TL Mafia XXVII
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 03 2010 03:46 Korynne wrote: For sures. Yay! Also, having you as a moderator will bring back nice memories from PYP mafia. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 03 2010 04:16 Korynne wrote: I don't get it. xD It was just us sticking out to the end with Foolishness. =P (Hopefully he'll play too? xP) Yup. Good times. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 04 2010 11:44 Incognito wrote: How bout I make you a Veteran and I give mafia aligned dayvig to someone who has a grudge against you? Him dying is never about grudges, it's about respect. Also, you'd think by now watchers/medics/etc. would get a clue, eh? | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 05 2010 03:00 LunarDestiny wrote: Sorry I am trolling this thread again. I want to ask is Radfield THAT good of a player that he is always the #1 target for the mafia. I search a little in the forum, but can't seem to find a game with his late game plays. It all depends on the crowd. This time many vets are playing, so I don't know. On the other hand, if the expectation is that Ace and L will bicker and kill each other anyway, Radfield's looks like a better mafia target. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 06 2010 10:46 flamewheel wrote: Awesome. I've... graduated. Should have more time now. I think. Congrats! And, no :-) | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 10 2010 13:07 citi.zen wrote: I am fine with the mass role-claiming suggestion. There are 4 vanilla townies here + miller so the mafia would not have a very easy time hiding among them. Claiming a blue role is very tricky for the reds since the rightful owner will know it. Never mind, had not read this part: There is a possibility that not all roles listed here will be used in the game. I need to think about this more... it's not the no-brainer I initially thought it was. If there is a non-assigned blue role it would be perfect for the mafia to try to claim it late. And there would be more townies to "hide" the other mafia. + Show Spoiler + I'll be honest: I don't have a lot of time. I am nominally on vacation, but in reality at home with an 18 months old with bad separation anxiety (3rd night in a row puking before bed) and a newborn. My more active mafia games happen when I am at work :-) That said, I hope if I make it into a late game situation I can make the right call. If not, so be it, at least I took a bullet for someone else! Under the spoiler to save Foolishness his "nobody cares" sticker. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 11 2010 19:54 Radfield wrote: I also just noticed we have 4 voters in the voting thread. What the heck people!? Do NOT vote without posting an explanation, that helps the mafia coast. (I realize Chez posted a reason) It's posts like these: On June 11 2010 14:28 ohN wrote: 'Forgot about this game lol. Interesting how we have a lot of greens claiming and not much else. Everybody should keep claiming imo, puts the mafia in a tough spot and narrows down who we need to look at. On June 11 2010 14:44 ohN wrote: Whole point of the plan is to get everybody to claim. If only like half of us claim it hurts us more than help. Not much, but I don't see a better candidate right now... so w/e. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 12 2010 02:50 AcrossFiveJulys wrote: Hold your horses flamewheel. L's "plan" awhile back asked vets to claim detective as well in order to confuse mafia. And people calling me mafia (RoL I'm looking at you) because I mistakenly thought for a second that lynched millers flip townie are fucking retarded. I've been in games where millers were lynched so I never should have thought that, was just a temporary mistake (wasn't a matter of not looking at the rules). So who are we going to lynch today? Guess I'll start with voting for RoL since he started off accuse-happy and claimed townie. I'm always up for lynching MooCow though :D Suspect post - why would you be up for lynching a claimed blue? | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 12 2010 03:12 AcrossFiveJulys wrote: Btw we shouldn't lynch Ludwig or MooCow because as of now what they have both claimed is legal by L's plan. We should either go after someone who claimed townie or someone who didn't claim anything. That's better. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 12 2010 20:19 Radfield wrote: Agreed, although it's still early in the game and everyone has contributed at least some. The more I think about it the more it seems like we should just check/lynch whoever seems most scummy. I'd like to hear other peoples opinions on who to lynch though. My opinion is that, rather than speculating endlessly on who is more or less "active" (ie - posting nonsense) we should wait for the night actions to come in. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 13 2010 10:02 AcrossFiveJulys wrote: yes? I got a PM from incognito last "night" saying that I've been role blocked. This is not how it works in any other game. Can a mod chime in? | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 13 2010 11:26 AcrossFiveJulys wrote: Also, reiterating, if anyone else wants to say they got role blocked, please do. If no one else speaks up you should be able to put some trust in that I was the one role blocked and therefore probably not mafia. If someone does speak up then it will be obvious that they are mafia if I get lynched and flip town. Except in every other game vanilla townies are not PMed that information since technically there is no action to "block" at night. So, unless Incogito confirms that in this game he will send PMs to everyone who gets blocked, even vanilla townies, your statement is meaningless. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 13 2010 11:31 flamewheel wrote: Actually most games that I've seen recently with roleblockers involve the person being roleblocked getting told he is roleblocked, whether he has an action or not. OK, this helps. Thanks, would still be nice to confirm from Incognito. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 14 2010 12:24 MooCow wrote: Even though I invested AFJ I still don't think we should lynch him because even if he is mafia they still only have 1KP so that doesn't really change much unless we get a role blocker and either way if we do get role blocked again someone should come out and say so. I'm one for lynching the inactive in this game especially because of the 1KP mafia. Either way AFJ is heavily in the spotlight we can rest assured that he'll be banging on about something in the coming days, which would either help us or make us lynch him. Now with AFJ being suspected of being a mafia and me coming out and defending him will obviously make me look like a mafia. If I were mafia I would not chose to investigate another mafia target. There were a couple ways I could of avoided this situation. 1. Chose the target before letting LuDwig chose the target. Why would I want to risk investigating another mafia member? ( I'm a lot more active than LuDwig but I let him chose ). I wanted to investigate someone inactive so we could lynch them as a test pig. 2. I wouldn't come out here and try to defend him and draw attention to myself. The risks of me doing this as a mafia almost has no reward. If it were 1KP/2Mafia then yea I would of been rewarded if AFJ is safe but doing this gives me nothing as mafia. If he flips red I can plead insane/paranoid and it puts me in the same boat as LuDwig. ( I also posted my findings on AFJ before LuDwig did ) So I don't think he's really mafia but maybe he is. For today I think we should just look at 2 of those inactive, lynch one and pre-plan for the night so we can all be on the same targets ( meeple, if he checked AFJ and came out with his information this would be a lot easier ) The 1 KP talk is a non-starter - catching reds is still what the game is about. Also, according to L, who presumably has more information, if he flips red we also confirm Foolish is red. You ignore this and instead offer weak "if i were mafia" arguments. OK... | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
##Kill L No d-vig here. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 15 2010 02:27 Foolishness wrote: To go by history, Vivi57 is usually inactive when he's townie, and very active if he has a blue role. Not as sure as when he's mafia, but I'd go for RoL just in case. You're pretty confirmed too I guess, with A5J. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
If your discussion with L was all scripted you deserve the Oscar. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 15 2010 03:38 redtooth wrote: ok guys i had a lot of work the past weekend so i couldn't keep up with the thread as much as i would have liked. quoting my post on why L should have died immediately. good job citizen for actually pulling the trigger though. L was so scummy and the fact that he was alive was the biggest incrimination against him. if citizen is playing his role right then A5J should flip red tomorrow. doesn't look like voting could swing in any other direction but go ahead and stack it against him anyways. also, foolishness is probably not mafia aligned. radfield seems scummy or retarded, can't tell atm. A5J? Really? Are you reading the thread at all? | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 15 2010 01:48 Radfield wrote: Wow wow wow. Either an amazing shot Citizen, or you're mafia and hoping to get all our roleclaims and allay all suspicion. An extremely ballsy move actually, considering that if L flipped green, then we would certianly use the next lynch on you. Doubly hurting the town. I'm still very ok with lynching AFJ, but if people don't agree I'm fine with that. List of fairly inactive players: vivi57 redtooth RoL Ohn I say we go after RoL first. He strikes me as moderately scummy, and is the scummiest looking player who voted for Jspazz. And to this... what % would you assign to the likelihood of me being mafia? Why would it make sense for me to kill the GF right now instead of a goon if I wanted credibility? Furthermore, there was no immediate danger of being lynched for either me or L, why not save the hit for later when it could be decisive /end the game? You know I of all people love a good conspiracy theory, but give me a break - this one makes no sense. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 15 2010 08:00 Foolishness wrote: [/blue]We don't need to spend time right now lynching possible DT's because they have a slim chance of being red. That's something we do if we're in a desperate scenario. Godfather being dead now means we stick to the original plan of lynching an inactive and coordinating DT checks on someone tomorrow (I like Ohn, he's always inactive when he's mafia I have first hand experience with that) This sounds fine. Will vote ohn - thought his lack of reaction to my day one vote was a bit odd. At any rate he ain't helping us. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
Good show. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 16 2010 05:54 MooCow wrote: Yea I must be REALLY bad at this game for citizen ( if he's town ) to want to kill me. I'm not even trying to look like mafia and i'm DT but I still come off as mafia! 2 faces -__-;; T__T. You actually did fine this game. The team strategy wasn't bad either, but it did fail. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 14 2010 01:17 Radfield wrote: I think lynching moocow right now is premature. If he's telling the truth then we hurt ourselves doubly: the loss of a town aligned player, and giving the mafia less blue targets to shoot at. I realize that by focusing on AFJ today we're kind of giving the less active players a pass. But we can focus on them tomorrow. I'd like to know the opinions on whom we should lynch from these people: Vivi57 citi.zen Foolishness redtooth RebirthOfLeGend I'd like to hear everyone else's opinion as well, but these 5 are a bit on the inactive side. Pretty weak for someone who is good at this game, but it happens. What's worse is his most recent post of suspects: On June 15 2010 11:17 Radfield wrote: I agree 100% with foolishness. By having our dt's check the same person, and then subsequently killing that person, we should be able to get very close to figuring out the sanities. I also think that the results should not be made public, and should be pm'ed to two people before having the results released. My absence is due to exceeding our bandwidth limit and basically getting cut off for 24 hrs. Our speed drops to almost zero, and sometimes doesn't work at all. These are our remaining players Claimed Blue Meeple Ludwig Moocow Not very suspicious at the moment Foolishness Citizen AcrossFiveJulys Mildly Suspicious Chezinu Flamewheel Redtooth People can slot me in wherever they think I belong. Personally I find moocow to be more suspicious then ludwig, but I think it possible that both are legit dt's. Very likely one is naive if that's the case. It's still premature to start offing the blues though. Despite the fact we have 2 mafia down, losing 3 greens today seriously hurts us. Day 5 is lynch or lose at this point, assuming no medic saves or vets. Personally I find redtooth the most suspicious of those three, Chez second, Flamewheel third. Note the odd organization, then read the translation: don't touch blues (hi Moocow!); suspect everyone, even confirmed townies; and lynch... Chez, Flamewheel or RedTooth. Yet in a PM he sent me after this forum post he still advocated lynching... A5J. + Show Spoiler + ----------------------------------------- Original Message: Your probably right, I'm just having a difficult time shaking the thought that he's mafia. Also, I've been kind of assuming that we have either an insane or a naive dt. Because otherwise town would be a bit overpowered at this point. I do think it's valuble to determine the sanity, but given that we're running out of time, I doubt we'll be able to do much with our dt('s) anyways. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: On A5J - do you really think his PM with L is staged? And their thread conversations? I've never seen a mafia team put that much effort into a risky strategy like that. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: Honestly, if I could take anyone out with a night vig shot it would be AFJ. I'm still moderately skeptical of his posting, as well as the whole roleblocker thing. It also helps us determine alignment of the dt's. Taking out moocow still seems a bit premature, but I'm alright with it if you go for it. I imagine we'll need to eliminate him as some point anyways. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: You're right, he seems very sketchy. I have a night vigilante I am talking to. I will ask them to take MooCow out tonight. Thanks! ----------------------------------------- Original Message: I'm a townie. I don't particularly trust moocow. I DO trust both ludwig and meeple. Don't tell moocow anything more than he needs to know. ----------------------------------------- Original Message: Please let me know what you think of MooCow. An honest list of suspects looks like this: Confirmed townies: Myself. Foolishness. Meeple. A5J. Browns: Chez. Flamewheel. Others: Radfield MooCow RedTooth Ludwig- Radfield wants RedTooth dead. Ludwig- seems Ok. Leaving... Radfield and MooCow. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
I am going to stop, so I don't "dominate the debate" and other people can slowly figure this out too. Or not. Either way I did my part. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
BTW: there is no vigilante, the MooCow "hit" was a bluff. Some of you already knew this. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 16 2010 13:41 LuDwig- wrote: Just wake up. Checked radfield. Result: Green. ROFL. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 17 2010 10:11 Korynne wrote: The last mafia has expressed wishes not to concede. Gogogo. This is silly. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 17 2010 14:08 Foolishness wrote: So who's getting checked tonight? Obviously we should do one of: Radfield, redtooth, Chezinu. Then we must decide who to kill tomorrow assuming a green result. So I would say, we check redtooth and kill Radfield. Unless of course the result of the check is Mafia. RedTooth is really inactive and seems useless even if town. I'd say ... check Chez and kill Radfield. Also, don't forget to add Flamewheel to that list. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 17 2010 14:32 Radfield wrote: Trust me, if it was me as mafia, I would concede. What kind of player do you think I am? I'm not here to waste people's time. I very much doubt redtooth is mafia, as he's playing a very strange pseudo inactive strategy if he is. It's just too obvious. He'll probably be modkilled anyways though. I think Flamewheel would concede at this point. I know Chezinu would not concede at this point. Also, Chez seems quite confident that I am not mafia, and he seems to be the only person in the thread who really thinks so. The only other player in this game who was sure I was pro-town was Ludwig. Also, Flamewheel isn't necessarily not mafia because he got roleblocked. Ludwig needed to roleblock Flamewheel so that if the watcher looked at flamewheel, he would see that both 'dts' visited. Also, we have a watcher, tracker, doctor and dayvig. It seems likely we have a naive dt and not a sane one. Having a sane dt would make this game a cakewalk. I recommend that if you lynch me, you then lynch Flamewheel and Chezinu, in whatever order you like. The only shred of doubt in my mind as to whether you are red is Korynne's comment. I think that is what Chez is basing his opinion on as well. Regardless, we agree on the general plan. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
On June 18 2010 11:32 Vivi57 wrote: great game thanks to citizen otherwise, we'd probably have been sweeped Even the blind chicken will get a piece of corn every now and again. Seriously. GJ Foolish/Meeple, really well played Chez, but you were always going to remain on the suspect shortlist. Taking a break for a couple of weeks. | ||
citi.zen
2509 Posts
| ||
| ||