TL Mafia XLIII - Page 2

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 02 2011 22:19 GMT

#322

On August 03 2011 07:14 OriginalName wrote:
BIG IRC LOG POST INCOMING
+ Show Spoiler +

[16:49] <@Kurumi> ok ok
[16:49] <youngminii> not that anyone cares
[16:49] <@Kurumi> hm
[16:49] <CUru> hey munk e
[16:49] <@Kurumi> dropbear would care
[16:49] <@Kurumi> but he isn't playing
[16:49] <CUru> who do you think is scummy?
[16:49] <Munk-E> Mainly mig
[16:49] <Munk-E> but i'm also analysing varp
[16:49] <Munk-E> and lucidity
[16:49] <youngminii> oh look syllogism told mig that we're talking about him and now mig is here
[16:50] <Lucidity> lol
[16:50] <youngminii> /talkingoutofmyass
[16:50] <Munk-E> Oh snap when did he get here?
[16:50] <mig__> just got here I was just in irc until I had to disc like 15 min ago lol
[16:50] <mig__> maybe longer
[16:50] <OriginalName> it was like
[16:50] <OriginalName> an hour ago
[16:50] <OriginalName> when you dced
[16:50] <mig__> k
[16:52] <CUru> ym why would you want to lynch mig day 1?
[16:52] <CUru> he has a ridic track record of finding scum
[16:52] <DoctorHelvetica> i agree with curu
[16:52] <youngminii> oh that's fair enough reason to not lynch him actually
[16:52] <DoctorHelvetica> wait on mig
[16:52] <youngminii> yeah
[16:52] <CUru> scum would be much more afraid of him than town
[16:52] <syllogism> mig was mean to him so he started tunnelling the most active player in a game where the thread is pretty dead, standard
[16:52] <youngminii> ok unvoting
[16:52] <CUru> if hes scum then we can tell when he doesnt find any scum
[16:53] <youngminii> splendid work syllogism, as usual
[16:53] <syllogism> it's true
[16:53] <OriginalName> So
[16:53] <OriginalName> are we down to Varpu/Lucidity
[16:53] <OriginalName> for likely suspects?
[16:53] <youngminii> what, the fact that your backseat sheeping is splendid?
[16:53] <syllogism> what am I sheeping
[16:53] <OriginalName> On Mig
[16:54] <syllogism> on what
[16:54] <OriginalName> when he could theoretically be perfectly wrong
[16:54] <OriginalName> and your just not doing any of your own thinking
[16:54] <youngminii> on literally everything he has done this game
[16:54] <OriginalName> on his lynches
[16:54] <OriginalName> Syllogism
[16:54] <youngminii> i'm not even kidding, you're just following his every single thought
[16:54] <OriginalName> you are not mig
[16:54] <syllogism> i've been talking to him and a few others all game on skype
[16:54] <OriginalName> think for yourself
[16:54] <youngminii> you mean on quicktopic?
[16:54] <syllogism> you apparently dont know me very well
[16:54] <syllogism> if you think i dont think for myself
[16:54] <OriginalName> but you havent shown that yet
[16:54] <OriginalName> at all
[16:54] <OriginalName> ._.
[16:54] <syllogism> in thread yes
[16:55] <OriginalName> THEN SHOW IT IN THE GOD DAMNDED THREAD
[16:55] <OriginalName> THATS WHERE IT MATTERS
[16:55] <youngminii> you haven't shown it in irc either
[16:55] <OriginalName> I dont give a fuck about your private behind closed doors shit
[16:55] <syllogism> it's a channel with 15 people
[16:55] <OriginalName> i want to see it
[16:55] <syllogism> not exactly ideal
[16:55] <youngminii> so you're showing it in your PMs to mig
[16:55] <@Kurumi> I like turtles
[16:55] <OriginalName> Because afaik your just sheeping
[16:55] <syllogism> what am I sheeping, you still havent said
[16:55] <OriginalName> Kurumi are you trying to troll me cause of WaW2?
[16:55] <Lucidity> how is it more ideal to show to 1 person syllogism?
[16:55] <Lucidity> lol
[16:55] <OriginalName> ._.
[16:55] <syllogism> all i've done is argue against bad logic by YM
[16:55] <youngminii> wtf
[16:56] <youngminii> you can't see what you're sheeping
[16:56] <youngminii> oh my god
[16:56] <syllogism> Lucidity: it's not one
[16:56] <youngminii> oh my god
[16:56] <youngminii> i can't
[16:56] <youngminii> handle this
[16:56] <@Kurumi> I am not trolling anyone
[16:56] <@Kurumi> _^_
[16:56] <@Kurumi> I am hosting a game
[16:56] <@Kurumi> this is serious
[16:56] <@Kurumi> _^_
[16:56] <youngminii> syllogism's got to be the biggest troll
[16:56] <OriginalName> ._.
[16:56] <@Kurumi> but
[16:56] <@Kurumi> what happened
[16:56] <OriginalName> no
[16:56] <OriginalName> the turtle things
[16:56] <@Kurumi> I am not paying attention
[16:56] <OriginalName> shit
[16:56] <@Kurumi> aa
[16:56] <@Kurumi> I just like turtles
[16:56] <@Kurumi> _^_
[16:56] <OriginalName> mmk
[16:56] <Lucidity> is it just me or does
[16:56] <Lucidity> ( OriginalName ) So
[16:56] <Lucidity> ( OriginalName ) are we down to Varpu/Lucidity
[16:56] <Lucidity> 02,02 12,00 2302:125302.1234 02,02 02( OriginalName 02) for likely suspects?
[16:56] <Lucidity> scream scum?
[16:56] <OriginalName> because
[16:56] <Lucidity> lol
[16:56] <OriginalName> we want a solid lynch
[16:56] <OriginalName> not just
[16:56] <OriginalName> herp derp everyone off doing their own shit
[16:57] <OriginalName> Dont even try that scum shit on me
[16:57] <Lucidity> we're still 24 hours away from lynch
[16:57] <OriginalName> so what
[16:57] <OriginalName> we tookj
[16:57] <OriginalName> 24 hours
[16:57] <Lucidity> what possibly reason is there to start tunneling now
[16:57] <Lucidity> haha
[16:57] <OriginalName> to get that plan away
[16:57] <OriginalName> its gonna take 24 hours
[16:57] <youngminii> LOL
[16:57] <OriginalName> to get our shit together
[16:57] <syllogism> tunneling is fine if it creates discussion
[16:57] <OriginalName> Im starting early
[16:57] <DoctorHelvetica> no it doesnt scream scum lol
[16:57] <Lucidity> That's just asking, "Hey guys, who are the 2 candidates I can tag on to without upsetting shit?"
[16:57] <DoctorHelvetica> have you read
[16:57] <DoctorHelvetica> vers town guide
[16:57] <DoctorHelvetica> tunneling isnt a scumtell
[16:57] <DoctorHelvetica> jesus
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> town is more likely to do it than mafia
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> mafia want to plays afe
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> they go where the town goes
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> has no reason to tunnel
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> as long as mafia doesnt get lynched it doesnt matter lol
[16:58] <OriginalName> And i cant tunnel as scum
[16:58] <Lucidity> which is exactly what ON is doing?
[16:58] <OriginalName> i tried it once
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> what motivation would ON possibly have as scum
[16:58] <Lucidity> roflll
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> to tunnel you
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> because youre bad
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> if it was
[16:58] <alanismorisette> wow after that syllo now looks redic scummy
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> BC
[16:58] <OriginalName> it fucking
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> id understand
[16:58] <OriginalName> failed
[16:58] <Lucidity> I'm not saying he's tunneling he's scum
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> what
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> thats exactly what you said
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> wow
[16:58] <OriginalName> Lucidity
[16:58] <Lucidity> I'm saying he's asking the town for 2 safe candidates
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> lol
[16:58] <DoctorHelvetica> jesus
[16:58] <OriginalName> just
[16:58] <OriginalName> just
[16:58] <OriginalName> wow
[16:58] <OriginalName> ffs
[16:58] <Lucidity> ?
[16:59] <OriginalName> No
[16:59] <OriginalName> i give up
[16:59] <@Kurumi> wanna a replacement
[16:59] <@Kurumi> the next in the line is..
[16:59] <@Kurumi> Bill Murray
[16:59] <OriginalName> no
[16:59] <@Kurumi> so how about that?
[16:59] <OriginalName> Im not a ragequit
[16:59] <@Kurumi> kk whatever
[16:59] <OriginalName> im giving up on explaining
[16:59] <OriginalName> why I said that
[16:59] <youngminii> if bm was next in line
[16:59] <DoctorHelvetica> lucidity its normal if people have a suspicion to tunnel it
[16:59] <Lucidity> You think we found the scum
[17:00] <youngminii> i'd give my spot just to see him play
[17:00] <youngminii> again
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> because the towns goal is to kill a scum
[17:00] <Lucidity> in those 2 candidates?
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> if you think someone is scum
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> you tunnel them lol
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> thats the pro town thing to do
[17:00] <OriginalName> i think those two candidates
[17:00] <OriginalName> have the highest chances
[17:00] <OriginalName> of being scum
[17:00] <youngminii> i don't
[17:00] <Lucidity> with so little info out
[17:00] <OriginalName> From what i have deduced in the thread
[17:00] <OriginalName> Ok then
[17:00] <Lucidity> rofl
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> there is a lot
[17:00] <OriginalName> put more info in then
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> to analyse
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> already
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> lol
[17:00] <alanismorisette> wow@heist
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> we dont have flip info
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> but
[17:00] <Lucidity> There is a lot more to analyse
[17:00] <Lucidity> l
[17:00] <Lucidity> o
[17:00] <Lucidity> l
[17:00] <OriginalName> Lucidity
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> whats so funny
[17:00] <OriginalName> The OMGUS from that
[17:00] <OriginalName> doesnt help you
[17:00] <DoctorHelvetica> you know what i would do if i ws mafia id say
[17:00] <OriginalName> btw
[17:01] <DoctorHelvetica> "ignore the day 1 discussion ther eis no info nothing to analyse move on lol"
[17:01] <OriginalName> DrH is prob town
[17:01] <OriginalName> YM is meh
[17:01] <youngminii> ignore the day 1 discussion ther eis no info nothing to analyse move on lol
[17:01] <Lucidity> OMGUS?
[17:01] <OriginalName> I want to see more from BC
[17:01] <OriginalName> oh my god you suck
[17:01] <Lucidity> rofl
[17:01] <OriginalName> someone accuses
[17:01] <Lucidity> I know what it means
[17:01] <OriginalName> then you shout back
[17:01] <Lucidity> where did I do it?
[17:01] <DoctorHelvetica> when you said on is scum after he said youre scum
[17:01] <DoctorHelvetica> lol
[17:01] <DoctorHelvetica> jesus
[17:01] <Lucidity> no
[17:01] <OriginalName> [16:56] <Lucidity> ( OriginalName ) So
[17:01] <OriginalName> [16:56] <Lucidity> ( OriginalName ) are we down to Varpu/Lucidity
[17:01] <OriginalName> [16:56] <Lucidity> ( OriginalName ) for likely suspects?
[17:01] <OriginalName> [16:56] <Lucidity> scream scum?
[17:01] <Lucidity> You're completely misrepresenting
[17:02] <DoctorHelvetica> yes
[17:02] <@Kurumi> hey guys, just do what Ace recommended in Mini
[17:02] <DoctorHelvetica> that looks like omgus
[17:02] <@Kurumi> RANDOM LYNCH
[17:02] <Lucidity> It's scummy because he's asking the town for safe candidates
[17:02] <@Kurumi> jk jk :3 play mafia
[17:02] <Lucidity> not because i'm one of the 2 suspects
[17:02] <Lucidity> rofl
[17:02] <@Kurumi> now brb
[17:02] <DoctorHelvetica> its not scummy hes seeing if people agree
[17:02] <DoctorHelvetica> thats normal to do
[17:02] * chaos13_ is now known as chaos13away
[17:02] <DoctorHelvetica> no matter what side youre on
[17:02] <OriginalName> Its called checking your work
[17:02] <OriginalName> making sure im not completely off my rocker
[17:02] <Lucidity> horseshit
[17:02] <Lucidity> roofl
[17:02] <OriginalName> ...
[17:02] <OriginalName> fuck it
[17:02] <Lucidity> what work?
[17:02] <OriginalName> Lucid is soooooo scum
[17:02] <Lucidity> You haven't posted anything
[17:03] <OriginalName> ...
[17:03] <OriginalName> oh
[17:03] <OriginalName> my
[17:03] <OriginalName> god
[17:03] <OriginalName> ...
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
[17:03] * OriginalName facedesks
End of relevant conversation

Im going to point out the arguement between Lucidity and Me. Take what you will from it, but I think hes definitly up there on the scum leaderboard.

I already apologised for that on IRC. I thought you joined IRC and asked for 2 safe candidates. I didn't recognise your nick from the thread -.-

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 02 2011 22:34 GMT

#328

I think you missed one of Varpulis' important posts Munk-E:

On August 03 2011 03:23 Varpulis wrote:

Show nested quote +

I got called out for wishy washiness in PTP (day 1) as well. Day 1 nothing is solid, there's rarely anything to base arguments off of until late in the day, and I'm usually focused on proving my activity, not calling people scum. I haven't taken a stance because I don't have a really strong feeling about anybody yet.

By the way, if we're going ahead with the plan, could we have a soldier/sniper claim? If there are none we need to reevaluate.

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 03 2011 09:53 GMT

#359

Drazerk did indeed act in a similar way in AA and he ended up being town. That doesn't mean we should allow him to act that way again, but it doesn't indicate that he's scum right away to me. Between the two I'd rather lynch Varpulis at this point.

Someone who is also bugging me is Curu. In AA he was a very aggressive scum hunter. In here he has only commented on the plan and made some jokes.

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 03 2011 09:55 GMT

#360

The similar way being "Trying to start a wagon and then disappearing". I didn't notice his IRC habits.

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 03 2011 16:58 GMT

#392

On August 04 2011 01:44 Curu wrote:
Varpulis is currently on pace to be modkilled.

Consider letting him die because of that and finding someone else to hit with the lynch, we have a few hours.

Is there some benefit to the town that this double lynch would accomplish that I'm missing?

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 03 2011 17:05 GMT

#394

Well let's wait for Kurumi to clarify what will happen first.

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 03 2011 22:04 GMT

#418

!@#$

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 04 2011 12:28 GMT

#516

I really doubt that's the entire scum team right there. There's no way they'd all do the same thing. But I feel like there's at least one scum in there. Repeat of AA gotime?

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 04 2011 22:45 GMT

#569

Please do not claim to Mig.

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 05 2011 12:37 GMT

#615

On August 05 2011 10:37 Curu wrote:
18 out of 21 Players are alive.
15 out 17 Town aligned players are left.
3 out of 4 Mafia team are left.
Mafia KP is #/2 rounded up.
Mafia KP now is 2.

Where Mafia KP is down. Durr.

Anything above 2 KP = oh look he was right he's a Vig. Vig is easily self confirmable. TAA fakeclaiming Vig as scum is beyond stupid.

This is quite obviously wrong. It doesn't prove that he's a Vig at all. It proves that there is A Vig out there. Does it have to be TAA because he claimed? No.

I don't understand why you'd make that post though. Are you trying to push the case that it's a terrible move as scum? So that it looks unlikely that TAA is scum? The logic is too obviously wrong to be a mistake o_o

Do Vets and targets who were med protected get notified when they are hit?

Do players get notified if they are Role Blocked? Even if they are scouts?

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 05 2011 13:35 GMT

#618

On August 05 2011 10:42 OriginalName wrote:

Show nested quote +

TAA is likely just an idiot townie, we had a long dissucssion on it. I highly reccommend you read both IRC logs i posted.

Lucidity is my biggest scumread at the moment:

Primarily because

-Scum didnt try to really divert the wagon to him despite him having some votes in the middle of the day.
-His reactions on IRC while could be being misrepresented say quite alot on the subject.
-Keeps casting doubt on Mig despite his supposed role and all his actions during D1 (Which were quite Pro-town)

I need to go over his posts one more time but it will probably be tommorrow when I have a clearer head, i sometimes find the need to step away from a game for a sec so when i come back i can reevaluate and maybe catch things i didnt find the day before etc.

+ Show Spoiler +

[17:48] <BloodyC0bbler> i suddenly like
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> your day 1 finger pointing
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> at lucidity
[17:49] <redFF1> :O
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=249971&currentpage=8#156
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=249971&currentpage=29#569
[17:49] <redFF1> yeah
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> keep in mind mig
[17:49] <redFF1> i dont like him
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> isnt 100%
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> but
[17:49] <redFF1> yeah
[17:49] <redFF1> those 2 posts
[17:49] <redFF1> contradict
[17:49] <Lucidity> Mig is not a confirmed townie
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> are very
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> hes not
[17:50] <BloodyC0bbler> but seriously dude
[17:50] <Original|Laptop> Mig is very close to confirmed
[17:50] <BloodyC0bbler> who the fuck
[17:50] == Lucidity [~nnscript@Lucidity.users.quakenet.org] has quit [Quit: ( www.nnscript.com :: NoNameScript 4.22 :: www.esnation.com )]
[17:50] <BloodyC0bbler> shoots trotske
[17:50] <Original|Laptop> oh lol
[17:50] <Original|Laptop> Lucid
[17:50] <Original|Laptop> fucking leaves
[17:50] <Original|Laptop> after he knows hes wrong
[17:50] <BloodyC0bbler> rofl
[17:50] <Drazerk> lol
[17:50] <Original|Laptop> and grasping
[17:50] <Original|Laptop> wow
[17:50] <Original|Laptop> thats so sad
[17:50] <BloodyC0bbler> "oh shit i got caught"
[17:50] <Original|Laptop> I didnt like him before
[17:50] <Original|Laptop> But im almost sure now
[17:50] <Original|Laptop> Hes trying to cast doubt on Mig
[17:50] <Kenpachi_> loool
[17:51] <BloodyC0bbler> http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=249971&user=86738
[17:51] <BloodyC0bbler> add in that
[17:51] <BloodyC0bbler> he liked idea of day 2 confirmed
[17:51] <BloodyC0bbler> townie
[17:51] <BloodyC0bbler> -_-

On August 05 2011 18:14 Barundar wrote:
Mig is pretty clear town, he was already by night time for leading the varp lynch, and the missing kp in the day post just adds to that. I don't see a reason not to claim to him.

I'm not sure why no one can see this, but Mig is not confirmed town. The only way to confirm your role is to shoot someone in the Day or to die. Mig hasn't done either. Yes he looks very pro town. No he isn't confirmed.

I didn't ragequit IRC as is being suggested. This happened at approx 1am my time. I was tired and busy shutting down programs. I read the thread, I read a few lines on IRC. I replied and I quit. I didn't stay around, because I had plans of putting my head on my pillow, not arguing about Mig.

I think my position has produced some interesting results at least. This is my first game with BC, but everyone always suggests that he is a Veteran and an amazing player. The way he reacted to my position suggests otherwise:

[17:48] <BloodyC0bbler> i suddenly like
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> your day 1 finger pointing
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> at lucidity
[17:49] <redFF1> :O
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=249971&currentpage=8#156
[17:49] <BloodyC0bbler> http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=249971&currentpage=29#569

Here he contrasts me being pro-confirming to a confirmed townie and being against it when it's Mig. This is a terrible comparison, because Mig isn't a confirmed townie. He's trying to show me contradicting myself by misrepresenting the situation. Essentially scum painting.

[17:51] <BloodyC0bbler> http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=249971&user=86738
[17:51] <BloodyC0bbler> add in that
[17:51] <BloodyC0bbler> he liked idea of day 2 confirmed
[17:51] <BloodyC0bbler> townie
[17:51] <BloodyC0bbler> -_-

Again, he's implying that I'm contradicting myself. I wasn't. A Day 2 confirmed townie is great. Mig isn't one of those.

Why would such a great player make such silly mistakes?

Now, I've had a slight uneasiness with Mig ever since he PMd me early on Day 1.

+ Show Spoiler +

Original Message From Mig:
Hey,

I really like your observations and I agree with most of what you had said.

Varp starts off with attempting to appear super pro town but shortly after he falls into making bland vague statements without taking any stands.

Varp and chaos both attacked trotske and both had very poor reasoning behind their attacks. Along with that I think there were logic errors in both of their arguments against sand's plan. Definitely very suspicious of both of them, although chaos' post defending himself against syllo made him seem a bit more townie to me.

Drh really not sure yet. I am not familiar enough with his meta. BC has said that Drh is fearless as scum and very willing to push mafia objectives openly. Where as when he is town he is a lot less sure of himself. So right now I would lean slightly scum but I really want to see him call some people out and see him do some scum hunting before I feel strongly one way or the other about him.

Besides them I have been in contact with bc/sandro/curu/syllo I feel like at least one of them is very likely scum just from a balance perspective. Right now I would lean curu being scum because he hasn't been nearly as aggressive as he was in AA as town. However that is just an early suspicion.

Show nested quote +

As you can see I made a very basic reply. He replied with, "I really like your observations!". To me that's not how a townie would react. It's almost as if he's trying to make me like him by complimenting a bland analysis, agreeing with what I had to say. This is something that scum does. They want you to like them. They want you to trust them. When two townies interact in PMs they are both suspicious of the other one. They don't try to have the other like them, because he could be scum. Obviously this doesn't make Mig scum, but it didn't sit well with me and I was wary of him ever since this exchange.

In AA we had a similar scenario where Palmar effectively lynched scum on his own on Day 2. Many people hailed him as a confirmed townie and advocated a mass claim to him. Palmar turned out to be an anti-town role.

Mig appears very pro-town at the moment, but he is not confirmed town. I don't like mass claiming to non-confirmed town.

I have to ask though, why are people so keen to mass claim to him? If he is town, then we gain the benefit of an organised night. If Kenpachi's RB claim was real, then we also more than 4 Blue's most likely, which makes night organisation more useful. If Mig is red though, we lose every blue in the game? It's a gamble when we don't need to take one. I don't like it.

TAA's claim is confusing. It's bad as either town or scum. While there are occasions where it is acceptable to lie as Town (RoL in AA for example. His plan was good and had the chance to work), this wasn't one of them. There was absolutely no pro-town outcome on the cards. Then again, I can't see the pro-scum outcome either? Other than possible confusion? But that's quite risky for minimal reward. It's fucked. If we don't find a real scum candidate (i.e. one who actually acted pro-red) we should turn to LAL. It has the added benefit of discouraging townies from lying in the future too.

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 05 2011 13:37 GMT

#619

On August 05 2011 22:27 Kurumi wrote:
Everything is in the OP besides vets getting notified of losing lives. They are notified .

Cool beans.

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 05 2011 13:38 GMT

#620

"Here he contrasts me being pro-confirming to a confirmed townie "

Sorry that was pro-claiming to a confirmed townie.

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 05 2011 16:31 GMT

#627

That's simply not true. He "breadcrumbs" that he's going to kill X. X dies. Mafia killed X -.-

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 05 2011 17:37 GMT

#635

On August 06 2011 01:32 Curu wrote:

Show nested quote +

Then there's only 2 KP in the night and he's not confirmed Vig.

Herp.

Not true. Another Vig could have killed a 3rd player. Scum/Vigs could hit a Vet/Med protected player etc. The fact is there are too many variables to confirm the player at night.

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 06 2011 18:02 GMT

#701

I've got stuff to do and places to be. So:
+ Show Spoiler +

19:37.21 ( taa ) i think
19:37.27 ( taa ) chaos is the 4th scum
19:37.45 ( taa ) like
19:37.54 ( taa ) he tries to divert the votes to munk e
19:41.05 ( ON|AFK ) taa
19:41.07 ( ON|AFK ) wait till
19:41.10 ( ON|AFK ) jeejee flips
19:41.12 ( ON|AFK ) to speculate
19:41.14 ( ON|AFK ) on scum number
19:41.15 ( ON|AFK ) lol
19:41.17 ( taa ) ok
19:42.53 ( Lucidity ) I don't think any scum is under the illusion that the vote can jump to someone else
19:42.53 ( taa ) Wishy-washy doesn't even begin to explain this. He just won't make up his mind! While I'm not sure this indicates him 100% as being scum, it is VERY suspicious. Unfortunately however, I don't think it's possible to brand him as scum from JUST this. but he's certainly quite possibly scum.
19:43.00 ( Lucidity ) they're probably all on the bandwagon already
19:43.12 ( taa ) read that quote
19:43.13 ( taa ) lol
19:43.26 ( Lucidity ) Munk-E is mad scum
19:43.27 ( taa ) but he's certainly quite possibly scum.
19:43.33 ( Lucidity ) I was going to post chaos' analysis actually
19:43.43 ( Lucidity ) if JeeJee filps medic
19:43.49 ( alanismorisette ) yeah
19:43.51 ( Lucidity ) i think BC is scum
19:43.57 ( alanismorisette ) u guys are too set on lynching jeejee
19:44.05 ( alanismorisette ) Lucidity: if u think that why is ur vote on jeejee
19:44.11 ( Lucidity ) my vote is nowhere
19:44.14 ( Lucidity ) I haven't been here today
19:44.26 ( Lucidity ) I was just busy reading now
19:44.27 ( alanismorisette ) oh its not
19:44.29 ( alanismorisette ) k
19:45.01 ( Lucidity ) Munk-E was the much better candidate at the start of the day imo
19:45.07 ( Lucidity ) but JeeJee kind of dug his own grave
19:45.14 ( Lucidity ) culminating with his selfvote
19:45.23 ( Lucidity ) double you tea eff mate
19:46.00 ( Lucidity ) Why did Mig reveal the names of all the claimed medics?
19:46.06 ( Lucidity ) JeeJee was going to be lynched anyway
19:46.08 ( Lucidity ) there was no reason to
19:46.16 ( alanismorisette ) i guess he wants full disclosure
19:46.20 ( alanismorisette ) to town
19:46.22 ( alanismorisette ) ?
19:46.24 ( Lucidity ) But with the names out in the open, when the medics staart dying
19:46.32 ( alanismorisette ) Kurumi:
19:46.32 ( Lucidity ) he can say he wasn't the only one with access to the names

Voted JeeJee. If he's really medic he fucked up big time. Also BC should be looked at if he does. Will post more during Night 2 if that happens.

Munk-E is scummy scum scum. Basically I agree with the general vibe of chaos' post.

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 06 2011 19:59 GMT

#706

So you call me and Mig scummy. You post analysis on us. You never vote for us. You didn't vote for me on Day 1, because you thought that would make you look scummy. Have you forgotten about your previous posts? Why are you abandoning your two best suspects for drH and BC?

Why do we definitely have a DT?

Explain the 2 greedy scouts or whatever. That sentence confused me.

Lucidity

South Africa603 Posts

August 07 2011 11:47 GMT

#767

I'm also for Munk-E first, but they should both die so I don't think it matters much?

Could someone please post the case against me in the thread? I keep seeing myself on scum lists and being called scummy, but I'm not entirely sure why. I'd like to clear up any misconceptions so that we can focus on real scum.

I'll address the "cases" so far.

On August 07 2011 08:55 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
I find it very strange that no attention was put onto Lucidity when those bandwagons were split. JeeJee went onto Drazerk when Lucidity would have been the easier target for mafia. Both me and Mig felt very unsettled about that fact, I think a DT (if they exist) would be well fit to check Lucidity. YM is an unnecessary check, he's pretty damned as it is. I think the DT should throw their check on Lucidity or Munk-E at this point. JeeJee was fucked right off the bat and now it's clear the mafia tried to get behind BC on lynching Draz. If I'm DT I check Lucidity tonight. That's my advice.

JeeJee went to Drazerk, while Varpulis went to me. We only have 2 confirmed scum and they did different things. I'm not sure why I would have been the easier target for Mafia? From what I can see the case against me and Drazerk at that point was the same (voting for redFF), but Drazerk went lurker mode at that point, while I was still active. Drazerk would be the scummier one then? Also note Munk-E tagging on to the Varp wagon at the end when there was no way to change the outcome anymore. He didn't even want to vote for Varp as he found me more scummy........

On August 05 2011 07:58 Munk-E wrote:
Lucidity analysis!

Show nested quote +

this first post is very VERY for the plan to the point that he immediately calls scum on people for it. They both later attacked him for this, and Redff even voted to lynch him. I think he is WAY to for the plan here without even considering the consequences. It seems scummy to me to pressure people that disagree with you.

Show nested quote +

Here DH is defending himself from lucidity's aggressiveness quite well, however he just continues to press the issue. He is still calling scum for having a different opinion here. He would give an arm and a leg for this plan it seems at this point.

Show nested quote +

Here he votes for redFF (But doesn't actually vote for him). I find it strange that he's THIS passionate this early on in the game! I mean seriously WTF? He is given A LOT of reasons why the plan is dumb, but he refuses to hear it! He just keeps accusing!

Show nested quote +

By this point, most people were against the plan.
Yeah...
I'm not sure how much I buy that defense of "Oops, klutzy me! I thought there'd be more medics!" as an excuse to completely change his mind from "This plan is so good that everyone against it is obviously scum" to. "This plan is stupid!" This is the scummiest post I think he's made. I mean it would be hard to make that transition, and it losing popularity requires you to if your against it so hard and you want to be in the majority. and why would you want to be in the majority so bad? If you're scum.

Show nested quote +

This post astonished me. At first i thought since he voted for varp after it was the bandwagony thing to do. However, if you look at the time, at the time of this post Varp only had 2 votes for him from a while ago. This post sort of STARTS the bandwagon on varp! I don't know if this was intentional or not, but WTF! Up until now I was sure lucidity was scum, but this makes me wonder!

Show nested quote +

Here he is completely against the plan now. He was so for it at first and now is completely against it. He even states that no one is for it anymore. His backing of the plan is directly proportional to it's overall popularity. He just wants to blend in, like a chameleon that works for the mafia.

In the end, I just don't know! He's VERY scummy with his bandwagon hopping when it comes to the plan, and sure he only voted varp after the bandwagon was rolling, but he was in second and might have done that to avoid being lynched, not to seem inconspicuous.if varp had flipped town, i would think he'd definitely be mafia, but he started a bandwagon on varp, it may be accidental for all i know and he was just trying to distance himself, but it seems strange that he would do this.

P.S. sorry about not talking at night i didn't know it was a rule.

I think the main issue with this analysis is that of misconceptions.

[b]1) I'm scummy for attacking anyone who opposed the plan

This isn't really true. Go look at my posts. I pointed out BAD reasons for opposing the plan. At that point in the game I thought the plan was good, so I thought anyone against it for bad reasons was suspicious. drH had some epically bad reasons mixed in with valid ones. redFF only had bad ones and later parroted other people's valid concerns. From my perspective I thought scum was trying to stop a good plan.

2) I only changed my view only because popular opinion changed

I'm not sure the plan was scrapped at that point, but even if it was, I didn't change opinion randomly for no reason. If you look at the post just above mine, it points out there that more than 4 Blue roles is unlikely. Up until that point I had it in my head that all the roles mentioned were in the game, possibly multiple medics too. Looking back that seems a little silly in a game of 20 players, but yeah. At that point the benefits of the plan basically reduced to organizing 2/3 blue actions at night and with no way to report on it the following day. That wasn't worth it.

The last quote you site where I am against the plan and "a chameleon" is just a complete misrepresentation. If you read it properly again you'll notice that I am addressing certain players. drH/YM etc were whining non-stop on IRC and in the thread about this plan being useless etc etc, but they weren't discussing things they thought were worthwhile. So I called them out on it. Essentially they were wasting time and acting in a way scum would be - wasting time when they know they are and there is no reason to. The post had nothing to do with my views on the plan as you suggested.

I hope that clears things up.