EPTThis was my first mafia game and I was Townie. anyone mind commenting on things that I did or didn't do that I should work on to improve?
Thanks.
Godfather Mafia - Page 86
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
rastaban
United States2294 Posts
This was my first mafia game and I was Townie. anyone mind commenting on things that I did or didn't do that I should work on to improve? Thanks. | ||
|
Hesmyrr
Canada5776 Posts
 )Also I agree L modkill really screwed the town; loss of traitor/mafia really cost them valuable window to counterclaim youngminii in that critical day. | ||
|
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On July 13 2010 23:35 Hesmyrr wrote: youngminii used his abilities splendidly, I think. He literally won us a game in what I find to be extremely mafia-sided setup. Also props to Bill Murray for his decision to jail me and I think Chenizu at the very last night?- I have no idea why I stood out that much compared to rest of the veterans, honestly. (double jail AND recruit attempt? )Also I agree L modkill really screwed the town; loss of traitor/mafia really cost them valuable window to counterclaim youngminii in that critical day. You actually didn't stand out - that is why I tried to recruit you. I was very close to recruiting Abenson or BM in your place, but decided BM was better at causing chaos on his own and Abenson is no danger to the mafia team anyway. Instead I went for a roster which combined some experience with lower-key but solid players. Then L got killed so I tried to replace him with BC (I thought there was a decent chance Ace was a Mason given Korynne's early play), and got lucky enough to be DT checked on the very first try. This set-up seems high-variance: the right DT check pretty much ended the game (granted I made a moronic mistake, at that point the town would still RB/bomb/distrust me); the wrong DT check and a successful night 2 recruitment means mafia pretty much wins. | ||
|
Ace
United States16096 Posts
| ||
|
YellowInk
United States578 Posts
Since mafia hadn't conceded and BM being ridiculous, when I was lynched I was convinced youngminii was mafia. I figured we were looking at a mafia victory. With all the lying that was going on in the town, I don't see how we could have won without the streak of luck even if it were a level game. Since most of you wouldn't tell me in thread, I'm curious what convinced you guys I was mafia? | ||
|
Qatol
United States3165 Posts
| ||
|
bumatlarge
United States4567 Posts
| ||
|
Chezinu
United States7463 Posts
On July 14 2010 01:15 bumatlarge wrote: lol GG... You totally called so many things and didn't know it! | ||
|
BrownBear
United States6894 Posts
Bearies coming later tonight. | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
| ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
On July 14 2010 00:55 YellowInk wrote: Mafia got incredibly unlucky here. If the GF can stay under the radar till day 5 or so, it's practically unwinnable for town with the number of blues we had. This is why I was convinced we had at least two roleblockers - how can you honestly expect the GF to be found by the midgame? You need some way to draw the game out and have a reasonable chance for a town win without finding the GF in the early game. This kind of setup is just really swingy. Since mafia hadn't conceded and BM being ridiculous, when I was lynched I was convinced youngminii was mafia. I figured we were looking at a mafia victory. With all the lying that was going on in the town, I don't see how we could have won without the streak of luck even if it were a level game. Since most of you wouldn't tell me in thread, I'm curious what convinced you guys I was mafia? noone was convinced you were mafia we just wanted you to shut up | ||
|
rastaban
United States2294 Posts
On July 14 2010 00:55 YellowInk wrote: Mafia got incredibly unlucky here. If the GF can stay under the radar till day 5 or so, it's practically unwinnable for town with the number of blues we had. This is why I was convinced we had at least two roleblockers - how can you honestly expect the GF to be found by the midgame? You need some way to draw the game out and have a reasonable chance for a town win without finding the GF in the early game. This kind of setup is just really swingy. Since mafia hadn't conceded and BM being ridiculous, when I was lynched I was convinced youngminii was mafia. I figured we were looking at a mafia victory. With all the lying that was going on in the town, I don't see how we could have won without the streak of luck even if it were a level game. Since most of you wouldn't tell me in thread, I'm curious what convinced you guys I was mafia? I thought you were mafia day 1, but after that (I assumed Ace RBed you) I thought you were in the clear. I voted for you the day of the lynch as a place holder vote and when I came back you had already been railroaded. I was going to switch my vote since I didn't see any reason to lynch you but by then there was no way to sway everyone else and it fit the plan so I went with it. | ||
|
youngminii
Australia7514 Posts
On July 14 2010 00:55 YellowInk wrote: Mafia got incredibly unlucky here. If the GF can stay under the radar till day 5 or so, it's practically unwinnable for town with the number of blues we had. This is why I was convinced we had at least two roleblockers - how can you honestly expect the GF to be found by the midgame? You need some way to draw the game out and have a reasonable chance for a town win without finding the GF in the early game. This kind of setup is just really swingy. Since mafia hadn't conceded and BM being ridiculous, when I was lynched I was convinced youngminii was mafia. I figured we were looking at a mafia victory. With all the lying that was going on in the town, I don't see how we could have won without the streak of luck even if it were a level game. Since most of you wouldn't tell me in thread, I'm curious what convinced you guys I was mafia? My list of suspects were: BM YI BC I checked BM and then I voted for you since you were next on the list. It's not that your posts were overly scummy and it was hugely obvious that you were mafia (and you weren't) but it was more that no one else seemed scummy and your posts did have a little bit of scumminess in them. I did say that my vote wasn't completely serious and I'd be fine if you weren't lynched, as I'd just check you that night anyway. But other people ended up voting you as well, 'cause I guess at that point it became a game of follow the cop or something, I'm not sure. | ||
|
Incognito
United States2071 Posts
On July 14 2010 00:56 Qatol wrote: When Darth PMed me with the idea for this game, my first response was "I don't know how the heck we're going to balance this." I'm just happy it turned out to have a playable format, even if the game changed a lot from the last time I gave input to the final version (Coroner and Dream Catcher weren't in that version and I don't think Jailkeeper was either?). Nicely done Darth and whomever you talked to for the final iterations. *Gasp* a town win? Impossible... | ||
|
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
On July 13 2010 17:48 Chezinu wrote: oh Darth, did you use the queen of spades and queen of diamonds for the masons? nah I used Aces. lol yea. I was like o.O at the things happening. Just got back so I'll make a list of the night actions and all that asap. | ||
|
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + 1. Chezinu - Dream Catcher -> Mad Hatter 2. BrownBear - Townie 3. YellowInk - Townie 4. zeks - Free Mason 5. Thegilaboy/BloodyC0bbler - Townie -> Night 2 Mafia 6. Divinek - Coroner/Lover 7. Bill Murray - Jailkeeper 8. citi.zen - Godfather 9. L - Traitor -> Night 0 Mafia 10. DCLXVI - Townie 11. Hesmyrr - Townie 12. youngminii - Detective 13. bumatlarge 14. [s]Korynne/Ace - Roleblocker 15. lakrismamma - Coroner 16. Abenson - Townie/Lover 17. ElyAs - Townie 18. AcrossFiveJulys - Mad Hatter/Free Mason 19. rastaban - Townie 20. BrowneY - Townie | ||
|
Chezinu
United States7463 Posts
| ||
|
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
On July 14 2010 08:51 Chezinu wrote: A5J is mason right? yea, typo, just fixed it. Also, I'll vouch for Chez's "decoding" zeks thing. | ||
|
Chezinu
United States7463 Posts
On July 14 2010 08:52 DarthThienAn wrote: yea, typo, just fixed it. Also, I'll vouch for Chez's "decoding" zeks thing. Here was the pm: + Show Spoiler + From: DarthThienAn [ 1702 posts | Profile | Buddy ] Subject: Re: For post-game Date: 7/5/10 09:35 lol, okay. ^^. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: When I said I "think" I cracked the code. It is really just a big guess. I noticed that the code had 15 characters so I decided to play hangman. First thing I decided to do was assume that he was naming his partner for his death post. so, I was like who have a name 15 characters long --> AcrossFiveJulys So that was my guess, whether it is right.. I have no idea, lol! g6<9<<x?N.n<?C= -> AcrossFiveJulys Also, proof roleclaiming helps: + Show Spoiler + On July 07 2010 13:11 Chezinu wrote: Player List Based on people's roleclaims and people's reaction (this does not necessarily represent my opinion unless it is 100% correct): 1. Chezinu 2. BrownBear 3. YellowInk 4. zeks 5. 6. Divinek 7. Bill Murray 8. citi.zen 10. DCLXVI 11. Hesmyrr 12. youngminii 16. Abenson 18. AcrossFiveJulys 19. rastaban Ace confirmed DCLXVI as innocent | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On July 13 2010 17:12 Youngminii wrote: I'm too good at this shit. I shall henceforth be known as Scumhunter Youngminii. yeah you sure sniffed me out you scum hunting genious. and yi too god you're amazing | ||
| ||
