|
United States44465 Posts
On May 07 2007 06:20 Smurg wrote: Imagine you are one of them, this is what they see as justification for what the girl did.
It isn't wrong for them.
It's wrong for us.
So there is nothing we can do that will change this fact - it's their belief apparently. Committing adultery to them and having their family shamed is probably on par with someone gunning down your family.
The 'Yazidi' people, as they appear to be, use stoning routinely for acts that shame their family...adultery in this instance.
I think my main opinion is - we can't fucking do anything, this is what they believe in...the only way we could put an end to it is to kill them - then who're we to pass judgement?
Respect for beliefs is greatly exaggerated. Dawkins makes an excellent point about this. He says that he will respect a religion to the same extent that he will respect a mans opinion that his wife is beautiful and his children clever. They are all very personal beliefs. You'd not get me to say my girlfriend is ugly because I believe very strongly that she isn't. And I'd expect my friends to stay quiet around me if they think she is simply out of respect for my beliefs. But if I were to start making sweeping political statements based upon my girlfriend being hot then you'd not stay quiet simply out of respect for my beliefs. And yet with religion, people do.
You could be a well reputed philosopher who has written many books on pacifism and have trouble being admitted as a conscientuous objector should there be a draft. But if you father was a Quaker, no questions asked.
|
ppl are so fucking idiot :/
|
Canada3819 Posts
On May 07 2007 06:52 Kwark wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2007 06:20 Smurg wrote: Imagine you are one of them, this is what they see as justification for what the girl did.
It isn't wrong for them.
It's wrong for us.
So there is nothing we can do that will change this fact - it's their belief apparently. Committing adultery to them and having their family shamed is probably on par with someone gunning down your family.
The 'Yazidi' people, as they appear to be, use stoning routinely for acts that shame their family...adultery in this instance.
I think my main opinion is - we can't fucking do anything, this is what they believe in...the only way we could put an end to it is to kill them - then who're we to pass judgement? Respect for beliefs is greatly exaggerated. Dawkins makes an excellent point about this. He says that he will respect a religion to the same extent that he will respect a mans opinion that his wife is beautiful and his children clever. They are all very personal beliefs. You'd not get me to say my girlfriend is ugly because I believe very strongly that she isn't. And I'd expect my friends to stay quiet around me if they think she is simply out of respect for my beliefs. But if I were to start making sweeping political statements based upon my girlfriend being hot then you'd not stay quiet simply out of respect for my beliefs. And yet with religion, people do. You could be a well reputed philosopher who has written many books on pacifism and have trouble being admitted as a conscientuous objector should there be a draft. But if you father was a Quaker, no questions asked. The real question is: Is your girlfriend hot?
But anyhow, I don't think religious or cult belief will ever be understood properly...or why it drives people to act - all I know is that belief is a rather strong thing.
If someone honestly believed they had to kill aliens that had manifested themselves inside black people because of radio waves that they saw in their dreams by stoning them to death - the world could be a fucked place if that person could persuade a mob of people to the same way of thinking.
Oh wait...the KKK?
|
Fucking idiots!!!
Fucking angry right now, that video was one of the most horrible things i've ever seen.
Something needs to be done, we can't respect beliefs like these. Countries like these needs to get themselves secularized ASAP
|
On May 07 2007 01:14 KrAzYfoOL wrote: scientology makes alot more sense than the filth they believe in.
no, this does.
i did';t watch the vid because i don't want to get depressed or anything :/
|
That's just terrible, it isn't just third world countries either, this sort of reckless hate happens all over the world all the time.
It's a sad time we live in.
|
And the hits keep on coming.
http://www.newswire.co.nz/main/viewstory.aspx?storyid=369181&catid=3011
+ Show Spoiler + Revenge Killings In Mosul 6:44 am, 23 Apr 2007 Print this story Gunmen have shot dead 23 factory workers from an ancient minority sect in an apparent revenge killing in the northern Iraqi city of Mosul.
Iraqi security forces say the gunmen stopped a mini-bus, forced the workers out and gunned them down in the eastern al-Nour district.
They belonged to the pre-Islamic Kurdish sect, Yazidi.
The police say the killings appeared to be in retaliation for an incident in which a Yazidi woman was stoned to death several weeks ago for converting to Islam.
Car bombs in the capital, Baghdad, have also killed 18 people.
In the worst attack, two suicide car bombers rammed their vehicles into a police station in a mostly Shi'ite neighbourhood, killing 12 people - most of them civilians.
The police say 95 people were wounded.
|
Smurg, she was 17 years old, she did not comit adultery. And anyway around, nothing justifies killing a human being like that. She got humiliated, hit with rocks, that's a death i wish for no one. It's not only about the killing, it's about the way they did it. And don't tell me a bullet in the head is exactly the same like it happened to her or to that couple (there was a thread about it, a couple which was tortured and killed). We can do something, try and explain them there is nothing more precious than life. Try to explain them we evolved from 5 centurys ago tortures.
Flaccid, that's the way it goes in their world. An eye for an eye.
|
i disapprove of the Muslim religion because i think it's mostly been interpreted so that men have all the power and women are merely property. But whatever that religion that girl was, it doesn't sound any different from some stories i have heard of Muslim men doing the same to their daughters or sisters or wives - just because of some impiety like not wearing your head scarf, or some suspected relationship. (Men in history have done much worst than that, and yet they get pass scot-free.) I hope, the family of the girl take a step back and remove any religious beliefs from their judgement and actually see from that video what they just did. They are, if anything quite similar to the Muslim religion than they thought it seems.
|
And thats the biggest problem, violence breeds more violence. We can say that we'd go there and kill all those people involved, however that isnt going to change the situation, its just going to add to it.
|
OK, after reading the philosophy thread I couldn't resist going to this thread, regardless of the NSFW and the fact I'm in a school library and where a librarian might randomly pop up and wonder why I'm on a website "where they use obscene language" and then I have to tell off because I'm doing a project for forensics (haha good one, huh?). But anyways, I'm a little nervous about watching the video because I read some of the posts below the OP and I saw that it was horrible.
I'm so sick of the Middle East being so fucking close-minded; if she wants to live her life with somebody that she actually wants, then she should be able to.
|
|
|
Why is it that eventhough I try, I can't be affected by this story. I watched the movie, yet felt nothing.
|
Those morons should rot in jail...disgusting.
|
I haven't read all the comments but I think they should bomb the entire country and make parking spots.
And those ppl should get the "Animal"-treatment by those americans in that other horrific thread.
|
Canada3819 Posts
On May 07 2007 07:46 Pika Chu wrote: Smurg, she was 17 years old, she did not comit adultery. And anyway around, nothing justifies killing a human being like that. She got humiliated, hit with rocks, that's a death i wish for no one. It's not only about the killing, it's about the way they did it. And don't tell me a bullet in the head is exactly the same like it happened to her or to that couple (there was a thread about it, a couple which was tortured and killed). We can do something, try and explain them there is nothing more precious than life. Try to explain them we evolved from 5 centurys ago tortures.
Flaccid, that's the way it goes in their world. An eye for an eye. Ok she didn't commit adultery...but she did elope with a muslim man and convert to Islam. So it has to be realised this isn't the work of muslims, it is the result of Yazidi belief.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yazidi
They are apparently the 'devil' worshippers of the muslim world According to the Encyclopedia of the Orient, "The reason for the Yazidis reputation of being devil worshipers, is connected to the other name of Melek Taus, Shaytan, the same name as the Koran's for Satan."[2] However, according to the Kurdish linguist Jamal Nebez, the word Taus is most probably derived from the Greek and is related to the words Zeus and Theos, alluding to the meaning of God. Accordingly, Malak Ta'us is God's Angel, and this is how Yezidis themselves see Melek Taus or Taus-e-Malak
All of this aside, what they believed they were doing was right according to their old rituals...sure they might be 'out-of-date' but as we've seen - still practised. She was one of their own, and it just goes to show what they will do with their beliefs.
I swear it's so savage, but somehow in Christianity has taken a different path right? I mean if one of the 10 Commandments said we had to kill our 2nd born son and it was enforced all throughout history...do you think it would still be upheld?
Our societies are in general, loosely based around the religious belief that is held by the majority of the population of a certain country.
Modern-day Christianity can be seen as goody-goody - we have strong governments and justice systems in each country...we generally believe in the good of our fellow man and know 'evil' when we see it. This is why this is so savage to us.
The Muslim religion and other Middle Eastern religions seem to have older and more savage customs in their societies...such as stoning people to death. Although I'm sure a few people got stoned to death in bible somewhere. :/
But as a general rule, in a lot of middle eastern countries... people are a lot more aggressive and nonchalant in general...and definitely easy to be stirred up angrily with regards to their religion.
Not sure what it is...but I'd say it's the imbuing of different religious beliefs across the vast multitude of countries throughout the centuries, that separates them.
As in: Our society can never be the same as theirs, because our religions differ so greatly.
|
|
|
Canada3819 Posts
On May 07 2007 08:37 Storchen wrote: I haven't read all the comments but I think they should bomb the entire country and make parking spots.
And those ppl should get the "Animal"-treatment by those americans in that other horrific thread. So this makes us better than them then?
If we kill them all and fuck them up 'animal' style...are we any better than them? I don't think so.
They seem more primitive to us because perhaps they are in a sense, primitive to see that we don't need to kill human beings needlessly.
Yet in their eyes, honour plays a large part in society...someone defiling their religion is the worst thing anyone can do, because they are so bound up in their beliefs that nothing can separate their barbarism from what we would call 'civilised' humanism as long as their religious beliefs are still in place.
But we don't have a right to take their beliefs away from them...religious rights > human rights in this case...and according to the media...in every case.
|
That's just terrible.. shows how life is cruel and full of stupid violence.
|
Religion didn't kill this girl, people did.
|
|
|
|
|
|