EPTah you're right, my penalty is one use as well i simply misinterpreted the wording of the OP as well as my own pm lol
however i feel that revealing it would be very not good for town, it is a very anti town thing that has a specific condition
Penalty Mafia - Page 2
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
ah you're right, my penalty is one use as well i simply misinterpreted the wording of the OP as well as my own pm lol however i feel that revealing it would be very not good for town, it is a very anti town thing that has a specific condition | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 09 2010 10:16 Ace wrote: Not at all. Reading the OP: If you are town you have a penalty. Doesn't matter if you are blue or green. Scum have fake penalties. # vote Pyrr Bill Murray may be an idiot, but I'm pretty certain you're scum. why is it that you are certain? it seems as soon as a game comes up with all these new rules i cant seem to understand what is going on (i mean i do have reasons formulating in my head like perhaps demonstrating a bit too much knowledge of certain things, or an attempt to split us up and re direct us from any plan trying to help us like with your penalty plan) i agree that i get a bad feeling based on what's happened, and i dont like flopping my vote around too much, but i would rather have my vote on scum than on an idiot. and i just like to see where other people are coming from in order to solidly incorporate things they see that i might have missed | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 09 2010 10:49 Ace wrote: and how will they find said medic? They can't because they don't know who the medic is. They just know penalties. Once again penalties do not imply roles. If it does then tell me my role, and tell zeks his role if you believe this. And Pyrr is mafia. Stop voting for Bill Murray and deal with him tomorrow. you didnt answer my question  | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
| ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
that if your penalty is such and such like 'you can only use your ability every other night' then all penalties should accurately describe the nature of the person sure that SPECIFIC example does make the person look awfully blue but i can assure not all penalties do, as mine makes me look just the opposite of what i am, if you're following that line of reasoning | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 09 2010 11:04 Ace wrote: oh ok. Do you want like, an entire breakdown of Day 1 with all my logical queries and conclusions, with big picture breakdown + small quips or do you want the simple one paragraph stuff where I say he's scum and just quote some of his nonsense? lol well more stuff can be more to digest, so i prefer simpler as im a fan of occams razor i really just want your reasonings, all of them, for believing he is scum as you obviously demonstrate a better grasp as to wtf is going on in this game with rules/roles/other stuffs that are confusing me and i dont like a confused town/townie | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 09 2010 11:23 citi.zen wrote: Perhaps I am reading this too closely, but I don't see the word "action" in either of those descriptions. In fact, they are quite different from what you and bumatlarge described, but close to what zeks posted. At any rate what Bill did is against the rules unless he is red or knows something we don't. So I am still all for lynching him right now. what did he do that was against the rules? | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 09 2010 11:30 citi.zen wrote: If he is not red, does not have additional information and has no restriction on speaking (as the OP says), he went for personal vendetta at the risk of screwing he town over. Usually there is a "play to win" rule. well to be fair it was a random vote that only meant something because someone made something out of it. People do place holders or random votes all the time in periods such as the RVS and such. But it is possible that he knows something we dont isnt it, with all the weird roles out there. Like maybe his final votes have to always be on the person with a first letter closest to the start of the alphabet..the possibilities are infinite and he really should try to explain himself. But BM always does things at the risk of screwing the town over this is not new. Perhaps we should always kill him day 1 or get him vigi popped otherwise if he doesnt stop acting so retarded. It really is annoying | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
and now that i got what i wanted from ace, his post seems to confirm his aligntment for me for now and thus it seems perfectly right to believe him so im definitely believing my original intentions, now that the votes on bm actually pressured him into talking, and getting this wagon starter on ace lynched ##unvote ##vote pyrr | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
if a mafia is lynched it negatively impacts on me for the following night | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 10 2010 09:26 zeks wrote: lets just get rid of one (or more) of BM and Ace and reset from step 1 if not one of you (or more) are scum then considered my mind blown - 3 of the "best" players on a see-saw for the past day or two and all end up town? i dont buy it surely you mean 2 of the best players. I dont think BM is banned from ace's games because his play is so good it breaks the balance factor | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 10 2010 12:15 bumatlarge wrote: Pretty desperate. If I didn't know better (I'm sure you'd make a 5 paragraph essay speculating in a roundabout way about how do not know better) you would like me to use my ability, wouldn't you? well if you did use it then you really would be a god in this game wouldnt you or at least an immortal! that's quite the one up | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 10 2010 12:38 bumatlarge wrote: Yeah it would seem Ace doesnt care whether or not I use it. You would think a townie would say that that would be a very bad move, but that's probably my noobie tendencies talking. I mean how bad can it be to give mafia 4 against, whats this now? 8 then? Hmm and no DT because, oh look hes dead! Because of some brilliant plan! Man what should we do now Ace? well i think the only thing we gain from it is a confirmed townie. But in a game with such a small number of players, shifting the balance by TWO people, 1 for each side is down right ridiculous and i dont think you could ever justify using it. Like seriously even if you were to be lynched it'd be better to give town -1, than -1 and +1 mafia, unless you knew for sure someone else was scum or something. Because a confirmed townie isnt really much to go off of what with us not being allowed to pm and stuff this game, that and probably our only dt is dead anyway. | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 11 2010 08:49 LSB wrote: FYI, Nytophobic is a fear of Darkness. Maybe Ace had to pick who to save during the day? hmm that would make sense with the telegraphing thing then wouldnt it | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 11 2010 09:35 bumatlarge wrote: Well it's starting to make a little sense how this all came to be. Bill is Bill and does his Bill thing. Pyrr in all his DT glory goes ahead and makes a silly assumption about bill right off the bat. Bill being Bill, he agrees and essentially lies ( ) Ace being Ace, instantly sees pyrrs little guess as a scum trick, and underestimates Bill's Billness, and shoots for pyrr as the head honcho of the operation. He only feels more convinced when Bill comes out of his charade. As a result, pyrr dies, which seems an unfortunate coincidence that he was a DT. And now Ace dieing, no matter how he died, is bad luck since he was medic. I think its safe to assume we have at most 2 more blues left, with very little chance either is a DT or medic.Honestly, Bill deserves a policy lynch for what he has done. policy lynching always seems to be what gets bm. I'm kind of interested in the people who were going balls out at arguing against ace, because obviously if they knew he was going to die at night it would make them look pretty good. Not that their arguments weren't justified, they certainly seemed very solid. It just makes it that much easier to come off clean. Without a vigi claiming it would be silly to assume that's how ace died, because a vigi has little reason not to claim now after doing that. But someone like lsb assuming he did to possibly draw suspicion off him self for reasons stated above it quite interesting. I'm curious if we had any other blue roles with powers like maybe a watcher or something that found anything out. But unless a vigi claims im very weary of at least one of the people pushing for ace to die. | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 11 2010 10:54 Scamp wrote: Mafia have no penalties. Read the OP. Now, maybe someone has a power that forces them to do that, like their hit got deflected or something. It's pretty fucked up that that might make the most sense if we didnt have a vigi shot | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 11 2010 12:21 youngminii wrote: Anyone else think BM's role seems stupid and made up? It would completely fuck up the balance of the game and I'm pretty sure there wouldn't be a role like that. Also, what better way to prevent the town from lynching you? And yeeeeeeeeeeeeah I'm not claiming. well the enabler is a real thing in the parts of mafia land. But why on earth would you publicly admit that was your role is beyond me. Unless he's lying, which it wouldnt be the first time for bm. So he's either lying about his role, and he's town Or he's lying about his role and he's mafia either way he's lying...unless somehow ace protected him last night and ended up dying from it? But that doesnt make any sense from an enabler, or i can hardly see ace wanting to protect bm based on what happened yesterday so wtf | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 12 2010 01:51 Korynne wrote: Oops, thanks Hesmyrr. In that case it looks like BM will have to off Divinek or bumatlarge tonight if he decides to use his ability. In this case I'd like to see at least an adjective claim from Divinek, though I suspect he's probably off birthday celebrating... fuck yeah i am! so ill be on in spurts tonight cause my bday! anyways my adjective is Unwary, and ive mentioned my penalty before, but i cant get specific cause that'd out my role | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
lets look at young's amazing contribution to the game thus far woooooooooooooooooooo On August 10 2010 02:47 youngminii wrote: LOL OKAY I TOTALLY DID NOT KNOW THIS GAME STARTED WILL START READING LOL spam On August 11 2010 09:11 youngminii wrote: Cool so the doctor stabs the DT and then gets killed. Does anyone think that he might have been Vigi shot? Seems like a plausible explanation to me although that leaves the question of where the mafia KP went unanswered. states what happened, asks a question, answers question. HI-larious On August 11 2010 12:21 youngminii wrote: Anyone else think BM's role seems stupid and made up? It would completely fuck up the balance of the game and I'm pretty sure there wouldn't be a role like that. Also, what better way to prevent the town from lynching you? And yeeeeeeeeeeeeah I'm not claiming. enablers exist in mafia, and they seem somewhat reasonable in this set up as long as you dont publicly admit you are an enabler as such, because how else would anyone ever know. I dont see how it fucks with the balance anymore than something like a tree stump. It does seem like kind of a weird thing to go with a vigi, but not unreasonable? I dunno i think he might be lying bout vigi tos ave his own ass WAIT, im digressing! This post REEKS of confusion. Just asks 2 questions, without really putting anything forward, typical fanning flames play. Typical mafia not wanting to put anything forward but suspicion on someone else On August 11 2010 23:54 youngminii wrote: My adjective is "selfish" which matches my real life persona. well that is what it is, could have gotten that from his mafia pm or something On August 12 2010 10:56 youngminii wrote: In that case. ##Vote Bill Murray Lynch All Liars. policy lynch wooooooooooooo, nothing to tie him to the person if that person should flip anything but red. It has also been justified that lynching bm is stupid because he'll die to delicious JUSTICE if he is lying about his role, and if he's not we need to let him live to use it SHIZA, so to sumarrize this, that doesnt look right, summarize YOUNGMINII hasnt contributed ANYTHING since the game started so that scum fuck is getting my vote because that's the best case i can come up with, im pretty sure this would be my vote even if i was not under the influence of substances so my fellow citizens, and even my fellow citi.zens. I URGE you to consider the case I have presented you, if you believe play like this doesnt deserve a lynch, or at least intense scrutiny, then what the fuck is wrong with you. cheers ##vote youngminii i hope i spelled his name right because i ilke spelling names right, but im sure our host will know good night gahh | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On August 13 2010 08:22 LSB wrote: Youngminii said he couldn't devote that much time in the other game. Youngminii would be modkilled anyways, for not voting. hi just got back from work before the deadline :D crazy driving yay also he's not going to get mod killed Bill Murray (1) youngminii from the vote totals on page 1, and those are quite up to date. And uh i like my vote where it is based on the few things that have been said. No lynch would be silly. | ||
| ||
