Magic: The Gathering Mini Mafia - Page 7

Also, I believe we should be voting on the NT vs Hiro case because we get a confirmed scum out of the claim (NT if Hiro flips green and Hiro if NT isn't lying) despite how confident VE is in his read

The odds are EXTREMELY higher that one of hiro/NT are scum than VE/WBG

On May 30 2012 05:34 Katina wrote:
You're so sweet.

On May 30 2012 08:14 HiroPro wrote:
Are you fucking kidding me. Do you really think that I'm that stupid that I'd confirm someone with a red check on me when I am mafia????

Get your votes off me. Mafia obviously killed Nova to make me look scummy. If you lynch me now, we lose.

On May 30 2012 13:42 wherebugsgo wrote:
I don't think hiro is scum because I really doubt scum would overlook shooting a confirmed town just to shoot a DT.

The only explanation for it is that they don't have a roleblocker and they wanted to lock the lynch on hiro. It's one of the oldest scum tactics; when you're in a situation where town will lynch a guy if someone else dies, scum kill the guy and then watch town tear itself apart with no real effort of any kind.

I mean think about it, if hiro is town it's a perfect plan for scum.

On May 30 2012 13:54 wherebugsgo wrote:
I think scum framed Hiro, yes.

If scum framed hiro then it makes total sense that Zealos would call hiro scum (and claim DT at that.)

Obviously the pussy way out is to simply kill hiro. I suppose we can do that if we're lazy and I certainly feel lazy. I just think it's too easy and that scum would probably not kill NT if that was the case.

Maybe I'm just paranoid and this scumteam doesn't know what it's doing. Who knows.

On May 30 2012 14:52 Katina wrote:
Navillus has been up and down this whole game. He sheeped along the VE lynch. Been hard for me to read. Same goes for Tunkeg, though his posting is always a roller coaster. But given recent events I find it likely one of them is mafia, along with Mattchew.

Mattchew has been plain bad from the start. He came into the game with his quotes and completely ignoring confrontation with other players. He hasn't been giving any reads or making any cases. He cracked and started posting normally again and attacking his attackers.



This is a blatant contradiction and the start of his posts that show he is trying to take credit for things he did not accomplish. He only pushed Mouldy Jeb when using the quotes. And we all know him using quotes accomplished nothing for the town. When he stopped using quotes, he immediately focused on the people who were suspicious of him (myself, Tunkeg, Marvellosity, etc). He also attacked VE. If you look at his filter, he doesn't justify any of those accusations. It's more along the lines of, "this person is stupid for voting me. Therefore they are mafia." Pretty sound logic there. He also defended Zealos and the end of day 1 and into day 2. He used the quotes day 1 so he could subtely push a lynch and not be accountable for it. Then he just started attacking anyone who was suspicious of him. Also, he was very adamant about killing zelblade, but hasn't said a word about him in over a day.

On May 31 2012 03:16 Katina wrote:
We really should lynch Mattchew though.

The guy has been painfully scummy from the start. I have made multiple accusations and cases against but everyone has completely ignored his actions. Basically his overall defense is "I know you are but what am I?" "You're stupid" derp derp derp. We have wasted our time going after people that have been half as scummy as Mattchew while completely overlooking the big red bullseye drawn all over his face.

I bet he could have a name tage saying "I'm Mattchew and I'm Mafia" and people would still overlook it.