusing to discuss with me, when I flip town you're going to look AWFUL sir. TERRIBLE. Shutting down discussion is one thing, but you're NOT EVEN ALLOWING discussion.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

July 10 2012 21:17 GMT

#696

CHRIST if I'm up against a slOosh/marv scumteam I'm literally going to cry.

Like, literally guys.

VisceraEyes

United States21170 Posts

July 10 2012 21:18 GMT

#697

Like literally.

slOosh

3291 Posts

July 10 2012 21:18 GMT

#698

I'm not allowing it because there is no purpose to it. You state that my logic backward and convoluted. Of course I would rebut that. My thinking process is the same, I haven't consciously changed my play aside from WBG's advice to push my gut reads which I consistently did D1 with Sinensis. The early vote on drwiggl3s I've explained already.

You say that I'm not even considering the possibility that you might be town. Sure I did. It's just when you never really contributed, did some scummy stuff and with the pool of possible scum is so small, it's not that hard to come to such a conclusion. Plus this is really roundabout discussion. Are you trying to figure out if I'm scum or are you trying to gather information to prove to town that I am scum? Because you've done everything except actually call me scum.

Barbiero

Brazil5259 Posts

July 10 2012 21:19 GMT

#699

On July 11 2012 06:17 VisceraEyes wrote:
CHRIST if I'm up against a slOosh/marv scumteam I'm literally going to cry.

Like, literally guys.

marv is confirmed town VE. confirmed.

He claimed, right at the deadline, a MsZontar shot.

MsZontar died on that night together with NoSmurfHere.

Nobody counterclaimed vigilante, nobody had a breadcumb for NSH's shot.

marv can only be the Vigilante.