i just watched it until i saw them throw her unto the ground then i got sick and stopped it
TT_TT
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
Vin{MBL}
5185 Posts
i just watched it until i saw them throw her unto the ground then i got sick and stopped it TT_TT | ||
|
defenestrate
United States579 Posts
On May 07 2007 16:01 ChoboCop wrote: I truely believe that there are such things as thought viruses. These are intellectually mal-ethical ideas that permeate the brains of those with lesser I believe Moral Relativism and Ayn Rand's objectivism to be two clear examples. I want to be brief and spare you a paper on the subject; honestly there is a prethora of clearly written critiques that smash these ideologies to pieces. Let me say this, the Nazi's thought that genocide was the best course of action for them. Was it therefore right for 'their' culture? The study of ethics is to guide our actions, but these beliefs deny any notion of duty or the real concept that lies at the heart of WHY we study ethics: To create a better living for humankind. Objectivism(the innapropriate title of Randian ideology) suggests that we should all be selfish; misapplying the invisible hand theory that govern economics. It is clear to see that in a room of 10 people if you(and the other members) are concerned with the group firstly and thus every other member before yourself, then when a problem arises you have 9 others looking out for you instead of just 1(you). Furthermore, if it was okay to act in your best interest(Rands selfishness) then you would decide it's okay not to pay back loans. Thus the whole system of lending My take is that this is just newage anarchism. You are attributing false positions. Selfishness as a virtue merely means that one should not sacrifice for the benefit of others. Rand has never condoned breach of contract. Kindly read the material before you spew such BS. | ||
|
boghat
United States2109 Posts
Every society has to decide what their own morality is. I think it's probably wise to let societies develop their own morality structures on their own and not to interfere, but this point is where the real debate begins. Usually most societies steadily develop a morality with an emphasis on the sanctity of life and empathy toward fellow humans. This is the morality "civilized" countries so brazenly think is universal. But this doesn't mean empathy and life are universally and inherently "good". The fact is, for life to continue death must occur. Life feeds on itself to sustain. Sure we don't want to die personally because we have cognition and abstract thinking, but that doesn't mean death is a bad thing. Obviously we all know these points but they're easily put in the back of our minds. Death is the driving force of evolution and all of life. Death makes room for new species to have a chance at life and it has culminated to us humans at this point in history on earth. Trying to pretend like we can and should prevent all death like some extreme vegans want is not only absurd but dangerous thinking. Yes, through empathy most societies have decided death and slavery is morally suspect. But the fact is death is responsible for humans being the most powerful species on the planet right now and slaves helped build the United States into the industrial and economic superpower it became in the 20th century. Nothing is good or bad, it just is. One of the biggest problems with human society has been the thought process that there is a universal morality and that we can achieve perfect utopias. This kind of thinking should be abandoned. There will never be a perfect political or economic system. Religion is based on silly premises. And bad and good things don't exist, it's all perspective and it's all relative. And that's the word: moral relativism. | ||
|
backdrOp
United States104 Posts
On May 07 2007 16:07 CharlieMurphy wrote: Man that video was stupid, you can't see shit. Still fucked up though. Religion = Bad. you looked at the wrong vid. scroll down @ that website a bit.. and youll see the correct vid. | ||
|
fusionsdf
Canada15390 Posts
| ||
|
Muta_lisk
Canada13 Posts
| ||
|
white_box921
United Kingdom967 Posts
| ||
|
8players
United States208 Posts
it really is disturbing... really dont think you should watch... but | ||
|
JinKazama23
United States234 Posts
On May 07 2007 17:23 Muta_lisk wrote: every culture has its own punishment methods. look back in history, im sure ull be amazed on what u find. beheading is practiced by all cultures........ Sure, but if we go back in history, we would be still hanging on the tree eating banana, wouldn't we ? In my opinion in modern world, people should be appreciating human beings more then anything else. If for some people throwing 50pound stone on someone's head is just activity before going to church, then I'm really wondering what am I doing here. | ||
|
SK.Testie
Canada11084 Posts
| ||
|
GoGoGo[cF]
China545 Posts
| ||
|
Clutch3
United States1344 Posts
On May 07 2007 17:01 boghat wrote: The way I see it, one of the reasons laws are necessary is precisely because there is no such thing as good or bad or a universal morality. If you do something "bad" you aren't just magically punished. Ideologically men established religion to try to promote this belief but obviously a philosophy where punishment never happens in this reality and lifetime is useless for human society. Every society has to decide what their own morality is. I think it's probably wise to let societies develop their own morality structures on their own and not to interfere, but this point is where the real debate begins. Usually most societies steadily develop a morality with an emphasis on the sanctity of life and empathy toward fellow humans. This is the morality "civilized" countries so brazenly think is universal. But this doesn't mean empathy and life are universally and inherently "good". Never procreate. please. | ||
|
pirate cod
810 Posts
On May 07 2007 20:36 Clutch3 wrote: Show nested quote + On May 07 2007 17:01 boghat wrote: The way I see it, one of the reasons laws are necessary is precisely because there is no such thing as good or bad or a universal morality. If you do something "bad" you aren't just magically punished. Ideologically men established religion to try to promote this belief but obviously a philosophy where punishment never happens in this reality and lifetime is useless for human society. Every society has to decide what their own morality is. I think it's probably wise to let societies develop their own morality structures on their own and not to interfere, but this point is where the real debate begins. Usually most societies steadily develop a morality with an emphasis on the sanctity of life and empathy toward fellow humans. This is the morality "civilized" countries so brazenly think is universal. But this doesn't mean empathy and life are universally and inherently "good". Never procreate. please. He's right. While I believe murdering someone is completely barbaric and has no place in any society regardless if one deems it retribution, he serves a good point that you completely missed and instead of attempting to understand what you just read the only words you were able to conjure up from that well developed thought is that of a retarded asshole. | ||
|
MaZza[KIS]
Australia2110 Posts
On May 07 2007 00:33 pubbanana wrote: There was also a girl's school that burned to the ground (I don't recall which country this occured in. Edit: Saudi Arabia - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/1874471.stm) and all of the 20-something students were killed because the head master of the school wouldn't let them leave unless they put on their bee-keeper suits. What a barbaric, backwards culture. please don't say it like that. this is not culture related...it's a basic human flaw.. like beyonder implied, humans are animals... all of us have it in us to do this... the discrimination you show in your post is the same type of discrimination that lead to this stoning... so, Stop discriminating! | ||
|
bine
United States2352 Posts
On May 07 2007 20:36 Clutch3 wrote: Show nested quote + On May 07 2007 17:01 boghat wrote: The way I see it, one of the reasons laws are necessary is precisely because there is no such thing as good or bad or a universal morality. If you do something "bad" you aren't just magically punished. Ideologically men established religion to try to promote this belief but obviously a philosophy where punishment never happens in this reality and lifetime is useless for human society. Every society has to decide what their own morality is. I think it's probably wise to let societies develop their own morality structures on their own and not to interfere, but this point is where the real debate begins. Usually most societies steadily develop a morality with an emphasis on the sanctity of life and empathy toward fellow humans. This is the morality "civilized" countries so brazenly think is universal. But this doesn't mean empathy and life are universally and inherently "good". Never procreate. please. This is an absolutely worthless reply to a relatively thoughtful post. If you disagree with him, disagree with him. But all of these stupid one line responses to people who have said something clearly thought out is extremely frustrating. Someone who disagrees with subjective ethical relativism should actually mount an objection to it that's not just based on confusion or distraction. There are perfectly valid arguments against ethical relativism. Let's talk about them rather than be silly and frustrating. | ||
|
lil.sis
China4650 Posts
| ||
|
Slithe
United States985 Posts
What motive is there for to such a thing? They didn't just want the girl to die, they wanted her to suffer. People can rant on and on about the subjective nature of morality, but I still say bullshit. There's nothing beneficial about making a person suffer before they die, it's stupid and sick. Obviously it is impossible for people to have an objective view but in general I'm sure most people would prefer a society of less suffering. | ||
|
.kaz
1963 Posts
| ||
|
bine
United States2352 Posts
On May 07 2007 21:12 Slithe wrote: This isn't just a murder. This is humiliation and torture. What motive is there for to such a thing? They didn't just want the girl to die, they wanted her to suffer. People can rant on and on about the subjective nature of morality, but I still say bullshit. There's nothing beneficial about making a person suffer before they die, it's stupid and sick. Obviously it is impossible for people to have an objective view but in general I'm sure most people would prefer a society of less suffering. Ok, so let's dig into your claim that moral relativism is bullshit: you've essentially claimed that the stoning is immoral because it is in no way beneficial, with the supporting points that it is stupid and sick. Well, the question quickly arises - who are you to decide a) what's beneficial and b) what's "stupid and sick"? Obviously, the people who perpetrated the stoning think it's beneficial, and presumably don't think it's stupid and sick. | ||
|
mistapooh
United States376 Posts
On May 07 2007 21:07 lil.sis wrote: also keep in mind that we used to burn people alive less than 300 years ago Yeah, criticizing their religion and standards? Of course what they did was wrong, but It's not like the USA is any better. A 100 years ago, lynching had a picnic atmosphere where parents would bring their kids to enjoy the show, with thousands of spectators. We even had postcards with lynching on them. | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Other Games Organizations Other Games
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 League of Legends |
|
RSL Revival
AI Arena Tournament
BSL
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
OSC
IPSL
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
WardiTV Weekly
Kung Fu Cup
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
[ Show More ] PiGosaur Cup
The PondCast
KCM Race Survival
|
|
|