|
On December 13 2010 10:04 LSB wrote:1) Show nested quote +Your main argument is lack of contribution. As RoL pointed out, there are only perhaps three players who had contributed anything substantive at that point. And I believe I have contributed now, with my analysis of beneather. *Illusion of contribution. Illusion of contribution is a good way to find scum. Scum try to pretend to be active without actually saying anything I'm looking at Ver's Analysis of Protactium2) Show nested quote +You failed to show that any of my posts could not have a townie motivation for posting them. Wut? 3) Show nested quote +You even put words into my mouth. I never said RNG a mayor, and I don't recall anyone else saying that either. Right here Show nested quote +On the other hand, if we vote for 'someone who will listen to the town', we might as well forget there even is a MoM. Just RNG a mayor, vote as normal for a lynch, lynch the mayor day 2 if he fails to comply. The thing is, at this time, everyone was talking about how we should vote for 'someone who will listen to the town'. You were assuming that people would take up your idea. 4) Annul told us to drop it, so I'm dropping it. Talking about smurfs is a great way to get postcounts for my Reaver thou
1) My contributions were not an illusion. I pressured two newbs/lurkers to post by calling them out about voting for deconduo, and I got another (acutally the same) lurker to post by doing the whole smurf routine. I found a solid lynch candidate in beneather. Even though this was posted after your analysis of me, I wrote the analysis (and posted it) before I ever saw your accusation of me.
2) You went through my posts and blew them off as not saying much. You never took the next step and showed why a townie would not post the things I posted. Thus your analysis is weak. Furthermore, I can give reasons for why I posted what I did. I have done so already for some posts (smurfs).
3) Already went over this.
4) I guess you're conceding on this one.
|
My role is town aligned. I have special win conditions that do not interfere with town interests. I do not have any abilities that would allow me to prove my alignment.
|
Welcome to NIGHT 1
Night has fallen on Hogsmeade. The citizens of the wizarding world are clamoring to avenge the death of former Minister Beadeadsoon. They've taken to the polls and have elected a new Minister for Magic, Meapakk_Ziphh. The first order of business for the Ministry: take out their prime suspect for Ima's assassination.
The new Minister, Meapakk_Ziphh, placed aidnai under arrest. aidnai was brought to the bottom level of the Ministry building and placed in the witness chair.
"DID YOU KILL IMA BEADEADSOON?," shouted the new Minister.
"... no, no I did not!," replied aidnai.
"CONFESSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!"
"... NO, I didn't do anything! I swear!"
The new Minister realized this tactic was not working. He remembered talking a walk down to the Misuse of Muggle Artefacts Office, where he saw this peculiar item. It was a box, lined with buttons, and a wire sticking out the back. On the front, it had a picture, a picture that moved just like wizarding pictures. It also broadcast this... sound, as if, people were talking. They called it... a "tilla vichawn," yeah!
On that tilla vichawn was a man. A man who would know exactly what to do in this situation. "Accio TILLA VICHAWN!" cried the new Minister.
Into the courtroom flew a nice, 17 inch television, complete with a DVD player and a box set of an epic television show. Yes, Meapakk_Ziphh knew what he had to do:
+ Show Spoiler +
The new Minister utilized the tactics he learned in that television show. aidnai reacted thusly:
+ Show Spoiler +
Sadly, tears could not save aidnai from the Veil. In he went.
* * * * *
It is the end of the first year up at Hogwarts. Harry Potter recently vanquished Quirrell, navigated the devil's snare trap, the flying key trap, the potion logic trap, and the chess game trap, to get there. In other words, nothing of great significance happened this year. One wonders what might happen in future years to affect the wizarding world and the loyalties of those within. . .
* * * * *
aidnai the Draco Malfoy has been lynched.
+ Show Spoiler +you are Draco Malfoy!
you had a hard life. you almost got caught in with the death eaters and shit.
if draco malfoy is alive when five or less players are alive, draco malfoy wins an alternate win.
if draco wins by any manner, and is alive when he does so, both lucius malfoy and narcissa malfoy also win. you are not allowed to tell anybody (even your parents) about this ability until dawn of day 6
* * * * *
It is now Night 1. Night lasts 22 hours and will end Monday, December 13, at 7 PM EST/9 AM KST. All players with roles that directly affect other players should make a good-faith attempt to submit their night actions as soon as possible, so that role interactions can be correctly resolved under the rules.
Night roles will be resolved in the following order:
1. Substitution roles.
2. Protection roles
3. Investigation roles.
4. Non-standard kill roles.
5. Non-Voldemort standard mafia kills.
6. Voldemort's personal kill.
Conflicting role usage at each level will be resolved using RNG as to who goes first. I will RNG a kill order for the death eaters and all level 5 attempted kills will follow that order, with the top two on the RNG list going first, then the next, et cetera.
As of Night 1, there are 8 players aligned with the Death Eaters remaining, the Death Eaters have a KP of 3, and there are 7 players with potential alternate victories remaining.
|
I have a bad feeling about this...
If I die, I want to have this stuff out there:
-jackal58 and ilovejonn are active lurkers. They should have received more suspicion today.
-LSB did a criminally weak analysis on me. I know he's capable of better. Since he is sticking to it even after my analysis of beneather and hearing my defense, he is another prime suspect.
-Beneather is an awesome day 1 lynch. If you don't get him today, please get him soon.
|
Well Wizards and Witches I come before you as your duly elected Minister of Magic to inform of my first and only action. This was not an easy decision for me to make. I looked many places for condolences and sought reassurance that this was the right thing to do. I played robot unicorn attack on facebook, I went and looked at funny pictures of cats doing stupid things, and I read the recap of my 49ers beating the Seahawks. But none of these things brought me any closer to the answer I sought. I asked myself “what would Dr. H do”? Because he was won the mayorship in the last game I played that featured a mayor. But this didn’t provide me with any answers either. With nothing left to do I read the entire thread through one more time. Nothing I saw could dissuade me from my final decision. Though my target made a few good points once the guns were turned on him, I found this sudden jolt of helpfulness to be not assuring. For a second or two I had nodded in agreement with my target but after rereading it I was even surer of my choice. And after all, I had pledged to be a mayor who listened to the town and they were calling for my target’s head. With nothing else to do I sent the PM. The first person voted off of survivor Harry Potter Mafia is
Aidnai
|
EBWOP
I wanted to post that once I made my decision but annul told me I had to wait for the night post.
|
Oh we have tons of options for tomorrow's lynch or even a vigi hit.
|
sorry for shitting up the thread with so many posts but I realized that this wasn't that bad of a lynch.
+ Show Spoiler +you are Draco Malfoy!
you had a hard life. you almost got caught in with the death eaters and shit.
if draco malfoy is alive when five or less players are alive, draco malfoy wins an alternate win.
if draco wins by any manner, and is alive when he does so, both lucius malfoy and narcissa malfoy also win. you are not allowed to tell anybody (even your parents) about this ability until dawn of day 6
While we didn't hit a red it sounds like aidnai could have won without the town so at least we hit someone who wasn't pure town.
Sorry though Aidnai, if you had posted in the first nine tenths of the game like you did for the last part you probably would have lived.
|
On December 13 2010 11:07 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:sorry for shitting up the thread with so many posts but I realized that this wasn't that bad of a lynch. + Show Spoiler +you are Draco Malfoy!
you had a hard life. you almost got caught in with the death eaters and shit.
if draco malfoy is alive when five or less players are alive, draco malfoy wins an alternate win.
if draco wins by any manner, and is alive when he does so, both lucius malfoy and narcissa malfoy also win. you are not allowed to tell anybody (even your parents) about this ability until dawn of day 6
While we didn't hit a red it sounds like aidnai could have won without the town so at least we hit someone who wasn't pure town. Sorry though Aidnai, if you had posted in the first nine tenths of the game like you did for the last part you probably would have lived.
Yeah that's what I was gonna say.
At least that's one alternative victory down the drain. Fewer to worry about.
|
let me just say that townies having alternate wins do not mean they are not also town.
if an alternate win happens the game continues and the "normal" winners can still claim victory.
|
im flattered u thought of me but that is not what i would have done lol
|
Vatican City State1650 Posts
Fuck... there's so many reds in this game. And we couldn't get a day 1 kill.
|
DOCH LYNCHES ME WHEN HES UNSURE.
|
Lord Voldemort
Cho Chang
Bellatrix Lestrange
Gilderoy Lockhart
Cedric Diggory
Walden Macnair
Severus Snape
Albus Dumbledore
Poppy Pomfrey
Fenrir Greyback
Sibyl Trelawney
Firenze
Luna Lovegood
Ollivander
Draco Malfoy
Nymphadora Tonks
Ernie Prang
Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington
Mulciber
Parvati Patil
Padma Patil
Moaning Myrtle
Lucius Malfoy
Narcissa Malfoy
Violet
Harry Potter
Colin Creevey
Nicolas Flamel
Hermione Granger
Angelina Johnson
Roger Davies
That leaves someone out.
Possible death eaters
Snape- I believe Snape is the miller, but there is a possibility he's mafia
Gilderoy Lockhart- Erasing people's memories isn't very townish
One of the Patils- This is very very weak, but it could be the generic lovers role. One town, one mafia. Doesn't make much sense storywize.
|
FREEAGLELAND26781 Posts
At least modkilling Draco doesn't automatically modkill Lucius and Narcissa in this game.
|
On December 13 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:Show nested quote +Lord Voldemort
Cho Chang
Bellatrix Lestrange
Gilderoy Lockhart
Cedric Diggory
Walden Macnair
Severus Snape
Albus Dumbledore
Poppy Pomfrey
Fenrir Greyback
Sibyl Trelawney
Firenze
Luna Lovegood
Ollivander
Draco Malfoy
Nymphadora Tonks
Ernie Prang
Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington
Mulciber
Parvati Patil
Padma Patil
Moaning Myrtle
Lucius Malfoy
Narcissa Malfoy
Violet
Harry Potter
Colin Creevey
Nicolas Flamel
Hermione Granger
Angelina Johnson
Roger Davies That leaves someone out. Possible death eaters Snape- I believe Snape is the miller, but there is a possibility he's mafia Gilderoy Lockhart- Erasing people's memories isn't very townish One of the Patils- This is very very weak, but it could be the generic lovers role. One town, one mafia. Doesn't make much sense storywize.
Snape may be mafia with a town-sided alternate win condition? Perhaps to keep Harry alive or something along those lines? I just can't see any of the other characters as mafia.
Gildetroy Lockhart seems more like a third party to me, as well as Moaning Myrtle (if there's a fool or village idiot in the game, I'd bet it's her). If they win with town then I'm sure they have alternate winning conditions.
We were told to pay attention to the last line of annul's posts. I believe that this time we are supposed to get a hint from:
It is the end of the first year up at Hogwarts. Harry Potter recently vanquished Quirrell, navigated the devil's snare trap, the flying key trap, the potion logic trap, and the chess game trap, to get there. In other words, nothing of great significance happened this year. One wonders what might happen in future years to affect the wizarding world and the loyalties of those within
This suggests that each day in this game is going to be equivalent to a year in Harry Potter world. If Day 1 was Philosopher's Stone then Day 2 will be Chamber of Secrets. This also suggests that character's loyalties may change over time. Characters who were significant in Chamber of Secrets were Gilderoy Lockhard, Moaning Myrtle, Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington, and Colin Creevey. One or more of these characters may have some sort of agenda for next day.
|
On December 13 2010 11:50 GGQ wrote:Show nested quote +On December 13 2010 11:27 LSB wrote:Lord Voldemort
Cho Chang
Bellatrix Lestrange
Gilderoy Lockhart
Cedric Diggory
Walden Macnair
Severus Snape
Albus Dumbledore
Poppy Pomfrey
Fenrir Greyback
Sibyl Trelawney
Firenze
Luna Lovegood
Ollivander
Draco Malfoy
Nymphadora Tonks
Ernie Prang
Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington
Mulciber
Parvati Patil
Padma Patil
Moaning Myrtle
Lucius Malfoy
Narcissa Malfoy
Violet
Harry Potter
Colin Creevey
Nicolas Flamel
Hermione Granger
Angelina Johnson
Roger Davies That leaves someone out. Possible death eaters Snape- I believe Snape is the miller, but there is a possibility he's mafia Gilderoy Lockhart- Erasing people's memories isn't very townish One of the Patils- This is very very weak, but it could be the generic lovers role. One town, one mafia. Doesn't make much sense storywize. Snape may be mafia with a town-sided alternate win condition? Perhaps to keep Harry alive or something along those lines? I just can't see any of the other characters as mafia. Gildetroy Lockhart seems more like a third party to me, as well as Moaning Myrtle (if there's a fool or village idiot in the game, I'd bet it's her). If they win with town then I'm sure they have alternate winning conditions. We were told to pay attention to the last line of annul's posts. I believe that this time we are supposed to get a hint from: Show nested quote +It is the end of the first year up at Hogwarts. Harry Potter recently vanquished Quirrell, navigated the devil's snare trap, the flying key trap, the potion logic trap, and the chess game trap, to get there. In other words, nothing of great significance happened this year. One wonders what might happen in future years to affect the wizarding world and the loyalties of those within This suggests that each day in this game is going to be equivalent to a year in Harry Potter world. If Day 1 was Philosopher's Stone then Day 2 will be Chamber of Secrets. This also suggests that character's loyalties may change over time. Characters who were significant in Chamber of Secrets were Gilderoy Lockhard, Moaning Myrtle, Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington, and Colin Creevey. One or more of these characters may have some sort of agenda for next day.
GREAT POST.
if draco wins by any manner, and is alive when he does so, both lucius malfoy and narcissa malfoy also win. you are not allowed to tell anybody (even your parents) about this ability until dawn of day 6
I'm guessing the significance of day 6 is that in Half Blood Prince he played a major role in the attempted murder of Dumbledore. Somehow I think one of Dumbledore's conditions is death on night 6...but he should have some imba power right now.
Gilderoy Lockhart lost all his memories in book 2 after attempting to erase Harry's - could possibly mean he'll be much weakened after night 2?
Myrtle - ...hmm no idea of what she could have
Colin - no idea either
Honestly 8 death eaters out of 31 seems very unreasonable so I think its likely this number will drop by natural causes or something...
I'm also certain there is a bus driver with Ernie Prang.
|
zeks that is true that if there is no Draco Malfoy then the Death eaters cannot get in to Hogwarts. But remember that Snape actually killed Dumbledore because Draco could not. So as long as Snape is a live Dumbledore will die by Day 6 as you guys have said.
|
On December 13 2010 10:35 Amber[LighT] wrote:Show nested quote +On December 13 2010 10:32 LunarDestiny wrote:
Again, I don't have a clear lynch choice. But I want to ask Aidnai if he can prove his innocence with his role. If he can and promise to do so within maybe a day of game time, then we should give him the chance to prove himself.
Pandain's sudden post after Meapak calling him out as a lynch possibility is weird. Pandain in all other mafia games tends to be more talkative. To his defense he's the most vocal when he's scum, so this isn't much of a surprise. (Check Salem mafia)
your sentence operates on the assumption that you "know" hes town
scumslip?
|
On December 13 2010 13:04 Coagulation wrote:Show nested quote +On December 13 2010 10:35 Amber[LighT] wrote:On December 13 2010 10:32 LunarDestiny wrote:
Again, I don't have a clear lynch choice. But I want to ask Aidnai if he can prove his innocence with his role. If he can and promise to do so within maybe a day of game time, then we should give him the chance to prove himself.
Pandain's sudden post after Meapak calling him out as a lynch possibility is weird. Pandain in all other mafia games tends to be more talkative. To his defense he's the most vocal when he's scum, so this isn't much of a surprise. (Check Salem mafia) your sentence operates on the assumption that you "know" hes town scumslip?
Am I so naive to make a mistake like that if I were scum? Players can be analyzed especially when you play with them on more than one occassion 
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://filipspagnoli.files.wordpress.com/2009/07/jack_bauer_torture.jpg)
![[image loading]](http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_UymY4piPqjo/R1F5uq0PJ5I/AAAAAAAAHlU/F4t-YgkqjUI/s1600-R/cry_babies_24.jpg)
