|
SPOILER WARNING If you only watch the show, this thread will spoil you of future events in HBO's Game of Thrones. Thread contains discussion of all books of the series A Song of Ice and FireClick Here for the spoiler-free thread. |
On May 15 2014 06:12 Wolfstan wrote: What is the fake Arya arc? I just read the wiki and is it where she pretends to be someone else?
No. It's the arc that involves passing off Jeyne Pool as Arya Stark and marrying her off to Ramsay to secure Winterfell. The show is nowhere near that, and there has been no mention of it.
|
On May 15 2014 06:12 Wolfstan wrote: What is the fake Arya arc? I just read the wiki and is it where she pretends to be someone else? No, the Lannisters/Boltons use Jayne Poole and claim she's Arya, who they found. They then marry her to Ramsay, hoping that it legitimizes the Bolton's hold on the North. Theon knows she's not Arya.
|
On May 15 2014 06:12 Wolfstan wrote: What is the fake Arya arc? I just read the wiki and is it where she pretends to be someone else?
They're talking about the "Arya" Ramsay wed.
|
At the end of season three didnt bolton's men leave with a fake arya. I am not sure but I think it was noted. I could be mistaken with the book though
|
Germany25657 Posts
Pretty sure that didn't happen.
|
There hasn't been a Jeyne Poole on the show, there were some girls in season 1 who could have been Jeyne in Winterfell at the feast when Robert visited, but she was never named. The fake Arya storyline is summarized on Jeyne's wiki entry
|
On May 15 2014 07:43 karazax wrote:There hasn't been a Jeyne Poole on the show, there were some girls in season 1 who could have been Jeyne in Winterfell at the feast when Robert visited, but she was never named. The fake Arya storyline is summarized on Jeyne's wiki entry
Thanks never really read up on characters that weren't introduced in to show/dont really care about. Any other wiki entries that you would recommend that aren't introduced in the show yet?
|
On May 15 2014 07:58 Wolfstan wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2014 07:43 karazax wrote:There hasn't been a Jeyne Poole on the show, there were some girls in season 1 who could have been Jeyne in Winterfell at the feast when Robert visited, but she was never named. The fake Arya storyline is summarized on Jeyne's wiki entry Thanks never really read up on characters that weren't introduced in to show/dont really care about. Any other wiki entries that you would recommend that aren't introduced in the show yet? Have you read the books? Jeyne Poole isn't a main character, but she comes up pretty often.
|
I haven't read the books, no, just the first half of Dance with Dragons.
|
why are you in this thread then >_>
|
If you haven't read the books? I mean if you just want a cliff notes of what has happened with more details than the show, read the chapter summaries for every chapter on Tower of the Hand and then look up more info on anyone who interests you. There are lots of characters who were cut from the show or changed significantly, and most of the story lines have at least some change.
Some that have been cut include Belwas, Coldhands, Shagwell, Vargo Hoat, Brown Ben Plumm, but really you can just go down the character list and see which ones sound interesting. All of them potentially include spoilers for future seasons of course.
Reading the books is worth it though, even if you think you know what is going to happen. Even having read them before, re-reading pulls in new details I missed the first time and if you aren't a big reader, get the audio books, which are really well done. Compared to the show there are tons of more details to soak in.
|
On May 14 2014 20:11 TigerKarl wrote: The Asha scene is the most ridiculous and poorly written thing they've done on the show. Too bad the director had to work with that poor writing, because otherwise he's done a stellar job.
It was bad, but I disagree. The shit where they do typical cheezy fantasy stuff is the worst. Jon being in false danger has been the recurring one, but the prize has to go to the absurdity when they made it to the top of the wall in "the climb". Princess Bride was more reserved about their use of schmaltz and that movie was tongue in cheek.
I like to think they've been reasonably slapped for their worst offenses:
![[image loading]](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/timeline/dddb59ca3829ca285757e0c86384646e.png)
...but I know people blame mother's day for the sharp dips after some of the most painfully weak episodes. To that I ask why mothers day was called off in 2011 and 2012.
|
On May 15 2014 08:17 karazax wrote:If you haven't read the books? I mean if you just want a cliff notes of what has happened with more details than the show, read the chapter summaries for every chapter on Tower of the Hand and then look up more info on anyone who interests you. There are lots of characters who were cut from the show or changed significantly, and most of the story lines have at least some change. Some that have been cut include Belwas, Coldhands, Shagwell, Vargo Hoat, Brown Ben Plumm, but really you can just go down the character list and see which ones sound interesting. All of them potentially include spoilers for future seasons of course. Reading the books is worth it though, even if you think you know what is going to happen. Even having read them before, re-reading pulls in new details I missed the first time and if you aren't a big reader, get the audio books, which are really well done. Compared to the show there are tons of more details to soak in.
Thanks again, I found the book I started quite boring, and I find it ridiculous how people have righteous indignation about spoilers and state that they are terrified of being spoiled. I just prefer the TV show/cliff notes as a medium than the books.
|
On May 15 2014 08:38 Irrelevant Label wrote:Show nested quote +On May 14 2014 20:11 TigerKarl wrote: The Asha scene is the most ridiculous and poorly written thing they've done on the show. Too bad the director had to work with that poor writing, because otherwise he's done a stellar job. It was bad, but I disagree. The shit where they do typical cheezy fantasy stuff is the worst. Jon being in false danger has been the recurring one, but the prize has to go to the absurdity when they made it to the top of the wall in "the climb". Princess Bride was more reserved about their use of schmaltz and that movie was tongue in cheek. I like to think they've been reasonably slapped for their worst offenses: ![[image loading]](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/timeline/dddb59ca3829ca285757e0c86384646e.png) ...but I know people blame mother's day for the sharp dips after some of the most painfully weak episodes. To that I ask why mothers day was called off in 2011 and 2012. I'm really not sure if you're serious about people not watching this episode because of some bad scenes, or of mother's day not being the one blatantly obvious reason for the rating dip..
|
On May 15 2014 07:43 karazax wrote:There hasn't been a Jeyne Poole on the show, there were some girls in season 1 who could have been Jeyne in Winterfell at the feast when Robert visited, but she was never named. The fake Arya storyline is summarized on Jeyne's wiki entry She most definitely existed in season 1. Though, maybe as you noted, not identified by name.
|
TV thread.
On May 16 2014 06:40 suxN wrote:Show nested quote +On May 15 2014 21:43 TLHP wrote: Everyone like Oberyn, but till now he shows us nothing except being bisexual :D Why? Hasn't he shown us a lot of things: he is smart, handsome and deadly with finesse weapons. Most of all his dialogues are nothing short of excellent, and the lifestyle he leads seems to be very entertaining (travels around the world, beats up assholes, fucks like a bunny and collects wisdom). He is climbing to become my favorite character, kinda like Tyrion and Jaime would be combined.
D'awww I can't wait for episode 8.
|
i wonder if that would show up under his quoted posts. but lol thats like ned being your favorite character.
|
TAIWAN NUMBAH WAN5956 Posts
On May 16 2014 06:55 dudeman001 wrote:TV thread. Show nested quote +On May 16 2014 06:40 suxN wrote:On May 15 2014 21:43 TLHP wrote: Everyone like Oberyn, but till now he shows us nothing except being bisexual :D Why? Hasn't he shown us a lot of things: he is smart, handsome and deadly with finesse weapons. Most of all his dialogues are nothing short of excellent, and the lifestyle he leads seems to be very entertaining (travels around the world, beats up assholes, fucks like a bunny and collects wisdom). He is climbing to become my favorite character, kinda like Tyrion and Jaime would be combined. D'awww  I can't wait for episode 8.
that poor guy
|
On May 16 2014 06:55 dudeman001 wrote:TV thread. Show nested quote +On May 16 2014 06:40 suxN wrote:On May 15 2014 21:43 TLHP wrote: Everyone like Oberyn, but till now he shows us nothing except being bisexual :D Why? Hasn't he shown us a lot of things: he is smart, handsome and deadly with finesse weapons. Most of all his dialogues are nothing short of excellent, and the lifestyle he leads seems to be very entertaining (travels around the world, beats up assholes, fucks like a bunny and collects wisdom). He is climbing to become my favorite character, kinda like Tyrion and Jaime would be combined. D'awww  I can't wait for episode 8.
Teh reactions will be amazing.
|
On May 16 2014 08:01 way2mash4u wrote:Show nested quote +On May 16 2014 06:55 dudeman001 wrote:TV thread. On May 16 2014 06:40 suxN wrote:On May 15 2014 21:43 TLHP wrote: Everyone like Oberyn, but till now he shows us nothing except being bisexual :D Why? Hasn't he shown us a lot of things: he is smart, handsome and deadly with finesse weapons. Most of all his dialogues are nothing short of excellent, and the lifestyle he leads seems to be very entertaining (travels around the world, beats up assholes, fucks like a bunny and collects wisdom). He is climbing to become my favorite character, kinda like Tyrion and Jaime would be combined. D'awww  I can't wait for episode 8. Teh reactions will be amazing. What?? Oberyn dies? :O
|
|
|
|
|
|