A Game of Thrones Mafia

On March 20 2012 14:26 Hesmyrr wrote:

dumbledore kills dumbledore
God, how behind on the canon are you?

On March 21 2012 16:48 wherebugsgo wrote:
hi I'm vanilla town

On March 22 2012 03:15 Acrofales wrote:
Any further discussion will have to wait til I'm home. Be back in about an hour.

PS. I read through a couple of games before signing up for this one. It's quite different to play than to watch! :D

On March 22 2012 06:10 Mattchew wrote:


then MrZentor, bad reading comprehension in hand, makes a terrible post with his lead point of his slippery slope theory being untrue because Mattchew (who is awesome, sexy and lover of all townies) never even voted for Acrofales!

On March 22 2012 09:33 wherebugsgo wrote:
I'm fine with killing GreYMisT.

I'm also fine with killing DoYouHas. Let's kill them all!

On March 22 2012 09:35 SamuelLJackson wrote:
HEY! arcosomething and gumshoes are likely town you morons. Oberyn however is scum with his 4 random quotes and a very bland and carefully constructed post.
Let's kill Oberyn gogogo.

On March 22 2012 02:41 gumshoe wrote:
Acrofales seeing as your lynch is getting to be pretty likely maybe you should role claim? It could help your case, also why did you vote for Mattchew in the first place?

On March 22 2012 09:24 risk.nuke wrote:

just to clarify, my original vote for greymist was pressure and I want to lynch him now for other reasons.

On March 23 2012 05:48 Mattchew wrote:

Sandroba I presume?

He called like 5 people town 5 people scum gave like 4 people "passes" and then called the rest "idk or null"

There was a little of his own opinions in there (his reads on ald and sinensis)

There are some things I heavily disagree with such as



All in all this post seemed genuine and honest. I would have liked him to actually take a stand and vote someone at then end but meh w/e

On March 23 2012 05:48 Mattchew wrote:

Sandroba I presume?

He called like 5 people town 5 people scum gave like 4 people "passes" and then called the rest "idk or null"

There was a little of his own opinions in there (his reads on ald and sinensis)

There are some things I heavily disagree with such as



All in all this post seemed genuine and honest. I would have liked him to actually take a stand and vote someone at then end but meh w/e

On March 23 2012 09:38 wherebugsgo wrote:
Explain how layabout's posts are harmful? Just saying so does not make them so.

In addition, lynching someone because they're a "bigger threat" as scum is stupid unless you've got 2 confirmed scum to lynch from. And guess what, that pretty much never happens, and that probably means town has already won.

On March 23 2012 10:42 wherebugsgo wrote:
not to mention layabout is a pretty good townie, so that pretty much flushes your entire argument down the toilet.

On March 24 2012 07:18 wherebugsgo wrote:


rofl you liar, you love it.

cause you're scum.

On March 24 2012 07:21 Acrofales wrote:

Don't read shit into it that's not there. I don't want to policy-lynch, I want to lynch Mattchew, but that is clearly not going to happen. Rather than wasting my vote there and having whoever the fuck wants switch at the last second to mislynch a useful townie, I'd rather policy-lynch a lurker or someone who's going to get modkilled. I chose the modkilled.

Now stop confusing shit more than it is already and consolidate your own vote somewhere useful, or make a better case against Oberyn, because so far it has been: he's useless. He is a lot LESS useless than Evantrees or Nicolas, so if that's your criteria, your vote's in the wrong place.

On March 24 2012 07:18 wherebugsgo wrote:


rofl you liar, you love it.

cause you're scum.

On March 24 2012 07:24 wherebugsgo wrote:


You could replace "Oberyn" with almost any name in the thread and the statement would still be valid.

Hell, I'm the most pro-town player in here.

I have the names of all the scum team and you homos won't listen to a word I say.

On March 24 2012 08:55 risk.nuke wrote:
if layabout was mafia, mafia could so easily save him and kill greymist right now. Unless you think the entire scumteam is already on greymist.

On March 24 2012 09:01 Mattchew wrote:
can someone tell me why layabout is scum?

On March 24 2012 09:03 Risen wrote:
I posted precisely why I feel like I do.

On March 24 2012 17:13 SamuelLJackson wrote:
WBG let's join forces. I don't want to win with town anymore. I went out at 6 o'clock, I told everyone my case on laya was shit and people still sheep me. Srsly town why the fuck did you lynch laya. I was obviously joking. I realize I sound scummy as fuck. Dun care.

On March 25 2012 06:39 wherebugsgo wrote:
I think GreYMisT is colorblind, guys.

What a sad day.

GreYMisT how come you're trying to bus Risen now?

On March 25 2012 07:11 wherebugsgo wrote:
Shut up Risen I'm shooting you

On March 25 2012 07:12 Alderan wrote:



- You make a terrible play pressuring Gumshoe.
- Realize it and move to another lurkish player: Oberyn.
- Your case against Oberyn is not as good as you want everyone to think it is. You're accusing a new player of being scum for not posting productively on the first day when you know good and well how much bull shit goes on Day 1 around here, especially in this game.
- You scold town for switching vote targets, ironically just as you become a primary suspect.
- You keep playing up this "suspicious" dropping of Oberyn as a target. The reason people dropped him as a primary lynch suspicion was because he had posted very little of substance and was lurking really hard, he began posting more, and with much more substance. I don't understand whats causing you to continue your suspicion but you're not suspicious of Evantrees or Lyter. You're tunneling really hard (except of course when you and your scum buddy had to switch votes to save you, in which case you were very open to changing vote targets).


As an aside, I admire how selfish you were in getting Risen to put himself on the line for you, but I'm assuming that decision was calculated by the fact that Risen had been buddying you too hard Day 1.

On March 25 2012 07:18 wherebugsgo wrote:


That's scum for: "I would have killed my teammate, but some other guy could be mislynched, so why the hell would I work against my own wincon?"

Also Risen you can't shoot me. But you can roleblock me. Good luck, biatch.

On March 25 2012 07:49 Alderan wrote:


I read this in the voice of a 13 year old on Call of Duty.

On March 25 2012 07:30 Risen wrote:
AFAIK I said anyone who jumped on Greymist for his joke is clearly acting scummy. No town player would do that. I then look at risk's post and say that Greymist did in fact have some scummy posting. Then when Greymist asks me if I think he's scum I say no, I do not think you are scum. Then layabout goes, lolderp imma vote greymist peace bitches. Clear scum move in my mind, instantly place my vote on him since people won't vote acro.

Feel free to point out anything I missed.

On March 25 2012 10:16 Mattchew wrote:
Cool so I'm like confirmed town

On March 25 2012 10:35 Mattchew wrote:
No I'm confirmed town because layabout and alj and dyh flipped town

On March 25 2012 10:28 Risen wrote:


If you follow the logic that acro=mafia then mattchew=town? Yes.

I've been thinking. WBG wants a close endgame. He told us greymist was mafia, but we lynched a townie anyways. He's now pushing hard on me. He knows I'm town, so his motives to me are suspect (obviously). It comes back to the 10-3 town to mafia at the start of night 3 should I be lynched as he wants, which is pretty on track for a WBG victory assuming it drops to 8-3 following night 3.

Maybe it's the first one and he's just trying to show us who the mafia is by outlining who jumps on me. I hadn't considered that a 10-3 town/mafia ratio is perfect for him at the end of day 3 when I originally posted, though.

On March 25 2012 10:42 wherebugsgo wrote:





There you have it ladies and gentlemen, Risen has claimed scum. Again.

If you don't kill him, you're seriously braindead.

On March 25 2012 13:52 Mattchew wrote:
so if risen is telling the truth im like 3 times confirmed town, and if hes not im like 4 times confirmed town

On March 26 2012 04:41 chaoser wrote:


Once again, this doesn't take into account the OP. Are you not reading or are you purposefully being ignorant? If acro flips scum or miller, we DON'T KNOW if risen is town or not. So we would not be saving a townie or a lynch. We would still be in WIFOM.

On March 26 2012 05:39 wherebugsgo wrote:


You've scumslipped every time you've been in an exchange with...well, anyone. That's pretty sad, since half the time it was me pressuring you.

For the record, I WAS roleblocked, and my kill of Risen was prevented. No one counterclaimed roleblock; you can actually believe me on this one.

That's one of at least a dozen reasons to lynch Risen.

On March 26 2012 05:35 wherebugsgo wrote:


If you're town you should probably shut up, because my god all of your posts are utterly horrible.

Hell, they're worse than mine, because some of the things you say have convinced me you must be trolling; I think no one could ever be THAT stupid. But then I'm still confused because you still seem to believe the garbage you're spouting. At least you know for sure when you read some of my posts that I'm actually trolling.

On March 26 2012 05:57 wherebugsgo wrote:


Mostly in the post I quoted it's the idea that you should never lynch a claimed role first. This is precisely why TL towns get destroyed by fake claims and why I suggested in the postgame of C9++ that the scum team should have fake claimed cop. Anyone can claim anything at anytime. You don't just believe it solely based on them saying they're what they say they are when under pressure.

In fact, the simple way that Risen says "lynch acro, and if I'm wrong lynch me" tells you that he's mafia. He doesn't outline the reasons he's a townie. He doesn't give the breadcrumb of his check (he says he breadcrumbed his role...which anyone can do, look at my claim from Mini X) and so he could just be making shit up. Acro has acted far more town-like to the pressure and by all means he looks town. But risen doesn't even consider the fact that acro could be miller or framed until it's pointed out that it looks bad that he isn't considering it. Then he panics and overcompensates by saying "oh you should've claimed miller" which is just hilariously bad.

On March 26 2012 08:10 wherebugsgo wrote:
There is nothing to suggest evantrees is scum because there very well could be two roleblockers, evantrees could be a veteran, evantrees could have been protected or jailed, and evantrees could be PGO. Since the OP states that roles can be on either side, it doesn't make a difference what evantrees's alignment is; we have no idea why he survived.

On March 26 2012 08:10 wherebugsgo wrote:
Also, timing of the claim IS relevant. Scum generally claim earlier in the day than townies would, often in positions where normally townies would not feel as threatened. Don't believe me? Look at chaoser's DT claim from XLIV, or Palmar's cop claim from Some Mafia Game, or my jailkeeper claim from Mini X. In all of these situations mafia claim in a spot where it will shift potential lynch attention onto the target of their choice. From a mafia perspective it's all about buying time, and the longer town discussion is held up on false ideas and leads, the easier it is for the remaining mafia to hide.

If you've noticed, this claim has destroyed all discussion of any suspects outside of Risen and potentially Acro. If Risen flips scum we still have to find 3 more scum, and we have few leads from today. That's a win for scum if they thought Risen was going to die anyway.

On March 27 2012 13:12 wherebugsgo wrote:
ok so we kill acrofales now.

easy peasy lemon squeezy.

On March 29 2012 08:02 wherebugsgo wrote:
Wtf does that have to do with evantrees being scum?

Just read his filter, it'll take you all of 30 seconds.

On March 29 2012 08:09 wherebugsgo wrote:


Lol wut? How are they worse than a player who has posted...8 times?

Also, you voted Risen too, dipshit.

On April 05 2012 17:42 wherebugsgo wrote:
If anyone's curious as to my thought process/what I was doing:

I should mention, I didn't originally intend to troll to the level that I ultimately did. However, I noticed that reason and logic were not actually effective methods of getting my point across.

There were three players I wanted to kill day 1, and they were Xatalos, GreYMisT, and gumshoe.

At first I though gumshoe was the best choice but I never expressly pushed that in thread because I was afraid people would think "oh the third party wants to lynch this guy, better not lynch him" but day 1 was such a derpfest it didn't even matter.

So, I made a series of serious posts after my short period of elation over being unkillable. I realized quickly that no one cared, so I stopped. I picked Oberyn day 1 as a target because I didn't actually think he would get shot nor lynched, despite sandro wanting to kill him. In fact, just BECAUSE sandro wanted to kill him, I knew he probably wouldn't die, because no one ever listens to town sandro. (I identified him as a smurf as well)


+ Show Spoiler [serious posts] +

I didn't foresee the layabout lynch at all (tbh I don't think anyone did) and honestly if I thought I could have anticipated the day 1 lynch I would've picked someone other than Oberyn.

Day 2 was more derp, and then day 3 was even more derp, and at that point I had no vested interest in the game beyond figuring out which of the players were scum/god awful townies and would never die. I had an inkling at targetting chaoser, but figured it might be risky because someonewould pick up on thefact he was alive and then he'd get lynched. Of course, no one actually used their brains so this was, in the end, a stupid fear.

Anyway I learned a bit. Not much, since I'd much rather have actually played a pro-town game to facilitate my wincondition. If the easy way out is to just incessantly troll, then of course I'd rather do that than try to be serious while my head explodes from the stupidity.

On March 22 2012 22:57 Mattchew wrote:
Also he looks like he contributes, but in reality all of his posts say next to nothing. He tries to pressure vote Gumshoe, OriginalName, and Nicolas but is extremely flaky about each one and votes someone new basically as soon as they post regardless of what it is (Somehow he reads Gumshoe's posts and then moves his vote to OriginalName, and then calls Gumshoe his 2nd biggest scum read)