| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.gg For currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On October 08 2013 07:37 Shaella wrote: except for the writing. And the character design. And the overly cartoony mecha design. BACKPACKS Saying things like "omg the writing is bad!" is code speak for "I just hate bandwagon this thing like a sheep, and can't justify my own opinion on it since I haven't seen it, so I'll just say the writing is bad". | ||
|
Maxie
Sweden2653 Posts
By the way, there's nothing wrong with backpacks. | ||
|
Shaella
United States14828 Posts
On October 08 2013 07:40 Sentenal wrote: Saying things like "omg the writing is bad!" is code speak for "I just hate bandwagon this thing like a sheep, and can't justify my own opinion on it since I haven't seen it, so I'll just say the writing is bad". -.- I have watched -every- gundam series. I sat through fucking Destiny and AGE. SEED is shittily written. Its trying way too hard to be 0079 for its first half, and then Kira magically appears in space because reasons and lacus gives him the freedom and aUAFHGUAFHG OH MY GOD THE STORY GETS SO DUMB | ||
|
WolfintheSheep
Canada14127 Posts
So many other Gundams just devolve into some pseudo-philosophical debate, and everyone's motivations seem more like creating examples for a thesis than actual cause. Wing and 00 were some of the worst offenders of that... | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On October 08 2013 07:43 Shaella wrote: -.- I have watched -every- gundam series. I sat through fucking Destiny and AGE. SEED is shittily written. Its trying way too hard to be 0079 for its first half, and then Kira magically appears in space because reasons and lacus gives him the freedom and aUAFHGUAFHG OH MY GOD THE STORY GETS SO DUMB If you have, lets see you justify why you think its "bad writing" Trying way too hard to be 0079? Wtf does that even mean? Kira getting into space is one of the places I'll acknowledge was poorly written. Beyond that, it just sounds like you whining. How is Lacus giving him Freedom "bad writing"? If you are going to complain about all this, I'd expect you to hate Zeta Gundam, with its atrocious script, or hate Char's Counter Attack. | ||
|
Ushio
Canada868 Posts
| ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On October 08 2013 07:53 Ushio wrote: How could you hate Zeta or CCA thats blasphemy! I don't. I like them both. I'm just not blind to their flaws. You can't look at a character like Reccoa, CCA Char, or Quess, and tell me they are well written characters. | ||
|
Shaella
United States14828 Posts
>NOT UNDERSTANDING CCA CHAR I'm out. | ||
|
Seiuchi
United States931 Posts
On October 08 2013 07:55 Sentenal wrote: I don't. I like them both. I'm just not blind to their flaws. You can't look at a character like Reccoa, CCA Char, or Quess, and tell me they are well written characters. All of them are well written characters. They're incredibly flawed and unlikeable, but that's how they're intended to be. | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On October 08 2013 07:55 Shaella wrote: ... >Not getting the point of Reccoa and Quess I'm out. Are you seriously going to start defending Reccoa and Quess of all characters? hahaha, okay, thanks for the laugh. On October 08 2013 07:56 Seiuchi wrote: All of them are well written characters. They're incredibly flawed and unlikeable, but that's how they're intended to be. They are also completely retarded, who have little to no reason to do the things they did. | ||
|
Shaella
United States14828 Posts
On October 08 2013 07:56 Sentenal wrote: Are you seriously going to start defending Reccoa and Quess of all characters? hahaha, okay, thanks for the laugh. Um. Yes. They serve exactly the purpose they're intended to. Are you gonna start telling me that Tomino is a Misogynist next? | ||
Kipsate
Netherlands45349 Posts
| ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
On October 08 2013 07:58 Kipsate wrote: what a fun day. Gundam otaku fightooo ! | ||
|
Emnjay808
United States10665 Posts
| ||
|
synapse
China13814 Posts
| ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On October 08 2013 07:58 Shaella wrote: Um. Yes. They serve exactly the purpose they're intended to. Are you gonna start telling me that Tomino is a Misogynist next? What 'purpose' were they supposed to serve? Please, I want to see Reccoa and Quess defended as characters. And no, why would I do that? Having two abysmal female characters in his anime doesn't make him a misogynist. I didn't see this edit: On October 08 2013 07:55 Shaella wrote: ... >Not getting the point of Reccoa and Quess >NOT UNDERSTANDING CCA CHAR I'm out. Defending CCA Char. Confirmed for trolling. | ||
|
Seiuchi
United States931 Posts
On October 08 2013 07:56 Sentenal wrote: Are you seriously going to start defending Reccoa and Quess of all characters? hahaha, okay, thanks for the laugh. They are also completely retarded, who have little to no reason to do the things they did. Quess is a spoiled child who listened to some hippie bitch on Earth and started adoring Newtypes and contolism. Because her father ignored her, she tried to latch onto Amuro and Char as replacement father figures, Amuro realizing he couldn't fill that role and didn't want to, and Char realizing he could use her as a tool since she had Newtype powers and he needed more pilots. Reccoa the entire show points out she doesn't really have any strong ideals or attachments, she's just an adrenaline junkie and AEUG lets her accomplish that. She falls in love with Char, but he rejects her, so she gets caught up in Scirocco's newtype swag because he actually lets her know she's wanted and useful. | ||
|
Seiuchi
United States931 Posts
On October 08 2013 08:01 Sentenal wrote: What 'purpose' were they supposed to serve? Please, I want to see Reccoa and Quess defended as characters. And no, why would I do that? Having two abysmal female characters in his anime doesn't make him a misogynist. I didn't see this edit: Defending CCA Char. Confirmed for trolling. CCA Char makes total sense if you realize what a selfish and petty person is during MSG and Zeta. Kamille got mindfucked and the AEUG got crippled, so Char decides he has to do it himself because the hope he was starting to foster in the younger generation in Zeta went nowhere. | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On October 08 2013 08:03 Seiuchi wrote: Quess is a spoiled child who listened to some hippie bitch on Earth and started adoring Newtypes and contolism. Because her father ignored her, she tried to latch onto Amuro and Char as replacement father figures, Amuro realizing he couldn't fill that role and didn't want to, and Char realizing he could use her as a tool since she had Newtype powers and he needed more pilots. Reccoa the entire show points out she doesn't really have any strong ideals or attachments, she's just an adrenaline junkie and AEUG lets her accomplish that. She falls in love with Char, but he rejects her, so she gets caught up in Scirocco's newtype swag because he actually lets her know she's wanted and useful. Yes, I know the 'justification' for the characters. That doesn't make their protrayal believable or well-written, though. Quess and Hathaway in CCA practically gave me brain damage with how dumb they were. And your analysis of Reccoa completely ignores all her "men and women" quotes, which is the main, primary reason for her character being trash. On October 08 2013 08:06 Seiuchi wrote: CCA Char makes total sense if you realize what a selfish and petty person is during MSG and Zeta. Kamille got mindfucked and the AEUG got crippled, so Char decides he has to do it himself because the hope he was starting to foster in the younger generation in Zeta went nowhere. Two things. First, his last portrayal in Zeta and then jumping straight into him dropping Asteroids on Earth with no explanation at all is terrible writing. Then, when Char gives his reasoning for doing what he is doing (aka when hes not giving a propaganda speach and hes really speaking his mind), he starts talking about his grudge against Amuro OVER LALAH. This is the same Char, who in Zeta, told Amuro to get over her! And now hes back in CCA, as if Zeta never happened, angry over Lalah, who engineered the entire war to get revenge against him. He wasn't mad about Kamille getting mindfucked (how was that the Federation's fault, anyway?) or the AEUG getting crippled. He never expected the AEUG to start driving people off the Earth by using Genocide to force people off. He was mad about Lalah. That was his given reason. It is terrible, irredeemable writing. | ||
|
Seiuchi
United States931 Posts
On October 08 2013 08:16 Sentenal wrote: Yes, I know the 'justification' for the characters. That doesn't make their protrayal believable or well-written, though. Quess and Hathaway in CCA practically gave me brain damage with how dumb they were. And your analysis of Reccoa completely ignores all her "men and women" quotes, which is the main, primary reason for her character being trash. Two things. First, his last portrayal in Zeta and then jumping straight into him dropping Asteroids on Earth with no explanation at all is terrible writing. Then, when Char gives his reasoning for doing what he is doing (aka when hes not giving a propaganda speach and hes really speaking his mind), he starts talking about his grudge against Amuro OVER LALAH. This is the same Char, who in Zeta, told Amuro to get over her! And now hes back in CCA, as if Zeta never happened, angry over Lalah, who engineered the entire war to get revenge against him. He wasn't mad about Kamille getting mindfucked (how was that the Federation's fault, anyway?) or the AEUG getting crippled. He never expected the AEUG to start driving people off the Earth by using Genocide to force people off. He was mad about Lalah. That was his given reason. It is terrible, irredeemable writing. Quess and Hathaway are teenagers. Do you expect for them to act intelligent? I don't think anyone but a teenager would argue teenagers usually make terrible and impulsive decisions. Reccoa's men and women quotes are supposed to be bullshit. She might believe it, but the whole point is she's making stupid excuses she believes in to justify her actions. Are you once again saying no one in real life does this? People complain about Tomino's characters like this because they're realistic and they don't like these people in real life so they don't want them in their animu, but let's not pretend this isn't realistic. That speech Char makes in Zeta is before Kamille is mindfucked and before ZZ shows the Federation is corrupt as ever and is willing to let Haman drop colonies just to cull population. He speaks in Zeta about how people need to leave the Earth and let it heal, but what happens at the end of Zeta and ZZ is what drives him to think that he needs to do it forcibly. Obviously this could've been written in better, but looking at how Char develops in Zeta it's pretty reasonable. The one thing I'll agree with you is that CCA is too heavy on MAH LALAH, but I think you're reducing it too far into just her, and at the same time the movie establishes that she spends her time regularly fucking with both Char and Amuro so with years of that I can see why they'd both get bitchy about it. That being said, saying CCA pretends Zeta never happened ignores how petty Char is still in Zeta and the repercussions of everyone in that show forcing him back into a leadership role he didn't want. | ||
| ||
|
|
GSL
Rogue vs Percival
Zoun vs Solar
Replay Cast
GSL
Cure vs TriGGeR
ByuN vs Bunny
KCM Race Survival
Big Gabe
Replay Cast
Replay Cast
Escore
OSC
Replay Cast
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
