TL Mafia XLIII - Page 37

On August 07 2011 05:38 Munk-E wrote:
The epic fight between DrH and BC for who the real medic is commences!

I would like to mention that the reason I am doing this is NOT because I think jeejee is innocent, I absolutely think he is Mafia, I just don't see how voting or analysis would help since he's in the vast majority of votes already. Since we have already figured out there is only going to be 1 medic, I am trying to figure out which of DrH or BloodyC0bbler is mafia.

The first thing to note is that BC didn't vote for varp day 1. DrH DID change to varpulis, but only after the score was 6 to 3 with varp leading. I realize this was before the super big bandwagon vote, but for all I know, DrH could have seen that as the opportune time to switch to avoid suspicion. It does seem like the perfect time and he is experienced at this game i hear.

As for this vote, They both are voting for JeeJee. However BC voted for him near last after it was obvious he was going to be killed no matter what practically. He qualified doing this by saying he forgot to vote. I'm not sure how much I believe this. Meanwhile DrH voted at a modestly normal time. Almost TOO normal, like right in the middle again, where bandwagon hopping wasn't an issue.

BC put a lot of pressure on JeeJee this round BEFORE the mass voting really began! He did vote for JeeJee last time too, so he could quite easily just be sticking to his guns! DrH however states that he often changes his mind. What I find weird about DrH is that he's never really accusing anyone. He frequently cites other people as his arguments against who he's lynching. I'm guessing since he's a veteran player, he feels comfortable just talking in the thread. A lot of his posts don't contribute at all. Furthermore, he seems to be trying to run the game. It feels like he's currently in a state where no one really suspects him at all due to activity. The only other mafia game I played iGrok did the same thing and he was regarded the same way. He ended up being GF.

In the end, BC has been after jeejee since the he first attacked him. He has continued to add (Rather compelling) evidence against jeejee. I think he did just forget to vote. While he's here proving his case, DrH is content to just blend in and appear active. For these reasons I am compelled to think DrH knew when to jump on the bandwagons. It is a close call, but in the end i think BloodyC0bbler is the real medic.

##vote DoctorHelvetica

On August 07 2011 06:13 Munk-E wrote:
First and foremost, may I say, SWEET! GF! HECK YEAH!

Next I would like to say that, unless someone has a better plan, I recommend both alleged medics protect each other. That way, we can either have a dead medic and a confirmed mafia, or an alive medic.

On August 07 2011 06:15 syllogism wrote:
Don't tell who is going to protect whom, just make sure one of the medics is protecting mig and one is protecting the other

On August 07 2011 06:17 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
i dont wanna defend myself too much but can i just say that when people were casting all kinds of doubt on the varp lynch and calling it bad (jeejee immediately saying there was no reason for it on day 2) i was the one who really pushed it in irc. it was large parts a gut read but my feeling was strong. there was a golden opportunity to switch onto drazerk or lucidity on day 1 and knowing my ability to get town to stupidly follow whatever i say, if i were scum i guarantee varpulis would not have been lynched on the first day lol

On August 07 2011 06:18 DoctorHelvetica wrote:

good point. i won't necessarily be protecting mig. i'll PM bc and we'll RNG who we protect between the other medic and mig. this will confuse the mafia a bit.

On August 07 2011 06:28 TheAwesomeAll wrote:
i voted on jeejee before it was cool :3

On August 07 2011 06:29 Munk-E wrote:

I still don't completely buy that there's 2 medics. How do I know that you're not mafia, and you convince BC to protect you and lynch BC, or vice versa? Or you could kill mig and say BC was supposed to protect him.