EPTBut I do agree that Stein gate does not fit well on the list though.
Anime Discussion Thread - Page 1408
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.gg For currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net | ||
|
SheaR619
United States2399 Posts
But I do agree that Stein gate does not fit well on the list though. | ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
On September 13 2011 13:51 NationInArms wrote: Well, they're recs and not gateway anime. Some of the anime listed aren't even close to gateway anime. Well I didnt say they werent gateway's any anime can be a gateway I just didnt say they were good ones. People can easily get turned of this kind of thing with a show like Madoka it isnt everyone's cup of tea even if they're looking for magical girl. edit; I just glanced at it before because Id seen most of the shit I was interested in already but yea considering some of the stuff thats up there you could probably throw up both. | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
| ||
blahz0r
3030 Posts
On September 13 2011 15:54 Rebs wrote: Well I didnt say they werent gateway's any anime can be a gateway I just didnt say they were good ones. People can easily get turned of this kind of thing with a show like Madoka it isnt everyone's cup of tea even if they're looking for magical girl. edit; I just glanced at it before because Id seen most of the shit I was interested in already but yea considering some of the stuff thats up there you could probably throw up both. It's pretty simple, it's just a list of stuff to watch before you ask for more stuff to watch. It's not meant to be an introduction into anime or some genre. As for both Madoka and S;G, they'd probably deserve a spot on there. On September 13 2011 16:08 Sentenal wrote: Hey, there's a new list in progress Why do we need a recommendation chart with anime on it other than School Days. Thats all we recommend, anyway.  | ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/nzDm8.jpg) On September 13 2011 16:33 blahz0r wrote: It's pretty simple, it's just a list of stuff to watch before you ask for more stuff to watch. It's not meant to be an introduction into anime or some genre. As for both Madoka and S;G, they'd probably deserve a spot on there. yea duh.. thats what it says next to the link. It was just for conversations sake. | ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
| ||
|
Shauni
4077 Posts
On September 13 2011 16:33 blahz0r wrote: It's pretty simple, it's just a list of stuff to watch before you ask for more stuff to watch. It's not meant to be an introduction into anime or some genre. As for both Madoka and S;G, they'd probably deserve a spot on there. Hey, there's a new list in progress They do not deserve a spot on a recommendation chart. That one however, is already filled with so much trash it wouldn't even be noticeable to clutter it up with two more bad anime. I tried fixing the chart long ago but was met with so much resistance that I gave up. I guess it resembles the kind of taste people have in here since it was impossible to even remove K-On from the recommendation chart. | ||
|
BnK
United States538 Posts
well even if anime rating is subjective matter but hmmmm.... really? | ||
|
PikaXchU
Singapore379 Posts
| ||
|
Skilledblob
Germany3392 Posts
On September 13 2011 21:04 BnK wrote: ok my friend just told me Angel Beats! is the best anime he has ever watched. well even if anime rating is subjective matter but hmmmm.... really? where is the problem? he said it is the best anime HE ever watched. Doesnt mean it is the best anime around ever.... | ||
|
Latham
9578 Posts
| ||
|
BnK
United States538 Posts
and no. I didn't say that I hate his opinion, but I completely disagree with him. | ||
|
Ferrose
United States11378 Posts
On September 13 2011 12:43 Spazer wrote: I watch it for humor. And indeed, I get something that resembles humor, but unfortunately, isn't really all that funny. Also, this show thrives on character interaction, yet they refuse to play up some of the better relationships. Take a look at the Christmas episode, for instance. It had a perfect setup for some Ayano and Kyouko action, and instead, we got Ayano and Yui sitting on a bench, doing nothing. Real hilarious. -_- And the latest ep gave us really bad drama. Keep that shit out of my comedy shows, please. Huh, well I certainly find it funny. I guess it helps that I'm not so stubborn about the character relationships. Besides the Kyouko and Chitose stuff in that ep was good imo  Though I do agree that the dramatic moment was way out of place. On September 13 2011 21:04 BnK wrote: ok my friend just told me Angel Beats! is the best anime he has ever watched. well even if anime rating is subjective matter but hmmmm.... really? Angel Beats! is objectively bad, don't watch it. | ||
|
Southlight
United States11768 Posts
| ||
|
Xswordy
United Kingdom425 Posts
On September 13 2011 21:34 BnK wrote: but he even watched Clannad, FMA Bakemonogatari and Madoka before Angel Beats!. and no. I didn't say that I hate his opinion, but I completely disagree with him. There are many high quality animes out there that some people can't put one above the other, therefore the lastest one they watch, if they think it's really good, becomes the best one they ever watched. | ||
|
Southlight
United States11768 Posts
12:54 *** Zergneedsfood joined #tladt 12:54 *** Wala joined #tladt 13:00 *** Wala quit (*.net *.split) 13:00 *** Zergneedsfood quit (*.net *.split) 13:04 *** Wala joined #tladt 13:04 *** Zergneedsfood joined #tladt 13:19 *** Zergneedsfood quit (*.net *.split) 13:19 *** Wala quit (*.net *.split) 13:24 *** Wala joined #tladt 13:24 *** Zergneedsfood joined #tladt 13:29 *** Zergneedsfood quit (*.net *.split) 13:29 *** Wala quit (*.net *.split) 13:31 *** Zergneedsfood joined #tladt 13:31 *** Wala joined #tladt 13:35 *** Wala quit (*.net *.split) 13:35 *** Zergneedsfood quit (*.net *.split) Always together. Edit: The saga continues. Edit2: They're joined O_O 13:39 *** Wala joined #tladt 13:39 *** fusionsdf joined #tladt 13:39 *** Zergneedsfood joined #tladt 13:43 *** Zergneedsfood quit (*.net *.split) 13:43 *** fusionsdf quit (*.net *.split) 13:43 *** Wala quit (*.net *.split) The drama! Edit 3: It grows, like a katamari damacy! 13:47 *** Ferrose joined #tladt 13:47 *** fusionsdf joined #tladt 13:47 *** Zergneedsfood joined #tladt 13:47 *** Wala joined #tladt 13:50 *** Wala quit (*.net *.split) 13:50 *** Zergneedsfood quit (*.net *.split) 13:50 *** fusionsdf quit (*.net *.split) 13:50 *** Ferrose quit (*.net *.split) Will they kidnap another one to join their brigade? Edit 4: Oh no, fusion!!! 13:54 *** Ferrose joined #tladt 13:54 *** Wala joined #tladt 13:54 *** spazer joined #tladt Edit 5: Oh wait, that was spazer, znf got left behind! 13:57 *** Zergneedsfood joined #tladt Edit 6: Betrayed by spazer, but joined by XCE, they embark on a new quest 14:08 *** Zergneedsfood quit (*.net *.split) 14:08 *** XCE quit (*.net *.split) 14:08 *** Wala quit (*.net *.split) 14:08 *** Ferrose[afk] quit (*.net *.split) Edit 7: But only two have returned 14:32 *** Wala joined #tladt 14:32 *** Zergneedsfood joined #tladt 14:33 Wala we're back 14:33 Seki only two 14:33 Seki RIP the other two 14:33 Seki T_T | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On September 13 2011 20:58 Shauni wrote: They do not deserve a spot on a recommendation chart. That one however, is already filled with so much trash it wouldn't even be noticeable to clutter it up with two more bad anime. I tried fixing the chart long ago but was met with so much resistance that I gave up. I guess it resembles the kind of taste people have in here since it was impossible to even remove K-On from the recommendation chart. By "fixing" he means removing a bunch of popular anime that he personally hates, to replace with crap that only Shuani has ever heard of. Because, of course, Shauni is so open-minded about anime, that his opinion and personal taste is objective. | ||
|
Zergneedsfood
United States10671 Posts
On September 14 2011 02:26 Sentenal wrote: By "fixing" he means removing a bunch of popular anime that he personally hates, to replace with crap that only Shuani has ever heard of. Because, of course, Shauni is so open-minded about anime, that his opinion and personal taste is objective. inb4 shitstorm | ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
On September 13 2011 20:58 Shauni wrote: . I guess it resembles the kind of taste people have in here since it was impossible to even remove K-On from the recommendation chart. Why is that a problem that needs fixing though ? If someone is coming here looking for recc's then people will tell them what they like. There is no such thing as an objective opinion. People are free to consider theirs otherwise ofcourse. | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On September 14 2011 02:32 Rebs wrote: Why is that a problem that needs fixing though ? If someone is coming here looking for recc's then people will tell them what they like. There is no such thing as an objective opinion. People are free to consider theirs otherwise ofcourse. No you don't understand, Shauni has objective taste in anime. No one else does. | ||
| ||
