|
On December 18 2010 06:35 LunarDestiny wrote:Something don't make sense here. The reasons that we are lynching Dr.H is because: 1. He defends Pandain. We can't use this to determine if he is town or mafia. 2. jcarlsoniv's post Show nested quote +I can confirm that Dr.H PMd me at the start of the game (as Airbag) posing as a noob. He was asking some questions, saying he wanted to team up with a veteran to stay alive. I am by no means a veteran, and he was trying to sweet talk me to get my trust. After watching him post, I had determined that he was most certainly a smurf. When I called him out on it, he eventually told me that he was DocH. He also made a claim early that he was able to protect people, so I figured he was Poppy. When talking to Kitaman, he said that he had a DT who had found the real Poppy, and it was not Airbag/Dr.H.
This post shows us that Dr.H claimed to jcarlsoniv to be Poppy. jcarlsoniv was told by Kitaman who was told by a dt that another Poppy was found. There's too many loopholes here. If either Kitaman or the dt is mafia, then lynching Dr.H would be stupid.
More indirect defense of DOCH
|
On December 18 2010 06:50 LunarDestiny wrote:
If exposing a dt can confirm we lynching a mafia and reduce mafia's KP by 1, I can fine with it.
Yes, the post is a defense to Dr.H.
defense of defense of doch
|
Coagulation you have contributed literally nothing to this game except for telling others "Hey look this person is saying we shouldn't lynch this person. They must be scum"
If you can not see how that argument is fundamentally flawed in the first place, I suggest you stop playing mafia forever because you will never be good.
|
I agree with having someone check DrH, or at least one more person come out and say "I also knew that there was another person who claimed bla bla."
Just one person's word and the fact that he "heard it from someone who heard it from a dt" should not be enough evidence to lynch one of the most experienced players in the game so far. We already lost pretty much everyone else.
The only problem is, if he turns out green, we WILL need the other one to claim as well and get rid of both (because we obviously can't have two people with the same role).
Also, if he flips green on DT check, Meapak should probably turn over whoever said DrH turned red (because, let's face it, even if we will have 2 greens with the same role, there's no way either of them would have flipped red), so Meapakk's source is most likely red.
Alternatively, we could get lucky with today's lynch and get one of the "doubles".
Either way, I'm not gonna support DrH's lynch based on one testimony alone.
|
Coag, you are not helping. Are you saying I am mafia or I am disillusion that I am defending Dr.H?
Back on topic:
Annul clarified the rules a page back. Can anyone find any loophole to this plan?
Kenpachi name checks Dr.H.
Dr.H protects Kenpachi.
|
Also, if someone else is DT and can check DrH.
FOR THE LOVE OF GOD DON'T CLAIM IT.
Having DTs claim is one of the dumbest things town can do.
Seriously, part from highly unusual circumstances, DTs should NEVER claim in the open. If you have to do it, use a town circle or smth.
|
And I was totally kidding about modkilling for roleclaim in PMs. Come on people, I'm not that dumb lol.
|
Kitaman, have your dt personally claim to me and I will prove that I am town to him also.
If my prove is flawed in that it is not enough to prove I am 100% town, then either one of you can tell town. If I am mafia, town also knows Mr.Zergling is mafia.
|
On December 18 2010 06:56 LunarDestiny wrote:
Coag, you are not helping. Are you saying I am mafia or I am disillusion that I am defending Dr.H?
Back on topic:
Annul clarified the rules a page back. Can anyone find any loophole to this plan?
Kenpachi name checks Dr.H.
Dr.H protects Kenpachi.
They kill DrH?
|
On December 18 2010 07:02 Barundar wrote:Show nested quote +On December 18 2010 06:56 LunarDestiny wrote:
Coag, you are not helping. Are you saying I am mafia or I am disillusion that I am defending Dr.H?
Back on topic:
Annul clarified the rules a page back. Can anyone find any loophole to this plan?
Kenpachi name checks Dr.H.
Dr.H protects Kenpachi. They kill DrH?
Then they will do us a favor and stop every suspicion we have on Dr.H.
Yes, we lose a medic but Mafia will have to use 1 KP on him. So another townie will be spared.
|
On December 18 2010 07:02 Barundar wrote:Show nested quote +On December 18 2010 06:56 LunarDestiny wrote:
Coag, you are not helping. Are you saying I am mafia or I am disillusion that I am defending Dr.H?
Back on topic:
Annul clarified the rules a page back. Can anyone find any loophole to this plan?
Kenpachi name checks Dr.H.
Dr.H protects Kenpachi. They kill DrH?
They could, sure, but why would Mafia kill someone who's under high suspicion from town? Just let the town lynch him. Besides, I'm sure that mafia would rather aim for a DT rather than a medic. Besides #2, there should be more medics in the game, so someone could STILL protect DrH anyway.
And since nobody is helping me push tube in the spotlight, I'll move my vote to pandain. My argument is that he played exactly like this in kingmaker, where he was scum. And I should know, I was his scumbuddy.
Sorry buddy!
|
On December 18 2010 07:02 LunarDestiny wrote:
Kitaman, have your dt personally claim to me and I will prove that I am town to him also.
If my prove is flawed in that it is not enough to prove I am 100% town, then either one of you can tell town. If I am mafia, town also knows Mr.Zergling is mafia.
Just begging to get the name of that DT
If Mafia kills the DT it would be much easier to sweep this all under the rug.
|
Anyone that reveals our DT to Lunardestiny is an idiot.
|
A someone immediately claimed dt to me...
|
just because im not spamming does not mean im scum -.-
|
3 nonvoters: kenpachi, ilovejonn, node. less than 2 hours to go.
bedtime. if they do not vote by the deadline, they're all dead.
ill put up night post when i wake up. if its really significantly late then ill extend night or someting.
voting is extremely close today so if you are on a placeholder vote, remember to do something with it
|
LOL I BET IT WAS PANDAIN CLAIMED DT
LOL LAST DITCH ATTEMPT TO GET OFF THE HOOK FROM LYNCH
|
On December 18 2010 07:13 Coagulation wrote:
LOL I BET IT WAS PANDAIN CLAIMED DT
LOL LAST DITCH ATTEMPT TO GET OFF THE HOOK FROM LYNCH
if you're right that's a pretty lucky guess
lucky enough to be a mafia slip. i don't know why we aren't all lynching you since it's painfully obvious you're mafia.
|
On December 18 2010 07:17 DoctorHelvetica wrote:Show nested quote +On December 18 2010 07:13 Coagulation wrote:
LOL I BET IT WAS PANDAIN CLAIMED DT
LOL LAST DITCH ATTEMPT TO GET OFF THE HOOK FROM LYNCH if you're right that's a pretty lucky guess lucky enough to be a mafia slip. i don't know why we aren't all lynching you since it's painfully obvious you're mafia.
its clearly based on pandains 1 post every 3 days being 3 minutes after lunardestiny post's that someone just roleclaimed DT
Plus we all know how pandain loves to fake roleclaims
(Even fakes roleclaims when hes town WTF?)
|
On December 18 2010 07:19 Coagulation wrote:Show nested quote +On December 18 2010 07:17 DoctorHelvetica wrote:On December 18 2010 07:13 Coagulation wrote:
LOL I BET IT WAS PANDAIN CLAIMED DT
LOL LAST DITCH ATTEMPT TO GET OFF THE HOOK FROM LYNCH if you're right that's a pretty lucky guess lucky enough to be a mafia slip. i don't know why we aren't all lynching you since it's painfully obvious you're mafia. its clearly based on pandains 1 post every 3 days being 3 minutes after lunardestiny post's that someone just roleclaimed DT Plus we all know how pandain loves to fake roleclaims (Even fakes roleclaims when hes town WTF?)
Why would you out him for that? There is no reason for a town member to say "hey this guy is probably the DT"
even if you think it could be fake that's extremely dumb of you to do. that's why I think you're mafia. you aren't THAT bad at this game even though you are pretty bad. You're playing exactly the same way you did in Insane mafia. Agitating, loud, and worthless.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
