Penalty Mafia - Page 35

On August 16 2010 11:17 Bill Murray wrote:


What negative impacts come from this?
FoS: Divinek

On August 16 2010 11:22 Bill Murray wrote:
We have 24 hours left. Darth voting Korynne, and claiming to "look guilty" looks guilty, but it might be town because of his ability to laugh that off. I'm starting to pick up on underlying trends from this game. If Korynne is red I feel like we get a lot of information based upon who was defending her (LSB)

I'm sort of torn on my vote. I hate feeling frustrated as town.

On August 16 2010 11:48 Korynne wrote:
Like I said, I strongly suggest we lynch someone who is not me or BM tonight and let BM vigi me tonight.

BM, I'm not red. So you won't get a lot of information when I die. Instead it FoS's you and citi.zen. I don't know if I think you or citi.zen is red...

So, I'm town, I'll let BM vigi me tonight by voting for majority. (But of course it wouldn't work if me or BM was lynched today) If I was mafia and we're in LYLO tomorrow then obviously you lynch me tomorrow. This is pretty much like a double lynch, since we got to choose to vigi me.

On August 16 2010 12:15 Divinek wrote:


i cant say exactly what it is, because

if i say exactly what it is i will surely be killed by it if the condition is met

On August 17 2010 03:20 DarthThienAn wrote:
Can we lynch bum? :D

On August 17 2010 04:07 Divinek wrote:


we could try but he might stump on us

On August 17 2010 03:41 Korynne wrote:
If BM claims to vigi me and mafia doesn't shoot or shoots me at night then like, they basically wasted a chance to kill someone. Like if we lynch BM if he doesn't shoot me, then if mafia doesn't shoot anyone/shoots me at night that's the equivalent of them shooting BM instead at night, and we lynch someone else during the day, which is giving us another chance at hitting mafia, so it's not bad.

So like seriously, can we lynch someone else today and then:
1) I follow instructions and vote majority, BM vigis me tonight
2) I don't follow instructions and don't vote majority, BM vigis someone else or doesn't vigi at night, you guys lynch me tomorrow (if I'm town I wouldn't screw you guys over and so if it's LYLO lynching me is totally fine because then I'm obviously mafia)
3) Me + someone else doesn't die tonight, in which case we lynch BM tomorrow

Like, lynch BM if I'm the only one that dies. If BM's mafia and can't vigi, then obviously lynch him. If BM's not mafia then mafia framed him, but like I said, that's equivalent to killing him at night.

On August 17 2010 04:18 DarthThienAn wrote:


Oh. I totally forgot about that. I still don't fully understand that. Does someone get converted? Or is one person just considered toward the mafia count? It makes sense that it only happens to one person so then it'd be -1 townie and +1 mafia, in the same way that recruitment works. Whether or not they become part of the mafia team is questionable. Also, how does that person get picked? I want answers!

On August 17 2010 05:21 Korynne wrote:
citi.zen, I don't feel about anyone. Like I said, just not me or BM.

With a lot of you adamant on me being mafia, anyone I bring up strongly kind of becomes a big circle of WIFOM.

So taking out me and BM for obvious reasons (execution of the plan), the choices we have are:
chaoser
citi.zen
Divinek
bumatlarge
Scamp
LSB

From word/penalty/role claims, I would go for chaoser, Darth, Scamp, or Divinek. I guess I'll do an analysis of each when I get home today.

On August 17 2010 06:27 citi.zen wrote:

Your plan requires:

a. A better, 3rd lynch candidate (right now you and BM have all the votes); and
b. A bandwagon for that candidate.

Waiting until the last moment after we've had a 72h day seems designed to distract, more than find reds or implement your plan. Still, finally hearing your thoughts will be interesting.

On August 17 2010 06:31 Divinek wrote:
seriously where the hell has chaoser been his last few posts have just been his votes

On August 12 2010 10:11 chaoser wrote:
I am Obvious. I'm starting to think that there is no townie role, everyone is just blue. Think about the penalties so far, Ace could only do an action if he tells it ahead of time, meaning everyone will know/suspect he's blue. And Pyrr's is that he had to wait till Night 2. Those are some crazy penalties. Unless we're all blue.

On August 17 2010 06:44 citi.zen wrote:
Jayme could well be red as well, so I think lynching Korynne is still the better bet.

On August 17 2010 06:42 DarthThienAn wrote:


Come to think of it, why isn't chaoser dead? Why would mafia hit zeks? To remove the threat of the +1 vote? All they would need to do that is prevent zeks from being lynched.




This post obviously implies that he's either blue or red. So if he's not red, mafia would know that he's blue. So why would they hit zeks, who was just a townie?

##unvote
Vote chaoser