|
Canada3819 Posts
On May 07 2007 09:58 {88}iNcontroL wrote: You sir have a huge problem with the mentally/physically handicapped dont you? Or you just think the prime slander is "retarded" ? Have some sense man. You are upset with their actions yet you spew bigot language against homosexuals and the handicapped.
This sure as hell is a tragedy, but it is interesting seeing what kind of colors it brings out in some people. Responding by stoning and beating the members with hate and vengence in your teeth would not solve the problem. Only garuntee that it will happen again. Look to the "revenge killings" as an example. You think the brutal murdering of these people wouldn't be followed up by more "revenge killings" ? Think again.
And the people saying "religion is what caused this." It isn't. It is the manipulation and warping of religion that caused this. It is the inability to change and evolve that has caused this. It is the bloodfilled climate and reality those people live in that caused this. Religion certainly played a part but to blame it solely on them is ludicrous. Billions world wide are muslim, how come such a tiny population of that has and does kill in the name of religion? A little fact people are quick to forget. These people weren't Muslim - they were Yadizi - a comparably smaller branch of pre-Islamic religion.
This whole thing sparked at the barbarism they displayed, it isn't to do with the entire 'muslim' population, it's not even aimed at the muslim faith. Although it will of course be misconstrued as such and thus bringing back allusions of 9/11 and further fuelling the hatred for Middle-Eastern countries and their 'shocking' ways.
The main element to this story is the shock factor aka 'how could they do this?'. As to what part I believe religion played, refer to my previous posts.
|
On May 07 2007 09:58 {88}iNcontroL wrote: You sir have a huge problem with the mentally/physically handicapped dont you? Or you just think the prime slander is "retarded" ? Have some sense man. You are upset with their actions yet you spew bigot language against homosexuals and the handicapped.
This sure as hell is a tragedy, but it is interesting seeing what kind of colors it brings out in some people. Responding by stoning and beating the members with hate and vengence in your teeth would not solve the problem. Only garuntee that it will happen again. Look to the "revenge killings" as an example. You think the brutal murdering of these people wouldn't be followed up by more "revenge killings" ? Think again.
And the people saying "religion is what caused this." It isn't. It is the manipulation and warping of religion that caused this. It is the inability to change and evolve that has caused this. It is the bloodfilled climate and reality those people live in that caused this. Religion certainly played a part but to blame it solely on them is ludicrous. Billions world wide are muslim, how come such a tiny population of that has and does kill in the name of religion? A little fact people are quick to forget.
You often troll threads senselessly, but you do have a good head on your shoulders, inc. People want to blame something - anything to rationalize the sheer magnitude of certain tragedies like this, I believe. Sometimes, there really is no one to blame but the self. Those who stood by letting it happen are just as guilty as those who let it happen, yes? It's hypocritical coming from me though, since I would be too much of a pussy to make a stand myself.
|
On May 07 2007 03:25 DwmC_Foefen wrote: I said it before and ill say it again ..... Religion sucks ^^ (wouldnt the world be better of without religion? I mean those people dont look like extremists, they look like ordinary people but still they are stoning her because she wanted to change religion.)
Richard Dawkins FTW
Anyways, this is just sick. People should be allowed to believe in whatever they want, for whatever reason they want. No one should be allowed to punish others for not believing in the same thing they do.
Read the God Delusion by Richard Dawkins Best book ever.
Edit: The video made me change my mood
|
Canada3819 Posts
On May 07 2007 10:06 ilovezil wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2007 09:58 {88}iNcontroL wrote: You sir have a huge problem with the mentally/physically handicapped dont you? Or you just think the prime slander is "retarded" ? Have some sense man. You are upset with their actions yet you spew bigot language against homosexuals and the handicapped.
This sure as hell is a tragedy, but it is interesting seeing what kind of colors it brings out in some people. Responding by stoning and beating the members with hate and vengence in your teeth would not solve the problem. Only garuntee that it will happen again. Look to the "revenge killings" as an example. You think the brutal murdering of these people wouldn't be followed up by more "revenge killings" ? Think again.
And the people saying "religion is what caused this." It isn't. It is the manipulation and warping of religion that caused this. It is the inability to change and evolve that has caused this. It is the bloodfilled climate and reality those people live in that caused this. Religion certainly played a part but to blame it solely on them is ludicrous. Billions world wide are muslim, how come such a tiny population of that has and does kill in the name of religion? A little fact people are quick to forget. You often troll threads senselessly, but you do have a good head on your shoulders, inc. People want to blame something - anything to rationalize the sheer magnitude of certain tragedies like this, I believe. Sometimes, there really is no one to blame but the self. Those who stood by letting it happen are just as guilty as those who let it happen, yes? It's hypocritical coming from me though, since I would be too much of a pussy to make a stand myself. You do realise being anything more than a 'pussy' would most likely have resulted in your death. They would have probably cast the same punishment for you as you were aiding and abetting the one who had shamed them...and so forth. I suppose this is the mindset, and it isn't one worth getting involved in. It's worth believing in things sure, but how far will you take them before you overstep the basic rights of being human?
|
i'm not saying what they're doing it right, but i dont think you should look down on other people's society just because it disagrees with your own. They just value family and honor a lot more than we do. They probably look at a lot of the things we do and are like "Barbarians!" and it's not like we don't have the death penalty here.
|
On May 07 2007 10:10 geometryb wrote: i'm not saying what they're doing it right, but i dont think you should look down on other people's society just because it disagrees with your own. They just value family and honor a lot more than we do. They probably look at a lot of the things we do and are like "Barbarians!" and it's not like we don't have the death penalty here.
No, we should definitely look down on this.
|
Canada3819 Posts
On May 07 2007 10:14 pubbanana wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2007 10:10 geometryb wrote: i'm not saying what they're doing it right, but i dont think you should look down on other people's society just because it disagrees with your own. They just value family and honor a lot more than we do. They probably look at a lot of the things we do and are like "Barbarians!" and it's not like we don't have the death penalty here. No, we should definitely look down on this. In our society yes, in regard to human rights yes, in regards to western religion yes.
With regards to their society and respective beliefs no.
|
On May 07 2007 10:10 Smurg wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2007 10:06 ilovezil wrote:On May 07 2007 09:58 {88}iNcontroL wrote: You sir have a huge problem with the mentally/physically handicapped dont you? Or you just think the prime slander is "retarded" ? Have some sense man. You are upset with their actions yet you spew bigot language against homosexuals and the handicapped.
This sure as hell is a tragedy, but it is interesting seeing what kind of colors it brings out in some people. Responding by stoning and beating the members with hate and vengence in your teeth would not solve the problem. Only garuntee that it will happen again. Look to the "revenge killings" as an example. You think the brutal murdering of these people wouldn't be followed up by more "revenge killings" ? Think again.
And the people saying "religion is what caused this." It isn't. It is the manipulation and warping of religion that caused this. It is the inability to change and evolve that has caused this. It is the bloodfilled climate and reality those people live in that caused this. Religion certainly played a part but to blame it solely on them is ludicrous. Billions world wide are muslim, how come such a tiny population of that has and does kill in the name of religion? A little fact people are quick to forget. You often troll threads senselessly, but you do have a good head on your shoulders, inc. People want to blame something - anything to rationalize the sheer magnitude of certain tragedies like this, I believe. Sometimes, there really is no one to blame but the self. Those who stood by letting it happen are just as guilty as those who let it happen, yes? It's hypocritical coming from me though, since I would be too much of a pussy to make a stand myself. You do realise being anything more than a 'pussy' would most likely have resulted in your death. They would have probably cast the same punishment for you as you were aiding and abetting the one who had shamed them...and so forth. I suppose this is the mindset, and it isn't one worth getting involved in. It's worth believing in things sure, but how far will you take them before you overstep the basic rights of being human?
Yes, I understand where you are coming from. The idealistic side of me wants to believe that I would make a stand and die at least trying, but the rational side of me leans towards docility(proper word?). From here on, it's just a matter of your beliefs conflicting against that of others'. I'm sure that someone who strongly believes in justice would make a stand and die trying. There are also those who are charismatic enough to make a difference. Sad to say, I don't fall under any of those categories and would have been able to absolutely nothing in that situation. That kind of powerlessness makes me feel suffocated with frustration and anger, but it's just the way it is...
|
Fuck their society and respective beliefs?
|
When evil manifests itself in an entire society, that is an intangible matter which is not helped by ideological reductionism. If the Kurd stones other Kurds, it is because his father has stoned other Kurds' fathers, and their fathers have in turn done the same. When I am angry at a man but hold from killing him, I do not think that I am observing the commandment "thou shalt not kill." Moral traditions are deeper than religious ideas, and while ideology can create a few saints (or demons) it can never occupy the simultaneous motives of a people. This is why, even if you do not espouse Christianity directly, the internal dignity of man and of life is a moral tradition you inherit when denouncing these killings as senseless. It is no more, and no less a religious idea than what is happening here.
|
On May 07 2007 10:20 MoltkeWarding wrote: When evil manifests itself in an entire society, that is an intangible matter which is not helped by ideological reductionism. If the Kurd stones other Kurds, it is because his father has stoned other Kurds' fathers, and their fathers have in turn done the same. When I am angry at a man but hold from killing him, I do not think that I am observing the commandment "thou shalt not kill." Moral traditions are deeper than religious ideas, and while ideology can create a few saints (or demons) it can never occupy the simultaneous motives of a people. This is why, even if you do not espouse Christianity directly, the internal dignity of man and of life is a moral tradition you inherit when denouncing these killings as senseless. It is no more, and no less a religious idea than what is happening here.
So then what would be your remedy to this situation? Sure anyone can see the clear evil in such situations, but what do you propose we do about it? If the answer is nothing, it would have been better that you saved that minute or so of thinking up clever words to say humanity sucks. I don't mean to say this as a mindless flame, mind you.
|
the death penalty is used for: murder, espionage, treason cowardice, desertion, insubordination, and mutiny (military) drug trafficking, corruption (some countries, singapore?)
i can see lots of crimes in that list that i don't think deserve a death penalty, but they're there because other cultures consider them very serious.
they consider adultery a very bad crime. it's just that our culture tells us that fucking lots of guys isn't that bad. but they're different, what's wrong with that?
|
can i kill someone? those guys kicking lets hang the muther fuckers, and burn there fucking legs off ill fuckin rip there legs off and shit in them and then take there teeth out one by one iwth my fuck bare hands, then ill take the stones from the ground and mash there fucking toes into mush, then the same to there hands, and legs and nees and faces and ill fuckem up ill fucking beat the fuckl out them afuauisdgfar789 q389 tiosg odgu goof.. rat muther fuckers. need to be wiped out
|
there culture is like that because they never had real leadership by the way so get off ur high horse buddy who spoke before Myself.
|
On May 07 2007 10:25 geometryb wrote: the death penalty is used for: murder, espionage, treason cowardice, desertion, insubordination, and mutiny (military) drug trafficking, corruption (some countries, singapore?)
i can see lots of crimes in that list that i don't think deserve a death penalty, but they're there because other cultures consider them very serious.
they consider adultery a very bad crime. it's just that our culture tells us that fucking lots of guys isn't that bad. but they're different, what's wrong with that?
brb gettin sum rox n goin to geo's house (shouldnt you be studying for finals noob?)
all joking aside i agree with this noob freshman. tolerance and understanding are the first steps to showing populations with human rights issues the error of their ways
|
Canada3819 Posts
On May 07 2007 10:29 orionClan wrote: can i kill someone? those guys kicking lets hang the muther fuckers, and burn there fucking legs off ill fuckin rip there legs off and shit in them and then take there teeth out one by one iwth my fuck bare hands, then ill take the stones from the ground and mash there fucking toes into mush, then the same to there hands, and legs and nees and faces and ill fuckem up ill fucking beat the fuckl out them afuauisdgfar789 q389 tiosg odgu goof.. rat muther fuckers. need to be wiped out Proving you didn't read anything in the thread and/or you would be the sort of person who instigates war and perpetuates more death if you had the power to.
gg world.
|
On May 07 2007 10:24 ilovezil wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2007 10:20 MoltkeWarding wrote: When evil manifests itself in an entire society, that is an intangible matter which is not helped by ideological reductionism. If the Kurd stones other Kurds, it is because his father has stoned other Kurds' fathers, and their fathers have in turn done the same. When I am angry at a man but hold from killing him, I do not think that I am observing the commandment "thou shalt not kill." Moral traditions are deeper than religious ideas, and while ideology can create a few saints (or demons) it can never occupy the simultaneous motives of a people. This is why, even if you do not espouse Christianity directly, the internal dignity of man and of life is a moral tradition you inherit when denouncing these killings as senseless. It is no more, and no less a religious idea than what is happening here. So then what would be your remedy to this situation? Sure anyone can see the clear evil in such situations, but what do you propose we do about it? If the answer is nothing, it would have been better that you saved that minute or so of thinking up clever words to say humanity sucks. I don't mean to say this as a mindless flame, mind you. Well he pretty much spelled out what would have to change: the moral traditions of these people. That will take awhile and probably changing their religious beliefs is a good first step to speed up the process. Empathy taught through moral tradition is good and all but I'm sure these people delude themselves into thinking that if they did the same crime as the girl that was stoned they'd take the punishment. How else can western societies condone the death penalty? It's the same concept, they just have different standards. I guess the worst part of this is the brutal way of death, at least we've meticulously evolved from stoning to hanging to electric chairs to gas chambers to lethal injections. But it's all still death.
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
On May 07 2007 10:29 orionClan wrote: can i kill someone? those guys kicking lets hang the muther fuckers, and burn there fucking legs off ill fuckin rip there legs off and shit in them and then take there teeth out one by one iwth my fuck bare hands, then ill take the stones from the ground and mash there fucking toes into mush, then the same to there hands, and legs and nees and faces and ill fuckem up ill fucking beat the fuckl out them afuauisdgfar789 q389 tiosg odgu goof.. rat muther fuckers. need to be wiped out
You cant do half the stuff you said because you already burnt the legs off you silly fuck.
But yeah, they were so bad you should do exactly the same thing to them. So then someone somewhere can read about you and say "Fuck I am going to shit down their ripped off legs (lol)" and the cycle repeats itself...
|
On May 07 2007 09:07 Smurg wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2007 09:03 xM(Z wrote:I said the only way we could stop them doing things like this is to kill them. Then I'm saying...how can we pass judgment on them killing needlessly if we kill them too? Smurg, on the other hand people accept the judgement of God without asking any questions, without blaming him because he is superior. You think your society is superior to theirs and that in it self should give you the power to pass judgement. (it's a strech but can be applied in some circumstances) I'm not saying our society is superior to theirs, I'm saying we are different. What would the will of Christianity's 'God' be? To kill all of these people? I don't even know. so your ignorance prevents you from taking any action. if you were the one getting stoned wouldnt you want to be saved? if you were there and that girl asked you to help her you would still do nothing? It's not like you're watching a documentary on animal planet where you see a lion killing a gnu and go: man, im so sad for the gnu but it's the law of nature, i can't entervine. There is a striking diference beetwen: all lions kill for a their survival vs a hand full a people kill for their retarded believes. You are where you are because people took the life in to their hands and made it happen. You are not privileged because thats the way shit happened, someone made it so and you are fucking gratefull to him(them). Their motive is religion, their excuse is fear.
|
We have some users from South-Asia in TL.net, don't we? I'm really interested what do they have to say to this.
|
|
|
|
|
|