EPTSmash Bros. Melee General Discussion - Page 148
| Forum Index > General Games |
We have created an irc channel (#tl-smash on Quakenet) for people to find others to play with on Dolphin or just to chat about Smash. Feel free to join! | ||
Souma
2nd Worst City in CA8938 Posts
| ||
motbob
United States12546 Posts
There is a case to be made that Billy Bob was the best player in 2015. The issue is that variance exists in Melee, and the best player at EVO may not be the "true" best player. Players have good days and bad days. Billy Bob's true skill may be higher than what he showed at EVO, or it may be lower. Someone ranking the players may say, "Billy Bob's play was so good that I am comfortable that he would win a matchup against any top player. I'm ranking him #1." Or, another pundit might say, "We didn't see Billy Bob against Hungrybox or against any competent Marth, so I don't feel comfortable saying he would match his EVO success if he attended more tournaments." The point is that a lack of data should not automatically count against a player, unless we feel that attending tournaments is an act worth rewarding. Lack of data simply places a burden on observers to draw inferences based on the little data that exists. To say that PPMD was clearly better than Hungrybox in 2015 is either to claim that no one could reasonably draw the inference that he would have put up comparable performances at tournaments other than Apex/EVO (a questionable claim) or to claim that the act of attending tournaments itself should be part of the criterion of the MIOM rank (something I would not agree with). I don't have any issue with saying that PPMD should be 5th, but I do have an issue with the language implying that no reasonable person could put him above Hungrybox. In the end, lack of data just means that many different opinions are valid. | ||
|
Souma
2nd Worst City in CA8938 Posts
So suffice it to say, a lack of data should not count for a player. I personally think PPMD's performance at EVO should have damaged him quite a bit. He still got 3rd but it wasn't exactly pretty. He beat SFAT, HugS and Plup. His road was significantly easier than Hbox's and it was still sloppy. | ||
|
The_Red_Viper
19533 Posts
to claim that the act of attending tournaments itself should be part of the criterion of the MIOM rank I simply don't understand why you don't agree with this. How do you rate someone/something when there isn't enough data? To me that makes very little sense. It's a guessing game at this point which is a bad thing. Lack of data doesn't really count "against" the player, but the lack of data makes it almost impossible to find things which count FOR him at the same time. Another problem is what a list wants to achieve (what timeframe are we considering?), etc | ||
|
motbob
United States12546 Posts
| ||
|
The_Red_Viper
19533 Posts
| ||
|
Souma
2nd Worst City in CA8938 Posts
| ||
Spazer
Canada8032 Posts
On August 19 2015 08:39 The_Red_Viper wrote: Another problem is what a list wants to achieve (what timeframe are we considering?), etc This particular MIOM Ranking takes into account all tournaments from January to EVO. Of course, all the people who did the voting will still weight recent tournaments differently and all that... | ||
|
eieio
United States14512 Posts
| ||
|
aRyuujin
United States5049 Posts
 Yeah it's netplay and it's a secondary (and fox online is especially gross) but it's still pretty neat!http://www.twitch.tv/hungrybox/v/11762887?t=0h36m45s | ||
|
Souma
2nd Worst City in CA8938 Posts
| ||
|
Eppa!
Sweden4641 Posts
| ||
|
Carnivorous Sheep
Baa?21244 Posts
HTC really going all out on this :o S2J, Tako, Zhu all getting invited too. | ||
|
Souma
2nd Worst City in CA8938 Posts
Thanks HTC <3 | ||
|
bo1b
Australia12814 Posts
It's even worse because he arguably is the best lol | ||
|
Muffloe
Sweden6061 Posts
https://www.facebook.com/smasheurope/posts/1639933359564764 | ||
|
Targe
United Kingdom14103 Posts
also if i was him id be dumb and skip the rest of the circuit reading through that statement its pretty bullshit, 10x longer than it needs to be, talking about "PR" and complaining that players didnt use their mains. | ||
|
bo1b
Australia12814 Posts
Bo5 > being able to stream the tournament Pot's too small. Don't think you can have both tbh, not without multiple streams. | ||
|
Targe
United Kingdom14103 Posts
changing entry from 3 to 5 pounds would have added like 700 pounds to the pot and would have affected none of the entrants (5 pound entry for a major tournament is still pretty cheap if you ask me). | ||
|
BrTarolg
United Kingdom3574 Posts
But hey, now im the british guy that they are referring to who is banned from the mic LOL Which is jokes because me and leffen had a blast on commentary. But it's ok, we will find a way onto paragon commentary LOL | ||
| ||
