TL Mafia XXVIII - Page 54

On July 22 2010 10:21 DarthThienAn wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
yea you did. See BB and Amber.

On July 22 2010 10:28 Subversion wrote:
lol, now the other 2 suspects have joined forces to oust me.

Guys please wake up. Literally the only valid suspicion on me, is some stupid remark. We've got to stop banging that drum.

Please can we pick a valid target. To be honest, I don't like this vote at all. I'm not particularly convinced that chaoser and DTA are scum at all. Although if I had to choose, I'd choose DTA.

But really, I am not the right person to lynch here. When you find out I'm not scum, what information are you going to gain from that?

On July 22 2010 10:31 Divinek wrote:
im totally game for saving darth's ass though if it comes down to it just because he's been sending me sexual messages via pm

On July 22 2010 10:31 Divinek wrote:
im totally game for saving darth's ass though if it comes down to it just because he's been sending me sexual messages via pm

but ill only vote for sub if it's necessary because i see him as more useful for us to lynch than darth at this point(info etc), since i think it's reasonable for either of them to be red it's all about convincing then and sub has convinced me to be more red than darth so far

even if darth is being a silly billy, i have faith he'll help us the next day or die

so is darth on the block if it's a tie right now or what?

On July 22 2010 09:00 tree.hugger wrote:
This is the stupidest thing, pretty much ever.

Is there evidence against chaoser? Nobody can really explain what it is. Is there evidence against DTA? Hardly. Is there evidence against Subversion? Yes, there is.

1) Subversion voted at the last minute to lynch someone who's bandwagon was pathetic from the start, and really had nothing behind it. But the real significance of that vote, was that it saved someone else (youngminii). We didn't know about it at the time, because BM's count was off, but the mafia (assuming for a moment that youngminii is red) would clearly have a much more accurate count. They might've assumed that BM's vote count would be a cover, but at any rate they needed to make sure to save their own member.

2) Subversion's post, in which he commented on how well the mafia were doing was (a) not true, and (b) something that I don't think I've ever heard anyone innocent ever say in a game of mafia. That's something I can see a new mafia member thinking a townie would say, but that's not something a townie would actually say.

Furthermore, lynching Subversion just makes plain sense from a town perspective. A whole host of people have put their reputations on the line to save Subversion. Nobody has said anything in chaoser's defense. Nobody has said anything in DTA's defense. They've been left to defend themselves, and, apparently to some people that looks guilty.

What does that mean? Aside from being absurdly suspicious, if we lynch Subversion, then we gain a ton of information. If Subversion flips red, then we catch youngminii right off the bat. citi.zen has been defending Subversion nearly every post he gets, albeit a little more subtlety. Almost everyone in the game is on record saying something about Subversion, which means that if we lynch him, we get to figure out who was right, and who was wrong and proceed from there.

None of the other lynch candidates are even close to as valuable as Subversion. If we lose another day lynching people who aren't mafia, then we're going to be in trouble.

On July 22 2010 10:41 Pandain wrote:


Nah, ends at 12.

At least not in 22 minutes.

On July 22 2010 10:10 Bill Murray wrote:
day ends in 2 hours and 49 minutes and around 14 seconds... er make that 48 minutes and 40 seconds... you get the drift