|
On July 14 2015 03:42 Acritter wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:41 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote: [quote] yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic
thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build? Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective. Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there. yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own and he'd be wrong in that disagreement your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them. At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas. i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. can you point out where it was used with that second sense in this discussion aside from your inference of what i meant when i applied the label not-positive to socrates Then I have to ask how it's possibly a bad thing to explain why people are full of shit. it's not bad but it's not particularly good
see twilight of the idols or something
|
On July 14 2015 03:45 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:42 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:41 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote: [quote] When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.
Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build? Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective. Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there. yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own and he'd be wrong in that disagreement your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them. At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas. i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. can you point out where it was used with that second sense in this discussion aside from your inference of what i meant when i applied the label not-positive to socrates Then I have to ask how it's possibly a bad thing to explain why people are full of shit. it's not bad but it's not particularly good see twilight of the idols or something So the peer review of the scientific process isn't "particularly good?"
|
not saying all applications of critical questioning aren't particularly good
oh whatever sure i'll concede the point
anyway re-quoting my main point:
anyway my whole point is if you're going to criticize the idea of teaching history using the socratic method you shouldn't distort the argument by starting out with the assumption that everyone will use your idea of what 'socratic method' should mean. even if you disagree with the popular definition, you should go along with it because that's not the focal point of the argument in the first place
|
On July 14 2015 03:43 Acritter wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:43 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote: [quote] yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic
thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build? Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective. Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there. yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own and he'd be wrong in that disagreement your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them. At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas. i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method". You missed an important post of mine, I think. Your argument started with
On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote: Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"
I think we either have very different ideas of what the Socratic Method is or what history is.
If that is the basis for your argument, then I think you have a poor understanding of history at its core. History is derived from interpretations of documents and writings from the era, all which as subjective in nature because of the author. The discussion of "why do you think the GDP of Italy was BLANK" is a completely valid question and discussion.
History is not objective fact or a science. Its why I have a Bachelors of Arts, not Science.
|
On July 14 2015 03:48 Plansix wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:43 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote: [quote] When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.
Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build? Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective. Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there. yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own and he'd be wrong in that disagreement your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them. At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas. i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method". You missed an important post of mine, I think. Your argument started with Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote: Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"
I think we either have very different ideas of what the Socratic Method is or what history is. If that is the basis for your argument, then I think you have a poor understanding of history at its core. History is derived from interpretations of documents and writings from the era, all which as subjective in nature because of the author. The discussion of "why do you think the GDP of Italy was BLANK" is a completely valid question and discussion. History is not objective fact or a science. Its why I have a Bachelors of Arts, not Science. I believe you missed the post directly after that. It's a big post.
On July 14 2015 03:48 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:not saying all applications of critical questioning aren't particularly good oh whatever sure i'll concede the point anyway re-quoting my main point: Show nested quote +anyway my whole point is if you're going to criticize the idea of teaching history using the socratic method you shouldn't distort the argument by starting out with the assumption that everyone will use your idea of what 'socratic method' should mean. even if you disagree with the popular definition, you should go along with it because that's not the focal point of the argument in the first place The argument started before me with the idea of professors telling students to discuss math problems they couldn't understand with one another and then moved to the professors asking questions directly to the students to bring them towards the answer to the problem (note: not asking them what they think or feel). This is where the discussion of teaching this way started, and where I posited the notion that even though this method is excellent for teaching some people and less effective for others, that the people it doesn't work well for might do better to just learn simple procedure for abstract concepts they can't fully grasp and leave the serious abstractions alone. This is where P6 changed the topic to encouraging critical thinking and educated opining via questions, which I tried to push back against by pointing out the distinction between the two styles. I misunderstood his initial comment on history, because we were talking previously about specific answers in mathematics and because it is nonsensical to teach the specific answers in history via questions (and whatever you want to say about history being subjective, the specific materials we have are indeed objective facts: there are contemporary accounts of Roman life, for example, and although their veracity is often dubious their existence is fact that needs to be taught before subjective views can be taken). So I don't see where I distorted the argument.
|
On July 14 2015 03:48 Plansix wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:43 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote: [quote] When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.
Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build? Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective. Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there. yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own and he'd be wrong in that disagreement your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them. At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas. i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method". You missed an important post of mine, I think. Your argument started with Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote: Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"
I think we either have very different ideas of what the Socratic Method is or what history is. If that is the basis for your argument, then I think you have a poor understanding of history at its core. History is derived from interpretations of documents and writings from the era, all which as subjective in nature because of the author. The discussion of "why do you think the GDP of Italy was BLANK" is a completely valid question and discussion. History is not objective fact or a science. Its why I have a Bachelors of Arts, not Science. i was with you until your last sentence... dats a false dichotomy... the undergrad school i went to literally only offers b.a.,s including in the hard sciences (the one exception was engineering)
also saying something isn't a "science" begs the question of what constitutes a science which in itself is a point of contention blah blah blah semantics stupid arguments ok im done back to watching rtz's techies pearl harbor some hoes
|
On July 14 2015 03:50 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:48 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote: [quote] Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective. Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there. yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own and he'd be wrong in that disagreement your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them. At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas. i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method". You missed an important post of mine, I think. Your argument started with On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote: Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"
I think we either have very different ideas of what the Socratic Method is or what history is. If that is the basis for your argument, then I think you have a poor understanding of history at its core. History is derived from interpretations of documents and writings from the era, all which as subjective in nature because of the author. The discussion of "why do you think the GDP of Italy was BLANK" is a completely valid question and discussion. History is not objective fact or a science. Its why I have a Bachelors of Arts, not Science. i was with you until your last sentence... dats a false dichotomy... the undergrad school i went to literally only offers b.a.,s including in the hard sciences (the one exception was engineering) It depends on the school. My school has a faculty of arts AND sciences, but you either get a BA, or a BSC on your diploma when you graduate.
|
On July 14 2015 03:51 IntoTheheart wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:50 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:48 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote: [quote] Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there. yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own and he'd be wrong in that disagreement your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them. At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas. i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method". You missed an important post of mine, I think. Your argument started with On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote: Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"
I think we either have very different ideas of what the Socratic Method is or what history is. If that is the basis for your argument, then I think you have a poor understanding of history at its core. History is derived from interpretations of documents and writings from the era, all which as subjective in nature because of the author. The discussion of "why do you think the GDP of Italy was BLANK" is a completely valid question and discussion. History is not objective fact or a science. Its why I have a Bachelors of Arts, not Science. i was with you until your last sentence... dats a false dichotomy... the undergrad school i went to literally only offers b.a.,s including in the hard sciences (the one exception was engineering) It depends on the school. My school has a faculty of arts AND sciences, but you either get a BA, or a BSC on your diploma when you graduate. my point had less to do with what schools actually offer and more with the abstract idea there's no clean division between the concept of art and science with respect to academic disciplines
you can have the sense that throwing painting on canvases is more "art" than "science" but blah blah blah spectrum blah blah lbaljfldkadsfjk
|
On July 14 2015 03:52 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:51 IntoTheheart wrote:On July 14 2015 03:50 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:48 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote: [quote] yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own
and he'd be wrong in that disagreement
your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them. At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas. i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method". You missed an important post of mine, I think. Your argument started with On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote: Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"
I think we either have very different ideas of what the Socratic Method is or what history is. If that is the basis for your argument, then I think you have a poor understanding of history at its core. History is derived from interpretations of documents and writings from the era, all which as subjective in nature because of the author. The discussion of "why do you think the GDP of Italy was BLANK" is a completely valid question and discussion. History is not objective fact or a science. Its why I have a Bachelors of Arts, not Science. i was with you until your last sentence... dats a false dichotomy... the undergrad school i went to literally only offers b.a.,s including in the hard sciences (the one exception was engineering) It depends on the school. My school has a faculty of arts AND sciences, but you either get a BA, or a BSC on your diploma when you graduate. my point had less to do with what schools actually offer and more with the abstract idea there's no clean division between the concept of art and science with respect to academic disciplines My mistake - you are correct in saying that.
|
On July 14 2015 03:52 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:51 IntoTheheart wrote:On July 14 2015 03:50 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:48 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote: [quote] yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own
and he'd be wrong in that disagreement
your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them. At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas. i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method". You missed an important post of mine, I think. Your argument started with On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote: Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"
I think we either have very different ideas of what the Socratic Method is or what history is. If that is the basis for your argument, then I think you have a poor understanding of history at its core. History is derived from interpretations of documents and writings from the era, all which as subjective in nature because of the author. The discussion of "why do you think the GDP of Italy was BLANK" is a completely valid question and discussion. History is not objective fact or a science. Its why I have a Bachelors of Arts, not Science. i was with you until your last sentence... dats a false dichotomy... the undergrad school i went to literally only offers b.a.,s including in the hard sciences (the one exception was engineering) It depends on the school. My school has a faculty of arts AND sciences, but you either get a BA, or a BSC on your diploma when you graduate. my point had less to do with what schools actually offer and more with the abstract idea there's no clean division between the concept of art and science with respect to academic disciplines Also the first thing you learn when majoring in history is that there are no objective facts. Only accepted interpenetration. It is one of the root flaws in most arguments involving history.
But yes, stating my degree an Art degree does not add any gravity to my argument.
|
speaking of history i'm going to EU next month :D:D
first timing leaving NA much excite
|
|
|
You should write a liquid blog about it like Passive.
|
Cool, where in Europe?
There's so many places in such a small area lol
|
i just watched rtz's techies on his team rekt the enemy tinker cause he mined in between the trees where tinker blinks on sidelanes
|
On July 14 2015 03:54 Plansix wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:52 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:51 IntoTheheart wrote:On July 14 2015 03:50 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:48 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote: [quote] Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them.
At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas. i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method". You missed an important post of mine, I think. Your argument started with On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote: Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"
I think we either have very different ideas of what the Socratic Method is or what history is. If that is the basis for your argument, then I think you have a poor understanding of history at its core. History is derived from interpretations of documents and writings from the era, all which as subjective in nature because of the author. The discussion of "why do you think the GDP of Italy was BLANK" is a completely valid question and discussion. History is not objective fact or a science. Its why I have a Bachelors of Arts, not Science. i was with you until your last sentence... dats a false dichotomy... the undergrad school i went to literally only offers b.a.,s including in the hard sciences (the one exception was engineering) It depends on the school. My school has a faculty of arts AND sciences, but you either get a BA, or a BSC on your diploma when you graduate. my point had less to do with what schools actually offer and more with the abstract idea there's no clean division between the concept of art and science with respect to academic disciplines Also the first thing you learn when majoring in history is that there are no objective facts. Only accepted interpenetration. It is one of the root flaws in most arguments involving history. But yes, stating my degree an Art degree does not add any gravity to my argument. Which is entirely wrong. There are objective facts in any discipline, but they are by definition meaningless (because meaning is a subjective construction). So you found a rock that seems to have writing on it. Good for you, nobody can contest that the rock exists, but there's no historical relevance until you project meaning onto it (e.g. hey, some people wanted to translate between Egyptian and Greek).
|
On July 14 2015 03:49 Acritter wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:48 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote: [quote] Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective. Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there. yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own and he'd be wrong in that disagreement your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them. At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas. i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method". You missed an important post of mine, I think. Your argument started with On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote: Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"
I think we either have very different ideas of what the Socratic Method is or what history is. If that is the basis for your argument, then I think you have a poor understanding of history at its core. History is derived from interpretations of documents and writings from the era, all which as subjective in nature because of the author. The discussion of "why do you think the GDP of Italy was BLANK" is a completely valid question and discussion. History is not objective fact or a science. Its why I have a Bachelors of Arts, not Science. I believe you missed the post directly after that. It's a big post.
You mean this one:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:12 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:03 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 02:44 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 02:41 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 02:37 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 02:34 andyrau wrote:On July 14 2015 02:03 BluemoonSC wrote: [quote]
then you weren't challenged enough with the level of questioning. the cavalierri's principle debate is one of my favorites because the answer isn't so obvious if i say that i have a rectangular and a triangular prism..or like a weird shaped prism that isnt an n-gon well it happened all the time in uni too; either nobody knew the answer or everyone already had a good answer in their heads I found professors that frequently broke us off into arbitrary group discussions were slow paced and somewhat ambivalent in direction, regardless of subject. ime instructors that engaged in some form of socratic instruction had better structure and were more effective at fostering critical thinking but i guess everyone has their own way of teaching & learning You have hit the nail on the head. I'm with you on Socratic teaching and it being the best way for me to learn. But its worthless for someone like my brother who would rather be hands on or interacting with anything. On July 14 2015 02:34 IntoTheheart wrote:On July 14 2015 02:31 dismiss wrote: Slardar in our game:"sry I afk 10 min"
They want us to wait.
What a guy. What happened next? Did you guys say "fuck that" and play without him? Plan6, I'd rather know that that person's gonna be gone so that I can do other shit in the meantime. Agreed. I can make myself a cup of coffee if I 100% knew the game was going to paused that entire time. If you're a hands-on learner, shouldn't you be studying practical subjects instead of abstract subjects? In a perfect world, yes. But hands on learners need to know about history, math and other abstractions. Even by brother, who pull engines out of military vehicles needs to know how to make spread sheets. Or how property rights and mortgages work. History obviously doesn't work in the Socratic format (rather, it works best when delivered as a narrative) and a lot of day-to-day math can be taught as a ritual pragmatic skill analogous to operating the interface of some machine or other. Your brother probably doesn't need to know how a computer works in order to use it, so why does he need to know how a spreadsheet works if he can perform the ritual operations on it neatly? Similarly, property rights and mortgages are basically just technical dos and don'ts. If you know you have to give someone receipts X, Y, and Z after working on their engine or get in trouble with the state, you can certainly figure out that you need to have deeds X, Y, and Z after purchasing property. It's probably not worth it to try and figure out alternate teaching methods intended for advanced math and other similar fields of study if the people they're directed for are likely uninterested and almost certainly won't benefit from them. I studied history in college and loved the Socratic format. It has always been the best way for me to learn anything. I will listen to a history book over reading it. You're prescribing teaching methods for the advancement of a specific field, which is not the topic at hand. This is about teaching the populous though a variety of methods so they can navigate the modern world. And my brother does need a computer to do his job. He manages the parts inventory for the base and and needs to create spread sheets and interface with other computer software. He is required to be well rounded and have a variety of skills, including leadership and communication since he is also a Master Sergeant. And property ownership is not that simple and its not a just list of does and don't. And anyone teaching people that property rights and mortgages are that should stop right away, since that is a sure fire way to face litigation. Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?" are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts? no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close. This statement in your argument is incorrect. There are no facts in the study of history, accepted interpenetration. We cannot objective observe historical events as we were not there.
On July 14 2015 04:01 Acritter wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:54 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:52 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:51 IntoTheheart wrote:On July 14 2015 03:50 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:48 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote: [quote] i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method". You missed an important post of mine, I think. Your argument started with On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote: Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"
I think we either have very different ideas of what the Socratic Method is or what history is. If that is the basis for your argument, then I think you have a poor understanding of history at its core. History is derived from interpretations of documents and writings from the era, all which as subjective in nature because of the author. The discussion of "why do you think the GDP of Italy was BLANK" is a completely valid question and discussion. History is not objective fact or a science. Its why I have a Bachelors of Arts, not Science. i was with you until your last sentence... dats a false dichotomy... the undergrad school i went to literally only offers b.a.,s including in the hard sciences (the one exception was engineering) It depends on the school. My school has a faculty of arts AND sciences, but you either get a BA, or a BSC on your diploma when you graduate. my point had less to do with what schools actually offer and more with the abstract idea there's no clean division between the concept of art and science with respect to academic disciplines Also the first thing you learn when majoring in history is that there are no objective facts. Only accepted interpenetration. It is one of the root flaws in most arguments involving history. But yes, stating my degree an Art degree does not add any gravity to my argument. Which is entirely wrong. There are objective facts in any discipline, but they are by definition meaningless (because meaning is a subjective construction). So you found a rock that seems to have writing on it. Good for you, nobody can contest that the rock exists, but there's no historical relevance until you project meaning onto it.
History is not a rock. It is a study of documents and writings from a different time. Believing their are facts is flawed study because you have not ability to verify the statements of the author. The Declaration of Independence was sign on July 4th because it is dated on July 4th and all accounts state it was signed on July 4th. We cannot confirm that to be 100% true, but it likely is.
Without at time machine, there are no objective facts in history.
|
On July 14 2015 04:02 Plansix wrote:Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:49 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:48 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:43 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote: [quote] Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there. yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own and he'd be wrong in that disagreement your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them. At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas. i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies. I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method". You missed an important post of mine, I think. Your argument started with On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote: Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"
I think we either have very different ideas of what the Socratic Method is or what history is. If that is the basis for your argument, then I think you have a poor understanding of history at its core. History is derived from interpretations of documents and writings from the era, all which as subjective in nature because of the author. The discussion of "why do you think the GDP of Italy was BLANK" is a completely valid question and discussion. History is not objective fact or a science. Its why I have a Bachelors of Arts, not Science. I believe you missed the post directly after that. It's a big post. You mean this one: Show nested quote +On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 03:12 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 03:03 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 02:44 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 02:41 Acritter wrote:On July 14 2015 02:37 Plansix wrote:On July 14 2015 02:34 andyrau wrote: [quote] well it happened all the time in uni too; either nobody knew the answer or everyone already had a good answer in their heads I found professors that frequently broke us off into arbitrary group discussions were slow paced and somewhat ambivalent in direction, regardless of subject.
ime instructors that engaged in some form of socratic instruction had better structure and were more effective at fostering critical thinking but i guess everyone has their own way of teaching & learning You have hit the nail on the head. I'm with you on Socratic teaching and it being the best way for me to learn. But its worthless for someone like my brother who would rather be hands on or interacting with anything. On July 14 2015 02:34 IntoTheheart wrote: [quote] What happened next? Did you guys say "fuck that" and play without him?
Plan6, I'd rather know that that person's gonna be gone so that I can do other shit in the meantime. Agreed. I can make myself a cup of coffee if I 100% knew the game was going to paused that entire time. If you're a hands-on learner, shouldn't you be studying practical subjects instead of abstract subjects? In a perfect world, yes. But hands on learners need to know about history, math and other abstractions. Even by brother, who pull engines out of military vehicles needs to know how to make spread sheets. Or how property rights and mortgages work. History obviously doesn't work in the Socratic format (rather, it works best when delivered as a narrative) and a lot of day-to-day math can be taught as a ritual pragmatic skill analogous to operating the interface of some machine or other. Your brother probably doesn't need to know how a computer works in order to use it, so why does he need to know how a spreadsheet works if he can perform the ritual operations on it neatly? Similarly, property rights and mortgages are basically just technical dos and don'ts. If you know you have to give someone receipts X, Y, and Z after working on their engine or get in trouble with the state, you can certainly figure out that you need to have deeds X, Y, and Z after purchasing property. It's probably not worth it to try and figure out alternate teaching methods intended for advanced math and other similar fields of study if the people they're directed for are likely uninterested and almost certainly won't benefit from them. I studied history in college and loved the Socratic format. It has always been the best way for me to learn anything. I will listen to a history book over reading it. You're prescribing teaching methods for the advancement of a specific field, which is not the topic at hand. This is about teaching the populous though a variety of methods so they can navigate the modern world. And my brother does need a computer to do his job. He manages the parts inventory for the base and and needs to create spread sheets and interface with other computer software. He is required to be well rounded and have a variety of skills, including leadership and communication since he is also a Master Sergeant. And property ownership is not that simple and its not a just list of does and don't. And anyone teaching people that property rights and mortgages are that should stop right away, since that is a sure fire way to face litigation. Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?" are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts? no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close. This statement in your argument is incorrect. There are no facts in the study of history, accepted interpenetration. We cannot objective observe historical events as we were not there. I've addressed twice why this is completely wrong.
|
you guys seem to be unaware of the fact that if ur quote train reaches the "TL automatically redacts part of ur quote train" level then ur argument has gone to shit and should be dropped
|
Acritter: Yes, but you argument is shit. History is not a rock because you don't' have a time machine. You can't contest the existence a document exist, but the veracity of what is on it is always in question.
|
|
|
|
|
|