Bang Bang Mafia 2 - Page 24

On June 12 2012 13:38 rastaban wrote:

I support this!

On June 12 2012 22:40 rastaban wrote:
The following People need to post, they are very inactive, and if they have said anything it is only a few one liners.
risk.nuke
Kenpachi
payl

gonzaw I don't see him for mafia, but I don't have a problem with making him shoot someone else if it will lessen the distracting discussion on him. So far the biggest arguments against him have been that he supported ROL and that he claimed He hadn't seen a Mafia fake a miller claim before. To me he doesn't seem scum at all, and most of the case is hinged on defending ROL, If ROL is really a miller then all the discussion seems moot.

ROL Controversy, We still have no other Millers claiming, and until we get some other contenders I am very inclined to believe ROL. There should have been 2 hits last night (mafia & SK), and only 1 went down. Unless someone else claims to have been protected I see no reason to disbelieve this. I lean towards an SK 1 shot power as if it is reuseable it would be way over powered, I think we keep an eye on him and see how things progress. If the Mafia tried to shoot him, and an SK tried to remove the gun, then I think we should hold off on killing him for a bit since there must be a reason so many people tried to hit him last night. Again if more Millers come forward then I agree we should re-evaluate the claim but for now I think his play seems town and we should hold off a final judgment for him.

Meapak_Ziphh, your filter looked really bad last night tons of filler and no posts contributing to discussion, but you seem to be posting more like your normal self today. Mind explaining what was going on?

On June 13 2012 02:06 rastaban wrote:
I say we have Gonzaw shoot payl. We find out if Gonzow has a gun and if he does, we off the single post Smurf. I have a feeling at least one if not more of the mafia are in the lurking crowd intentionally or not and it is causing confusion in the Mafia ranks.

If gonzaw won't fire lets let chaoser kill him.

On June 13 2012 03:27 Mr. Wiggles wrote:
I don't want to have anyone shoot until RoL comes in and proves he's not lying. He can shoot Gonzaw if he likes. Also, Gonzaw, shoot again with the right formatting.

On June 13 2012 03:38 rastaban wrote:

@gonzaw But the whole point is that you can't shoot. I thought you could shoot, so now that you can't and you have this many accusations on you it is time to kill you. Claim your role if you are town.

On June 13 2012 03:37 rastaban wrote:
Well he also messed up the formatting as well, but does it matter, refusing to shoot and not shooting are the same thing correct? I mean I think we all believe he can't shoot or he would have, that is nothing to hide. The real questions is, is he Scum or is he Blue?

On June 13 2012 03:51 Mr. Wiggles wrote:

He claimed Miller on Night 1. Then in the morning he claimed he had his gun taken away. He needs to shoot. If he does, and nothing happens, then it means he either had his gun taken away, or he was lying about being a miller, same thing as what we were at. If he can shoot, then he lied about having his gun taken away, and I'd say he's scum then. The whole point of people claiming miller was to get them to shoot as soon as possible to confirm themselves. Then he claims he can't shoot anymore, and introduces the worry of there being a role that can take away our guns. There's no reason to make that lie as town. This is to make sure he's at least not lying about not having a gun.

On June 13 2012 03:59 VisceraEyes wrote:
gonzaw why did you act as if you had a gun N0 when chaoser first introduced the notion that you should shoot today? I know you never explicitly said one way or the other, but you never even opposed the idea of you shooting.

On June 13 2012 03:15 gonzaw wrote:


I didn't want to out myself as blue so soon just because 1 guy (you) was buggering me about shooting.

On June 13 2012 03:51 Mr. Wiggles wrote:

He claimed Miller on Night 1. Then in the morning he claimed he had his gun taken away. He needs to shoot. If he does, and nothing happens, then it means he either had his gun taken away, or he was lying about being a miller, same thing as what we were at. If he can shoot, then he lied about having his gun taken away, and I'd say he's scum then. The whole point of people claiming miller was to get them to shoot as soon as possible to confirm themselves. Then he claims he can't shoot anymore, and introduces the worry of there being a role that can take away our guns. There's no reason to make that lie as town. This is to make sure he's at least not lying about not having a gun.

On June 13 2012 03:45 gonzaw wrote:


I don't want my role to create more chaos.

If I'm being shot (someone puts ##Kill: gonzaw in the thread), then I'll claim my role.
But until then it will only serve to distract people (they'll start thinking "Oh what if his claim is real? Oh what if we let him live and bla bla bla?").

In the off-chance I survive this (not likely), then scum won't know my role either.



rastaban, if it came down to it, would you shoot me?
You say "so now that you can't and you have this many accusations on you it is time to kill you...."

So, it is time to kill me because I have accusations against me...but not because you think I'm scum?
Also, me having a gun or not had nothing to do with your "town" read on me.

On June 13 2012 04:02 gonzaw wrote:




What do you guys think of rastaban?

@Wiggles: I think rastaban was talking about me and not RoL, but I'm not really sure

On June 13 2012 03:27 Mr. Wiggles wrote:
I don't want to have anyone shoot until RoL comes in and proves he's not lying. He can shoot Gonzaw if he likes. Also, Gonzaw, shoot again with the right formatting.

On June 13 2012 04:05 VisceraEyes wrote:


But you're the guy who was pushing the idea of all guns outting N0, thereby outting all blues. You were the one saying this should be an analysis game. This is a blatant contradiction in your philosophies.

On June 13 2012 04:03 rastaban wrote:
Sorry gonzaw I won't tell you if I have a gun or not, Scum is already trying to snipe our VEs as it is, you will just have to wait and see.

On June 13 2012 04:05 marvellosity wrote:
RoL will (attempt to) shoot gonzaw and that's that. Great plan by Wiggles.