| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
TheMango
United States1967 Posts
On January 06 2011 05:44 Qatol wrote: Of course. Their role is mafia, so they will flip red. sorry, probably should take this to a PM, but since you answered here... So what strategic value would there be for mafia to kill each other? | ||
|
Mr. Wiggles
Canada5894 Posts
On January 06 2011 05:55 TheMango wrote: sorry, probably should take this to a PM, but since you answered here... So what strategic value would there be for mafia to kill each other? They could pretend one of them was vig I guess and start a town circle. No other vig would claim the kill if they didn't make it probably. That could be clever. Or incredibly stupid haha. | ||
|
Qatol
United States3165 Posts
On January 06 2011 05:55 TheMango wrote: sorry, probably should take this to a PM, but since you answered here... So what strategic value would there be for mafia to kill each other? Pretending to be a vigilante, maybe gaining the trust of the medic you know is protecting you. The use of this is very situational. The main use of it is to keep a medic who makes a save from being 100% certain that they protected an innocent if there is no SK or Vigi hit (or they can account for said hit). Anything else is just someone being creative (for which they should be commended). | ||
|
Pandain
United States12989 Posts
On another note, I'd like to reiterate that everyone should roleclaim to Opz. He is entirely confirmed. If anyone can think of a reason not to please PM me, regardless of your role. | ||
|
~OpZ~
United States3652 Posts
either there are no blues or they arent paying attention. or they just dont believe me | ||
|
Mr. Wiggles
Canada5894 Posts
| ||
|
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
opz, zergling, orgolove, lunardestiny, wiggles, barundar, GGQ possible mafia: seraph, insanious, pandain, d3, tree, shockeyy, jackal58 Since I was asked to look at GGQ specifically, here's some analysis: He hasn't posted too much, but he hasn't done anything scummy either, either than lack of posting I guess. Could be worse. Most of what he said day 1 is pretty logical and generic stuff, not a tell for either side. On December 28 2010 13:24 GGQ wrote: Yeah my bad. I was bus driver and redirected a mafia kill to you. You died to save a detective, though! LSB's advice in this game has been very similar to his posts in the pokemafia game where he was town, but he's gotten into an argument here which he carefully avoided in that game. I know he gave a reason for that already, but I think that it's not a good enough reason for this whole drawn-out argument. I'm not ready to vote for him, but it's worth noting. I don't know why annul is so focused on him. It was good to bring his spamminess to everyone's attention so he would be under the town's focus and forced to post more constructively, but it's not good to be tunnel-visioning him already. If this argument gets too much focus then everyone else will fly under the radar. This post, he's defending LSB and accusing annul subtly. Well, accusing is a strong word for it, but he's calling annul out for sure, while offering LSB some defense. On December 29 2010 03:23 GGQ wrote: But you were, in fact, a guerilla? How is that helping your argument here? Here he calls out annul for bad posting. On December 29 2010 04:48 GGQ wrote: I'm unsatisfied with this answer. No, if you did an analysis of me and FOSed me as mafia when I'm not, that in and of itself would not make me any more suspicious of you. In fact, active scumhunting would make you more likely to be town. As for his analysis being 'all lies', I don't see any lies in his analysis post. You may disagree with his opinions, or think his logic is weak, but that doesn't make him mafia. If you are town, you're the only one who knows that so it doesn't make sense to vote for someone just because they voted for you. What really worries me about this lynch is that besides deconduo there hasn't really been anyone trying to divert the lynch, so either LSB is town or his buddies are abandoning him. Brings up several good points about posting styles. Be wary of people that post like town, but don't do any scumhunting. Unforunately, LSB ended up beign town anyway, but these are all valid points. On December 29 2010 13:07 GGQ wrote: I don't particularly FOS you, but it should be pointed out that this doesn't clear you by a long shot. Mafia knows better than anyone who is clear, and it's very easy for them to buddy a townie to appear clean when he flips. As for annul and pandain, we shouldn't lynch them just because they are wrong. But we also shouldn't let them get away too easily. Some people have suggested that they wouldn't be so bold if they were mafia. But with the godfather and the framer(s) to mess with the DTs, mafia can afford to be pretty bold this game. Pointing out the possibility of annul being godfather... big no no if he was mafia. On December 31 2010 04:20 GGQ wrote: I feel that I should reveal this information since mafia already knows it; I was roleblocked last night. I just read through the entire thread again and here are my thoughts: -Pandain doesn't seem like scum to me, just a flip-flopping townie. -Brockett narrowly avoided a lynch and still hasn't contributed anything. Much fewer posts and different posting style than his townie play in Pokemafia -I'm still suspicious of TheMango but don't have solid reasoning for it -I am pretty confident that ROL is town, but I dont necessarily agree with all his picks for mafia -Insanious doesn't seem scummy to me. People keep saying that he was 'so sure' LSB was blue, but if you actually read his posts, that's not what he was saying -I'm on the fence about annul. I always thought his tunneling on LSB was stupid, but that doesn't make him mafia. He certainly could be, though -I'm most suspicious atm of Seraph (as ROL pointed out) and Mr Wiggles. While reading, I noticed that all of Mr Wiggles posts are riddled with uncertainty, fear, and unwillingness to commit. He may be a newer player, but it still makes me very susicious of him. My vote goes on him for now He got roleblocked. No one counterclaimed, right? And while it's possible that mafia dodged their first roleblock to make GGQ seem more legitimate, combine this with his other posts, and it's very very very likely that GGQ is town. On January 03 2011 03:43 GGQ wrote: How does someone going for you make them mafia? Barundar just added me to his suspects list, but I don't think he's mafia one little bit. Gotta love logic. Anyway, conclusion: GGQ is 90% town to me. | ||
|
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
I forgot to state explicity the general theme of my analysis: GGQ called annul out/brought attention to annul WAY too much to be mafia. At least in my opinion, as a mafia, you don't call out your teammates, except maybe once or twice for the whole game (unless they're already a lost cause/getting bused). And the likelihood of annul getting bused this game is pretty low, because he was their godfather pick. It's a little extreme to throw that advantage away this early. So, the fact that GGQ was on annul's case early makes me think that he's town. | ||
|
Incognito
United States2071 Posts
![[image loading]](http://www.cgfocus.com/gal_images/starno/The_Decline_of_Babel_Myth_02_510449a544a818305fb0e76f43ea0fef.jpg) Day 4: Start It was a long, cold night. Fortunately, there was a blizzard out, making the townspeople feel safe in their homes. After all, it would be impossible for the mafia to blaze through the 8 foot deep snow to kill people tonight, right? GGQ sat at home, relaxing in front of the television while a large bonfire burned in the fireplace beside him. As the television was on full volume, he was unable to hear the noises above the house. But it was too late. From a helicopter above the roof, a large cloaked figure dropped two barrels of gasoline down GGQ's chimney before flying off into the gray clouds above. GGQ had no time to react as the house exploded unspectacularly and caved in due to all the snow surrounding it. On the other side of town, LunarDestiny frantically paced back and forth, looking through all the notes from his hard work. Exhausted, he decided to go downstairs and drink the rest of the night away. When the mafioso arrived, he was shocked at what he found. Upon opening the door, LunarDestiny just sat there, purring and clawing away at the air before the mafioso decided to end this silliness by stabbing him in the chest and walking away, leaving the door open. LunarDestiny probably never noticed that he was dying, and continued to claw away at the air until he eventually froze to death. Earlier this morning, analysts concluded that LunarDestiny died not from the knife wound, but from freezing to death. GGQ the Townie is now dead. LunarDestiny the Townie is now dead. It is now Day 4. Voting ends in 48 hours. | ||
|
LunarDestiny
United States4177 Posts
| ||
|
GGQ
Canada2653 Posts
Good-bye and good luck, town. | ||
|
Mr.Zergling
United States141 Posts
The mafia won't NK me, because I serve as a great distraction/lynch redirection... lol | ||
|
seRapH
United States9773 Posts
On January 06 2011 14:01 Mr.Zergling wrote: Well, at least greens.............................................................................................. The mafia won't NK me, because I serve as a great distraction/lynch redirection... lol I know! Isn't it great! The mafia will never suspect that we're actually Mad Hatters! | ||
|
Mr.Zergling
United States141 Posts
On January 06 2011 15:05 seRapH wrote: I know! Isn't it great! The mafia will never suspect that we're actually Mad Hatters! Wait what? | ||
|
RebirthOfLeGenD
USA5860 Posts
On January 06 2011 05:55 TheMango wrote: sorry, probably should take this to a PM, but since you answered here... So what strategic value would there be for mafia to kill each other? They can fake vigi/gain town cred. Better question! What strategic value would it have if the dead mafia didn't flip red if hit by his team mates? | ||
|
Qatol
United States3165 Posts
On January 06 2011 17:01 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote: They can fake vigi/gain town cred. Better question! What strategic value would it have if the dead mafia didn't flip red if hit by his team mates? What would you do if MBH says "I strongly believe that Ace, Chuiu, and LTT are all innocent. Furthermore, I think that Ver, Incognito, and Flamewheel are all mafia." and then immediately dies during the night and flips innocent? Wicked way to waste town resources/time. | ||
|
RebirthOfLeGenD
USA5860 Posts
But I think killing your own red and him appearing red can be an awesome play on Day 3 to claim vigi. But as another note, It would be awesome to see that happen in a game where mafia used cover and hit one of their own guys to make him appear town  In a game that I hosted I would have a cover + hit = town death considering its a waste of a lot of resources for a mafia. | ||
|
Qatol
United States3165 Posts
On January 06 2011 17:17 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote: hmm but how would that really waste time? I mean that is assuming that the town then does everything that MBH says and just because someone is confirmed innocent by death that doesn't mean by any stretch that all their opinions up until then are right. All it MIGHT do is if its a PM game, if a player was in contact with MBH they would be more likely to believe everything he said and not think they were being manipulated. But I think killing your own red and him appearing red can be an awesome play on Day 3 to claim vigi. But as another note, It would be awesome to see that happen in a game where mafia used cover and hit one of their own guys to make him appear town In a game that I hosted I would have a cover + hit = town death considering its a waste of a lot of resources for a mafia.I think you underestimate the analysis abilities of someone like MBH. You can switch Ver and MBH in my example if you like. Either way, players like that making claims like that will get attention and I can definitely see a town lynching based off those statements. | ||
|
RebirthOfLeGenD
USA5860 Posts
| ||
|
Incognito
United States2071 Posts
With that said, lets not clutter up the game thread please  | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 Lowko463 StarCraft: Brood WarRotterdaM  437Harstem 388mouzHeroMarine  321Hui .247 LamboSC2  225ProTech83 Livibee 31TKL  18Britney Dota 2  35911Larva  1343Barracks  845actioN 339firebathero 201Hyun 166Backho 74PianO 56yabsab 48Rock 37[ Show more ] Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games singsing3255 hiko953 FrodaN782 crisheroes388 Liquid`VortiX208 oskar114 Mew2King53 Beastyqt41 Trikslyr35 |
|
|
EPT
