On March 27 2012 01:13 risk.nuke wrote: You keep brining that game up as if it were a defense against you. I was supicious of you because you played scummy. Period. I don't know if it was part of your strategy in order to avoid beeing nightkilled by the mafia because you were a medic or something else but you were forced to roleclaim in order to not get lynched which means I wasn't tunneling you that game. You played poorly and I took notice of that which is a big difference.
I know you are mafia. It's just a matter of time before I can convince the others of it, and I'm not in a rush. I play mafia with my focus on the endgame and you will not survive it so as far as I care, I consider you a lynched man walking. And I got several ideas of whom your scumbuddies might be.
Someone is going to learn to live with dissapointment
On March 27 2012 09:26 Oberyn wrote: *cough cough*
Time to listen to everyone explain how bad Risen is and try to convince themselves that their vote was perfectly reasonable.
Maybe if I were a vet, my opinion wouldn't immediately be deemed invalid.
I'll save it for the post game. For now we have a lynched detective who claimed a red check on another player in the game. The OP states that alignments dectectives are guarenteed to be sane, thus either acro is scum, was framed, or is a miller.It sucks that our next day must be predeterimined, but we have to lynch acro because of this. letting a red-checked player live would generate too much wifom.
On March 27 2012 18:40 risk.nuke wrote: We don't need a case, we got a redcheck. Acro. Sit down shut up. Mods can we have a 24 hour day today if town agrees on it? There won't be or well you don't know with the ratio of morons in this city but there shouldn't be much confusion about who we're lynching.
So let me get this straight. You are advocating a policy of lynching anybody who has a confirmed red check, regardless of ANY other evidence?
The other evidence is a confirmed DT doing that confirmed red check.
And yes. when you have confirmed red check thats all the evidence you need. sucks if your a miller
So, your plan is to ignore all other evidence, kill a townie tomorrow and enter night 4 with no mafia and two wasted days. Boy, I sure like your plan, Mr. Scumbag!
Can I ask a stupid question? If this holds for millers and framed people, why does it not hold for godfathers? If Risen had said I was confirmed town, would I be above all suspicion? NO. Before starting to play, I read a game here, where a DT checked a godfather and he got lynched anyway, but I can't find it anymore (maybe one of the veterans remembers it). So why hold "red is dead" as a holy grail, when a green check is maintained as suspect?
Do you normally lynch your strongest town reads?
detectives would be pretty useless then wouldn't they?
On March 28 2012 01:21 Jitsu wrote: Also, real-life LOL at people who think I can sit down and read 50+ pages of a thread in one sitting after joining the game 12 hours ago when I worked last night.
Shit is jokes.
You're lucky you aren't replacing chaoser. Everybody thought he was scum, so the day I replaced him, they lynched me.
On March 28 2012 22:25 Lyter wrote: Hmm, the shit appears to have hit the fan today. I guess if the pm is real, then there was maybe a framing as we've already said back when risen was alive. Fuck knows what would happen then though, would it just a case of 'tough shit town, -1 tracker for you?'
We already knew that this was a possiblity last night. Why bring it up again in this way?
On March 29 2012 08:02 wherebugsgo wrote: Wtf does that have to do with evantrees being scum?
Just read his filter, it'll take you all of 30 seconds.
zealos and lyter are way worse.. why am i even bothering talking to you... remember risen?
Lol wut? How are they worse than a player who has posted...8 times?
Also, you voted Risen too, dipshit.
I would have voted Acro if I thought that it wouldn't lead to a scum decision. If I switched to acro it would have been 9 to 5 meaning only 2 scum have to switch to secure the lynch they want. I figured I'd trust in my fellow townies... lol... and I argued too vehemently against lynching risen to get called a dipshit over it.
You should probably stop arguing with WBG. Trust me, it will get you nowhere.
On March 29 2012 13:24 Alderan wrote: I've been away all day at a Game of Thrones premier in Atlanta (the second season is going to be awesome).
I'm happy to see that Greymist is finally being targeted. I've gotten scum vibes from him since Day 1, and he's done very little to support him being town since.
After some research, I noticed that your scum vibes on me resulted primarily from thoughts that I was too good to believe certain things about gumshoe (where has he run off to btw?). This was of course after you post this regarding risk.nuke:
On March 23 2012 04:19 Alderan wrote: Just threw in a lip. Let's see if I can't make some sense of the drivel so far in this thread (not a knock on anyone, Day 1 always sucks.
@risk.nuke: Greymist is suspicious to me yes, but for nearly none of the reasons you provided. His comment on wherebugsgo was a joke, at least that's how I took it when I read it. I don't think it was some secret agenda to try to divert town discussion at all (which notably was the entire point of your huge post). I want to wait on Gumshoe to come back before I comment anymore on Greymist though.
So at the time you wrote this were these other reasons just that you felt I was "too good" to be playing like I am?
I will have more ideas of where we should move as we get closer to the end of the night/the next day. I have some annoying meetings/tests during the next 2 days.
On March 29 2012 17:43 Zealos wrote: Lol, night time, derp. Though after reading over Grey's filter it does seem "Convineint" that whenever the town gets a false lead such as risen, he becomes quiet and leaves us to lynch him, no words for or agaisnt.
On March 30 2012 03:36 Zealos wrote: I really don't understand what makes me a good lynch target. Day 1 I called out Acro for being suspicious for his first post. I mean, I might have been trying to blend in, but it surely it would have been easier and less suspicious for Acro had I not said anything? Also, when Risen was being lynched anyway, surely as a mafia it would have been better to just vote and not say much, instead I was the one most pushing for the lynch. Why would I put the effort forward to do that as mafia if I knew that he was going to be killed anyway?
This is rather poor defense, and is strongly based in WIFOM. You could have put forth the effort to make a case against risen knowing that it would make you look more townish, and thus could have used it in a defense just as you are now.
On March 30 2012 19:13 Zealos wrote: I know, I won't vote until near the deadline for the voting thread. The votes in here is just my current desision.
I have to go o a funeral today, but I have enough of a spare moment to say: "what?"
Why not vote in the voting thread? its not like a vote there is set in stone, you have until the end of the day to alter it...
Sounds like someone is afraid of being committed to a vote, and is setting themselves up for an escape if need be
On March 31 2012 20:22 Zealos wrote: I'm voting for Grey because I think he's scum. If I try to make a case against him I become scum, because being an active townie makes you scum according to a lot of the people in this thread.
As for the case against Xata, I have to agree with what you've said, he's clearly quite a waffler, but I want to see him respond to it before taking a firm stance (Does this make me mafia too? )
You haven't made a real case against me, that's why you become scum
On March 31 2012 20:22 Zealos wrote: I'm voting for Grey because I think he's scum. If I try to make a case against him I become scum, because being an active townie makes you scum according to a lot of the people in this thread.
As for the case against Xata, I have to agree with what you've said, he's clearly quite a waffler, but I want to see him respond to it before taking a firm stance (Does this make me mafia too? )
You haven't made a real case against me, that's why you become scum
Hey GreyMisT, I didn't know you were here lurking, lol jk. I know you're here lurking. I also know you're mafia because this is an important day to lynch scum but you don't do anything or push anything. Because you're scum and already under alot of heat. So pushing hard for another townie lynch would spell the end for you. Which you probably realised which is why you aren't pushing very hard for my death. At the same time you don't want to bus. So you lurk and do nothing.
Was right about gumshoe/his replacement, After I died I talked to jitsu (after he died of course) and told him i thought the team was gum, chaoser, and xat. Damn.
I will admit I got frustrated and lost interest in this game pretty fast. I found it very difficult to invest time into a thread that was trolltastic from day 1.
EPT
