Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion - Page 9132
| Forum Index > Dota 2 General |
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
| ||
|
Fleetfeet
Canada2856 Posts
Reading some of the Brian Herbert adaptations, I was super disappointed to have them basically painted as literal goblins without much depth or intrigue. They're basically evil little monsters that conquer shit. That said, I don't really remember what specifically gave me my impression from my first readings. I just have this feeling that the Bene Tleilax were a cool faction, and not outright evil/the enemy. Also, analysing literary/artistic works to better understand them because of the culture they were written in still feels like such a bullshit academic thing to do and entirely misses the enjoyment of the fiction itself, but that's probably largely from years of biblical exegesis through christian schooling and upbringing. | ||
|
cecek
Czech Republic18921 Posts
| ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
On November 21 2017 05:48 Fleetfeet wrote: My first readthrough of Dune (when I was 16ish) left me with the awesome impression that the Bene Tleilax were a race that prioritized being cunning science and business in a way that the "heroes" of the story considered amoral. I also remember the Bene Tleilax following a tenet of something like "Try and trap someone, but always offer them an escape". Reading some of the Brian Herbert adaptations, I was super disappointed to have them basically painted as literal goblins without much depth or intrigue. They're basically evil little monsters that conquer shit. That said, I don't really remember what specifically gave me my impression from my first readings. I just have this feeling that the Bene Tleilax were a cool faction, and not outright evil/the enemy. Also, analysing literary/artistic works to better understand them because of the culture they were written in still feels like such a bullshit academic thing to do and entirely misses the enjoyment of the fiction itself, but that's probably largely from years of biblical exegesis through christian schooling and upbringing. Most literary critique and review of works happens decades after the work is released. And I don’t think it is any more bullshit than people who get super deep into a game called Smash Brothers, so the point where they turn off half the games features to make it “competitive”. | ||
|
Fleetfeet
Canada2856 Posts
It feels tangential at best to a discussion about the book itself. Sure it's helpful for contextually understanding where the writer was coming from, but it strikes me as something you'd do in a classroom that is attempting to dissect a period of history through the lens that the work provides, which has little to do with the book itself. Sure, it has its uses, but academia of that nature strikes me as masturbatory and self-serving more than anything; if your goal was to understand the history behind the works there are more direct avenues to do that. Ironically you'd have to look at my academic history and me as a person to understand the place that my opinions come from. You probably don't have to wait a decade though. Be an academic to learn shit, not to have pointless observations to talk about. | ||
|
Erasme
Bahamas15899 Posts
On November 21 2017 05:54 cecek wrote: What I've heard is that the Brian books stray pretty far from the original vision and most fans treat them as glorified fanfiction. I can't say for myself tho, I'm still not done with the Frank books, so II haven;t even really thought about reading the other stuff yet. somewhat good written fanfiction | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
On November 21 2017 06:21 Fleetfeet wrote: "bullshit academic" not "bullshit" It feels tangential at best to a discussion about the book itself. Sure it's helpful for contextually understanding where the writer was coming from, but it strikes me as something you'd do in a classroom that is attempting to dissect a period of history through the lens that the work provides, which has little to do with the book itself. Sure, it has its uses, but academia of that nature strikes me as masturbatory and self-serving more than anything; if your goal was to understand the history behind the works there are more direct avenues to do that. Ironically you'd have to look at my academic history and me as a person to understand the place that my opinions come from. You probably don't have to wait a decade though. Be an academic to learn shit, not to have pointless observations to talk about. Again, I find it amusing that you call it masturbatory and self-serving when we are on a website for a video game that people play for millions of dollars. In the world of subjective value, who are we to judge other people’s masturbatory and self-serving endeavors? | ||
|
Fleetfeet
Canada2856 Posts
Yes we do it, but these tournaments are run because they have tangible, literal value, not subjective value. Hence, not a point. I call it masturbatory and self-serving because all you get out of it is either something to discuss with fellow academics to further an atmosphere of academia, or a tidbit of information to drop on people to seem smart. Which annoys me. | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
| ||
|
Belisarius
Australia6233 Posts
| ||
|
Fleetfeet
Canada2856 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + THE FIELD! Of what? Academia? Science? DISCUSSION?!? | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
On November 21 2017 07:01 Belisarius wrote: Ah, the old "straight to ad hom while ignoring the subject" tactic, brought to you direct from the USpol thread. But this isn’t a discussion about a specific aspect of the field. This is a discussion questioning if there is any merit of the entire field of literary academia. Its like asking why anyone studies painting anymore. Or why anyone blows glass as an art form. | ||
|
PassiveAce
United States18076 Posts
On November 21 2017 04:46 cecek wrote: Explain the term 'problematic' please. To add to the conversation, I'm currently halfway through God Emperor of Dune and I currently have a huge crush on anything Dune. I don't think I've ever been as hype for a movie as I am for the Villeneuve Dune. If it turns out bad, I'm probably going to retreat into denial and pretend I liked it anyway. Also, I liked Lynch Dune. I think it's coookl, but in a lot of ways it's also pretty dumb. I absolutely hated the sci fi channel mini-series. A part of which is because it was shot here in Czechia and a lot of Czech movie and TV actors played in it, and not just extras, and I could tell they have a czech accent when they spoke english. It shattered my immersion so much I couldn't even finish watching it. problematic in the sjw sense. what snoman said i saw lynchs dune once and liked it too | ||
|
PassiveAce
United States18076 Posts
On November 21 2017 04:58 Sn0_Man wrote: He meant problematic from the perspective that moronic film critics always feel the need to opine on what social commentaries are made by films. "Oh women weren't empowered enough this is teaching sexist values" or "not enough LGBT people this is teaching our kids archaic gender norms". that kind of drivel. I think in this case his concern revolves around "Carefully bred Aristocratic outside individual is needed to bring poor indigenous peoples to relevance" or something, which of course isn't politically correct in this day and age. Of course, you have to be looking for ways to be offended for it to bother you, but these days so many people are. my problem with the 'white savior/noble savage' tropes isnt so much that i think theyr racist but more because i think theyr extremely hack these days. I cant really claim to be offended by dune when i like lovecraft stories which are about stuff like black mongoloid subpeople inbreeding into demons. | ||
|
PhoenixVoid
Canada32761 Posts
Somewhat of an appropriate song for a batshit crazy man. + Show Spoiler + | ||
|
lestye
United States4281 Posts
| ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
| ||
|
PassiveAce
United States18076 Posts
| ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
Those who drink have no rational reason to be mad at the person who doesn't partake in alcohol. But for some reason we have this primal reaction to hearing "No thanks, I don't drink." Because for some irrational reason, people think that they are being judged for drinking by the person who decided not to drink. People just want to enjoy Dune for the reasons they enjoy Dune. And when they read/hear people talking about the white savior trope, they don't want to be judged for not giving a shit about that. Which is totally cool right up until it becomes "all literary discussion is stupid and people who study it are dumb." | ||
|
PassiveAce
United States18076 Posts
On November 21 2017 05:48 Fleetfeet wrote: Also, analysing literary/artistic works to better understand them because of the culture they were written in still feels like such a bullshit academic thing to do and entirely misses the enjoyment of the fiction itself, but that's probably largely from years of biblical exegesis through christian schooling and upbringing. yeah subjecting books/movies/tv to that 'critical cultural lens' or whatever you want to call it is pretty much a purely masturbatory exercise. but masturbating is fun sooooooooooo ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ | ||
| ||