TL Mafia LII: JubJub Mafia - Page 3

On March 13 2012 20:41 VisceraEyes wrote:
VisceraEyes Very Valid and Logical Lynch List

Caller
At first glance, you might think Caller is town simply because he's calling people out and gung-ho about every post. I'd like everyone to take into account that there are players here on TL that are capable of fearlessly posting regardless of their alignment or role.

That being said, I still feel strongly that Caller is scum manipulating town here. Going over his posts, I noticed a couple of themes:

1) Stifling discussion
2) Sowing insecurity/doubt
3) Lining up lynches

Just take a look at his first few posts, you'll see what I'm talking about.

Remember this post?

I'd like you to note a couple of things. First of all, please note the three bolded names. We've got Jackal, prplhz and Mr. Wiggles.

Jackal and Mr. Wiggles get at least mentioned - but I'm having a hard time seeing the point in bolding prplhz. The most odd thing is, if you go back and read prplhz' concern with Caller's case, it's exactly the same concern that Jackal had with Caller's case! I mean, prplhz is slightly more verbose, but the spirit of their argument is virtually identical - Caller's reason for choosing DocH is nonexistant, and his logic is terrible.

So why is prplhz not scummy for it but Jackal is? This is a question he's refused to answer in spite of being asked. As close as I can figure it, he has a problem with the fact that Jackal didn't use the word "retarded" in his post on the matter.

Anyway, he hardly mentions prplhz again in that post, in spite of his name being bolded. Mr. Wiggles at least gets an honorable mention at the bottom for "not wanting to offend anyone". I like Wiggles, he's a nice guy. He wouldn't want to offend anyone as town either sir...that's a null as fuck point on Wiggles. But don't worry - he's only automatically red if Jackal flips red....somehow. He doesn't really elaborate on why. Just kinda says it.

Caller is scum, and someone needs to be shooting the fuck out of him tonight.

prplhz
Oh, to be prplhz and scum. To be honest I thought he was town at first - but then I got around to his push on Jackal. But I'll get to that in a second.

First I want to talk about him calling out Caller. Now, Caller's case on DocH was scummy as fuck. It was baseless and made no fucking sense. Prplhz goes back and forth with Caller a couple of times, here are his posts.





Note the bolded statements: they imply that prplhz thinks that Caller is acting scummy (if prplhz = town, and town lynch scum and Caller is scum then prplhz lynches Caller...simple). But here's prplhz' very next post.



Let's take note of all the things prplhz says about Caller in this post.

1) bad lynch
2) useless
3) not scummy
4) no resistance to lynch (lol while resisting lynch)
5) scummy?

One of these things is not like the others - hilariously, that one thing is the the thing he was saying about Caller IMMEDIATELY PRIOR TO THIS POST. So which is it prplhz? Is Caller being dumb and useless, but townie? Or is he being maliciously dumb and useless because he's scum? Prplhz doesn't make mistakes like this as town.

Prplhz is scum and should be on our lynch docket tomorrow if he's not dead.

On March 14 2012 12:28 Bill Murray wrote:
I am going to be making a case on deconduo shortly, if he is still alive. I am still finishing up another game, but when I am done with that, I will be catching up on this one, and hunting some scum.

On March 14 2012 13:26 Curu wrote:
Mattchew that is just such an awfully stupid vote. Dead Townie does not = correct reads.

On March 14 2012 22:19 deconduo wrote:


If you are thinking of killing me because you think I'm scum then you're wrong. If its because I've been inactive then fair enough. I would be pushing for my lynch too. I'm stepping up my game though.

On March 14 2012 23:53 Curu wrote:
Mattchew's looking pretty damn bad too. After VE made the case on Caller he didn't say anything about it, choosing to go for BM instead and not even commenting on the case.

After VE dies the case is suddenly "very good" and he decides to go with it without once mentioning or commenting on it before. Then he tries to ridicule the Jackal58 case with some stupid quoting from the OP then when Palmar lays it on Jackal as well he starts softly "reconsidering." Smells like riding the bandwagon to me.

Think Town, if I was scum what motivation would I possibly have to push Jackal as hard and singlemindedly as I am? To kill a "blue?" The blue role claimed is more detrimental to Town than Mafia, if I was Mafia I'd happily leave him be and let him do whatever he wants.