EPT
TL Mafia XXXIX - Page 107
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
PaqMan
United States1475 Posts
| ||
Ver
United States2186 Posts
| ||
|
DropBear
Australia4429 Posts
On May 17 2011 03:53 AirbladeOrange wrote: I only recall stating that Jaminz was playing differently than last game we played with him because he was doing more analysis. I felt even if he was mafia it was good that he was more active than he was last game. I don't remember defending ilovejonn. At the time I said blues (vigilantes) should not use their roles because it was way too early to get a decent read on anyone to kill. Wasting a shot on a townie is worse than taking a small chance the vig will die at night. I did not feel compelled to do an analysis on people who voted for Kurumi. But I still say it would be a good idea. Splitting up votes helps hold people accountable for their actions and makes it wasier to weed out mafia who give poor reasoning for voting or just bandwagon. I don't think I ever attacked conversion, I only said he was being too aggressive. I thought Mig had a good chance of being mafia. I thought there was a good chance EternalMisfit was mafia. 1. You did defend ilovejonn. On May 06 2011 13:58 AirbladeOrange wrote: I remember ilovejonn being mostly a lurker in the last mafia game providing no real analysis. Why is he suspicious this game when he was acting the same way last game and was town? 2. 3. Why do you not feel compelled to do analysis on who voted for Kurumi? 4. Why did you think Mig was a good chance of being Mafia? You never really gave reasons. 5. Why did you think there was a good chance of EM being mafia? You never really gave reasons. Has anyone asked for replacement this round? Where are you redtooth? | ||
|
DropBear
Australia4429 Posts
On May 06 2011 07:00 AirbladeOrange wrote: Please don't use any vigilante actions now. It's way too soon without having much to go on. These percentages don't really mean anything and anyone advocating the use of our blue roles at this point is not having the town's best interests in mind. | ||
|
DropBear
Australia4429 Posts
On May 17 2011 08:43 kitaman27 wrote: I agree everyone should be posting, but I dislike it when a certain people are told to analyze specific people. It hides information about their motives since they are told who to push/defend. Everyone should be analyzing who they feel is most scummy. Ok that makes sense about not forcing specific people to analyse specific others, I was trying to get everyone talking again. On May 17 2011 10:46 kitaman27 wrote: -DropBear was real wish-washy. He was one of the first people to bring up sinani and pushed for his lynch day 3, but then he got cold feed on day 4. I'm also leaning town since this doesn't seem like a mafia reaction to me. I've never been wishy-washy. I've been very decisive in attacking sinani206 up until day 4 when I was confused by ilovejonn's selfvote. The posts defending sinani206 all came after this and showed my reasoning quite clearly. Jaminz also need to get in here and do some explaining other than how there aren't any medics, which we worked out 2 days ago. People who have been contributing heavily today: VarpuliS DropBear chaos13 kitaman27 Impervious Xedat Forumite The game has kind of reset to a mini in some respects, in which the townies are running around discussing things Day 1. I feel that there is maximum 1 mafia on this list and likely none at all. Note how the big lynch targets have been completely silent. | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
| ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
Orgolove and Impervious have both voted ilovejonn. I think it is highly likely that at least one of them is scum. Forumite, Xedat, and AirbladeOrange have all voted orgolove. I think it is likely that all three of them are town. AO is the only one I'm slightly uncertain of, and even then there is little evidence of him being scum. VarpuliS, DropBear, and myself have all voted redtooth. I think Varpuli and DropBear are both town along with me. | ||
GMarshal
United States22154 Posts
Event 1: Thunderstorm Minigame ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/OAKfS.jpg) A new game inside the game has appeared! With dark clouds rolling in, lighting is sure to strike, however there are only enough shelters to keep three people safe from harm, vote for the three people you want to ensure live through the storm! three people will be chosen at random from the remaining population to be hit by lightning this may kill them, or grant them superpowers, depending on their role, it may also impose hilarious post restrictions on those caught outside in the uranium rain! PM me these votes, the storm will hit in a number of hours equal to the prime square of the number of letters in the winner of the last GSL's team's mascot name, plus or minus the variance factor! + Show Spoiler + Since I wasn't around yesterday at the day post, I felt like I had to do this  | ||
|
Qatol
United States3165 Posts
On May 17 2011 14:29 Ver wrote: Just wanted to say I'm sorry that I haven't responded to various coaching pm's in the past 2 days but now that my game is in full force and I've gotten over 100 pm's already from it, I don't exactly have the time to keep up on this thread anymore and give meaningful advice. Best of luck to everyone. Send coaching PMs to me instead. | ||
|
Xedat
Germany358 Posts
I also find his inactivity very suspicious and he is on my list. I just think that lynching him would not give us as much information, he has to post at least once not to be modkilled, if he does post something and it looks scummy I might switch my vote to him. Redtooth's inactivity is almost incriminating him too much. He contributed a fair amount and then suddenly he is dead quiet, I think it might have to do with real life stuff he does. Look at his post history, his last post here was may 17th, his last post on TL may 18th. This is not to say that he is not scummy, I just think that lynching him might not give us any information and he would be modkilled regardless. | ||
|
Xedat
Germany358 Posts
| ||
|
Xedat
Germany358 Posts
| ||
|
GMarshal
United States22154 Posts
On May 18 2011 01:02 Xedat wrote: Do I understand it correctly that one has to make one post per day/night cycle and has to vote in the voting threat not to be modkilled? Correct | ||
|
DropBear
Australia4429 Posts
I looked back through ilovejonn's history and he has a strange habit of coming under suspicion often when he is town, this coupled with the fact that he was the alternative candidate to sinani206 makes feel better about him than the others. Jaminz I'm not entirely sure what to think. Imo these are the best three candidates. Arguments for redtooth: - Defended Irish and Amber - Repeatedly attacked Cthazsa - Repeatedly attacked Chaoser - Disappeared day 3 - Is experienced enough to potentially be godfather - Analysis by VarpuliS, someone I trust. Arguments for orgolove - Defended sinani206 - Only analysis has been on voting patterns, admits himself he wouldn't have caught GGQ and sinani206 - Little other contribution - Is experienced enough to potentially be godfather Arguments for Impervious - Given two replacements while four others were modkilled (Yes Node and Marsh I know this isn't supposed to be a reason [/b]- Pushed on a lynch of EM for information over sinani206 - Only real contribution is a wierd analysis of kitaman27 which doesn't really say anything - Low post count of kevconsim and Rising_Phoenix - On sandroba's list of doom just before he died - analysis by chaos13, someone I trust I was very suspicious of redtooth's attempted town control on night 1, he hasn't come out to explain himself. My vote remains on him. I'll check the thread in the morning, if it looks like redtooth will be modkilled I will switch to Impervious. | ||
|
AirbladeOrange
United States2574 Posts
| ||
|
Ver
United States2186 Posts
On May 17 2011 14:29 Ver wrote: Just wanted to say I'm sorry that I haven't responded to various coaching pm's in the past 2 days but now that my game is in full force and I've gotten over 100 pm's already from it, I don't exactly have the time to keep up on this thread anymore and give meaningful advice. Best of luck to everyone. Actually just pm qatol your questions. He can handle them. | ||
|
ilovejonn
Canada2548 Posts
##Vote: orgolove | ||
Mig
United States4714 Posts
Redtooth - He originally pushed extremely hard that Cth was mafia and tried to link him to chaoser as mafia as well. His voting has been completely useless. Day1 he voted for chaoser when he obviously wasn't going to be lynched. Day 2 he voted for Cth before switching to amber after the dt claim. Day3 he voted for himself pointlessly. Day 4 he was the very last person to vote for sinani and he didn't even bother posting in the thread about it. I guess he might just be a demoralized townie after every single thing hes done has been incorrect but I feel like he might have decided to just lurk after all his plans fell through to try and avoid attention. I also think hes a good candidate for GF. Orgolove is very suspicious. It especially doesn't feel right to me that on day3 he was lurking and could have given his opinion and vote to decide the EM vs sinani lynch but didn't. So if people wanted to vote and lynch him I would have no problem with it. Impervious- rising phoenix's posts were suspicious, sandroba seemed 100% sure he was scum, pushed for em and defended sinani and overall his posts just seem a little off to me. I went back and reread jaminz's posts and his long posts do make him look a bit more town. I am still suspicious of him for still contributing very little overall, and while he may have just voted at an unlucky time it is still extremely suspicious that he was the one who saved sinani on day3. So my top 3 lynch candidates would be red/orgolove/impervious. After them I have a 2nd tier consisting of jaminz/ilovejonn/AO. | ||
|
Xedat
Germany358 Posts
I made a little list of "inactive" people: Not voted until now: Jaminz,elmizzt,Mig,kitaman27,redtooth zero posts: redtooth one post: Jaminz (one post night) low post count: Airbladeorange, elmizzt,kitaman27 (each 3 posts) only posted during night: ilovejonn (1 post day, 4 night) | ||
|
Xedat
Germany358 Posts
| ||
| ||
