EPTResurrection Mafia - Page 8
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
redFF
United States3910 Posts
| ||
|
sinani206
United States1959 Posts
Meta and policies aren't a good enough case for a lynch right now. The subject of Varpulis was a nice way to start discussion, but there's no need to tunnel. All of redFF's posts, however are very short and tangential, except for his analysis of Varpulis that was based entirely on meta. FoS redFF. | ||
|
redFF
United States3910 Posts
| ||
|
Ace
United States16096 Posts
On September 01 2011 11:57 jcarlsoniv wrote: Except...it would make sense that he would be "trying to look pro-town" if he were scum. The scum are the ones who would be "trying to look pro-town". He is posting guidelines that are delightfully obvious. The things he lists are things that should happen in any town, and it's the scum's job to want to make them happen. The people who are town are town. The people who are not town want to look town. I know you are a good scum hunter, Ace. And I know these are things you know. Why would you be so quick to refute the possibility of scum behavior? Everyone is trying to look pro-town. It prevents you from getting thought of as lynch bait. I'm not refuting the possibility of scummy behavior. I'm pointing out that something as inane as "he's trying to look pro-town" isn't going to help us find Scum. Town sided players also tend to look pro-town at times too you know? | ||
|
jcarlsoniv
United States27922 Posts
On September 01 2011 12:46 Ace wrote: Everyone is trying to look pro-town. It prevents you from getting thought of as lynch bait. I'm not refuting the possibility of scummy behavior. I'm pointing out that something as inane as "he's trying to look pro-town" isn't going to help us find Scum. Town sided players also tend to look pro-town at times too you know? Understood. But in the beginning, I think the little things tend to be nit-picked. Whether it may or may not be correct doesn't quite matter as much as generating the discussion to start finding the scum. | ||
|
bumatlarge
United States4567 Posts
| ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22634 Posts
Tunneling can be extremely useful. In my opinion (and quite contrary to most other people's opinion) the best environment to find scum is when everyone is shouting and emotional. Only problem with this is half the town is always unable to disconnect themselves from the shitfest and re-read for hunting scum. btw This sentence: "nice tunnel bro" = I think you're scum. ##Vote Varpulis | ||
|
Kenpachi
United States9908 Posts
Its the morning and im tired but who cares (ps. happy birthday ON, wasnt able to tell you on LoL) Im a townie and im sad because im not an awesome role that is the priest or the necromancer in an epic setup like this. le sigh my gut feeling is telling me that if varp is scum, his team doesnt consist of me I would also like a summary of these following players: Sknowman Wherebugsgo jcarlsoniv i dont know who these guys are and i would like to know if they are fellow lurkers or not. I want to say varpulis is scummy but i have seen too many useless introductory posts that i dont know anymore. Aside from that i want to bring your attention to this: On September 01 2011 12:31 sinani206 wrote: /confirm Meta and policies aren't a good enough case for a lynch right now. The subject of Varpulis was a nice way to start discussion, but there's no need to tunnel. All of redFF's posts, however are very short and tangential, except for his analysis of Varpulis that was based entirely on meta. FoS redFF. On September 01 2011 12:36 redFF wrote: wait why are you fosing me? Red was pretty senseless in posting this. Instead of atleast justifying or defending himself, he asks what does not need to be asked. fos redff | ||
|
Kenpachi
United States9908 Posts
bye guys | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
On September 01 2011 17:54 Kenpachi wrote: I would also like a summary of these following players: Sknowman Wherebugsgo jcarlsoniv Sknowman is active as town and more lurky as scum. I've only played one game with Wherebugsgo and he was a very active scumhunter as town. | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22634 Posts
I think that'd be a good way to start the game. Also, if sandroba doesn't start posting I'd be fine with lynching him. I think redFF and chaos13 are almost definitely town, but I need more evidence to be conclusive. | ||
|
bumatlarge
United States4567 Posts
| ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22634 Posts
On September 01 2011 21:43 bumatlarge wrote: Ill talk about wherebugsgo later today. Let's say I'd make him out to be similar to sandroba in terms of intelligence I don't know what that means to you, but Sandroba is one of the stronger players in this game. Wherebugsgo has the ambition and time, but he's still relatively new. Like, Sandroba is in my "If he's wrong, he's scum" category. | ||
|
Drazerk
United Kingdom31255 Posts
only scanned through the thread so far but I have FoS on Varp / 206 Ill post a bit more later but those are my main suspects for now. | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
On September 01 2011 21:32 Palmar wrote: So how about we lynch Varpulis and jcarlsoniv? I think that'd be a good way to start the game. Also, if sandroba doesn't start posting I'd be fine with lynching him. I think redFF and chaos13 are almost definitely town, but I need more evidence to be conclusive. I'm hesitant on Varpulis, but I certainly don't get a good feeling from him. I can read his reaction as either a scum pissed off at votes coming in on D1 or as town being frustrated against a weak argument. I see jcarlson as either probable town or strong scum. He seems like a solid player either way, but a the moment I'm leaning town on him and would not be okay voting for him. redFF is probably town. This is his usual sort of town play - FoS everyone and everything for anything at all. When scum he lurks more. | ||
|
jcarlsoniv
United States27922 Posts
On September 01 2011 17:54 Kenpachi wrote: ok sorry guys. i had to sleep early to wake up early but i never slept so i never woke up. Its the morning and im tired but who cares (ps. happy birthday ON, wasnt able to tell you on LoL) Im a townie and im sad because im not an awesome role that is the priest or the necromancer in an epic setup like this. le sigh my gut feeling is telling me that if varp is scum, his team doesnt consist of me I would also like a summary of these following players: Sknowman Wherebugsgo jcarlsoniv i dont know who these guys are and i would like to know if they are fellow lurkers or not. I want to say varpulis is scummy but i have seen too many useless introductory posts that i dont know anymore. Aside from that i want to bring your attention to this: Red was pretty senseless in posting this. Instead of atleast justifying or defending himself, he asks what does not need to be asked. fos redff You want a summary of 3 players after literally 2 pages of play? You can't take 10 minutes to ready through to find what we posted, but you have time to find what sinani posts and accuse Red of being scum. What Red posted is not senseless at all. Here Red is, pressuring Varp at the very start of the game, giving analysis (correct or not), getting reactions. I think it's definitely warranted for Red to ask why he's being FoSd. Tunneling works. It puts pressure on an individual, and obtains reactions from the other individuals. It exposes those who are grouping together. So far, I see: Varpulis Kenpachi sinani grouped through defenses. Also: On September 01 2011 21:32 Palmar wrote: So how about we lynch Varpulis and jcarlsoniv? I think that'd be a good way to start the game. If you absolutely wanted to lynch me, whatever. It would be a waste of a lynch, AND I would like to see some reasoning behind it. If you're lynching me because I'm lurking, well then read the last 2 freaking pages again. I'm not lurking even a little bit. On September 01 2011 21:32 Palmar wrote: I think redFF and chaos13 are almost definitely town, but I need more evidence to be conclusive. I don't necessarily disagree, but chaos13 has not posted much at all that would let me lean either way. I'm neutral on him at the moment. And I'll also be watching Red. While I agree with him that Varp seems scummy, some of the best scum hunters can turn out to be scum. They kinda cheat =) | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22634 Posts
On you, however, I'm leaning towards scum. | ||
|
jcarlsoniv
United States27922 Posts
On September 01 2011 22:41 Palmar wrote: Let's turn the question around, why should I not want to lynch you? Because it is a wasted lynch. If you really want to lynch me, I know there's little I can do to stop it. But if you lynch me, you're wasting a spot that could be used on scum. All you've done so far in this game is post observations and summarizing the events already going on. Most of the point of the game is to post observations...that's how you learn things. Not all too much has happened yet. There's only 2 pages of play thus far. I just made my own post on Kenpachi, but I suppose that was just "summarizing the events already going on" too? I'm not saying red is town because I think he's good at scumhunting. I read the thread and draw my own conclusions. redFF is not a bad player, so after reading his posts I'm leaning towards town right now. On you, however, I'm leaning towards scum. You're wrong. | ||
|
redFF
United States3910 Posts
On September 01 2011 12:31 sinani206 wrote: /confirm Meta and policies aren't a good enough case for a lynch right now. The subject of Varpulis was a nice way to start discussion, but there's no need to tunnel. All of redFF's posts, however are very short and tangential, except for his analysis of Varpulis that was based entirely on meta. FoS redFF. this is not a good reason to fos and actually makes little to no sense. current scumteam imo=varpulis, sinani, ace if i had to name it right now. i have ON as town, going out see ya guys later. | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
On September 01 2011 23:08 redFF wrote: this is not a good reason to fos and actually makes little to no sense. current scumteam imo=varpulis, sinani, ace if i had to name it right now. i have ON as town, going out see ya guys later. On September 01 2011 21:32 Palmar wrote: So how about we lynch Varpulis and jcarlsoniv? I think that'd be a good way to start the game. Also, if sandroba doesn't start posting I'd be fine with lynching him. I think redFF and chaos13 are almost definitely town, but I need more evidence to be conclusive. How do you guys do this just 12 hours into a game? I still think everybody is scum. | ||
| ||
