Gut says you, me, and Shraft but that includes some connections that are in the back of my mind. Also, we can't just assume the RB claim was faked, definitely need to look at it more objectively in a reread.

Besides, how can you list risk as SK if he had to be faking an RB claim?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

June 27 2012 23:30 GMT

#1303

I never said he had to be faking it, I said he could be faking it, because both you and Matt said it confirmed him if there was no counterclaim

he's either scum and faking it or scum roleblocked risk and he's sk

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

June 27 2012 23:31 GMT

#1304

Everyones town reads should be themselves Marv risk duh that's a bad question Marv and snarfa waffling is just showing he's not town

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

June 27 2012 23:32 GMT

#1305

why is risk such a big townread to you then matt?

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

June 27 2012 23:32 GMT

#1306

I asked after risk claimed ... If sk is rb'd he can't kill so he's town

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

June 27 2012 23:33 GMT

#1307

Cause no scum team wouldn't try to rb...

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

June 27 2012 23:34 GMT

#1308

Do you think I faked my nervousness about you shooting me

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

June 27 2012 23:34 GMT

#1309

why wouldn't they?

Mattchew

United States5684 Posts

June 27 2012 23:39 GMT

#1310

Cause sk is trying to kill scum so he can win... And it's not like he announces who he's shooting so why not try and stop him with an rb... If scum find sk they control all information

Snarfs

Canada1006 Posts

June 27 2012 23:39 GMT

#1311

Roleblock does block KP. In my last game, blazing was SK and he was roleblocked (jailed) night 1 and so his shot didn't go off. risk can't be both SK and RB'd.

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

June 27 2012 23:40 GMT

#1312

And if he's SK and faked the RB, how do mafia call him out on it?

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

June 27 2012 23:41 GMT

#1313

ok but no-one else claimed rb. ok scratch that sorry

Shraft

Sweden701 Posts

June 27 2012 23:54 GMT

#1314

rastaban + prplhz scum, I'm uncertain on the rest.

rastaban

United States2294 Posts

June 27 2012 23:56 GMT

#1315

On June 28 2012 08:41 marvellosity wrote:
ok but no-one else claimed rb. ok scratch that sorry

Yeah, very unlikely he is sk, though as you said scum is possible.
I am going to review the current players, I have felt risk was scum the whole game but I'd he was rbed that wouldn't work.

wherebugsgo

Japan10647 Posts

June 28 2012 00:02 GMT

#1316

If an SK is roleblocked his shot will not go through.

The same is true for the mafia assigned to the kill.

Shraft

Sweden701 Posts

June 28 2012 00:37 GMT

#1317

Did VK/xsksc get the chance of checking someone during N1? I'm asking because it appears as though VK posted during D1 and then disappeared. It's possible (even probable) that he did not submit a night action.

wherebugsgo

Japan10647 Posts

June 28 2012 00:42 GMT

#1318

On June 28 2012 09:37 Shraft wrote:
Did VK/xsksc get the chance of checking someone during N1? I'm asking because it appears as though VK posted during D1 and then disappeared. It's possible (even probable) that he did not submit a night action.

can't answer this

Shraft

Sweden701 Posts

June 28 2012 01:54 GMT

#1319

All right, I guess I'll just have to accept WBG's answer, but I feel that not knowing this is unfair. We'd be certain that our cop used his night action if it wasn't for the replacement. I'd like to hear WBG's reasoning behind his choice, but this feels more fitting in the post game discussion, as it isn't really a mod question. Not knowing whether or not he used check sucks. ._.

wherebugsgo

Japan10647 Posts

June 28 2012 02:06 GMT

#1320

Think about it from this perspective (this is all I'll say on the matter):

If in a normal situation a cop died and didn't provide checks would you ask whether the cop used his actions? Obviously not.

So what difference is there in this situation? What does the knowledge that a cop used his action give you?

It's not like knowing that will tell you who he used his action on.

e: or, for that matter, what the result of the check was