|
This is a thread that is dedicated to discussing One Piece. Do not read this thread if you are not currently caught up as there are spoilers in here.
If an episode or a chapter has already been officially released, then it is not necessary to post using spoilers.
If you have knowledge on a chapter that has not been officially released yet, do NOT post it in this thread. Ignoring this public note will result in a mod action. |
On April 06 2013 01:02 Mataza wrote:
I think Blackbeard is a valid owner of the mera mera fruit, from multiple viewpoints. He is the villain and the fruit is a treasure for luffy. For his own motivation it also makes sense, since he aims to get multiple strong fruits.
Burgess defeating Luffy is at least possible and would show us that the straw hats are not yet the strongest people in the world.
Bronze Kyros being picked up by Gol D. Roger is a nice find, didn't even think that far. It does sound likely.
Luffy getting beaten by one of blackbeards flunkies (and not even his strongest one) would be dumb Luffy should be stronger then one of blackbeards underlings
|
Luffy getting beaten would make Blackbeard a credible threat. So far nothing has been shown to really challenge the straw hats after timeskip.
|
On April 06 2013 01:29 Forikorder wrote:Show nested quote +On April 06 2013 01:02 Mataza wrote:
I think Blackbeard is a valid owner of the mera mera fruit, from multiple viewpoints. He is the villain and the fruit is a treasure for luffy. For his own motivation it also makes sense, since he aims to get multiple strong fruits.
Burgess defeating Luffy is at least possible and would show us that the straw hats are not yet the strongest people in the world.
Bronze Kyros being picked up by Gol D. Roger is a nice find, didn't even think that far. It does sound likely. Luffy getting beaten by one of blackbeards flunkies (and not even his strongest one) would be dumb Luffy should be stronger then one of blackbeards underlings
Burgess is the first division captain of a yonkou. Calling him a flunkie/underling is underestimating his power.
Burgess vs luffy would be a long hard victory for luffy, if he does win.
|
On April 06 2013 02:00 Mataza wrote:
Luffy getting beaten would make Blackbeard a credible threat. So far nothing has been shown to really challenge the straw hats after timeskip.
nothing was really shown to really challenge the straw hats pre-time skip until Aokiji showed up
if Luffy loses to some underling of blackbeard it invalidates the 2 year time skip since that means hes still weak as fuck and cant do jack shit
|
On April 06 2013 02:10 Forikorder wrote:Show nested quote +On April 06 2013 02:00 Mataza wrote:
Luffy getting beaten would make Blackbeard a credible threat. So far nothing has been shown to really challenge the straw hats after timeskip. nothing was really shown to really challenge the straw hats pre-time skip until Aokiji showed up if Luffy loses to some underling of blackbeard it invalidates the 2 year time skip since that means hes still weak as fuck and cant do jack shit
Doesn't invalidate, just show he's not up there yet.
|
Well considering BB will be the final boss (most likely), then luffy losing to his first division commander is expected given that straw hats shouldn't be at that level yet with the amount of time One Piece has left.
|
Blackbeard vs Luffy needs to build up more tension. That's why I don't think that Burgess will be completely defeated. Not even Moria-like.
If It wasn't Oda I'd say that someone steps in when Burgess has the upper hand. There are lots of players on Dressrosa.
|
On April 06 2013 04:23 shirtman wrote:
If It wasn't Oda I'd say that someone steps in when Burgess has the upper hand. There are lots of players on Dressrosa.
It's very possible, Oda uses this storytelling technique as well. Build up tension between two powerful parties beyond point of no return until an unseen 3rd party saves the day. Ex: Shanks after Marineford, Kuzan after Punk Hazard, Dragon after Loguetown.
Personally I am not too fan of this, it always feels like a letdown.
Actually I am very intrigued because I don't think Oda will do this right after Punk Hazard. Moreover, there is no way that Burgess will get defeated at this point of the story and since Oda put so much emphasis on how BB crew is looking for powerful fruits, he will not back down for a silly reason.
I see only two outcomes: Burgess get the fruit so we can all hate BB even more, or someone like Cavendish manage to steal / eat the fruit and then we have one more significant player to consider in the story.
|
Burgess will definitely not get defeated, and I don't see Luffy losing a big battle so soon after the timeskip either so yeah probably someone will intervene and prevent the fight, like maybe fujitora ( if it's him or if he/she comes later) steps in and burgess runs.
|
just wondering - how would you guys rate Skypiea?
|
On April 06 2013 06:53 hooahah wrote:
just wondering - how would you guys rate Skypiea?
I didn't like it too much, kind of drawn out. Compared to the other arcs ofc.
|
On April 06 2013 07:02 grush57 wrote:Show nested quote +On April 06 2013 06:53 hooahah wrote:
just wondering - how would you guys rate Skypiea? I didn't like it too much, kind of drawn out. Compared to the other arcs ofc.
The final battle was really drawn out, but I actually loved the concept... an elemental-class logia user, who possibly could be almost as strong as the admirals (unlikely but hey), but found a single natural enemy in an under-leveled Luffy. Also the idea that the sky folks didn't understand Rubber was really, really clever, which made for an epic Enel-face upon realization.
Honestly loved the arc, especially because it was such a clever idea with the Columbus concept, and with the light concepts of God. Left a lot of memorable moments too (flying upstream, octopus balloon, enormous snake, clouds). Also really introduced the power of elemental-class fruits.
|
On April 06 2013 06:53 hooahah wrote:
just wondering - how would you guys rate Skypiea?
10/10 would read and watch it again. My favorite arc in one piece.
|
FREEAGLELAND26782 Posts
Regarding Skypiea, one aspect of the arc many times overlooked is that the journey, drawn out though it may be, allows time for Robin to become part of the crew. Considering she joins pretty much right beforehand and then leaves for a while after Water 7, the time spent in Skypiea is incredibly meaningful for her. Without that arc, there would not have been such a level of tension (or as justifiable of a reason) for the rest of the Strawhat gang to foray into Enies Lobby.
|
On April 06 2013 08:07 LightRain wrote:Show nested quote +On April 06 2013 07:02 grush57 wrote:On April 06 2013 06:53 hooahah wrote:
just wondering - how would you guys rate Skypiea? I didn't like it too much, kind of drawn out. Compared to the other arcs ofc. The final battle was really drawn out, but I actually loved the concept... an elemental-class logia user, who possibly could be almost as strong as the admirals (unlikely but hey), but found a single natural enemy in an under-leveled Luffy. Also the idea that the sky folks didn't understand Rubber was really, really clever, which made for an epic Enel-face upon realization. Honestly loved the arc, especially because it was such a clever idea with the Columbus concept, and with the light concepts of God. Left a lot of memorable moments too (flying upstream, octopus balloon, enormous snake, clouds). Also really introduced the power of elemental-class fruits.
Yea I still liked it but it was the end of my like 200 ep marathon so I was pretty tired and it being drawn out made me kinda mad. It did progress a lot of things though.
|
skypiea was honestly my least favourite one piece arc
it was still better then lke 99% of arcs in 99% of mangas though 
|
On April 06 2013 12:42 Forikorder wrote:skypiea was honestly my least favourite one piece arc it was still better then lke 99% of arcs in 99% of mangas though
You must not read alot of manga then.
|
On April 06 2013 13:28 Tabbris wrote:Show nested quote +On April 06 2013 12:42 Forikorder wrote:skypiea was honestly my least favourite one piece arc it was still better then lke 99% of arcs in 99% of mangas though You must not read alot of manga then.
Or maybe that is just his opinion.
|
On April 06 2013 06:53 hooahah wrote:
just wondering - how would you guys rate Skypiea?
Epic villain, great backstory - Montblanc Norland and Calgara story is the best "flashback" story in One Piece imo. Plenty of cool stuff introduced (dials, Nami's waver). Some of the funniest moments in One Piece (just watch some youtube clips...). Very interesting characters like Gan Forr, Wiper, and that crazy giant snake.
I agree it was longer than it needed to be. Still one of the best arcs in One Piece.
|
On April 06 2013 06:53 hooahah wrote:
just wondering - how would you guys rate Skypiea?
Didn't liked it when I first watched, but now it's one of my favorites.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
