TL Mafia 'Area' LIII - Page 64

On April 22 2012 14:45 Janaan wrote:
I will say this, VE's claim fits his critique of Gonzaw's plan perfectly. At this point, I have no reason to doubt his claims.

Paqman, it's like you're purposely misunderstanding Mattchew about VE's claim, I understood exactly what he meant the first time he said it. Either that, or you just don't want to believe that Mattchew is actually making sense, which leads me to believe that you're tunneling him a bit too hard. Please, try to step back and objectively read what Mattchew is saying.

At the moment, none of the cases are terribly convincing for me. I also hate the fact that we're well over half through with day 1 and there are still players who haven't said a single word since the game started. I don't know if scum is among them or not, but at this point, it's impossible to tell.

The one vote that does make sense to me right now is Bill Murray. He's proven that he's in the thread, he's posted a few times, but he really doesn't seem to care at all. All his posts are entirely void of content, which makes me think that either he's scum trying to get away with not saying anything or he's a townie who just doesn't care about the game. Bill, if you DO care, start being more useful please.

##Vote: Bill Murray

I won't be on for another 14 hours or so, I'll be back in the thread around then if anything happens.

On April 25 2012 02:55 Janaan wrote:
At work so I don't have much time.

Ottoxlol, my question to you is this: You say you want to lynch to gain information. Ok, fine. That's not a good mindset, but I'll accept that you think it's a good idea for a minute. What I don't understand is why that makes BM the best lynch. He himself hasn't given any firm stances, and as far as I can tell, there hasn't been anyone who hasn't at least questioned him for lurking, and NO ONE has defended him. So exactly what information will we gain from lynching him that makes it the best choice? Working from the mindset that lynching for information is a good idea, it would make more sense to me to lynch a more controversial target.

On April 25 2012 10:56 johnnywup wrote:
Janaan is the only person I have on my powerpoint that I don't have some sort of shade of red or green. What do you guys make of him?

On April 25 2012 11:17 Bill Murray wrote:

I read him in isolation the other day, and even if his filter is only a page, his posting is very protown
i've got him in my leaning town category, and gonzaw had him as a townread with mattchew and layabout

On April 25 2012 11:13 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
What I'd like to know about Janaan is how he came from this



to this:



Namely how he went from BM being his one true stance to saying we shouldn't lynch BM because he's so scum nobody would drop information or give intel.

Otherwise, he just seems to agree with the general mood of the thread on everything. So he's either decent town or clever scum. I'd be betting the former at this point because I have nothing to accuse him of.

thinking about it, I retract my previous statement about marvellosity. For now.

On April 25 2012 11:20 marvellosity wrote:
I'd like a couple of other people to answer on Sentinel too (jdub, BM as you're here for a change)

On April 25 2012 09:27 johnnywup wrote:
I guess since no one's voting Zephirdd, I'll have to remake a case against him. I'm only going to post my thoughts on one post because I think it's enough to show how scummy Zephirdd is.


This post really pisses me off. I already posted I didn't like this and I thought it was contradictory. After I posted my disapproval of this post he says "Let me just place a palm in my face in the hopes that you realize how much of a bad logic that was." To restate what's wrong with it, if it's not obvious...it's that he says he Votes Marv because people had been voting him. Ok, sheeping. He hadn't analyzed him yet. Ok, relying on other people to be right. That's all scummy but the next thing blows it away. "I meant that marvellosity was a reasonable player to place a vote on and not look bad for voting VE". I think this is basically claiming scum because he basically admits to knowing how VE would flip. He knew he'd look bad if he voted VE before the lynch. How is that possible? Because he's mafia, obviously. His vote on marvellosity aside, that line alone makes him almost 100% scum in my eyes, and I already suspected him at that point.

On April 25 2012 08:03 Ottoxlol wrote:
johnnywup



I missed this case before, I think a couple of ppl too because no one really talked about this. I am feeling confident voting for johnny.

##Vote: johnnywup