[NSFW] Kurdish girl stoned to death - Page 9
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
zizou21
United States3683 Posts
| ||
|
xM(Z
Romania5299 Posts
I never talked from the agressors perspective because it was wrong. Yes, they believed they did the right thing, yes their moral/beliefs justify that action but frankly i don't care. I blame them for not thinking for themselfs and that my friend deserves a capital punishment. Those men become what they are because of indoctrination. They have been told one thing and they never question why. My parents took me to church when i was little but i didn't turn out christian because i started thinking for myself. | ||
|
bine
United States2352 Posts
On May 07 2007 13:31 zizou21 wrote: moral relativism doesn't make sense maybe you're right, care to clue us in on your thoughts? | ||
|
xM(Z
Romania5299 Posts
the girl fucked up in the first place; couldn't she have left first and then converted to islam?; i mean, jesus she must have known their laws. second: in other civilisations for that kind of mistake the person would get excommunicated/driven out of their society and left to live his live in solitude and shame; it was not killed. third: that girl was like you and me; the same biological, chemical, electrical entity; she felt, thought, resoned the way we do; she was not an animal or an alien; How can you say it's ethicaly corect to let her be murdered because the men from that tribe choose not to evolve?. | ||
|
JinKazama23
United States234 Posts
I'm sorry, shouldn't have said that, but this anger, that grows inside of me when I hear about something horrible, is just uncontrolled. | ||
|
CharlieMurphy
United States22895 Posts
| ||
|
ilovezil
United States4143 Posts
On May 07 2007 14:57 CharlieMurphy wrote: Fuck, The video got deleted already. I missed it did anyone save it or know where its posted elsewhere? I've never seen a stoning. I think generally, it's a good thing that you don't see it. It's really brutal to the point it makes you sick. | ||
|
pubbanana
United States3063 Posts
On May 07 2007 14:57 CharlieMurphy wrote: Fuck, The video got deleted already. I missed it did anyone save it or know where its posted elsewhere? I've never seen a stoning. Yeah, some users are making a big flap about YouTube deleting it. It's still on welcometowallyworld.com, though. | ||
|
CharlieMurphy
United States22895 Posts
On May 07 2007 15:01 pubbanana wrote: Yeah, some users are making a big flap about YouTube deleting it. It's still on welcometowallyworld.com, though. uh wtf is that site? | ||
|
pubbanana
United States3063 Posts
Here's the front page/blog section with the video | ||
|
zobz
Canada2175 Posts
it's kind of self-contradicting to say all morallity is subjective, then say the best way for their culture to develope is to let them evolve at their own pace. how is it not just part of some western culture or otherwise a meaningless individual opinion according to rules of subjective morallity to invade another country and spread your ideals. it's the suggestion that it doesn't matter what we do. believing that everything is subjective and nothing matters is not inherent in atheism. the idea that morallity is rationally definable at least to some extent is hardly nonexistent. it's arguable whether it makes sense to intervene in any way whatsoever as an atheist or not, or whether there is such a thing as a good deed. the middle east is a good example it seems of why violence is generally a bad idea. the person who wins is not necessarily right, they're just stronger. this is one of the cases where the morally wrong have greater strength in their numbers or their social intimidation. this system of justice dependent on being able to physically stop someone who acts in the wrong is flawed. i say someone needs to try arguing with the unreasonable, as well as pointing out flaws in the reasoning of leaders and systems of thought to general populouses. | ||
|
ChoboCop
United States954 Posts
I believe Moral Relativism and Ayn Rand's objectivism to be two clear examples. I want to be brief and spare you a paper on the subject; honestly there is a prethora of clearly written critiques that smash these ideologies to pieces. Let me say this, the Nazi's thought that genocide was the best course of action for them. Was it therefore right for 'their' culture? The study of ethics is to guide our actions, but these beliefs deny any notion of duty or the real concept that lies at the heart of WHY we study ethics: To create a better living for humankind. Objectivism(the innapropriate title of Randian ideology) suggests that we should all be selfish; misapplying the invisible hand theory that govern economics. It is clear to see that in a room of 10 people if you(and the other members) are concerned with the group firstly and thus every other member before yourself, then when a problem arises you have 9 others looking out for you instead of just 1(you). Furthermore, if it was okay to act in your best interest(Rands selfishness) then you would decide it's okay not to pay back loans. Thus the whole system of lending My take is that this is just newage anarchism. I think that relativists have poor epistemic notions. I think these people believe that knowledge only comes from the senses. Thus, these people do not believe in a priori knowledge. For those that don't know what a priori knowledge is, it's rationalism. It's a logical true, like geometry. You don't need senses to know that A^2 + B^2 = C^2. That is why they don't believe that there can be absolute truths or derived ethics that apply to all mankind, because they don't believe in the rational only the empirical. They have a view that morality is just some natural phenomenon that we see across cultures, thus it isn't correct to judge someone else's ethical system. I am a Kantian, I believe in duty ethics, and I think that moral relativism and Randian Objectivism pose problems for mature society's that abide by something like the ideas encapsulated in the Declaration of Human Rights. | ||
|
M[o]H-Pepsi
United States15 Posts
| ||
|
CharlieMurphy
United States22895 Posts
Still fucked up though. Religion = Bad. | ||
|
pooper-scooper
United States3108 Posts
On May 07 2007 16:07 CharlieMurphy wrote: Man that video was stupid, you can't see shit. Still fucked up though. Religion = Bad. "Religion = bad" is the same kind of shortsighted and foolish generalization that makes some people in religions do bad things. It is not impossible that "Sex = bad." or "Science = bad" was the generalization that lead to this stoning. If we say "religion = bad" and we get carried away with that generalization we can do just as horrible of things that some muslims do with "Judaism = bad." Be careful. DISCLAIMER: Not a personal attack, I understand that your entire views on the matter are not summed up with a two word post. Just making a point. | ||
|
zizou21
United States3683 Posts
On May 07 2007 13:33 bine wrote: maybe you're right, care to clue us in on your thoughts? well, for starters, u can justify anything w/ moral relativism quick example; it may have been majority belief that in the south there was nothing wrong w/ slavery. it does not mean that at that time, there was nothing wrong w/ slavery | ||
|
boghat
United States2109 Posts
On May 07 2007 16:30 zizou21 wrote: well, for starters, u can justify anything w/ moral relativism quick example; it may have been majority belief that in the south there was nothing wrong w/ slavery. it does not mean that at that time, there was nothing wrong w/ slavery Once you again there's no substance to your answer. Don't bother even trying to argue for a universal morality, you won't be able to do it. Who are you to say slavery was wrong in 1860? You can't. | ||
|
zizou21
United States3683 Posts
![]() | ||
|
mindspike
Canada1902 Posts
On May 07 2007 14:46 JinKazama23 wrote: Don't get me wrong but as I watch current events a terrible idea comes to my mind. Well it is thought that idea of Nazism was not quiet wrong, just look at those primitive cultures which are far way behind the modern world, sorry but I really believe that stove is a right place to put them -.-;; some groups of barbaric nations should be exterminated immediately in order to "treat" the sickness of this world. I'm sorry, shouldn't have said that, but this anger, that grows inside of me when I hear about something horrible, is just uncontrolled. The violence you speak of is 10x worse than the violence in that video. You're talking genocide... Obviously you're "just kidding" or however you want to frame it but its still an idiotic post. | ||
|
{ToT}Strafe
Thailand7026 Posts
On May 07 2007 16:07 CharlieMurphy wrote: Man that video was stupid, you can't see shit. Still fucked up though. Religion = Bad. You want to see more of it? I think it's better to put, grown up retards=bad | ||
| ||
