EPTInsane Mafia - Page 147
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
DCLXVI
United States729 Posts
| ||
|
LunarDestiny
United States4177 Posts
| ||
|
DoctorHelvetica
United States15034 Posts
On November 05 2010 13:18 LunarDestiny wrote: So how does your bombs activate again? LSB just edited out his explanation. if he dies but not if he is roleblocked | ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
On November 05 2010 13:19 DoctorHelvetica wrote: if he dies but not if he is roleblocked This (explination of edit, I changed it back to what generally happens with Bombers) | ||
|
Infundibulum
United States2552 Posts
On November 05 2010 13:16 DCLXVI wrote: So I should get lynched tomorrow then ideally yes. there might be some consideration of medic protecting you since mafia could try to roleblock/hit (if roleblocker is mafia oriented.... which it usually is) | ||
|
LunarDestiny
United States4177 Posts
| ||
|
Meapak_Ziphh
United States6789 Posts
On November 05 2010 13:55 LunarDestiny wrote: DC, one thing didn't make sense to me. Why did you role claim bodyguard on night 1? If the mafia decide to kill you, your mad hunter role is wasted. I don't think he was role claiming, I think he was checking to see if his bombs could kill the mayor and thought we would guess his role through his questions. | ||
|
LunarDestiny
United States4177 Posts
| ||
|
Node
United States2159 Posts
| ||
|
LunarDestiny
United States4177 Posts
| ||
|
Veldril
Thailand1817 Posts
| ||
|
Pandain
United States12989 Posts
On November 05 2010 11:25 LunarDestiny wrote: Pandain, I was expecting you to make some kind of response post to everyone that are suspicious of you, but you didn't. Before day3, you are one of the most active poster and one of the best analyzer in the thread. You were battling with DrH head to head and never shown weakness. It is not like you to not counter argue the suspicions pointing at you unless you are contented with Coag being lynched today and you die at a later time. Coag, a very aggressive poster, also seem wanting to protect you by not doing what he can to label you are a better lynch than him. It really makes me believe that you are highly likely to be a mafia and that your group is ok that Coag instead of you to be lynched today. I hope I am not too late to make this post. I beg that those who didn't vote for Pandain to really consider what I state above. If that make sense to you, please change your vote to Pandain. Except now there isn't really anythign I can do. Right now I'm getting voted because of coag, and some people may say because I pushed Dr. H but I stand by my reasons there. I can't explain coagulaiton, I can't. I can't prove myself with what I have unless you believe me that I did check infinite and nemesis and that they were both innocent. But there's nothing I can do. I am upset that I am getting lynched when we have a 100% mafia, but then again DXCVII has a bomb on coag so we don't want to waste that. My only defense is that you guys look at my posts(you guys never actually analyzed me :/). And I have firm conviction that you will see I did what I thought, that I have played pro town(even if I was wrong.) The only real argument against me is that coag supported me, and coag is confirmed mafia. I would plead with the town to let me stay another night to at least get one more check, so then when I turn blue you guys have even more information. So I guess, I do have somewhat an idea: 1.We lynch someone else(I would say nemesis cause that would slightly confirm me but I don't want a blue lynched so I suppose another person.) DXCVII move his other bomb to me. Then next day, we can lynch DXCVII and the two bombs go off on me and coag. But at least I'll get another piece of information for ya'll. Do MH bombs go off when they get lynched? Also, if I do die, please look at the people who are accusing me with horrid reasoning(KtheZ for instance, or even youngminii, albeit again keep in mind if he does have an unlynchable role that would be pretty op for mafia. But then again, we don't even know his role :/) If MH | ||
|
Pandain
United States12989 Posts
Also what to do after I get lynched(of course free to debate0. | ||
|
CubEdIn
Romania5359 Posts
Please explain in more detail why I should change to Pandain. Here is why I'm thinking I shouldn't. We are more sure that Coag is red then we are of Pandain. We are guessing Pandain is so due to behavior (both his and Coag's). We pretty much know that Coag is due to the DT, the way he reacted (I got a really cool role guys but you see, ummm, wait, i'll have to think about it a bit.), etc. Why should I vote for someone that I'm only ..say.. 75% sure of (Pan) when I can vote for someone that I'm 95% sure of (Coag) ?? The second the DT post was made, Coag was doomed. Mafia knew that as well as we did. The fact that you're thinking that they're letting him die and not Pandain BECAUSE Pand has a better role, seems silly. Also, for a kind-of wild card reason: Look at the vote lists. Assume that coag is red, and that pandain is a coinflip (humor me, for this, so there are 5-6 mafia left). Now look at the vote lists. Which of them seems more stacked with Mafia? Based on your own judgement of what happened so far, your own instincts and what not. To me, Pandain's list seems more stacked with people I don't trust 100% (Hyperbola, Beneather, Youngminii, Meapak_Ziphh). Although I don't trust them mostly because of lurking, I can't help but consider the possibility that Pandain is telling the truth and the mafia wants coag to live an extra day. I agree, the chance of Pandain NOT being mafia are LOWER then the chances of him being mafia. But we're like, 95% sure that Coag IS mafia. Why give him another day? Can't we give Pandain another day instead? Please feel free to convince me otherwise, I'll gladly change my vote if a good argument is made. P.S.: I do not really trust 666 due to his shifty play so far, plus, even if he's telling the truth he could (and probably will) be roleblocked, so I'm not gonna trust him 100% for a red's death, sorry. | ||
|
CubEdIn
Romania5359 Posts
| ||
|
Glasse
Canada1237 Posts
| ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On November 06 2010 00:20 CubEdIn wrote: @ Lunar - I am one of those who voted for Coag. Please explain in more detail why I should change to Pandain. Here is why I'm thinking I shouldn't. We are more sure that Coag is red then we are of Pandain. We are guessing Pandain is so due to behavior (both his and Coag's). We pretty much know that Coag is due to the DT, the way he reacted (I got a really cool role guys but you see, ummm, wait, i'll have to think about it a bit.), etc. Why should I vote for someone that I'm only ..say.. 75% sure of (Pan) when I can vote for someone that I'm 95% sure of (Coag) ?? The second the DT post was made, Coag was doomed. Mafia knew that as well as we did. The fact that you're thinking that they're letting him die and not Pandain BECAUSE Pand has a better role, seems silly. Also, for a kind-of wild card reason: Look at the vote lists. Assume that coag is red, and that pandain is a coinflip (humor me, for this, so there are 5-6 mafia left). Now look at the vote lists. Which of them seems more stacked with Mafia? Based on your own judgement of what happened so far, your own instincts and what not. To me, Pandain's list seems more stacked with people I don't trust 100% (Hyperbola, Beneather, Youngminii, Meapak_Ziphh). Although I don't trust them mostly because of lurking, I can't help but consider the possibility that Pandain is telling the truth and the mafia wants coag to live an extra day. I agree, the chance of Pandain NOT being mafia are LOWER then the chances of him being mafia. But we're like, 95% sure that Coag IS mafia. Why give him another day? Can't we give Pandain another day instead? Please feel free to convince me otherwise, I'll gladly change my vote if a good argument is made. P.S.: I do not really trust 666 due to his shifty play so far, plus, even if he's telling the truth he could (and probably will) be roleblocked, so I'm not gonna trust him 100% for a red's death, sorry. I think the main reason people feel we should lynch Pandain first is that it gives us more information to use in the upcoming double lynch. If he pops blue then we go after those who pushed his lynch, if he pops red then we go after those he is associated with. Even though we know Coag is probably red, he has been much quieter. There is also the fact that DC claims to have a bomb on Coag and a possible townie so if we lynch Coag, one of his bombs has the change of being wasted. That being said, I'm keeping my vote on Coag, as he is more of a sure thing and I haven't seen enough evidence against Pandain to convince me he is scum. | ||
|
CubEdIn
Romania5359 Posts
On November 06 2010 00:32 kitaman27 wrote: I think the main reason people feel we should lynch Pandain first is that it gives us more information to use in the upcoming double lynch. If he pops blue then we go after those who pushed his lynch, if he pops red then we go after those he is associated with. Even though we know Coag is probably red, he has been much quieter. There is also the fact that DC claims to have a bomb on Coag and a possible townie so if we lynch Coag, one of his bombs has the change of being wasted. That being said, I'm keeping my vote on Coag, as he is more of a sure thing and I haven't seen enough evidence against Pandain to convince me he is scum. Yeah I didn't really think of that. But it's starting to be WIFOM. If you're arguing that if he flips blue, you're going after who pushed him, why would the mafia push him? Sure, some might, but the ones that are fairly confident that they can't be uncovered afterwards. I don't know, it still seems fairly random to me. I don't like it, I'm keeping my vote on the sure thing, for now. @ Glasse: Day 3 ends in 7h15m. | ||
|
Pandain
United States12989 Posts
I don't see how that makes me 75% mafia either. | ||
|
youngminii
Australia7514 Posts
| ||
| ||
