|
SoCal8933 Posts
On July 14 2015 04:04 Sn0_Man wrote: you guys seem to be unaware of the fact that if ur quote train reaches the "TL automatically redacts part of ur quote train" level then ur argument has gone to shit and should be dropped
its been several pages already im actually sorta impressed
|
can you guys stop arguing semantics pls
the original post that p6 quoted said 'some form of socratic instruction', not the socratic method itself. his exact teaching method is irrelevant.
there are objective facts in history but there are also multiple ways of interpreting those facts. the 'projection of meaning' is exactly what history is. otherwise people could just recite how many human beings died at the battle of shiloh or how many metric tons of material was shipped over as part of the marshall plan and call it history.
|
first lesson for every history student: theres no objectivity
|
yah but depending on whose book u read different amounts of people died history is actually hilarious like that
|
On July 14 2015 04:09 Sn0_Man wrote: yah but depending on whose book u read different amounts of people died history is actually hilarious like that I had to do a presentation on the Algerian Independence War and the numbers went to shit very quickly.
|
On July 14 2015 04:08 teddyoojo wrote: first lesson for every history student: theres no objectivity Pretty much. Even your history book is bias, but its all you got. Learn from it, but read other sources.
|
yea because casualty counts arent tabulated by god himself
but yea acritter seems to be arguing the discipline of history is mostly about (or should be mostly about) finding the things closest to the objective truths which isnt at all how the discipline is actually practiced
|
On July 14 2015 04:11 SpiritoftheTunA wrote: yea because casualty counts arent tabulated by god himself
but yea acritter seems to be arguing the discipline of history is mostly about (or should be mostly about) finding the things closest to the objective truths which isnt at all how the discipline is actually practiced Please stop misrepresenting my arguments because you don't understand them, especially when my last post in the thread says the exact opposite.
And please don't go on talking about other people's arguments when a mod tells you to stop.
|
Was that potentially the longest singular discussion this thread has had?
|
I was not in any way acting as a moderator when i flamed everybody who participated in those quote trains i was just flaming
On July 14 2015 04:18 IntoTheheart wrote: Was that potentially the longest singular discussion this thread has had? definitely not
|
ongoing discussion about mangix the league hero i think
|
On July 14 2015 04:18 Sn0_Man wrote:I was not in any way acting as a moderator when i flamed everybody who participated in those quote trains i was just flaming Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 04:18 IntoTheheart wrote: Was that potentially the longest singular discussion this thread has had? definitely not Ah okay. I haven't been here for super long, but that was the first time that I've seen the quote train fall apart and have a reason for it.
|
oh right i forgot the issue was that you think that the socratic method can only be used to teach specific answers
my bad
|
On July 14 2015 04:14 Acritter wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 04:11 SpiritoftheTunA wrote: yea because casualty counts arent tabulated by god himself
but yea acritter seems to be arguing the discipline of history is mostly about (or should be mostly about) finding the things closest to the objective truths which isnt at all how the discipline is actually practiced Please stop misrepresenting my arguments because you don't understand them, especially when my last post in the thread says the exact opposite. And please don't go on talking about other people's arguments when a mod tells you to stop. Your arguments are obtuse because you are attempting to apply rational reasoning and philosophical arguments to a discipline that has largely rejected them.
|
If you guys start making it personal on the other hand... yeah please don't
|
damn i hope babaevslky keeps streaming until i get home i get off early today
|
corsair hero where u gonna b dawg
|
On July 14 2015 04:28 andyrau wrote: damn i hope babaevslky keeps streaming until i get home i get off early today at this rate he might not find a match until ur home so ur gucci
|
Is he still streaming? It must be a ~16-hour long marathon run.
|
Pls halp my 4k mmr sf decided convinced my team its a good idea to trilane vs undying with 2 melee heros and after the lane fed he abandoned. This is why i cant win on Windrunner.
|
|
|
|
|
|