EPTA Game of Thrones Mafia
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
| ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
On March 22 2012 03:04 Alderan wrote: I've played with gumshoe a couple times now, and he always seems to start out slow but then get better and eventually help. He's the kind of person that's going to post enough to eventually hang himself if he is indeed scum, I say we leave him for now. On March 22 2012 04:03 Alderan wrote: Certainly not giving him the free pass, just saying given the information we have right now I would feel uncomfortable lynching him given this is how he has begun every game I've played with him, and he was town both times. Nobody said we had to lynch him but you seem to be keen on keeping any pressure at all off of him. At the same time all your doing otherwise has been making snarky comments Gumshoe... I just dont get this dude, half the things he says seem to just scream posting for the sake of posting with huge paragraphs filled with nothingness. for example: Wasn't aware, always thought mayors were just achieved through consensus. In regard to Acrofales I'm sure your well aware that my sympathies always go to first time townies who fuck up at the start, but his response was just pure ombus, which was similar to sloosh and ech in suprisingly normal mini mafia, yet the difference was in that game Sloosh and Ech kept fighting blow for blow because they knew they were townies, Acrofales just sort of clammed up. He's not fighting hard enough, which first time newbie townies tend to do way too much. I'm down for voting for him not because of his silly ombus, but because he backed down when pressured. Random meta arguement that probably has zero bearing on the actual situation. Newbies reactions are hard to place because they are newbies YOU CANT META THE NEWBS THEY HAVE NONE. Also meta in and of itself really doesnt mean shit without other evidence first, if anything you seem to be just defending him because you feel bad that hes a newb. That is beyond a shitty reason to defend him and dives into the realm of stupid, we dont lynch new scum then we leave them till its too late. Personally I think we should stay clear of trying to lynch Baelish, unless someone claims there him just before we kill him, in which case they fully deserve to die as we had already decided. If we lynch Where it should be because we think hes scum, not Baelish, do you really think Where is scum this early in the game? ( : but keep in mind it is possible(though unlikely considering scums hate for flashy play early on) Scum play not being flashy early on? What are you talking about, how do you think scum influences lynches and such if anything scum is going to be loud in order to convince people that just because they are speaking and 'contributing' that it makes them obvious town. I mean really how often do people want to lynch actives day one on the basis that "we could go after lurkers" or other such excuses. If anything lynching an active but shitposting player is a much stronger way to start a game. If we run out of leads day 2 we start pressuring more lurkers or if we still have absoulutely nothing nearer to the end of day 1 then its in the meh choice and really if we are forced to kill a lurker day 1 then we clearly arent trying hard enough to make people actually spell out opinions. Personally I think we should stay clear of trying to lynch Baelish, unless someone claims there him just before we kill him, in which case they fully deserve to die as we had already decided. If we lynch Where it should be because we think hes scum, not Baelish, do you really think Where is scum this early in the game? ( : but keep in mind it is possible(though unlikely considering scums hate for flashy play early on) So right after you agree with Sand on the ignore Baelish point you come back and reference him again. What part of mod confirmed do you not understand HE CANNOT BE SCUM and im 95% sure this is not a bastard mod game where he is scum. Does he have a KP or not is irrelevant because we cannot stop him. There is no point in bringing up the is he scum or not unless your trying to misdirect people into searching for a reason to waste a lynch on him. | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
On March 22 2012 11:12 Alderan wrote: He gave away his wincon.... that wasn't so much a question as a comment to make it a little more clear for everyone. Anywho it's over now for good. So we can stop worrying about. My apologies. Carry on. Your failing at the ignore the third party portion of this, I also doubt WBG is retarded enough to slip his wincon this early and for all we know it could be misleading us its not over for good. | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
On March 22 2012 09:35 SamuelLJackson wrote: HEY! arcosomething and gumshoes are likely town you morons. Oberyn however is scum with his 4 random quotes and a very bland and carefully constructed post. syllo believe mattchew is likely town aswell, I can't understand his reasons, but he is probably right. Let's kill Oberyn gogogo. Arco prob town but why do you think gumshoes is, in all honesty im still 50/50 on him. Oberyn needs some more before i make a call too. | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
On March 23 2012 06:23 Risen wrote: Can't read OriginalName b/c there's just not enough to analyze. He has a long post criticizing Alderan, but the rest is just filler saying he can't form an opinion on anyone else b/c there's nothing to go on (which isn't horrible filler since it's true) HENCE WHY I POSTED IT. (also im here again just reading up from where i left off. Although the only thing that really irks me is oberyns super long post of opinions which really reads like. IM TRYING TO CONTRIBUTE BUT NOT REALLY CONTRIBUTING. Another thing to note is Samuels passiveness. hes running around voting people and switching around without even letting them post so it fails as a pressure vote. They post at most adequate reasons for things and a kicker is from a post where i asked them to explain themselves earlier. They did respond but only after i asked them. Why are you holding information back, there is no reason to hold it back and the votes seem to be pushing a scum agenda of just pushing whoever they damn well feel like because they know they are anti town. Alderan not helping himself lately again risens opinion actually is fairly correct although he really needs to stop spamming and consolidate his posts. I need to read mattchew again and will get back later, just doing some chem homework first then will get on it. | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
| ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
On March 23 2012 06:37 Risen wrote: Please explain what you mean by me holding information back in this post. What am I holding back? I'll stop for now since yeah my posting is pretty much 90% of the last couple pages SLJ was not you, your a goddamned open book in comparison. | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
For the following reasons I believe them to be scum. -There's two of them and they are both lurking hardcore there is no excuse for this behaviour -Not contributing any opinions before flaunting vet status and starting questionable bandwagon that everyone is jumping on. -Pushing agenda through above method -Doing nothing to contribute to atmosphere and using horrid paragraph/other crappie that neither usually ignore and makes it seem that they really don't care -Throwing votes down without reason The cases on layabout are fairly meh nothing of his outright rises suspicion other then his questionable alt targets. Alderan is increadably trashy as well with that clear bandwagon jump how do people get away with this. #Vote SLJ | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
If you guys wanna sick up to vets I've been here just as long or longer than those clowns + Show Spoiler + Or you man up and play for real and stop sucking their cocks and inflating their egos. Play the goddamned game and stop being sheeple | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
| ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
On March 23 2012 10:55 gumshoe wrote: Also how is it weird to equally suspect your two highest suspects? It means your indecisive and need to man the fuck up and figure out which is scummier instead of stalling I'm still not entirely convinced your town either Xant is completely up in the air right now and evantrees shouldn't be in the running as there is nothing really to be basing a case off of. | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
| ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
On March 23 2012 12:00 evantrees wrote: Seems to mostly be complaining about a joke, which followed a joke from bugs,and who posted before bugs kenpachi! Otherwise I have been useless so somewhat understandable. Since I would not mind seeing him lynched or shot for now ##Vote Mattchew. I think Mattchew and gumshoe would make good vig targets. I see a huge trend in people doing huge throwaway votes to fly under the radar. | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
just some observations on said person as well On March 23 2012 19:20 SamuelLJackson wrote: You do not know us, so it's easy to understand why you would make that assumption based on our in-thread activity, but nevertheless you are mistaken. Moreover, a hydra is a bit like a confirmed mason pair, and I do in fact discuss everything with sandroba, I'm just too lazy to post and most of the things that get said are town reads. Still hiding information, there is no use for town in this. The point of a mason is to disscuss with each other and to allow ideas to be bounced off and plans to be formed that can then be posted into the thread. You have really not shown any results within the thread and seem to be content with the game however it goes. There is absolutely nothing "suspect" about our behaviour, so while you have a point about us not putting in much effort yet, and I won't promise I will, you should focus your attention elsewhere. This is just a detrimental attitude towards lynching scum. | ||
|
OriginalName
Canada1140 Posts
On March 24 2012 06:11 SamuelLJackson wrote: ON stop nitpicking on syllo, you realize he is talking about only him and not SLJ as a whole. Honestly what do you think produces more information day1, me pushing a hard lynch I'm not very confident on and most town sheeping me blindly or if I stay cool and let the thread behave organically. I'm not here to behave as people think a townie should behave, I'm trying to get the most info out of this day. I find it hard to believe you really think we are the best lynch for day1 (LOL). Sit down and watch us get shot night 1 or come back day2 and murder all scum. There is no issues with pushing a hard lynch as often that push can cause scum to slip up harder. If they seem more townie as time goes on then fine switch off. Im just tierd of people playing passive on Day 1 because of what they deem as weak reads. Throw ideas out thats the point sure asking questions is fine but what and WHY do you think something Going to move over to Eventrees for now, Im likeing sandro if not syllo but really Im probably just wasting my vote atm. ##Vote Eventrees @Sandro Im probably picking on you more then most because you have 2 people working on an account with people who dont want to play the game. If anything im venting frustration on people who are being overall unhelpful and while i do believe that if you want to hide info between yourselves if you are town theres no harm in throwing out those ideas to us as well to throw our opinions on. @Generally everyone else What is everyone thinking about Sinesis i dont think its wise to truely ignore anyone and he seems to be just sitting there and not barging into the forefront. | ||
| ||
