|
On October 28 2009 13:39 Pyrrhuloxia wrote:Show nested quote +On October 28 2009 13:11 SugiuraMidori wrote:
Let me put this as clearly and succinctly as possible so that you guys can perhaps finally get it...
IF YOU SUSPECT REDTOOTH YOU HAVE TO SUSPECT VIVI AND VICE VERSA
Please kill these mafia already... I keep asking why you keep repeating this. Is it that they have been voting identically?
You haven't asked yet, but Shikyo just did in a PM so I guess no one has figured it out yet. I'm not going to roleclaim, as it IS one of the rules.... They have never once argued against each other in anything, and their posts are rather evenly interspersed within the thread, almost as if they're one person taking turns making a short burst of posts before retreating to the shadows... seems like mafia behavior to me.
Additionally, we can note that Judge and Scamp have behaved similarly, although in a much quieter way.
|
On October 28 2009 13:36 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:Show nested quote +On October 28 2009 13:15 iNfuNdiBuLuM wrote:
So either L got hit by a vigilante or the mad hatter bomb, but not the mafia? lol What are you saying? He was either hit by the mafia or the MadHatter. DF Either put a bomb on Judge and L, or Judge and Incognito. The mafia definitely used one hit on DF which activated (her?) bombs which hit either L and Judge, or Judge and Incognito. This is all assuming that L was actually protected/Veteran last night and that DF planted two bombs already (which is possible) The mafia also could of targeted Judge, however the last two things are highly unlikely. I doubt the mafia hit one of there own and if you look in DF's past posts, (She?) said she agreed with L on something, although that was very early on so her opinion could of changed. I didn't see any comments on incognito though.
oh right - i forgot df could have put a bomb on incog. i just kinda assumed mafia hit him.
|
yeah i think the scenario that makes the most sense is - mafia hit df and L, df has bombs on Incog and Judge
|
That scenario might make the most sense but it's wrong. The mafia hit Incognito and Dreamflower, unless the way the deaths are described have no meaning. There may not be clues, but the way they died is still valid.
Also don't forget that L could simply be lying.
|
On October 28 2009 15:15 Scamp wrote:
That scenario might make the most sense but it's wrong. The mafia hit Incognito and Dreamflower, unless the way the deaths are described have no meaning. There may not be clues, but the way they died is still valid.
Also don't forget that L could simply be lying.
Wow, is it just me or does everything about this post just scream mafia... gg Scamp
He clearly talks about the mafia like he is part of it.. if no one else can see this... I dunno what's up with you xD
|
On October 28 2009 15:15 Scamp wrote:
That scenario might make the most sense but it's wrong. The mafia hit Incognito and Dreamflower, unless the way the deaths are described have no meaning. There may not be clues, but the way they died is still valid.
Also don't forget that L could simply be lying.
How can you just say its wrong? You have nothing else backing that up. DF specifically said earlier in the thread that he agreed with L and nothing to the contrary. He could of been lying, he could have changed his mind but he never stated anything else.
I want to see how rest of this plays out, I want to see what L has in mind and I will observe and criticize for a change :D
|
I can say it's wrong because I read the day post. There may not be any clues in it but people are still going to die the way they died. You mean to tell me that Ver took a Mad Hatter hit and made it look like the mafia did it?
|
On October 28 2009 16:14 Scamp wrote:
I can say it's wrong because I read the day post. There may not be any clues in it but people are still going to die the way they died. You mean to tell me that Ver took a Mad Hatter hit and made it look like the mafia did it?
it's difficult to say because there are supposed to be no clues.
However I think you are correct: Incog's death was written before df's death. This basically means it was chronologically first. How could df bombs blow up Incog before df died? (they can't)
|
I think we should be going after Redtooth.
he doesn't defend himself.
he has been very quite.
All he has done was keep saying to lynch someone and not being really helpful.
Now that he is been called on it, he has become even more quite then usual.
I think he is a better bet then Vivi for now.
|
On October 28 2009 16:40 iNfuNdiBuLuM wrote:Show nested quote +On October 28 2009 16:14 Scamp wrote:
I can say it's wrong because I read the day post. There may not be any clues in it but people are still going to die the way they died. You mean to tell me that Ver took a Mad Hatter hit and made it look like the mafia did it? it's difficult to say because there are supposed to be no clues. However I think you are correct: Incog's death was written before df's death. This basically means it was chronologically first. How could df bombs blow up Incog before df died? (they can't)
To further expound on this: in the Day post it explicitly says "the mafia had sealed the exits."
Incognito was not killed by the mad hatter bomb.
L was either
a) hit by a vig
b) hit by the other bomb
c) not hit and is lying
My initial posts were incorrect. If the vig (i say the, there is most certainly not more than 1 if any) did hit L he should speak up. If there is no vig we narrow down the possibilities to b or c.
RoL. I find it curious that you were so quick to correct me on my initial and incidentally logical reaction...
|
On October 28 2009 15:59 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:Show nested quote +On October 28 2009 15:15 Scamp wrote:
That scenario might make the most sense but it's wrong. The mafia hit Incognito and Dreamflower, unless the way the deaths are described have no meaning. There may not be clues, but the way they died is still valid.
Also don't forget that L could simply be lying. How can you just say its wrong? You have nothing else backing that up. DF specifically said earlier in the thread that he agreed with L and nothing to the contrary. He could of been lying, he could have changed his mind but he never stated anything else. I want to see how rest of this plays out, I want to see what L has in mind and I will observe and criticize for a change :D
dreamflower is a "she" :O
|
I have a question for Amber[Light]. What is your opinion of Motbob, Judge, Myself, and Pyrr?
|
All right.. I really don't understand wtf you guys are doing now.. I give you two confirmed mafia and you run off and vote for Chez.. just because he's a brown-noser doesn't mean his brown obsession needs to cloud your judgments on the obvious truths laid out upon you :/
If Vivi is voting for Chez, he clearly knows Chez isn't red, as who else would vote for a teammate so early on in the day? PUH-LEAZE~
|
motbob
United States12546 Posts
On October 28 2009 18:29 SugiuraMidori wrote:
All right.. I really don't understand wtf you guys are doing now.. I give you two confirmed mafia and you run off and vote for Chez.. just because he's a brown-noser doesn't mean his brown obsession needs to cloud your judgments on the obvious truths laid out upon you :/
If Vivi is voting for Chez, he clearly knows Chez isn't red, as who else would vote for a teammate so early on in the day? PUH-LEAZE~
??? vivi is confirmed? I've obviously missed something
|
On October 28 2009 18:35 motbob wrote:Show nested quote +On October 28 2009 18:29 SugiuraMidori wrote:
All right.. I really don't understand wtf you guys are doing now.. I give you two confirmed mafia and you run off and vote for Chez.. just because he's a brown-noser doesn't mean his brown obsession needs to cloud your judgments on the obvious truths laid out upon you :/
If Vivi is voting for Chez, he clearly knows Chez isn't red, as who else would vote for a teammate so early on in the day? PUH-LEAZE~ ??? vivi is confirmed? I've obviously missed something
So is redtooth, they're both on the same team, like I've been saying for some time now :/
You can't have one without the other, they're partners in crime.
|
On October 28 2009 18:40 SugiuraMidori wrote:Show nested quote +On October 28 2009 18:35 motbob wrote:On October 28 2009 18:29 SugiuraMidori wrote:
All right.. I really don't understand wtf you guys are doing now.. I give you two confirmed mafia and you run off and vote for Chez.. just because he's a brown-noser doesn't mean his brown obsession needs to cloud your judgments on the obvious truths laid out upon you :/
If Vivi is voting for Chez, he clearly knows Chez isn't red, as who else would vote for a teammate so early on in the day? PUH-LEAZE~ ??? vivi is confirmed? I've obviously missed something So is redtooth, they're both on the same team, like I've been saying for some time now :/ You can't have one without the other, they're partners in crime.
Yeah but what motbob is wondering is WHY they are both mafia. how did you arrive at such a conclusion? I don't really see it either.
|
Just wanted to say: Yay, I died! And just in time, because my computer at home also just died. I must say, if I never get another role as townie-with-KP, it'll be far too soon.
|
On October 28 2009 18:42 iNfuNdiBuLuM wrote:Show nested quote +On October 28 2009 18:40 SugiuraMidori wrote:On October 28 2009 18:35 motbob wrote:On October 28 2009 18:29 SugiuraMidori wrote:
All right.. I really don't understand wtf you guys are doing now.. I give you two confirmed mafia and you run off and vote for Chez.. just because he's a brown-noser doesn't mean his brown obsession needs to cloud your judgments on the obvious truths laid out upon you :/
If Vivi is voting for Chez, he clearly knows Chez isn't red, as who else would vote for a teammate so early on in the day? PUH-LEAZE~ ??? vivi is confirmed? I've obviously missed something So is redtooth, they're both on the same team, like I've been saying for some time now :/ You can't have one without the other, they're partners in crime. Yeah but what motbob is wondering is WHY they are both mafia. how did you arrive at such a conclusion? I don't really see it either.
Vivi's voting for Ace to be the Pardoner although he thought that Tricode was the most likely green for sure, but still switched away.
Also, that kind of non-mafia pairs would be extremely rare in this kind of a game with DTs not knowing their sanity until after a couple of days. The other choices would be medic block or blind trust. Medic block is impossible and blind trust isn't really likely, so the logical conclusion is obvious.
This of course assumes that they both actually are in the same team, so I guess you should take the time to read through their post history and see what you think.
|
Right now, I don't really see how Chezinu is mafia, at least more than like Vivi. Care to explain?
|
motbob
United States12546 Posts
On October 28 2009 22:20 Shikyo wrote:
Right now, I don't really see how Chezinu is mafia, at least more than like Vivi. Care to explain?
He's being blatantly useless in all his posts, which is what he did when he was mafia. Maybe he does that all the time.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
