|
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.ggFor currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net |
2nd Worst City in CA8938 Posts
On May 07 2014 06:54 maru~ wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2014 06:35 Emnjay808 wrote:
I'm pretty excited that the list is finally being updated. There's so many SoL and romcoms that people should be more aware of. Space Brothers and Chihayafuru come to mind. Chihayafuru is neither though. Show nested quote +On May 07 2014 06:51 Souma wrote:
I'll give it some consideration, but are there even that many good harem shows that it warrants its own category?
Not sure I wanna be recommending people IS. You could put harem shows to romcom, drama or whatever, I don't think it needs its own category. But to be honest, I'm not sure if it's even worth the effort to make a new chart. The /a/ chart is pretty good, you could just replace and add some stuff if you must and be done with it.
Uhm, that's how we came up with the chart that's in the modnote. But now it's outdated so I'm gonna update it. We're not making a totally new chart, just updating it.
|
har·em
ˈhe(ə)rəm,ˈhar-/
noun
noun: harem; plural noun: harems
1.) shit
2.) something that would be better as a VN
3.) a very cute banling on teamliquid.net
synonyms: feces, garbage, something bigfan likes
|
On May 07 2014 06:56 Reaper9 wrote:
Hrmmmm true... Harem is usually a direct competition of multiple individuals, for one main character though?...Yea we have to define what a harem is? =_=? Sheepish grin* Maybe the point of the show is to win the main character's affection?
@Wolf yea...point taken, but people have a different view on what romance is as well XD.... but I suppose maybe a subcategory for romance? Since some people think romance entails between 2 people?... Arrrrkkkk this is hard D : <
Meh maybe I'm thinking too hard, just keep it under romance is fine and all
Well what about shows where the harem aspect is kinda secondary? Like Highschool DxD. Its mostly an action show but the dude also has a harem.
Edit: Also thats not fair Sent, I don't think BF likes harems anymore then he likes anything else.
You guys might be right though, any Harem can just be thrown under whatever secondary category it also falls under.
|
On May 07 2014 07:01 Slaughter wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2014 06:56 Reaper9 wrote:
Hrmmmm true... Harem is usually a direct competition of multiple individuals, for one main character though?...Yea we have to define what a harem is? =_=? Sheepish grin* Maybe the point of the show is to win the main character's affection?
@Wolf yea...point taken, but people have a different view on what romance is as well XD.... but I suppose maybe a subcategory for romance? Since some people think romance entails between 2 people?... Arrrrkkkk this is hard D : <
Meh maybe I'm thinking too hard, just keep it under romance is fine and all Well what about shows where the harem aspect is kinda secondary? Like Highschool DxD. Its mostly an action show but the dude also has a harem. Edit: Also thats not fair Sent, I don't think BF likes harems anymore then he likes anything else. 
He likes them more than FMP
|
Seriously, fmp wasn't good :-(
|
On May 07 2014 07:01 Slaughter wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2014 06:56 Reaper9 wrote:
Hrmmmm true... Harem is usually a direct competition of multiple individuals, for one main character though?...Yea we have to define what a harem is? =_=? Sheepish grin* Maybe the point of the show is to win the main character's affection?
@Wolf yea...point taken, but people have a different view on what romance is as well XD.... but I suppose maybe a subcategory for romance? Since some people think romance entails between 2 people?... Arrrrkkkk this is hard D : <
Meh maybe I'm thinking too hard, just keep it under romance is fine and all Well what about shows where the harem aspect is kinda secondary? Like Highschool DxD. Its mostly an action show but the dude also has a harem. Edit: Also thats not fair Sent, I don't think BF likes harems anymore then he likes anything else.
an action show?
If someone asked you what HighSchool DxD is you'd answer "it's kind of an actions show" because you think that's the major point of the show? Pretty sure you'd get veeeeeeery strange looks from people who don't know what it is after they finished it or even just gave it a try.
|
Netherlands45349 Posts
Hataraku maou sama on it pls
S2 when.
Gundam unicorn(age i found meh). Tonari no seki kun mb. Mono etc on it if its not already there prolly?servant x service?
|
Netherlands45349 Posts
And wtf hs dxd as i recall is harem with action not other way around.
|
On May 07 2014 07:05 Toadesstern wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2014 07:01 Slaughter wrote:On May 07 2014 06:56 Reaper9 wrote:
Hrmmmm true... Harem is usually a direct competition of multiple individuals, for one main character though?...Yea we have to define what a harem is? =_=? Sheepish grin* Maybe the point of the show is to win the main character's affection?
@Wolf yea...point taken, but people have a different view on what romance is as well XD.... but I suppose maybe a subcategory for romance? Since some people think romance entails between 2 people?... Arrrrkkkk this is hard D : <
Meh maybe I'm thinking too hard, just keep it under romance is fine and all Well what about shows where the harem aspect is kinda secondary? Like Highschool DxD. Its mostly an action show but the dude also has a harem. Edit: Also thats not fair Sent, I don't think BF likes harems anymore then he likes anything else. an action show? If someone asked you what HighSchool DxD is you'd answer "it's kind of an actions show" because you think that's the major point of the show? Pretty sure you'd get veeeeeeery strange looks from people who don't know what it is after they finished it or even just gave it a try.
Maybe I am just projecting what happens in the future, the LN def turn up the action later.
|
|
|
On May 07 2014 06:59 Souma wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2014 06:54 maru~ wrote:On May 07 2014 06:35 Emnjay808 wrote:
I'm pretty excited that the list is finally being updated. There's so many SoL and romcoms that people should be more aware of. Space Brothers and Chihayafuru come to mind. Chihayafuru is neither though. On May 07 2014 06:51 Souma wrote:
I'll give it some consideration, but are there even that many good harem shows that it warrants its own category?
Not sure I wanna be recommending people IS. You could put harem shows to romcom, drama or whatever, I don't think it needs its own category. But to be honest, I'm not sure if it's even worth the effort to make a new chart. The /a/ chart is pretty good, you could just replace and add some stuff if you must and be done with it. Uhm, that's how we came up with the chart that's in the modnote. But now it's outdated so I'm gonna update it. We're not making a totally new chart, just updating it.
Fair enough, it's just that you said you wanted to make it look prettier and there was the talk about categories and whatnot. Nevermind.
On May 07 2014 07:01 Slaughter wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2014 06:56 Reaper9 wrote:
Hrmmmm true... Harem is usually a direct competition of multiple individuals, for one main character though?...Yea we have to define what a harem is? =_=? Sheepish grin* Maybe the point of the show is to win the main character's affection?
@Wolf yea...point taken, but people have a different view on what romance is as well XD.... but I suppose maybe a subcategory for romance? Since some people think romance entails between 2 people?... Arrrrkkkk this is hard D : <
Meh maybe I'm thinking too hard, just keep it under romance is fine and all Well what about shows where the harem aspect is kinda secondary? Like Highschool DxD. Its mostly an action show but the dude also has a harem..
If you say it's mostly an action show then it obviously should be in the action category.
|
On May 07 2014 07:07 Slaughter wrote:Show nested quote +On May 07 2014 07:05 Toadesstern wrote:On May 07 2014 07:01 Slaughter wrote:On May 07 2014 06:56 Reaper9 wrote:
Hrmmmm true... Harem is usually a direct competition of multiple individuals, for one main character though?...Yea we have to define what a harem is? =_=? Sheepish grin* Maybe the point of the show is to win the main character's affection?
@Wolf yea...point taken, but people have a different view on what romance is as well XD.... but I suppose maybe a subcategory for romance? Since some people think romance entails between 2 people?... Arrrrkkkk this is hard D : <
Meh maybe I'm thinking too hard, just keep it under romance is fine and all Well what about shows where the harem aspect is kinda secondary? Like Highschool DxD. Its mostly an action show but the dude also has a harem. Edit: Also thats not fair Sent, I don't think BF likes harems anymore then he likes anything else. an action show? If someone asked you what HighSchool DxD is you'd answer "it's kind of an actions show" because you think that's the major point of the show? Pretty sure you'd get veeeeeeery strange looks from people who don't know what it is after they finished it or even just gave it a try. Maybe I am just projecting what happens in the future, the LN def turn up the action later.
idk man, if a friend of mine asked me what Highschool DxD is I'd probably try to not answer and if friend in question would keep on asking, for whatever reason, I'd probably say it's softporn or ecchi depending on how much person in question knows about anime.
|
DxD is definitely harem before action, although it definitely turns up the action a LOT later on.
+ Show Spoiler +I just want to watch the Rias vs Sairaorg battle animated. Would be everything i'd wish for if i were to wish for anything more of DxD being adapted
To me the DxD LN is fun because the author seems to give zero fucks about anything, all praise the chichigami.
|
Mfw I see EE's stream title -_-
|
IDK if DxD gets animated, the parts that Toad mentioned are actually the worst part of it and can be ignored much easier in the LNs. Which is why I love the LNs but never got into the anime.
|
Netherlands45349 Posts
Well its abime recs so ifnit was a rec it would be in the harem or w/r catagory.
Phone stronk
|
The anime sold pretty well, i could see a season three being produced. I primarily watched the anime to see the fights animated, especially the
+ Show Spoiler +First Issei vs Vali fight, was really well done in the anime actually
|
On May 07 2014 07:13 Emnjay808 wrote:
Mfw I see EE's stream title -_-
I have to agree with EE-sama on that one.
|
Canada8036 Posts
Charts again? Blergh.
Starting jojo at part 7 is a terrible idea because half the enjoyment comes from throwbacks. Be a man and read from part 1 (or 3 if you watched the anime). Failing to read the previous parts is a great way to invalidate the best twist of part 7.
I disagree with sent on break blade. The manga story is better than what they did in the movie for two main reasons: Girge and the final battle. I will concede that the anime's depiction of scenes is far superior to the manga though, because half the time I can't tell what's going on in the manga's battles. So both have their merits.
|
If you can't tell whats going on in a mecha battle, then something is wrong. This goes for both anime and manga. And Break Blade's battles in the anime are amoung Mecha anime's best. Speaking of charts, Break Blade probably deserves a spot in there somewhere too, lol
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
