|
On January 30 2011 23:15 Jackal58 wrote:Show nested quote +On January 30 2011 13:35 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On January 30 2011 10:59 Jackal58 wrote:On January 30 2011 09:50 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
##Vote Jackal58
The only connection to Jonathan Swift is that he wrote a satire called "A Modest Proposal" which advocated eating children in poor Ireland to solve the hunger problem. That could be connected to the disappearance of bodies but its verrrrry tentative.
Jackal58 is the strongest clue connection aside from Shann I guess. But Shann could really fit anything and Q doesn't jump out as me as much as Carlos the Jackal does. I already discounted J. Swift. If you want to include what he wrote Gulliver's Travels has lots of stuff in it that matches up with things in the day post. I don't know if LSB went that far. Are links on the wiki pages used to generate clues?And if you're all going to go with Pirates=Terrorists you might want to describe this "chainsaw defense" to me. I might need it. A couple things wrong here: A. Saying "I already discounted J. Swift" as though you are some sort of authority on who can or can't be related via clue. I said there was another tentative connection through that work which is a pretty famous one in actuality. In fact GMarshall even quotes "A Modest Proposal" in his profile.
B. You assume "pirates" is the important aspect of the story. There are always red herrings. Very rarely (if ever) will anyones chosen profile fit all aspects without one being contradictory. Otherwise the game is too easy. C. The Chainsaw Defense is defending yourself by attacking someone else (typically your accuser). Basically you have to find someone that fits the story better than you do. I was responding to your perceived implication of my apparent attempt to connect Jonathan Swift to the clues.If you wish to include A Modest Proposal in the list of things a clue could point to feel free. If that's how you guts are doing clue analysis this game is going to be a slam dunk for red. I'm disappointed. I thought the chainsaw defense was going to be something much more exciting.
i don't understand your response
so we should utilize only your connection of J Swift. and not consider any others? if anything its more likely he'll connect AMP than gullivers travels since that work is quoted in gmarshall's profile. it would be stupid not to consider it
|
On January 30 2011 08:43 Jackal58 wrote:Show nested quote +On January 30 2011 08:24 Pandain wrote:Okay let's get this started. First off I like Wiggles clue analysis, I think it really is the best option that we have as far as pinning people from clues go. The link to gaara is pretty vaugue, and while possible, there are more connections to Jackal than Gaara. Furthormore, on an analysis view point, Jackal sticks out to me very heavily. While he's been posting alot, he hasn't contributed anything besides a very weak clue analysis that really I don't even see how that fits to the missing bodies. Obviously there is a slight connection(flight +teleportion), but its very weak. Furthormore, he's often just brought up stuff, but not sure at all. I'm not sure how to phrase this, but its like he's just offering it up and then not actually "saying anything." I hope you know what I mean. On January 29 2011 13:57 Jackal58 wrote:
Jonathan Swift? Gulliver's Travels? 18th century British Naval references?
Anybody up on their Lilliputians?
I'm going to bed. My head hurts. On January 29 2011 13:22 Jackal58 wrote:
Pandas eat bamboo. If Q was pissed at pandas he'd just make them all disappear.
I'm not seeing anything but the wall/gravel connection yet. And that's not all that strong. This isn't a "your sure mafia", rather a FoS. Jackal, you said you found clues to everyone's profile, mind sharing that? Actually there are 3 that really have no attachment unless you really stretch it. 1. chaoser Holden Caulfield - Catcher in the Rye doesn't set off anything 2. darmousseh Gaara - Gravel 3. CubEdIn Raiden - Teleportation - No bodies 4. GMarshal Jonathan Swift - Unless this includes Gulliver's Travels nothing but perhaps time period 5. shannn Q Omnipotent character that can do anything. Including everything in the day post 6. Node Dinosaur Comics Main Cast - Other than squashing log cabins not much 7. Jackal58 Ilich Ramírez Sánchez Comparing pirates to terrorists 8. DoctorHelvetica Thom_Yorke Eye Patch, Eraser, British 9. Mr. Wiggles Yossarian Bombardier, Missing peoples 10. Kenpachi Zaraki Kenpachi Captain, Eyepatch, Blood 11. Pandain Ling Ling Dead Panda. Not much. Perhaps this is the "puzzle" part. 3 that aren't connected?
Not a ton of evidence to go on, but no one has really found anything more convincing than jackal58. If anyone find anything more convincing in the next 3-4 hours I might switch my vote.
##Vote: Jackal58
Also remember also the first post mentioned that the setting is 18th century britain so it is unlikely that we should use references to britain or english people as evidence of guilt.
|
|
|
United States4264 Posts
On January 31 2011 06:40 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On January 30 2011 23:15 Jackal58 wrote:On January 30 2011 13:35 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On January 30 2011 10:59 Jackal58 wrote:On January 30 2011 09:50 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
##Vote Jackal58
The only connection to Jonathan Swift is that he wrote a satire called "A Modest Proposal" which advocated eating children in poor Ireland to solve the hunger problem. That could be connected to the disappearance of bodies but its verrrrry tentative.
Jackal58 is the strongest clue connection aside from Shann I guess. But Shann could really fit anything and Q doesn't jump out as me as much as Carlos the Jackal does. I already discounted J. Swift. If you want to include what he wrote Gulliver's Travels has lots of stuff in it that matches up with things in the day post. I don't know if LSB went that far. Are links on the wiki pages used to generate clues?And if you're all going to go with Pirates=Terrorists you might want to describe this "chainsaw defense" to me. I might need it. A couple things wrong here: A. Saying "I already discounted J. Swift" as though you are some sort of authority on who can or can't be related via clue. I said there was another tentative connection through that work which is a pretty famous one in actuality. In fact GMarshall even quotes "A Modest Proposal" in his profile.
B. You assume "pirates" is the important aspect of the story. There are always red herrings. Very rarely (if ever) will anyones chosen profile fit all aspects without one being contradictory. Otherwise the game is too easy. C. The Chainsaw Defense is defending yourself by attacking someone else (typically your accuser). Basically you have to find someone that fits the story better than you do. I was responding to your perceived implication of my apparent attempt to connect Jonathan Swift to the clues.If you wish to include A Modest Proposal in the list of things a clue could point to feel free. If that's how you guts are doing clue analysis this game is going to be a slam dunk for red. I'm disappointed. I thought the chainsaw defense was going to be something much more exciting. i don't understand your response so we should utilize only your connection of J Swift. and not consider any others? if anything its more likely he'll connect AMP than gullivers travels since that work is quoted in gmarshall's profile. it would be stupid not to consider it
Goddamit I HAVE MADE NO CONNECTION TO SWIFT!!!!!!
Stop putting words in my mouth. 
|
On January 31 2011 07:47 Jackal58 wrote:Show nested quote +On January 31 2011 06:40 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On January 30 2011 23:15 Jackal58 wrote:On January 30 2011 13:35 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On January 30 2011 10:59 Jackal58 wrote:On January 30 2011 09:50 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
##Vote Jackal58
The only connection to Jonathan Swift is that he wrote a satire called "A Modest Proposal" which advocated eating children in poor Ireland to solve the hunger problem. That could be connected to the disappearance of bodies but its verrrrry tentative.
Jackal58 is the strongest clue connection aside from Shann I guess. But Shann could really fit anything and Q doesn't jump out as me as much as Carlos the Jackal does. I already discounted J. Swift. If you want to include what he wrote Gulliver's Travels has lots of stuff in it that matches up with things in the day post. I don't know if LSB went that far. Are links on the wiki pages used to generate clues?And if you're all going to go with Pirates=Terrorists you might want to describe this "chainsaw defense" to me. I might need it. A couple things wrong here: A. Saying "I already discounted J. Swift" as though you are some sort of authority on who can or can't be related via clue. I said there was another tentative connection through that work which is a pretty famous one in actuality. In fact GMarshall even quotes "A Modest Proposal" in his profile.
B. You assume "pirates" is the important aspect of the story. There are always red herrings. Very rarely (if ever) will anyones chosen profile fit all aspects without one being contradictory. Otherwise the game is too easy. C. The Chainsaw Defense is defending yourself by attacking someone else (typically your accuser). Basically you have to find someone that fits the story better than you do. I was responding to your perceived implication of my apparent attempt to connect Jonathan Swift to the clues.If you wish to include A Modest Proposal in the list of things a clue could point to feel free. If that's how you guts are doing clue analysis this game is going to be a slam dunk for red. I'm disappointed. I thought the chainsaw defense was going to be something much more exciting. i don't understand your response so we should utilize only your connection of J Swift. and not consider any others? if anything its more likely he'll connect AMP than gullivers travels since that work is quoted in gmarshall's profile. it would be stupid not to consider it Goddamit I HAVE MADE NO CONNECTION TO SWIFT!!!!!! Stop putting words in my mouth.
no
4. GMarshal Jonathan Swift - Unless this includes Gulliver's Travels nothing but perhaps time period
I was just saying there was something else possible besides Gulliver's Travels reference and that A Modest Proposal may be more likely to be referenced. That's all. I'm not insinuating you accused GMarshall. I'm just expanding on what you said.
|
United States4264 Posts
On January 31 2011 08:01 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On January 31 2011 07:47 Jackal58 wrote:On January 31 2011 06:40 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On January 30 2011 23:15 Jackal58 wrote:On January 30 2011 13:35 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On January 30 2011 10:59 Jackal58 wrote:On January 30 2011 09:50 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
##Vote Jackal58
The only connection to Jonathan Swift is that he wrote a satire called "A Modest Proposal" which advocated eating children in poor Ireland to solve the hunger problem. That could be connected to the disappearance of bodies but its verrrrry tentative.
Jackal58 is the strongest clue connection aside from Shann I guess. But Shann could really fit anything and Q doesn't jump out as me as much as Carlos the Jackal does. I already discounted J. Swift. If you want to include what he wrote Gulliver's Travels has lots of stuff in it that matches up with things in the day post. I don't know if LSB went that far. Are links on the wiki pages used to generate clues?And if you're all going to go with Pirates=Terrorists you might want to describe this "chainsaw defense" to me. I might need it. A couple things wrong here: A. Saying "I already discounted J. Swift" as though you are some sort of authority on who can or can't be related via clue. I said there was another tentative connection through that work which is a pretty famous one in actuality. In fact GMarshall even quotes "A Modest Proposal" in his profile.
B. You assume "pirates" is the important aspect of the story. There are always red herrings. Very rarely (if ever) will anyones chosen profile fit all aspects without one being contradictory. Otherwise the game is too easy. C. The Chainsaw Defense is defending yourself by attacking someone else (typically your accuser). Basically you have to find someone that fits the story better than you do. I was responding to your perceived implication of my apparent attempt to connect Jonathan Swift to the clues.If you wish to include A Modest Proposal in the list of things a clue could point to feel free. If that's how you guts are doing clue analysis this game is going to be a slam dunk for red. I'm disappointed. I thought the chainsaw defense was going to be something much more exciting. i don't understand your response so we should utilize only your connection of J Swift. and not consider any others? if anything its more likely he'll connect AMP than gullivers travels since that work is quoted in gmarshall's profile. it would be stupid not to consider it Goddamit I HAVE MADE NO CONNECTION TO SWIFT!!!!!! Stop putting words in my mouth. no Show nested quote +4. GMarshal Jonathan Swift - Unless this includes Gulliver's Travels nothing but perhaps time period I was just saying there was something else possible besides Gulliver's Travels reference and that A Modest Proposal may be more likely to be referenced. That's all. I'm not insinuating you accused GMarshall. I'm just expanding on what you said.
My apologies then.
|
5 mins til voting ends.... where is everyone?
|
I won't actually do modkills this game, since I realize that if Mafia is inactive, the clues can just pown them
But I am looking for replacements
|
United States4264 Posts
On January 31 2011 10:54 darmousseh wrote:
5 mins til voting ends.... where is everyone?
Collecting rope.
|
On January 31 2011 10:56 LSB wrote:
I won't actually do modkills this game, since I realize that if Mafia is inactive, the clues can just pown them
But I am looking for replacements
What will happen then instead?
|
United States4264 Posts
On January 31 2011 10:56 LSB wrote:
I won't actually do modkills this game, since I realize that if Mafia is inactive, the clues can just pown them
But I am looking for replacements
Ohhh ohh Sign me up.
|
On January 31 2011 10:59 Jackal58 wrote:Show nested quote +On January 31 2011 10:56 LSB wrote:
I won't actually do modkills this game, since I realize that if Mafia is inactive, the clues can just pown them
But I am looking for replacements Ohhh ohh Sign me up.
hahahahaha
|
Night 1
Marvelous
LSB picked himself of the floor.
“Carlos the Jackal could never put together good bombs”
LSB picked himself of the floor.
“Carlos the Jackal could never put together good bombs”
I stared at LSB in shock. “How did you know it was Jackal58?”
“Remember what I asked you? Why would the Pirates take over the fort?” LSB asked. “It was to free their buddy, Carlos who was busy spending time in prison.”
I countered, “Then why were there no bodies?”
LSB answered, “well, the pirates killed everyone as they entered. But they couldn’t negotiate unless they tricked the negotiators to thinking that the governor was still alive, so they dumped all the bodies down the well.”
“But how,” I asked, “How do you know they demanded the release of Carlos?”
LSB answered, “Well, the pirates were fanatics, the Inspector told me that they refused to be captured alive. This meant that they had some connection to the El-Kida organization.”
“When I arrived here, it was pretty clear from the lack of struggle, the people in this room were taken hostage and forced away. Now this is reminiscent of how Carlos dealt with the OPEC incident. However, the most important thing about Carlos that you can’t forget is that he wants money. Lots of it. That’s what separates him from all other fanatics.
“That’s why I checked the treasury. Normal fanatics wouldn’t stop to rob the place, but this one did. This one had to be Carlos”
Jackel58 the Mafia is dead
Conversation with Jackel58
+ Show Spoiler +Original Message From Jackal58: Well it's not like I'm going to say it.  Show nested quote +Original Message From LSB: All it takes is one word and you are dead. OPEC Original Message From Jackal58: They ain't that smart man Original Message From LSB: It is so so so connected, and once people figure out the connection, you're dead. I'm worried. Original Message From Jackal58: I just figured out the connection. Dude you're brutal in your vagaries. :p Original Message From LSB:
You are Mafia
Your goal is to eliminate everyone else in the town. Your ability, as a group, is killing off whomever you decide on at night and knowing the role of each other player in the mafia. You may choose to kill nobody if you so choose. You MAY kill other mafia. As a whole, your KP is 1 throughout the whole game, so choose wisely!
Your Team is.
Kavdragon
LunarDestiny
Jackal58
Jackal58 is the one being mentioned in the day 1 post. My apologies if it is to obvious.
Good luck Oops
Congratulations to Mr. Wiggles and SouthRawrea for figuring out the story.
Please send in your night actions
|
United States4264 Posts
|
We were right!!! Go town!!! Woot!!!!
|
|
|
Oh so jackal is mafia here...
|
Well done.
Hopefully the medics know who to protect tonight.
|
Night post updated with everything.
|
haha i knew it (even though i voted for darmousseh >_>)
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://imgur.com/3WMU6.jpg)
