EPTUser was temp banned for this post.
The KellyMilkies Fanclub - Page 33
| Forum Index > Fan Clubs |
This is a Fanclub and as such a place for fans to discuss the person in question for which the topic was created. Coming into this topic without having participated in it to criticise her or with the comment that this topic doesn't deserve to be here is unacceptable. So play nice in here and keep the debates and hate outside please. | ||
|
MerciLess
213 Posts
User was temp banned for this post. | ||
|
naux
Canada738 Posts
On September 03 2011 10:54 MerciLess wrote: I don't really care about kellymilkies. I don't watch her if she's casting because I have no idea what she's saying, but if she wants to cast, meh doesn't hurt me. But when 99.6% of the comments on TL and Reddit are negative, well it might be time to reevaluate yourself. If it was 50/50, even 60/40 or 70/30, you could pass it off as just preference. When almost everyone who has anything to say about it says you're unprofessional, they can't understand you, and they don't like what you're doing, I mean that should be a hint. i agree User was temp banned for this post. | ||
|
lowkontrast
United States855 Posts
On September 03 2011 10:54 MerciLess wrote: I don't really care about kellymilkies. I don't watch her if she's casting because I have no idea what she's saying, but if she wants to cast, meh doesn't hurt me. But when 99.6% of the comments on TL and Reddit are negative, well it might be time to reevaluate yourself. If it was 50/50, even 60/40 or 70/30, you could pass it off as just preference. When almost everyone who has anything to say about it says you're unprofessional, they can't understand you, and they don't like what you're doing, I mean that should be a hint. I don't think this is the kind of material you should be posting in her fanclub. | ||
|
redFF
United States3910 Posts
| ||
|
Theoriginalrod
101 Posts
| ||
|
S4KuR4
France52 Posts
| ||
|
sh4w
United States713 Posts
| ||
|
EsKy
Australia10 Posts
I don't get why her personal life has anything to do with sc2 or her casting, the two are separate. TL is for her sc2ing, and that's all anyone should be concerned with. As for her mistake at SMM, sure it was bad. But it's in the past and she's improved out of sight since then. Tobi was merely lucky to make all his casting mistakes in relative anonymity years before he became well known in DOTA. | ||
|
Clbull
United Kingdom1439 Posts
On September 03 2011 08:10 Mr.SoloDolo wrote: So basically Kelly's response is "None of this is true and Tobi is a liar". SOLID DEFENSE, I cant believe I ever doubted you kelly! User was warned for this post I can't believe I am about to say this but READ THE FUCKING POST. Kelly admitted that her casting during that event was a bit of a mistake and aimed to at least improve herself in later events. Plus the whole thing between her and Moonglade was frankly her business. Also, she gave HuK a hug after she broke up with Moonglade? Big fucking deal. It's not like she fellated him on-stage and live on television, is it? It's just a hug, which is frankly not that big of a deal. I mean she said she gives hugs to fans at events which are just exactly what they say on the tin. A hug. Plus she's friends with HuK. Is she suddenly not allowed to have friends as a professional member of the Starcraft II community? On September 03 2011 09:01 Chilliman wrote: Yeah it happened a long time ago and she still speaks english so fucking horribly. She may not cry over everything now but her casting is still fucking terrible. User was temp banned for this post. In case you haven't noticed, this is a FAN club thread. It doesn't mean that somebody can just chime in with "Trollololololol" and not expect the banhammer. Also, I've seen her cast a GSL game and she wasn't bad at all. Sure I've seen better casting from Tastosis, Day[9] etc, but I don't think she deserves the hate that she's been getting. On September 03 2011 08:47 dofz wrote: Can I get a 2days ban before I say something that might get me banned for more. I can't believe people need to be told it's not ok to leave in the middle of a cast to go shed a tear because someone wrote mean things about you on the internet. Stop giving girls special threatment User was temp banned for this post. How is everyone giving her "special treatment." She's a woman. Who cares? Also, haven't the amount of people who have gotten bans for the same thing taught you to stop acting like such a martyr. On September 03 2011 08:33 Persay wrote: Bad casters gonna cast bad User was temp banned for this post. Wow.... stupid, unconstructive and outright inappropriate responses like these are making me lose all hope in the Starcraft II community.... | ||
|
SecondSandwich
United States319 Posts
Gogo Kelly, I seriously have no idea why people love to hate you so much... | ||
|
motiust
Australia97 Posts
I want to remind everyone that this is a classic case of Cyber Bullying, it may cause serious consequences to certain individual. Cheers, | ||
|
askTeivospy
1525 Posts
| ||
|
Ansinjunger
United States2451 Posts
People are just listening to Tobi's story, not taking one second to ask themselves if Kelly had an issue at the time. Notice in Tobi's own account, he doesn't ask her if there's something wrong or if he can help. I understand his motivation, play the stoic sufferer, the regular guy minding his own business and in a way "the bigger man." When the result of playing the "mature one" allows you to publicly bash someone later, your true behavior shines through. It's incredibly typical for people who really want to bash someone or say something critical to preface their statement (or story) with the good old, "I don't wanna be one of those guys, but..." | ||
|
taLbuk
Madagascar1879 Posts
On September 03 2011 12:38 Ansinjunger wrote: I was thinking about the issue at work today, and what a one-sided story it really is, in spite of how it was told. I randomly opened page 30 since I noticed the drama continues, and lo and behold a response from Kelly which is just as believable, if not more so. People are just listening to Tobi's story, not taking one second to ask themselves if Kelly had an issue at the time. Notice in Tobi's own account, he doesn't ask her if there's something wrong or if he can help. I understand his motivation, play the stoic sufferer, the regular guy minding his own business and in a way "the bigger man." When the result of playing the "mature one" allows you to publicly bash someone later, your true behavior shines through. It's incredibly typical for people who really want to bash someone or say something critical to preface their statement (or story) with the good old, "I don't wanna be one of those guys, but..." I'm a fan of Kelly and I like what she does for the community, anyone involved in eSports and participating in events as staff or players are doing 99% more than your average forum warrior. However I'm also a fan of Tobi, and I highly doubt it is his quest to 'slander' Kelly etc etc. All it takes is one negative experience with a person, and in the eyes of a caster ditching the stage is one of the worst things you can do, but like Kelly said it wasn't malicious or lack of caring, she was simply new to the whole concept. In Tobi's eyes and many other casters it's the ultimate worse thing that you can do, and just like anyone's resume and job history are important, so is the history if your perusing to be a professional commentator. Goodluck Kelly and don't let people's harsh words get you down, also the community shouldn't overreact to peoples (tobi's and others) opinions so quickly, just let people say what they have to say and let it go, this wouldn't even be a hot topic if people could just learn to bite their tongue (including tobi) | ||
|
TheSwamp
United States1497 Posts
| ||
|
Earll
Norway847 Posts
On September 03 2011 05:58 kellymilkies wrote: As for Huk, I don't even know why he brought that up. I think people who have met me in real life, even fans that met me in Gamescom got a hug from me. Chris and I have been friends for quite a while now and he's a great guy. I have already apologised to Chris for any inconvinience that has be caused because of this! Haha, I got a hug from you at the playersparty at gamescom. At the same night I also got a hug from Moonglade (And from huk if i recall correctly!) Just wanted to throw in some support to my favorite Singaporean caster. Although you are not my favorite caster overall (tastosis <3) you are definetly getting a lot more flack than you, or anyone deserve. (sc)reddit seems to have a huge thing for witch hunts and bandwagons, and this entire thing is just blown way out of proportion and most of it just seems to be baseless speculation\rumours\shitthrowing. Obviously the Dota cast could have been handled better, but I mean that was 1 mistake, 8 months ago. Bringing that up, and the way it was done by tobi, was all pretty unprofessional or douchebagy or whatever I don't even know what to call it. Kelly hwaiting. | ||
|
HEROwithNOlegacy
United States850 Posts
User was warned for this post | ||
|
tGFuRy
United States537 Posts
| ||
|
doomscythe
61 Posts
So assuming his stories were real, Kelly broke up with Moonglade, she then hugged Huk. So what? Does all this shit has something to do with Tobi? Even in the eyes of a conservative Asian, I see nothing wrong with it. | ||
Whitewing
United States7483 Posts
On September 03 2011 13:31 HEROwithNOlegacy wrote: Likely hood that Tobi is lying about what he said about your casting and what you did during casts in my mind is 0. What does he benefit from finally saying what he feels about you, for the longest time he refused to talk about it. Until now, he really gains absolutely nothing by saying what his experience was with you. However you lose a lot if what he said is true, that is why I feel you are just lying to make yourself not look so bad. I think what he said is accurate (at least about getting up and leaving in the middle of the cast and letting the haters on forums get to you) That sounds like something you would do. I didn't like your casts before this and couldn't ever listen but what tobi said you did just makes you look like a child. Then get the hell out of her fan club and make a thread somewhere else about it. How do people not understand this? | ||
| ||
