On May 07 2007 01:04 evanthebouncy~ wrote:
Holy shit you are so right... I gues such wiseness only comes with age...
Holy shit you are so right... I gues such wiseness only comes with age...
no it doesn't
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
zobz
Canada2175 Posts
On May 07 2007 01:04 evanthebouncy~ wrote: Show nested quote + On May 07 2007 01:03 Physician wrote: And this is why, in my old age, I never jump in any bandwagons against anyone. This sort of shit is inside all of us, and the only solution is rational thinking and empathy. Holy shit you are so right... I gues such wiseness only comes with age... no it doesn't | ||
|
MoltkeWarding
5195 Posts
On May 07 2007 10:24 ilovezil wrote: Show nested quote + On May 07 2007 10:20 MoltkeWarding wrote: When evil manifests itself in an entire society, that is an intangible matter which is not helped by ideological reductionism. If the Kurd stones other Kurds, it is because his father has stoned other Kurds' fathers, and their fathers have in turn done the same. When I am angry at a man but hold from killing him, I do not think that I am observing the commandment "thou shalt not kill." Moral traditions are deeper than religious ideas, and while ideology can create a few saints (or demons) it can never occupy the simultaneous motives of a people. This is why, even if you do not espouse Christianity directly, the internal dignity of man and of life is a moral tradition you inherit when denouncing these killings as senseless. It is no more, and no less a religious idea than what is happening here. So then what would be your remedy to this situation? Sure anyone can see the clear evil in such situations, but what do you propose we do about it? If the answer is nothing, it would have been better that you saved that minute or so of thinking up clever words to say humanity sucks. I don't mean to say this as a mindless flame, mind you. "Nothing" is the moral thing to do. As time passes, a certain culture might learn to heal its own wounds more effectively. A moral revolution from outside has been shown to almost never work. Every child must fall down multiple times before he learns how to walk. Now we in the West have adopted this notion that we are responsible for the souls of the rest of humanity, a fanciful idea which is a vast overestimation of our powers. | ||
|
MaGnIfIcA
Norway2312 Posts
| ||
|
derderder
Benin46 Posts
| ||
|
Liquid`HayprO
Iraq1230 Posts
On May 07 2007 11:32 MaGnIfIcA wrote: Disgusting, shit like this makes me a racist, i swear... does that mean u hate the girl too? | ||
|
bine
United States2352 Posts
What is ethical relativism? + Show Spoiler + In philosophy, moral relativism is the position that moral or ethical propositions do not reflect objective and/or universal moral truths, but instead make claims relative to social, cultural, historical or personal circumstances. Moral relativists hold that no universal standard exists by which to assess an ethical proposition's truth. Relativistic positions often see moral values as applicable only within certain cultural boundaries or in the context of individual preferences. An extreme relativist position might suggest that judging the moral or ethical judgments or acts of another person or group has no meaning, though most relativists propound a more limited version of the theory. Some moral relativists — for example, the existentialist Jean-Paul Sartre — hold that a personal and subjective moral core lies or ought to lie at the foundation of individuals' moral acts. In this view public morality reflects social convention, and only personal, subjective morality expresses true authenticity. Moral relativism differs from moral pluralism — which acknowledges the co-existence of opposing ideas and practices, but accepts limits to differences, such as when vital human needs get violated. Moral relativism, in contrast, grants the possibility of moral judgments that do not accept such limits. From Wikipedia Basically, any standard we use to judge theactions of other people is essentially subjective (and therefore ultimately arbitrary), so we shouldn't convince ourselves that our world view is inherently superior to those of a different cultural vantage point. This gets interesting, however, because we are all still guided by some set of moral principles, and we tend to have an interest in having them be shared by other people. For example, I (subjectively) wish that no one killed anyone else (unless it was an emergency that, say, saved more lives), but just because I feel that very strongly and even viscerally, I can't really claim that someone who disagrees with me is wrong. Even within seemingly absolute moral frameworks, like Christianity for example, more questions arise that make a belief in absolute morality seem implausible. To what moral standard is God held? Is God moral? If we can't know if God is immoral (because we have no standard to measure it against), how can we know that it is moral to follow his moral guidelines? What if God is part of a larger system in which he is an immoral agent, and that by complying with his wishes, we are in fact perpetrating immoral actions ourselves? The point is that we can't possibly know, and that a "final" sense of ethics just seems impossible to ascertain. | ||
|
MaGnIfIcA
Norway2312 Posts
On May 07 2007 11:42 haypro wrote: Show nested quote + On May 07 2007 11:32 MaGnIfIcA wrote: Disgusting, shit like this makes me a racist, i swear... does that mean u hate the girl too? Im not even gonna argument on that, as im 100% sure you get what i mean. If not iv overstimated the average intelligence here. | ||
|
Pika Chu
Romania2510 Posts
On May 07 2007 11:40 derderder wrote: Show nested quote + On May 07 2007 10:10 geometryb wrote: i'm not saying what they're doing it right, but i dont think you should look down on other people's society just because it disagrees with your own. They just value family and honor a lot more than we do. They probably look at a lot of the things we do and are like "Barbarians!" and it's not like we don't have the death penalty here. Whoa, someone with a brain, hello! Pleasure to meet you on these here forums! You don't understand. Every community has it's own traditions and it's own standards yes? Everywhere strange stuff happen, like girls marry at 12 years etc, but this is MURDER, are you sugesting this should be just let be? there is a human life, and it was taken away. They seems they don't value the family since they killed the daughter. Value honor? Is murder honorable? | ||
|
il0seonpurpose
Korea (South)5638 Posts
On May 07 2007 00:33 pubbanana wrote: There was also a girl's school that burned to the ground (I don't recall which country this occured in. Edit: Saudi Arabia - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/1874471.stm) and all of the 20-something students were killed because the head master of the school wouldn't let them leave unless they put on their bee-keeper suits. What a barbaric, backwards culture. Why would they have to put on their beekeeper suits? If it was for reasons like doing research on bees, or was it just because the master was screwed up in his head? And what religion was she before? And did they stone the muslim guy she tried to run away with? I read in the bible about when Steven was being stoned, it is so bad actually a real person getting killed with stones | ||
|
QuietIdiot
7004 Posts
On May 07 2007 12:05 Pika Chu wrote: Show nested quote + On May 07 2007 11:40 derderder wrote: On May 07 2007 10:10 geometryb wrote: i'm not saying what they're doing it right, but i dont think you should look down on other people's society just because it disagrees with your own. They just value family and honor a lot more than we do. They probably look at a lot of the things we do and are like "Barbarians!" and it's not like we don't have the death penalty here. Whoa, someone with a brain, hello! Pleasure to meet you on these here forums! You don't understand. Every community has it's own traditions and it's own standards yes? Everywhere strange stuff happen, like girls marry at 12 years etc, but this is MURDER, are you sugesting this should be just let be? there is a human life, and it was taken away. They seems they don't value the family since they killed the daughter. Value honor? Is murder honorable? In their eyes, it ain't murder. Its a cardinal sin that must be punished for. Equivalent to our own interpretation to the execution of a low-life rapist, but in a more brutal way. | ||
|
bine
United States2352 Posts
On May 07 2007 12:05 Pika Chu wrote: Show nested quote + On May 07 2007 11:40 derderder wrote: On May 07 2007 10:10 geometryb wrote: i'm not saying what they're doing it right, but i dont think you should look down on other people's society just because it disagrees with your own. They just value family and honor a lot more than we do. They probably look at a lot of the things we do and are like "Barbarians!" and it's not like we don't have the death penalty here. Whoa, someone with a brain, hello! Pleasure to meet you on these here forums! You don't understand. Every community has it's own traditions and it's own standards yes? Everywhere strange stuff happen, like girls marry at 12 years etc, but this is MURDER, are you sugesting this should be just let be? there is a human life, and it was taken away. They seems they don't value the family since they killed the daughter. Value honor? Is murder honorable? It's pretty easy to dismantle these objections from certain points of view. For example, from the view of a religious person who is extremely convicted that this person is going to hell anyway, no amount of suffering they can inflict now will even register on the same scale as what they will be feeling for eternity. This could and would be the view of the stone-wielders and Christians alike (the girl, clearly a non-Christian, would be destined by Christianity to suffer in Hell for eternity). Also, from the viewpoint of an atheist, the girl was going to die eventually anyway, at which time she would cease to exist, and her suffering from her perspective would have never even happened. Eventually, the entire human race will disappear; in fact, the universe will eventually be nothing but disparate particles, and it will be as if human existence had never occurred. In a sense, it will be true that human existence never occurred, because we probably will not have even slightly affected the eventual outcome of the universe. We are all essentially meaningless within an atheistic view (and, I would argue, even within a theistic view, because one can just regress the question of meaning to man's creator, rather than man, and the effective meaninglessness will just trickle down), so any amount of pain or happiness for that matter is essentially the difference between 999999999999999999999 molecules of dust and 999999999999999999998 molecules of dust. In other words, it's pretty much impossible (I believe) to assert that the people who stoned this woman are cosmically wrong or bad or evil. Just because we might have an ingrained response to the idea of murder doesn't mean it's necessarily always or ever wrong. | ||
|
derderder
Benin46 Posts
| ||
|
bine
United States2352 Posts
On May 07 2007 12:08 il0seonpurpose wrote: Show nested quote + On May 07 2007 00:33 pubbanana wrote: There was also a girl's school that burned to the ground (I don't recall which country this occured in. Edit: Saudi Arabia - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/1874471.stm) and all of the 20-something students were killed because the head master of the school wouldn't let them leave unless they put on their bee-keeper suits. What a barbaric, backwards culture. Why would they have to put on their beekeeper suits? If it was for reasons like doing research on bees, or was it just because the master was screwed up in his head? And what religion was she before? And did they stone the muslim guy she tried to run away with? I read in the bible about when Steven was being stoned, it is so bad actually a real person getting killed with stones I think he was using bee-keeper suits euphemistically for Burqa, the all-enveloping cloaks that women and girls in some sects of Islam are required to wear at all times when going out. Again, though, from their perspective, the death of their physical body is trivial compared to the hell they would face if they sinned, and the 40 more years of life they might have had would be peanuts compared to the heaven that they can expect by being obedient followers of their faith. | ||
|
SK.Testie
Canada11084 Posts
Bill Maher famously coined Burqa's as bee-keeper suits and how it is outrageous to subject a group of people to doing one thing like donning a certain type of clothing. | ||
|
Tusk
Canada427 Posts
On May 07 2007 09:12 BlackJack wrote: Our society is clearly superior.. not superior. different. Ours works for us, theirs works for them. Your view of superior societies is a common western view. Very bad view. | ||
|
Newbistic
China2912 Posts
The best solution for us is probably to hurry the fuck up and develop an alternative fuel source, and isolate that section of the world to itself. When it is ready to join the rest of the world, we'll probably know. If it is not, then we'll just leave them alone like the backwoods tribes in the Amazon jungles. | ||
|
pubbanana
United States3063 Posts
On May 07 2007 12:26 MYM.Testie wrote: Yes. Bill Maher famously coined Burqa's as bee-keeper suits and how it is outrageous to subject a group of people to doing one thing like donning a certain type of clothing. Correct. While I'm not exactly a Bill Maher fan (I don't hate him or anything, I just don't agree with some of his stances), I sincerely agree with him about his view on this "we're just different" garbage. O’GORMAN: However, the people who are buying this are already the converted. They’re not going to be the people who are buying Anne Coulter’s book, “Slander: Liberal Lies about the American Right.” MAHER: That’s partly true. That’s true with any cause. But the thing about this book is that there are a lot of things that the people who buy Ann Coulter’s book would love. They would love that last essay which is titled “Not Just Different,” which says that the United States is not just different, it’s better. As much as I criticize this country, let’s not lose sight of the fact that representative democracy and freedom of religion and rule of the law and equality of the sexes and free speech, these things are better than beheadings and stonings and autocracy and no free speech and keeping women in those bee keeper suits and all the other stuff that we see around the world. It’s a very sort of cold-eyed defense of why America is the greatest country. | ||
|
xM(Z
Romania5299 Posts
On May 07 2007 11:48 bine wrote: I think we're getting into an interesting conversation here about moral and ethical philosophy. I tend to disagree with absolutely declaring anything wrong, evil, or immoral, as I am a subjective ethical relativist. What is ethical relativism? + Show Spoiler + In philosophy, moral relativism is the position that moral or ethical propositions do not reflect objective and/or universal moral truths, but instead make claims relative to social, cultural, historical or personal circumstances. Moral relativists hold that no universal standard exists by which to assess an ethical proposition's truth. Relativistic positions often see moral values as applicable only within certain cultural boundaries or in the context of individual preferences. An extreme relativist position might suggest that judging the moral or ethical judgments or acts of another person or group has no meaning, though most relativists propound a more limited version of the theory. Some moral relativists — for example, the existentialist Jean-Paul Sartre — hold that a personal and subjective moral core lies or ought to lie at the foundation of individuals' moral acts. In this view public morality reflects social convention, and only personal, subjective morality expresses true authenticity. Moral relativism differs from moral pluralism — which acknowledges the co-existence of opposing ideas and practices, but accepts limits to differences, such as when vital human needs get violated. Moral relativism, in contrast, grants the possibility of moral judgments that do not accept such limits. From Wikipedia Basically, any standard we use to judge theactions of other people is essentially subjective (and therefore ultimately arbitrary), so we shouldn't convince ourselves that our world view is inherently superior to those of a different cultural vantage point. This gets interesting, however, because we are all still guided by some set of moral principles, and we tend to have an interest in having them be shared by other people. For example, I (subjectively) wish that no one killed anyone else (unless it was an emergency that, say, saved more lives), but just because I feel that very strongly and even viscerally, I can't really claim that someone who disagrees with me is wrong. Even within seemingly absolute moral frameworks, like Christianity for example, more questions arise that make a belief in absolute morality seem implausible. To what moral standard is God held? Is God moral? If we can't know if God is immoral (because we have no standard to measure it against), how can we know that it is moral to follow his moral guidelines? What if God is part of a larger system in which he is an immoral agent, and that by complying with his wishes, we are in fact perpetrating immoral actions ourselves? The point is that we can't possibly know, and that a "final" sense of ethics just seems impossible to ascertain. that is a clasic example of beating arround the bush while basking in your innocence and selfworth. Why you don't apply that reasoning to children starving in Africa?. You should not help them, your ethics do not allow it. You choose to save children because there is no one that can lecture you about it, it's easier, more rewarding; but the minute your actions may have a negative impact on you (you get criticised, ridiculed..) you start with this ethic bullshit. Come on, the girl did not choose to be born there, she did not want to live there, she tried to change something (converting to islam - in my book that means she screamed for help) and you pull this ethic bullshit? | ||
|
xM(Z
Romania5299 Posts
| ||
|
bine
United States2352 Posts
On May 07 2007 12:54 xM(Z wrote: Show nested quote + On May 07 2007 11:48 bine wrote: I think we're getting into an interesting conversation here about moral and ethical philosophy. I tend to disagree with absolutely declaring anything wrong, evil, or immoral, as I am a subjective ethical relativist. What is ethical relativism? + Show Spoiler + In philosophy, moral relativism is the position that moral or ethical propositions do not reflect objective and/or universal moral truths, but instead make claims relative to social, cultural, historical or personal circumstances. Moral relativists hold that no universal standard exists by which to assess an ethical proposition's truth. Relativistic positions often see moral values as applicable only within certain cultural boundaries or in the context of individual preferences. An extreme relativist position might suggest that judging the moral or ethical judgments or acts of another person or group has no meaning, though most relativists propound a more limited version of the theory. Some moral relativists — for example, the existentialist Jean-Paul Sartre — hold that a personal and subjective moral core lies or ought to lie at the foundation of individuals' moral acts. In this view public morality reflects social convention, and only personal, subjective morality expresses true authenticity. Moral relativism differs from moral pluralism — which acknowledges the co-existence of opposing ideas and practices, but accepts limits to differences, such as when vital human needs get violated. Moral relativism, in contrast, grants the possibility of moral judgments that do not accept such limits. From Wikipedia Basically, any standard we use to judge theactions of other people is essentially subjective (and therefore ultimately arbitrary), so we shouldn't convince ourselves that our world view is inherently superior to those of a different cultural vantage point. This gets interesting, however, because we are all still guided by some set of moral principles, and we tend to have an interest in having them be shared by other people. For example, I (subjectively) wish that no one killed anyone else (unless it was an emergency that, say, saved more lives), but just because I feel that very strongly and even viscerally, I can't really claim that someone who disagrees with me is wrong. Even within seemingly absolute moral frameworks, like Christianity for example, more questions arise that make a belief in absolute morality seem implausible. To what moral standard is God held? Is God moral? If we can't know if God is immoral (because we have no standard to measure it against), how can we know that it is moral to follow his moral guidelines? What if God is part of a larger system in which he is an immoral agent, and that by complying with his wishes, we are in fact perpetrating immoral actions ourselves? The point is that we can't possibly know, and that a "final" sense of ethics just seems impossible to ascertain. that is a clasic example of beating arround the bush while basking in your innocence and selfworth. Why you don't apply that reasoning to children starving in Africa?. You should not help them, your ethics do not allow it. You choose to save children because there is no one that can lecture you about it, it's easier, more rewarding; but the minute your actions may have a negative impact on you (you get criticised, ridiculed..) you start with this ethic bullshit. Come on, the girl did not choose to be born there, she did not want to live there, she tried to change something (converting to islam - in my book that means she screamed for help) and you pull this ethic bullshit? Hmm, I'm having trouble deciphering your post. First and foremost, you should know that this isn't bullshit I pulled out of my ass, so to speak, but rather a substantially held (though not universally held, by any means) position on ethics and morality. I apply this reasoning to helping children in Africa easily: we have no moral directive on that situation any more than we do on any situation. If we do or do not choose to help children in Africa is meaningless from a cosmic perspective, and therefore cannot be said to have cosmic virtue. Sure, the girl may not have wanted to live there. But we aren't talking about her moral decisions, we're talking about the stone-throwers'. From their perspective, they were doing as they should, or, at the very least, could. Surely you don't believe that they thought that what they were doing was wrong and decided to do it out of a desire to be evil... In essence, what I'm saying is that as soon as you start to think of yourself as an evil person, good and evil just flipflop, and for you "evil" becomes the new good. | ||
| ||
StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 League of Legends Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games |
|
RSL Revival
AI Arena Tournament
BSL
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
IPSL
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
WardiTV Weekly
Kung Fu Cup
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
[ Show More ] The PondCast
KCM Race Survival
|
|
|