|
On April 28 2011 00:32 Protoss1 wrote:
I'm feeling more and more than Red and Yellow are on different sides of the town line, but I'm having a hard time figuring out which is which.
I still don't know why people think I should be the Day 1 vote... the only thing I've been guilty of is being new. I haven't been creating chaos or making random accusations and then silently backing away and letting other people argue it out and do my work for me.
If I get lynched, when does my role get revealed? (not sure if this should be in mod font, but I'm guessing you all can answer my question for me). Since I'm looking more and more likely to be lynched, according to the rules revealing your role is not against the rules, it's just frowned upon. Would revealing my role as a last ditch effort just serve to help the mafia more than the town?
For the last time: I am not scum.
You have 1 vote on you. Crack a beer and watch some porn dude.
Your role won't be revealed.
Role claiming to avoid a lynch works sometimes. Sometimes it doesn't. In this setup you could claim to be Winston Churchill's dog and we wouldn't know until after the game.
If you do wish to reveal your role to avoid a lynch odds are you'll be shot that night anyways.
|
On April 28 2011 00:40 purple2 wrote:Show nested quote +On April 28 2011 00:32 Protoss1 wrote:
I'm feeling more and more than Red and Yellow are on different sides of the town line, but I'm having a hard time figuring out which is which.
I still don't know why people think I should be the Day 1 vote... the only thing I've been guilty of is being new. I haven't been creating chaos or making random accusations and then silently backing away and letting other people argue it out and do my work for me.
If I get lynched, when does my role get revealed? (not sure if this should be in mod font, but I'm guessing you all can answer my question for me). Since I'm looking more and more likely to be lynched, according to the rules revealing your role is not against the rules, it's just frowned upon. Would revealing my role as a last ditch effort just serve to help the mafia more than the town?
For the last time: I am not scum. You have 1 vote on you. Crack a beer and watch some porn dude. Your role won't be revealed. Role claiming to avoid a lynch works sometimes. Sometimes it doesn't. In this setup you could claim to be Winston Churchill's dog and we wouldn't know until after the game. If you do wish to reveal your role to avoid a lynch odds are you'll be shot that night anyways.
Unfortunately I'm leading the vote right now, Blue has been gunning for me from just about Post #1 and Green also is voting, but I'm not sure how set he is.
|
But I do appreciate your advice, I might do just that. 
|
On April 28 2011 00:40 purple2 wrote:Show nested quote +On April 28 2011 00:32 Protoss1 wrote:
I'm feeling more and more than Red and Yellow are on different sides of the town line, but I'm having a hard time figuring out which is which.
I still don't know why people think I should be the Day 1 vote... the only thing I've been guilty of is being new. I haven't been creating chaos or making random accusations and then silently backing away and letting other people argue it out and do my work for me.
If I get lynched, when does my role get revealed? (not sure if this should be in mod font, but I'm guessing you all can answer my question for me). Since I'm looking more and more likely to be lynched, according to the rules revealing your role is not against the rules, it's just frowned upon. Would revealing my role as a last ditch effort just serve to help the mafia more than the town?
For the last time: I am not scum. You have 1 vote on you. Crack a beer and watch some porn dude. Your role won't be revealed. Role claiming to avoid a lynch works sometimes. Sometimes it doesn't. In this setup you could claim to be Winston Churchill's dog and we wouldn't know until after the game. If you do wish to reveal your role to avoid a lynch odds are you'll be shot that night anyways.
Role reveals in a no-flip game only cause wifom, and my policy is going to be to ignore them as far as making decisions, if someone has claimed I will check out their claim, only if after we pop our reveal power we find out that all the mafia are still amongst us. So yeah, claiming in a no flip game is not useful, and as far as I am concerned will not serve to deter the lynch
|
I'm not voting for you protoss1 because after more posts you actually do seem like a really newb town. I will be deciding on a candidate shortly.
|
On April 28 2011 00:48 Orange2 wrote:Show nested quote +On April 28 2011 00:40 purple2 wrote:On April 28 2011 00:32 Protoss1 wrote:
I'm feeling more and more than Red and Yellow are on different sides of the town line, but I'm having a hard time figuring out which is which.
I still don't know why people think I should be the Day 1 vote... the only thing I've been guilty of is being new. I haven't been creating chaos or making random accusations and then silently backing away and letting other people argue it out and do my work for me.
If I get lynched, when does my role get revealed? (not sure if this should be in mod font, but I'm guessing you all can answer my question for me). Since I'm looking more and more likely to be lynched, according to the rules revealing your role is not against the rules, it's just frowned upon. Would revealing my role as a last ditch effort just serve to help the mafia more than the town?
For the last time: I am not scum. You have 1 vote on you. Crack a beer and watch some porn dude. Your role won't be revealed. Role claiming to avoid a lynch works sometimes. Sometimes it doesn't. In this setup you could claim to be Winston Churchill's dog and we wouldn't know until after the game. If you do wish to reveal your role to avoid a lynch odds are you'll be shot that night anyways. Role reveals in a no-flip game only cause wifom, and my policy is going to be to ignore them as far as making decisions, if someone has claimed I will check out their claim, only if after we pop our reveal power we find out that all the mafia are still amongst us. So yeah, claiming in a no flip game is not useful, and as far as I am concerned will not serve to deter the lynch
How will you check them? Did you just claim dt?
|
On April 28 2011 00:49 Zerg1 wrote:Show nested quote +On April 28 2011 00:48 Orange2 wrote:On April 28 2011 00:40 purple2 wrote:On April 28 2011 00:32 Protoss1 wrote:
I'm feeling more and more than Red and Yellow are on different sides of the town line, but I'm having a hard time figuring out which is which.
I still don't know why people think I should be the Day 1 vote... the only thing I've been guilty of is being new. I haven't been creating chaos or making random accusations and then silently backing away and letting other people argue it out and do my work for me.
If I get lynched, when does my role get revealed? (not sure if this should be in mod font, but I'm guessing you all can answer my question for me). Since I'm looking more and more likely to be lynched, according to the rules revealing your role is not against the rules, it's just frowned upon. Would revealing my role as a last ditch effort just serve to help the mafia more than the town?
For the last time: I am not scum. You have 1 vote on you. Crack a beer and watch some porn dude. Your role won't be revealed. Role claiming to avoid a lynch works sometimes. Sometimes it doesn't. In this setup you could claim to be Winston Churchill's dog and we wouldn't know until after the game. If you do wish to reveal your role to avoid a lynch odds are you'll be shot that night anyways. Role reveals in a no-flip game only cause wifom, and my policy is going to be to ignore them as far as making decisions, if someone has claimed I will check out their claim, only if after we pop our reveal power we find out that all the mafia are still amongst us. So yeah, claiming in a no flip game is not useful, and as far as I am concerned will not serve to deter the lynch How will you check them? Did you just claim dt?
Check as in look back over it, not as in check them at night. Basically I'm saying that I'll ignore the claim until after their death, if and only if after we pop the power we find all the mafia to be amongst us. does that clear it up?
|
Orange, your analysis of green seems to me at least as much bullshit as green's analysis of red. Also, your strategy of voting for people one at a time until they post is ridiculous if you change your vote as soon as they post any random garbage. This is no pressure at all.
Protoss is playing so bad I have a hard time pinning him as either town or mafia. I don't want to hear any claims this early in the game.
I'm voting red. He has been useless so far and yellow made a good point. You jumping into his defense has intrigued me.
|
On April 28 2011 01:14 Blue1 wrote:
Orange, your analysis of green seems to me at least as much bullshit as green's analysis of red. Also, your strategy of voting for people one at a time until they post is ridiculous if you change your vote as soon as they post any random garbage. This is no pressure at all.
Protoss is playing so bad I have a hard time pinning him as either town or mafia. I don't want to hear any claims this early in the game.
I'm voting red. He has been useless so far and yellow made a good point. You jumping into his defense has intrigued me.
If we're using useless as a baseline for our votes I'd have to say terran1 wins that race.
|
Red2 seems like a good candidate for now, protoss1 initially responded hastily and scum like to my pressure, but he reacted calmly afterwards. I'm still watching you protoss1.
|
Terran1 has not posted yet. Being inactive is a null tell. Being active while pretending to be usefull while posting nothing of value is a scum tell.
|
Zerg, why are you instant bandwagoning all my votes? I can't say I dissagree with your logic, because you are voting the same as me, but I'd like a bit more content from you instead of mindlessly following all my votes.
|
On April 28 2011 01:29 Blue1 wrote:
Terran1 has not posted yet. Being inactive is a null tell. Being active while pretending to be usefull while posting nothing of value is a scum tell.
He has one post regarding when to use our reveal power. In that post he said he played in RoL's first exp game so he should be well aware of RoL's activity requirements. I am assuming that his is an issue of real life happenings and not being able to put in the time up to this point. I was not necessarily pointing an fos at him. However his inactivity either through lurking or an inability to get online does become an issue for us. At some point we will be forced to address it if it continues. If it does continue I'd rather deal with it today than in a lylo situation.
|
RoL, if a player doesn't vote, are you going to modkill?
|
On April 28 2011 01:26 Zerg1 wrote:
Red2 seems like a good candidate for now, protoss1 initially responded hastily and scum like to my pressure, but he reacted calmly afterwards. I'm still watching you protoss1.
I'm Sheriff.
|
On April 28 2011 01:14 Blue1 wrote:
Also, your strategy of voting for people one at a time until they post is ridiculous if you change your vote as soon as they post any random garbage. This is no pressure at all.
I think you aren't fully seeing my startegy, yes I do let off as soon as they post something, this is because later I can hold them to "you clearly saw the thread, you even posted _______ yet you failed to contribute" when building an argument, or if they actually posted well then I can commend them for it, let them post a one line spam of garbage to get my vote off them, I promise it will come back to haunt them, sooner rather than later.
That said, do you mind summarizing your argument against red? I see it as a "he is lurking" argument, which if is the case I am fine with, pressuring and even killing lurkers is fine by me. As I interpreted it you also want to lynch him because of the information it would reveal about my relationship with him? You realize that lynching for information is usually bad play right? Especially in a no flip game. If you are gunning for him for his inactivity/lurk then I can support that.
also Pink where the hell are you?
|
Pink is another issue we have to deal with.
RoL Can we request a mod kill?
It's going to suck hard if we have to use 2 lynches to get rid of inactives. Inactivity killed town in Exp 1
I have no intentions of losing due to the ambivalence of others.
|
I think you mean a replacement, not a mod kill, right?
|
On April 28 2011 06:31 yellow1 wrote:
I think you mean a replacement, not a mod kill, right?
Its indifferent, as long as we get rid of the issue one way or another.
So it seems our lynch right now is split between red and pink, I'm going to stick with pink because the lack of posting bothers me immensely.
|
On April 28 2011 01:51 Blue1 wrote:
RoL, if a player doesn't vote, are you going to modkill?
no, not immediately anyway. If someone is chronically missing votes by the end of the game I might consider giving them a ban, but overall I care about activity.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
