|
On May 07 2007 21:21 bine wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2007 21:12 Slithe wrote: This isn't just a murder. This is humiliation and torture.
What motive is there for to such a thing? They didn't just want the girl to die, they wanted her to suffer. People can rant on and on about the subjective nature of morality, but I still say bullshit. There's nothing beneficial about making a person suffer before they die, it's stupid and sick.
Obviously it is impossible for people to have an objective view but in general I'm sure most people would prefer a society of less suffering. Ok, so let's dig into your claim that moral relativism is bullshit: you've essentially claimed that the stoning is immoral because it is in no way beneficial, with the supporting points that it is stupid and sick. Well, the question quickly arises - who are you to decide a) what's beneficial and b) what's "stupid and sick"? Obviously, the people who perpetrated the stoning think it's beneficial, and presumably don't think it's stupid and sick. bine, what's your view on moral relativism? I'm very open to counter arguments and the main reason I believe this philosophy is probably because I've never heard any good counters to it. Although I haven't studied relativism, morality, philosophy, etc. that much so I don't claim to be any kind of expert. I just gave the opinion I hold now.
Also, to Clutch 3 - Just because I believe in moral relativism and don't think good and bad exist in any physical or meaningful way, doesn't mean I'm not personally moral. I live in a society that values life (except for the death penalty, which is a sticky argument for people that think it's so different that this stoning, it's a little different but not much) and I was brought up to care and feel empathetic to others. I choose not to kill because 1) I'm not a mean-spirited person but even if I was provoked I believe strongly in 2) the golden rule and I definitely don't want to be killed so I wouldn't kill anyone else. I think most of the reason I'm like this is because of the family and society I grew up in. It has nothing to with some "fact" or religious belief that killing is bad and wrong. Moltke said something along the same lines as this and I agree with him.
It's hard to judge morality on an individual to individual basis so culture and nationality are useful perspective points to use. What I mean is if this happened in the United States I'd obviously strongly condemn it because I live in the same culture and have a common law we agree to live by but I have no business judging the people who committed this crime in Iraq because I know little to nothing of their culture, law, and family upbringing traditions. Personally I find it morally repugnant but unless you live in a similar culture you aren't in a very good position to judge the morality of this act since it's all relative.
When countries that have the death penalty carry it out, countries that are opposed to it obviously think it's morally wrong. The method of death in this act is more severe but the conditions of society are also more severe, especially in the present, and also very different and unique.
|
I'll switch sides for a minute.
Look, we have a variety of ways we can challenge ethical relativism, all we have to do is point to a source we like for morality, and we can build from there. I could argue, for example, that morality arises from mutual interest. We all would seem intuitively to have an interest in staying alive, our most basic instincts can attest to that fact. I don't want to be murdered, and the only way I can try to make sure that doesn't happen is by advocating non-murder as a moral choice, most compellingly by not murdering anyone myself. In other words, the reason those men shouldn't stone the woman to death is that they themselves don't want to be stoned. If they believe it's OK to kill other people, they are essentially opening the gates for themselves to be killed. This is clearly manifest, too, by the number of violent deaths in incidents related to this sort of honor-killing practice that involve men being killed as retribution. The men in the video have a higher chance of being killed than they would if they lived peaceful lives. We can critique their culture on the basis of its permission of violence and murder because we ourselves have an interest in non-murder, as do those men in the video; both of our cultures have an interest in not being murdered, but our culture does a better job of it by not being hypocritical and not murdering anyone ourselves.
Another tack: Some of you have sort of been getting at this one, but instead of arguing you've just said things like "bullshit" or "like, whatever!!!". Why can't we just suggest that certain moral imperatives arise out of human nature? Find me someone well educated that doesn't believe that senseless murder is wrong. From the vast commonality of this idea (senseless murder is wrong), it makes sense to assume that this is just part of our wiring. Even if it's not "cosmically wrong," it's still wrong in the sense of what most people mean when they say something is immoral, which is "this is outside of the bounds of normal behavior to a degree that I find it unacceptable." Why can't we find it unacceptable just on the basis of our own innate sense of human nature?
As to whether or not this murder was senseless — it's another innate property of the human psyche that we want to be able to control our own destinies. Find me one person, fundamentalist or otherwise, who does not want to be able to choose how their life unfolds. Even if that choice is to put oneself in the "hands of God," that is still a choice that is made (if it wasn't a choice, it wouldn't be a virtuous act). The justification for this murder (I added the "senseless" qualifier, remember - this is to stave off questions about the ethics of the death penalty, etc., which is really beside the point at the moment) seems to be that she violated certain aspects of the prevailing religion of the area. Even within a mode of accepting the dogma and religion in question, it is certainly not in the interest of the faith to obtain false loyalty through fear. All they are doing by stoning this poor woman is trying desperately to scare people into believing, a horrible strategy for prosthletizing, especially these days. If she accepted the religion on the basis of fear, she wouldn't be participating fully in the religion anyway, so what's the point of forcing her? She'll get hers in hell after all, so why bother with her at all? The killing was senseless because it doesn't serve anyone's interests, not even the tradition that inspired it.
|
|
|
Sick people over there, is that Iraq? Where is the U.S troops?
|
On May 07 2007 20:56 MaZza[KIS] wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2007 00:33 pubbanana wrote:There was also a girl's school that burned to the ground (I don't recall which country this occured in. Edit: Saudi Arabia - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/1874471.stm) and all of the 20-something students were killed because the head master of the school wouldn't let them leave unless they put on their bee-keeper suits. What a barbaric, backwards culture. please don't say it like that. this is not culture related...it's a basic human flaw.. like beyonder implied, humans are animals... all of us have it in us to do this... the discrimination you show in your post is the same type of discrimination that lead to this stoning... so, Stop discriminating!
So, how many people were stoned to death in Australia this week?
None?
Okay.
|
The problem with moral relativism isn't that it's wrong or right but that is useless. People must evolve. They must make decisions that can make them evolve. Sometime they make the right(they experience an improvement in life quality) ones sometime they dont. Their actions influence themselfs primarily and that is their main concern. It may be 'group egoism' but that is what it matters.The universe perspective does not matter. From moral relativism i understand that no course of action can be made because our knowledge about things is close to zero. That prevents evolution. In science after an experiment you know what is right or wrong regarding that experiment then you extrapolate on to other systems without experimenting again. Your point has been proven right. In life it's trial and hope it works. Some values can be imported from other cultures and because people function the same way it's clearly that they can understand them. Experience in life makes one differentiate from wrong and right and we have aproximately 200.000(BP) years of experience. Life it's not about absolute right and absolute wrong it's about small steps in that direction, small truths.
|
On May 07 2007 21:21 bine wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2007 21:12 Slithe wrote: This isn't just a murder. This is humiliation and torture.
What motive is there for to such a thing? They didn't just want the girl to die, they wanted her to suffer. People can rant on and on about the subjective nature of morality, but I still say bullshit. There's nothing beneficial about making a person suffer before they die, it's stupid and sick.
Obviously it is impossible for people to have an objective view but in general I'm sure most people would prefer a society of less suffering. Ok, so let's dig into your claim that moral relativism is bullshit: you've essentially claimed that the stoning is immoral because it is in no way beneficial, with the supporting points that it is stupid and sick. Well, the question quickly arises - who are you to decide a) what's beneficial and b) what's "stupid and sick"? Obviously, the people who perpetrated the stoning think it's beneficial, and presumably don't think it's stupid and sick.
mm well it seems that my initial argument got melted in the face of moral relativism. Let's see if I can offer a better argument this time around.
I think that if we were to analyze the motive, we would find that they did not act out of reason or some moral standard. They did not act because of their religious principles, but because of the mob mentality that takes over rational thought. The people of the mob do not necessarily believe that their actions are "beneficial", they are just acting as they feel. In such a case, it is unfair to use the argument that they have different morals, as they aren't acting based on their morals anyway.
Now regarding the idea of morals, I am of the opinion that morality comes from the desire to achieve mutual or social benefit. For a social race such as humans, mutual benefit is very important to survival. Actions of such violence typically only breed malice and strife, which are not very conducive to mutual benefit. If their "morality" promotes this kind of destructive behavior, then they are backwards in their thinking. Their principles are going against the fundamental purpose of morals, which would make their actions "stupid".
|
Bine, the moral relativism has a limit. In this case the limit on which this "excuse" can be aplied is severly broken. People beat their children to "teach" them right (another savage mentality) but it can be justified by the traditions, their way to see it (things transmited through generation by father to son etc). That is not corect but can be justified. Bruises go, child learned his lesson... or not.
But there is a big difference from punishing someone by beating him, or as our society punishes people by jailing them, and the fact that someone is killing (MURDERING, yes it is a murder!) someone in a very cruel way just like the witches were killed 4 centurys ago. Why cant moral relativism be aplied now? Is life so precious? Yes life is precious. You can heal the bruises, you can heal the traumas, but can you give life? Can you give life to that girl again? I do not think so.
No matter how you take it, life is a thing just GIVEN to you. Nobody asks you when you're born if you wanna be borned, what family you'd like, where you wanna live, etc. You're just born. And life does not have a restart button (altho it needs). The same way you can't give someone's life back.
The first right of a human being is the right to live. Why are then human rights if everything is relative? because it's not... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_rights
Going from theory to practical, if their religion tells people to kill someone who made a mistake then that religion is wrong and must be banned. But if the community members have appropriated the religion rules into their self, their "eyes" will be blind, the rules of relligion will overrule any sense of human morals, human dignity and basic morals. That again, is an abnormal behaviour.
As Slithe says, there are a couple of fundamental unwritten laws which menhood should respect them. These are specified even in the bible. Now, that mob broke these primal rules. No matter their point of view, they should get punished. Why is this happening and how can it be stopped?
It could only be stopped by proper education in the sense of the human being. Everyone should know why you must not kill and you must not hurt your "fellow" and that's not because bible says so. If this is not possible they should be warned by punishment. The justice should imprison and therefor punish all the people pariticipating in that horrible murder. But since the justice does not work as it is supossed, who is to show the reference point of good and bad?
|
it is a simple case of how much a person values himself and his beliefs and how much he scorns those of others. morality is nothing about mutual benefit, you really think any person in a condition less than perfect abides by such a noble and forth-thinking philosophy? these people act the way they do out of a sense of superiority. the greater the sense of selfworth; the larger the scorn for things that displease them. we are raised and educated as followers of equity and respect, and avoid blind faith where it is important to avoid it (legal system, medicine).
|
plase somebody link a non-youtube video.. i havent watched this.
|
You don't want to see it. It's really disgusting and disturbing.
How I hate such mofos. They think they have the right to punish some else because in their eyes he (she) commited a crime and they take they right for themselves to MURDER that person, which is the worst crime humanity knows. They are the worst criminals at all, and the worst about it is, that they think, it's right what they did.
|
"we are justified in calling these people barbarians by reference to the laws of reason, but not in comparison with ourselves, who surpass them in every kind of barbarity"
|
Thats sick and disturbing. I find this so much worse than any other violent vids. Every ''movie'' and fictionfilm is just funny compared to stuff like this.
The worst thing : Everybody can throw stones at her and some do so. I mean .. come on.. thats just sooo siiick..
On the other hand : If u are finding this stuff as bad as i do, then please dont forget that war is basicaly the same except a thousand times worse.
Civs get killed, children and women raped , abused, killed and everything. Its the same in EVERY war. And droping a huge ass bomb and blowing up 200 people at once and just seeing a cloud of dust and flying away isnt any better.
So basicaly, all the guys here who werent against the war vs iraq or afgahnistan or every other war that ever happened. Basically every person who likes any army on the world be it US Army or whatever. Anyone person who found the war vs any other country ok or good, please think twice.
Just because we dont see the scenes..
like this stuff is sick.. and u will never understand why..
every war is that X 10^100
im out
|
On May 07 2007 21:43 boghat wrote: Also, to Clutch 3 - Just because I believe in moral relativism and don't think good and bad exist in any physical or meaningful way, doesn't mean I'm not personally moral. I live in a society that values life (except for the death penalty, which is a sticky argument for people that think it's so different that this stoning, it's a little different but not much) and I was brought up to care and feel empathetic to others. I choose not to kill because 1) I'm not a mean-spirited person but even if I was provoked I believe strongly in 2) the golden rule and I definitely don't want to be killed so I wouldn't kill anyone else. I think most of the reason I'm like this is because of the family and society I grew up in. It has nothing to with some "fact" or religious belief that killing is bad and wrong. Moltke said something along the same lines as this and I agree with him.
It's hard to judge morality on an individual to individual basis so culture and nationality are useful perspective points to use. What I mean is if this happened in the United States I'd obviously strongly condemn it because I live in the same culture and have a common law we agree to live by but I have no business judging the people who committed this crime in Iraq because I know little to nothing of their culture, law, and family upbringing traditions. Personally I find it morally repugnant but unless you live in a similar culture you aren't in a very good position to judge the morality of this act since it's all relative.
When countries that have the death penalty carry it out, countries that are opposed to it obviously think it's morally wrong. The method of death in this act is more severe but the conditions of society are also more severe, especially in the present, and also very different and unique.
First of all, my apologies for my initial reply to the thread. This thing has me worked up (or at least did last night). Let me say a little more.
Let's put aside for the moment the fact that the same argument can be used to justify the Holocaust, all forms of torture, ritualized incest, etc.
You still can't argue that one society has no right to even make a value judgement on the actions of another. Let's take your argument further. if we're saying that indivdual societies should be free to enforce any morality they wish, we can apply the same argument not only to individual societies but also to individual people. The choice of a "society" as the autonomous unit which is permitted to create and enforce its own ethics is somewhat arbitrary. There's no real reason why one should choose a "society" as this unit over, say, one family, or even the entire population of the planet. Therefore by the same argument, you have no right to argue when your next-door neighbor (or maybe your wife) sacrifices an innocent infant. However, if we define "society" as the whole of humanity, which really is no more or less valid than defining it on national/ethnic grounds as you have here, then it seems to me that the same argument should be in favor of us locking up all of these animals and throwing away the key.
I'm not making a religious argument for the rightness or wrongness of what happened here. Yes, a lot of our morality is shaped by our family and society. And you are right that this is a totally different society. But this is a classic example of the slippery slope argument.
I guess the question comes down to, how do we decide how to define the "unit" which is responsible for determining and enforcing ethics. Some example units we could choose, as I've mentioned, could be the entire population of the Earth, or maybe one country, or one family, or even each single individual. As you can tell, most societies have decided to place the ethical onus on a combination of these diffferent "units". For example, the judicial system at a national level covers most criminal acts (enforcing ethical rules), but the family unit is also trusted to raise kids and instill ethics in them. Finally, the individual is also given some rights and responsibilities. Since societal lines are somewhat arbitrarily drawn, how can you argue that the society of humanity as a whole doesn't have some responsibility to intervene in this case?
To put it another way, what if this happened in America or Europe? Would you still be in favor of standing by because the people were still brought up in a different culture? What if these people were living in Europe and were of Christian, European descent but had created a new sect/cult and claimed that their (sadistic) religion required this stoning? What if their religion required the stoning of innocent children who were not part of the sect? Which of these situations would you allow to pass? When do these people cease to receive a free pass because of "societal differences"? And how do we make any progress in the world if people don't even try to educated and enlighten other people?
How do you define "society"? Geographically? Religiously? Ethically? The world is too small and people are too interconnected to allow this type of thing to happen in the 21st century.
|
On May 07 2007 15:21 zobz wrote: the war on iraq i think being the main example of the badness of the western philosophy of thinking we're superior, it would be a bad one.
colonisation.
My people survived for millenia with tools thatwere good for them, the southern mohawks didnt need the wheel to live, then westerners came over and told us we were stupid devil worshippers.
|
|
|
|
|
Please never bump this again... -_-
|
On May 07 2007 17:18 fusionsdf wrote: never. ever. hitting play on that movie
|
Having the whole planet be the same "society" so that we all have the same moral values is one of our ultimate goals as humans, but right now it is not plausible or possible. Therefore, that's why "societies" or nations are usually considered the largest bodies of common morality. I too want everyone on the planet to agree to a common moral code but I think the best way to do that might be to let each individual culture to progress on its own. Forcing cultures to obey "more evolved" forms of moral code could be considered immoral itself.
|
|
|
|
|
|