|
i'll find the idea of european übermensch problematic once it stops being true
e. the reason why LotR was well received was it played to the strengths of the books and didn't try to fix it
like everyone knows the whole main plot of LotR is dumb and there's like two characters that don't fit the whole good vs bad divide
Gollum is like the only character that is actually corrupted by power, and even then he has multiple personalities. Like there is no grey to J.R.R Tolkien. I think it's part of this catholic rewrite of history were Nazis were not just normal people led astray by a populistic catholic cult. But that doesn't fit their worldview since faith is automatically supposed to make people morally above all that. Kind of like every single one of Mel Gibson's movies have this hamfisted theme of Christians being persecuted. it just ends up looking clumsy
so they made the visuals and the world neat just like the books
|
Czech Republic18921 Posts
The fact that people see white superiority in is blowing my mind. Dune of all books, I don't know of a more wide spread piece of media that portrays Islam in such a positive light. That is absolutely ridiculous. That's straight up giving me Black Mirror dystopia vibes.
Plansix wrote Those who drink have no rational reason to be mad at the person who doesn't partake in alcohol. But for some reason we have this primal reaction to hearing "No thanks, I don't drink." Because for some irrational reason, people think that they are being judged for drinking by the person who decided not to drink.
I like this analogy.
Charles Manson dying reminded me of Mindhunter. Manson is probably going to be in season 2.
|
On November 21 2017 07:16 Plansix wrote:Show nested quote +On November 21 2017 07:01 Belisarius wrote: Ah, the old "straight to ad hom while ignoring the subject" tactic, brought to you direct from the USpol thread. But this isn’t a discussion about a specific aspect of the field. This is a discussion questioning if there is any merit of the entire field of literary academia. Its like asking why anyone studies painting anymore. Or why anyone blows glass as an art form.
Wrong!
I am defending my point that bringing academic discussion into a discussion about a book is fruitless, masturbatory, and only tangentially about the book. Doubly so in the context of a website about gaming, not a forum for academia.
I have studied painting to understand painting and to become a better painter. I do not reject academia as useless in all contexts. I veer strongly away from it in situations where it is fruitless, and tend to avoid people that latch on to academia for its own sake. I find that people can be insecure about their own intelligence (which is totally fine) and use academics in a public setting as a mask to cover that insecurity (not totally healthy).
|
2774 Posts
I find it quite interesting and at the end of the day people are free to discuss academia in any setting and related to anything (well, almost). In my opinion that's what forums are for, including this one. Whether or not you feel like it's actually fruitful is up to you, feel free to ignore such commentary if it actually bothers you.
I have no personal qualms with it as long as it's kept within reasonable limits of course.
In short: Don't have to take it too seriously. It's fiiiiiiiiine.
|
Battlerite is pretty fun and i might actually buy the champ pack
|
Yeah, a classmate was talking to me about it earlier. Might also download and see how it plays.
|
Its is a good game. The time between rounds needs to be cut down a bit.
|
28104 Posts
On November 21 2017 09:27 Faruko wrote: Battlerite is pretty fun and i might actually buy the champ pack I haven't bought the pack but I might because it takes way too long to grind enough points to buy more champs.
|
I mean, I'm not terribly fired up about it. I feel like P6 is just misconstruing it as me declaring all academia and academics stupid, which is pretty unfair.
I'm so effing awful at battlerite tho
|
Do you have fun playing the game if you're bad? 
'Cuz I'd be shit.
|
Not really honestly. Its free now though, isn't it?
I was playing with people who had already played more than me and were decent (?) so I was behind the curve and not 100% what was happening, which made it suck more. Just felt like another dota / csgo in terms of effort I'd have to put into it to get or stay decent, so I kinda stopped before I started.
|
Just one part of academia, the analysis of literature. And since that specific displine has literal centuries of study behind it, I felt that labeling it as pointless maybe was an uninformed opinion.
|
I always imagined the people of dune to be of arabic descent and pauls mother has an olive complexion at some point in the book.
|
Same here. I never saw him or his family as Anglo Saxon nobles.
|
i like that Midas Mode went full charity, and this weird mode is pretty fun to watch
also zai trash talk is seriously glorious, what a player.
hopefully it becomes an anual thing and the charity thing stays in
|
Dune is SCIENCE FICTION guys even if our supposed Earth has anything to do with it (I've only read like 3 books so I dunno what Earth's status is or if it even exists in-universe) it takes place thousands of years after the Christian era and those times and peoples are almost completely forgotten.
What does this mean? that you're not supposed to be worrying about what color people are, that's literally one of the biggest characteristics of sci-fi fantasy, the societies depicted are not the same as ours and are not necessarily bound by the same social restrictions (they often are of course, but you cant just assume so)
|
I found the second dune book much more interesting than the first, but I found the third to be flat out unreadable and stopped there.
|
Herbert's writing is generally pretty boring imo, he was just a cool progressive guy who did drugs and was ahead of his time in a few neat ideas
I can't imagine how bad the books he didn't write are
|
Dune is science fiction that straight up takes words from Arabic and doesn't even change their meanings. It has fake space Muslims who live on the fake space middle east that has fake space oil that must flow.
|
also, holy shit that tf2 update is pretty good
|
|
|
|
|
|