Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion - Page 9131
| Forum Index > Dota 2 General |
|
SKC
Brazil18828 Posts
| ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
Also the films are really into the "Game of Throne" court politics and gloss over the other aspects of the world that are more interesting. https://www.imaginaryworldspodcast.org/the-book-of-dune.html Imaginary Worlds did a good podcast on Dune that sort of breaks down why people love it and why it is sort of a beautiful hot mess that manages to stand the test of time. On November 21 2017 03:23 SKC wrote: Is the Dune movie really that terrible? It's been ages since I saw it but I don't remember it being that bad. Nah, its great bad 70/80s sci-fi. Fun, over the top and barely touching the things that gave the book depth. | ||
|
intotheheart
Canada33091 Posts
| ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
| ||
|
Unleashing
Denmark14978 Posts
1½ month to go and i'm free from this hell | ||
|
Artisreal
Germany9235 Posts
On November 21 2017 03:32 intotheheart wrote: Would you think it'd be bad for someone who was a really big fan of the books, and was expecting an accurate representation of it? idk man. look at the LoTR films. It is an interpretation and it might differ highly from yours. I enjoyed both book and movies. I don't think that you can expect more than a roundabout adherence to the book's storyline. And that's fine imo. I don't want an attempt at a repeat of the book that fails miserably. Just with the mini-series of Mr. Norrel and Jonathan Strange or Sherlock that originate from written stories, they in and of themselves are rather brilliantly realised. | ||
|
intotheheart
Canada33091 Posts
And I was curious if it was the die-hards that got annoyed, or if the film wasn't capable of standing on its own merits. | ||
|
cecek
Czech Republic18921 Posts
On November 21 2017 02:57 PassiveAce wrote: i dunno man. i think that wold just kind of turn it into a story about how cosmopolitanism saved the natives. its still pro-imperialist in nature... i think dune is actually super problematic. like maybe two steps below lovecraft. I dont see any reading of it that doesnt make it look like a book about how a ubermensch european is needed to play savior to the "noble savages". If I were making it I would make every faction equally diverse in the hopes of sidestepping a lot of the race stuff altogether. Explain the term 'problematic' please. To add to the conversation, I'm currently halfway through God Emperor of Dune and I currently have a huge crush on anything Dune. I don't think I've ever been as hype for a movie as I am for the Villeneuve Dune. If it turns out bad, I'm probably going to retreat into denial and pretend I liked it anyway. Also, I liked Lynch Dune. I think it's coookl, but in a lot of ways it's also pretty dumb. I absolutely hated the sci fi channel mini-series. A part of which is because it was shot here in Czechia and a lot of Czech movie and TV actors played in it, and not just extras, and I could tell they have a czech accent when they spoke english. It shattered my immersion so much I couldn't even finish watching it. | ||
|
intotheheart
Canada33091 Posts
| ||
|
cecek
Czech Republic18921 Posts
| ||
|
Sn0_Man
Tebellong44238 Posts
I think in this case his concern revolves around "Carefully bred Aristocratic outside individual is needed to bring poor indigenous peoples to relevance" or something, which of course isn't politically correct in this day and age. Of course, you have to be looking for ways to be offended for it to bother you, but these days so many people are. | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
Lord of the Rings is a great example. It’s a wonderful story, but also has some weird themes about race and poverity. All the orcs in LotR talk like poor British people, with broken English and poor grammar. The evil race of Muslims stand ins all ride from the desert lands south of Mordor to invade fake Europe and destroy the civilized, proper English speaking Free Men of the West. Does it make the entire work racist? Nope. Does it mean we ignore those themes of European(specially Anglo Saxon European, for there are no Irish or Italians in Middle Earth) superiority? Nope | ||
|
intotheheart
Canada33091 Posts
On November 21 2017 04:56 cecek wrote: I think I'm gonna try and avoid reading anything online about it. But I'm also very likely going to give in and go full-on keyboard warrior on it. The 'die-hard' Dune fans are going to be the worst. They're gonna hate the movie for the littlest details and shit. If that's the case, please send us your greatest hits montage if you end up in the denial phase. | ||
|
Sn0_Man
Tebellong44238 Posts
| ||
|
intotheheart
Canada33091 Posts
| ||
|
Erasme
Bahamas15899 Posts
why cant u read something without inserting social commentary why orcs cant be just orcs instead of 'poor british people' does it make elves 'rich british aristocracy' ? | ||
|
Plansix
United States60190 Posts
On November 21 2017 05:13 Erasme wrote: idk man why cant u read something without inserting social commentary why orcs cant be just orcs instead of 'poor british people' does it make elves 'rich british aristocracy' ? You don’t have to. I can turn my brain off for a lot of things. I liked Fury Road and a John Wick without social commentary. And its not the elves are the rich, it is that the author decided to use the language of the poor as the language of an evil race he invented. And given Tolkien’s background, it makes perfect sense and I don’t think he is a bad person for it. But the stories live beyond their creator and say things about the culture at the time. Tolkien was also deeply Christian and that shows in the books as well. Being aware of this stuff doesn’t make the art you enjoy worse. I don’t enjoy LotR or Dune any less because of it. In reality, I likely enjoy them more. | ||
|
cecek
Czech Republic18921 Posts
| ||
|
Artisreal
Germany9235 Posts
It's contextual and has to be individually scrutinized. Yes that's work. And no, I don't think you can have an easy if, then framework. | ||
|
Gosi
Sweden9072 Posts
It's a heavy topic. | ||
| ||