• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 02:39
CET 08:39
KST 16:39
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #2312[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over5Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Team Liquid Map Contest #23 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Dark completes military service, returns to SC2
Tourneys
soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
Light introduces ShieldBattery on his YouTube List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ NaDa's Body
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4 [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL23] Ro16 Group D - Sunday 21:00 CET
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread The PlayStation 5 Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Nintendo Switch Thread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread The Big Programming Thread Trading/Investing Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 17665 users

Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion - Page 2609

Forum Index > Dota 2 General
Post a Reply
Prev 1 2607 2608 2609 2610 2611 10602 Next
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
July 13 2015 18:27 GMT
#52161
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:12 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:03 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:44 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:41 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:37 Plansix wrote:
[quote]
You have hit the nail on the head. I'm with you on Socratic teaching and it being the best way for me to learn. But its worthless for someone like my brother who would rather be hands on or interacting with anything.

[quote]

Agreed. I can make myself a cup of coffee if I 100% knew the game was going to paused that entire time.

If you're a hands-on learner, shouldn't you be studying practical subjects instead of abstract subjects?

In a perfect world, yes. But hands on learners need to know about history, math and other abstractions. Even by brother, who pull engines out of military vehicles needs to know how to make spread sheets. Or how property rights and mortgages work.

History obviously doesn't work in the Socratic format (rather, it works best when delivered as a narrative) and a lot of day-to-day math can be taught as a ritual pragmatic skill analogous to operating the interface of some machine or other. Your brother probably doesn't need to know how a computer works in order to use it, so why does he need to know how a spreadsheet works if he can perform the ritual operations on it neatly? Similarly, property rights and mortgages are basically just technical dos and don'ts. If you know you have to give someone receipts X, Y, and Z after working on their engine or get in trouble with the state, you can certainly figure out that you need to have deeds X, Y, and Z after purchasing property. It's probably not worth it to try and figure out alternate teaching methods intended for advanced math and other similar fields of study if the people they're directed for are likely uninterested and almost certainly won't benefit from them.

I studied history in college and loved the Socratic format. It has always been the best way for me to learn anything. I will listen to a history book over reading it. You're prescribing teaching methods for the advancement of a specific field, which is not the topic at hand. This is about teaching the populous though a variety of methods so they can navigate the modern world.

And my brother does need a computer to do his job. He manages the parts inventory for the base and and needs to create spread sheets and interface with other computer software. He is required to be well rounded and have a variety of skills, including leadership and communication since he is also a Master Sergeant. And property ownership is not that simple and its not a just list of does and don't. And anyone teaching people that property rights and mortgages are that should stop right away, since that is a sure fire way to face litigation.

Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"

are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts?

no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption

No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Unleashing
Profile Joined March 2011
Denmark14978 Posts
July 13 2015 18:27 GMT
#52162
On July 14 2015 03:15 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:10 goody153 wrote:
u guys don't have the heart of a true techies picker

(yeah he's not super fun fun like he's fun once in every long while)

Even reddit said that the mines giving so much vision would be OP and shockingly it was. I'm never even scared of the mines themselves. It the spirit breaker that gets picked every time I see a techies.

The mines still suck. Slows down the game and makes everything dull.

Would be OP? What exactly do you mean? I mean the way you're writing about it makes it sound like it was a recent buff that people talked about. The last patch that touched the mine area of vision(6.82) reduced it, it didn't increase it.
From the Ghastly Eyrie I can see to the ends of the world, and from this vantage point I declare with utter certainty that this one is in the bag!
Acritter
Profile Joined August 2010
Syria7637 Posts
July 13 2015 18:28 GMT
#52163
On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:12 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:03 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:44 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:41 Acritter wrote:
[quote]
If you're a hands-on learner, shouldn't you be studying practical subjects instead of abstract subjects?

In a perfect world, yes. But hands on learners need to know about history, math and other abstractions. Even by brother, who pull engines out of military vehicles needs to know how to make spread sheets. Or how property rights and mortgages work.

History obviously doesn't work in the Socratic format (rather, it works best when delivered as a narrative) and a lot of day-to-day math can be taught as a ritual pragmatic skill analogous to operating the interface of some machine or other. Your brother probably doesn't need to know how a computer works in order to use it, so why does he need to know how a spreadsheet works if he can perform the ritual operations on it neatly? Similarly, property rights and mortgages are basically just technical dos and don'ts. If you know you have to give someone receipts X, Y, and Z after working on their engine or get in trouble with the state, you can certainly figure out that you need to have deeds X, Y, and Z after purchasing property. It's probably not worth it to try and figure out alternate teaching methods intended for advanced math and other similar fields of study if the people they're directed for are likely uninterested and almost certainly won't benefit from them.

I studied history in college and loved the Socratic format. It has always been the best way for me to learn anything. I will listen to a history book over reading it. You're prescribing teaching methods for the advancement of a specific field, which is not the topic at hand. This is about teaching the populous though a variety of methods so they can navigate the modern world.

And my brother does need a computer to do his job. He manages the parts inventory for the base and and needs to create spread sheets and interface with other computer software. He is required to be well rounded and have a variety of skills, including leadership and communication since he is also a Master Sergeant. And property ownership is not that simple and its not a just list of does and don't. And anyone teaching people that property rights and mortgages are that should stop right away, since that is a sure fire way to face litigation.

Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"

are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts?

no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption

No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.

Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there.
dont let your memes be dreams - konydora, motivational speaker | not actually living in syria
BluemoonSC
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
SoCal8933 Posts
July 13 2015 18:28 GMT
#52164
On July 14 2015 03:19 Sn0_Man wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:13 BluemoonSC wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:09 Sn0_Man wrote:
I picked techies cuz it was a challenge once what a mistake lol
that hero is way dumb


well you played him so i know you're not referring to how he can extend games you've had in the bag

but what do you mean he's dumb? like as in he's really good/annoying if played right? or boring?

boring, op, game-extending, etc
you can't go high ground vs him, you can't clear his mines once he gets aghs, you literally should never have a creep wave in 2/3 lanes vs a semi-decent techies, you can't actually kill him cuz lolsuicide, you die a lot randomly with limited recourse thats entirely dependant on ur hero basically so if u picked wrong ur fucked, u can't really ignore him cuz mines do 89072 dmg to towers, he has 7 base armor and 700 range hahaxd everything about that hero is just stupid
and its not even like he's an interesting concept, like rtz said you ahve to have brain damage to play the hero too wow isn't it fun throwing mines everywhere and blowing urself up like this isn't afghanistan or w/e.


ya but your complaining is why techies players exist. they love to make people miserable and just generally be assholes.
LiquidDota Staff@BluemoonGG_
teddyoojo
Profile Blog Joined June 2011
Germany22369 Posts
July 13 2015 18:28 GMT
#52165
ive been flaming techies players in allchat ever since they got released questioning their mental abilities and such

everyones just copying me as usual
Esports historian since 2000. Creator of 'The Universe' and 'The best scrambled Eggs 2013'. Host of 'Star Wars Marathon 2015'. Thinker of 'teddyoojo's Thoughts'. Earths and Moons leading CS:GO expert. Lord of the Rings.
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
July 13 2015 18:29 GMT
#52166
On July 14 2015 03:27 Unleashing wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:15 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:10 goody153 wrote:
u guys don't have the heart of a true techies picker

(yeah he's not super fun fun like he's fun once in every long while)

Even reddit said that the mines giving so much vision would be OP and shockingly it was. I'm never even scared of the mines themselves. It the spirit breaker that gets picked every time I see a techies.

The mines still suck. Slows down the game and makes everything dull.

Would be OP? What exactly do you mean? I mean the way you're writing about it makes it sound like it was a recent buff that people talked about. The last patch that touched the mine area of vision(6.82) reduced it, it didn't increase it.

I think the basis of the argument that any vision on the Q mines since the player didn't interact with them.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
SpiritoftheTunA
Profile Blog Joined August 2006
United States20903 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-07-13 18:31:10
July 13 2015 18:30 GMT
#52167
On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:12 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:03 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:44 Plansix wrote:
[quote]
In a perfect world, yes. But hands on learners need to know about history, math and other abstractions. Even by brother, who pull engines out of military vehicles needs to know how to make spread sheets. Or how property rights and mortgages work.

History obviously doesn't work in the Socratic format (rather, it works best when delivered as a narrative) and a lot of day-to-day math can be taught as a ritual pragmatic skill analogous to operating the interface of some machine or other. Your brother probably doesn't need to know how a computer works in order to use it, so why does he need to know how a spreadsheet works if he can perform the ritual operations on it neatly? Similarly, property rights and mortgages are basically just technical dos and don'ts. If you know you have to give someone receipts X, Y, and Z after working on their engine or get in trouble with the state, you can certainly figure out that you need to have deeds X, Y, and Z after purchasing property. It's probably not worth it to try and figure out alternate teaching methods intended for advanced math and other similar fields of study if the people they're directed for are likely uninterested and almost certainly won't benefit from them.

I studied history in college and loved the Socratic format. It has always been the best way for me to learn anything. I will listen to a history book over reading it. You're prescribing teaching methods for the advancement of a specific field, which is not the topic at hand. This is about teaching the populous though a variety of methods so they can navigate the modern world.

And my brother does need a computer to do his job. He manages the parts inventory for the base and and needs to create spread sheets and interface with other computer software. He is required to be well rounded and have a variety of skills, including leadership and communication since he is also a Master Sergeant. And property ownership is not that simple and its not a just list of does and don't. And anyone teaching people that property rights and mortgages are that should stop right away, since that is a sure fire way to face litigation.

Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"

are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts?

no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption

No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.

Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there.

yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own

and he'd be wrong in that disagreement

your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something
posting on liquid sites in current year
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
July 13 2015 18:32 GMT
#52168
On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:12 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:03 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:44 Plansix wrote:
[quote]
In a perfect world, yes. But hands on learners need to know about history, math and other abstractions. Even by brother, who pull engines out of military vehicles needs to know how to make spread sheets. Or how property rights and mortgages work.

History obviously doesn't work in the Socratic format (rather, it works best when delivered as a narrative) and a lot of day-to-day math can be taught as a ritual pragmatic skill analogous to operating the interface of some machine or other. Your brother probably doesn't need to know how a computer works in order to use it, so why does he need to know how a spreadsheet works if he can perform the ritual operations on it neatly? Similarly, property rights and mortgages are basically just technical dos and don'ts. If you know you have to give someone receipts X, Y, and Z after working on their engine or get in trouble with the state, you can certainly figure out that you need to have deeds X, Y, and Z after purchasing property. It's probably not worth it to try and figure out alternate teaching methods intended for advanced math and other similar fields of study if the people they're directed for are likely uninterested and almost certainly won't benefit from them.

I studied history in college and loved the Socratic format. It has always been the best way for me to learn anything. I will listen to a history book over reading it. You're prescribing teaching methods for the advancement of a specific field, which is not the topic at hand. This is about teaching the populous though a variety of methods so they can navigate the modern world.

And my brother does need a computer to do his job. He manages the parts inventory for the base and and needs to create spread sheets and interface with other computer software. He is required to be well rounded and have a variety of skills, including leadership and communication since he is also a Master Sergeant. And property ownership is not that simple and its not a just list of does and don't. And anyone teaching people that property rights and mortgages are that should stop right away, since that is a sure fire way to face litigation.

Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"

are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts?

no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption

No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.

Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there.

Yeah, that doesn't make what he said objective truth. Other people just as smart and just as dead as him defined language differently. The world is a bigger place than when Socrates was alive and we have expanded the use of language. It doesn't mean we don't use his teaching techniques in education.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
teddyoojo
Profile Blog Joined June 2011
Germany22369 Posts
July 13 2015 18:32 GMT
#52169
ur all dumb
Esports historian since 2000. Creator of 'The Universe' and 'The best scrambled Eggs 2013'. Host of 'Star Wars Marathon 2015'. Thinker of 'teddyoojo's Thoughts'. Earths and Moons leading CS:GO expert. Lord of the Rings.
Howie_Dewitt
Profile Joined March 2014
United States1416 Posts
July 13 2015 18:33 GMT
#52170
On July 14 2015 03:32 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:12 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:03 Acritter wrote:
[quote]
History obviously doesn't work in the Socratic format (rather, it works best when delivered as a narrative) and a lot of day-to-day math can be taught as a ritual pragmatic skill analogous to operating the interface of some machine or other. Your brother probably doesn't need to know how a computer works in order to use it, so why does he need to know how a spreadsheet works if he can perform the ritual operations on it neatly? Similarly, property rights and mortgages are basically just technical dos and don'ts. If you know you have to give someone receipts X, Y, and Z after working on their engine or get in trouble with the state, you can certainly figure out that you need to have deeds X, Y, and Z after purchasing property. It's probably not worth it to try and figure out alternate teaching methods intended for advanced math and other similar fields of study if the people they're directed for are likely uninterested and almost certainly won't benefit from them.

I studied history in college and loved the Socratic format. It has always been the best way for me to learn anything. I will listen to a history book over reading it. You're prescribing teaching methods for the advancement of a specific field, which is not the topic at hand. This is about teaching the populous though a variety of methods so they can navigate the modern world.

And my brother does need a computer to do his job. He manages the parts inventory for the base and and needs to create spread sheets and interface with other computer software. He is required to be well rounded and have a variety of skills, including leadership and communication since he is also a Master Sergeant. And property ownership is not that simple and its not a just list of does and don't. And anyone teaching people that property rights and mortgages are that should stop right away, since that is a sure fire way to face litigation.

Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"

are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts?

no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption

No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.

Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there.

just as dead

Wut
Sisyphus had a good gig going, the disappointment was predictable. | Visions of the Country (1978) is for when you're lost.
Acritter
Profile Joined August 2010
Syria7637 Posts
July 13 2015 18:34 GMT
#52171
On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:12 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:03 Acritter wrote:
[quote]
History obviously doesn't work in the Socratic format (rather, it works best when delivered as a narrative) and a lot of day-to-day math can be taught as a ritual pragmatic skill analogous to operating the interface of some machine or other. Your brother probably doesn't need to know how a computer works in order to use it, so why does he need to know how a spreadsheet works if he can perform the ritual operations on it neatly? Similarly, property rights and mortgages are basically just technical dos and don'ts. If you know you have to give someone receipts X, Y, and Z after working on their engine or get in trouble with the state, you can certainly figure out that you need to have deeds X, Y, and Z after purchasing property. It's probably not worth it to try and figure out alternate teaching methods intended for advanced math and other similar fields of study if the people they're directed for are likely uninterested and almost certainly won't benefit from them.

I studied history in college and loved the Socratic format. It has always been the best way for me to learn anything. I will listen to a history book over reading it. You're prescribing teaching methods for the advancement of a specific field, which is not the topic at hand. This is about teaching the populous though a variety of methods so they can navigate the modern world.

And my brother does need a computer to do his job. He manages the parts inventory for the base and and needs to create spread sheets and interface with other computer software. He is required to be well rounded and have a variety of skills, including leadership and communication since he is also a Master Sergeant. And property ownership is not that simple and its not a just list of does and don't. And anyone teaching people that property rights and mortgages are that should stop right away, since that is a sure fire way to face litigation.

Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"

are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts?

no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption

No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.

Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there.

yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own

and he'd be wrong in that disagreement

your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something

Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them.

At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas.
dont let your memes be dreams - konydora, motivational speaker | not actually living in syria
Unleashing
Profile Joined March 2011
Denmark14978 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-07-13 18:35:02
July 13 2015 18:34 GMT
#52172
On July 14 2015 03:29 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:27 Unleashing wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:15 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:10 goody153 wrote:
u guys don't have the heart of a true techies picker

(yeah he's not super fun fun like he's fun once in every long while)

Even reddit said that the mines giving so much vision would be OP and shockingly it was. I'm never even scared of the mines themselves. It the spirit breaker that gets picked every time I see a techies.

The mines still suck. Slows down the game and makes everything dull.

Would be OP? What exactly do you mean? I mean the way you're writing about it makes it sound like it was a recent buff that people talked about. The last patch that touched the mine area of vision(6.82) reduced it, it didn't increase it.

I think the basis of the argument that any vision on the Q mines since the player didn't interact with them.

Those mines have a 64 range vision, which is less than their 200 trigger range. Hardly relevant vision.
If you can see anything inside that range then it's gonna already have triggered your mine.
From the Ghastly Eyrie I can see to the ends of the world, and from this vantage point I declare with utter certainty that this one is in the bag!
SpiritoftheTunA
Profile Blog Joined August 2006
United States20903 Posts
July 13 2015 18:35 GMT
#52173
On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:12 Plansix wrote:
[quote]
I studied history in college and loved the Socratic format. It has always been the best way for me to learn anything. I will listen to a history book over reading it. You're prescribing teaching methods for the advancement of a specific field, which is not the topic at hand. This is about teaching the populous though a variety of methods so they can navigate the modern world.

And my brother does need a computer to do his job. He manages the parts inventory for the base and and needs to create spread sheets and interface with other computer software. He is required to be well rounded and have a variety of skills, including leadership and communication since he is also a Master Sergeant. And property ownership is not that simple and its not a just list of does and don't. And anyone teaching people that property rights and mortgages are that should stop right away, since that is a sure fire way to face litigation.

Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"

are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts?

no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption

No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.

Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there.

yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own

and he'd be wrong in that disagreement

your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something

Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them.

At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas.

i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project
posting on liquid sites in current year
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
July 13 2015 18:37 GMT
#52174
On July 14 2015 03:33 Howie_Dewitt wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:32 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:12 Plansix wrote:
[quote]
I studied history in college and loved the Socratic format. It has always been the best way for me to learn anything. I will listen to a history book over reading it. You're prescribing teaching methods for the advancement of a specific field, which is not the topic at hand. This is about teaching the populous though a variety of methods so they can navigate the modern world.

And my brother does need a computer to do his job. He manages the parts inventory for the base and and needs to create spread sheets and interface with other computer software. He is required to be well rounded and have a variety of skills, including leadership and communication since he is also a Master Sergeant. And property ownership is not that simple and its not a just list of does and don't. And anyone teaching people that property rights and mortgages are that should stop right away, since that is a sure fire way to face litigation.

Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"

are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts?

no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption

No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.

Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there.

just as dead

Wut

The point is that Socrates lived and died in a different time. Then other people took his teachings and expanding on them and also died. Knowledge is cumulative and we build on previous teaching. Socrates is impressive in his time and for his forward thinking, but it doesn't make him magic or an authority on anything relative to today.
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Acritter
Profile Joined August 2010
Syria7637 Posts
July 13 2015 18:39 GMT
#52175
On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote:
[quote]
Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"

are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts?

no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption

No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.

Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there.

yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own

and he'd be wrong in that disagreement

your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something

Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them.

At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas.

i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project

Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies.
dont let your memes be dreams - konydora, motivational speaker | not actually living in syria
andyrau
Profile Joined December 2010
13015 Posts
July 13 2015 18:39 GMT
#52176
On July 14 2015 03:16 Acritter wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:12 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:03 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:44 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:41 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:37 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:34 andyrau wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:03 BluemoonSC wrote:
On July 14 2015 01:44 andyrau wrote:
everyone in my school hated the "see if they can figure it out by talking with their classmates" thing

everyone already knew the answer or nobody knew it and either way talking it out with other people wasn't going to change anything


then you weren't challenged enough with the level of questioning. the cavalierri's principle debate is one of my favorites because the answer isn't so obvious if i say that i have a rectangular and a triangular prism..or like a weird shaped prism that isnt an n-gon

well it happened all the time in uni too; either nobody knew the answer or everyone already had a good answer in their heads
I found professors that frequently broke us off into arbitrary group discussions were slow paced and somewhat ambivalent in direction, regardless of subject.

ime instructors that engaged in some form of socratic instruction had better structure and were more effective at fostering critical thinking but i guess everyone has their own way of teaching & learning

You have hit the nail on the head. I'm with you on Socratic teaching and it being the best way for me to learn. But its worthless for someone like my brother who would rather be hands on or interacting with anything.

On July 14 2015 02:34 IntoTheheart wrote:
On July 14 2015 02:31 dismiss wrote:
Slardar in our game:"sry I afk 10 min"

They want us to wait.

What a guy.

What happened next? Did you guys say "fuck that" and play without him?

Plan6, I'd rather know that that person's gonna be gone so that I can do other shit in the meantime.


Agreed. I can make myself a cup of coffee if I 100% knew the game was going to paused that entire time.

If you're a hands-on learner, shouldn't you be studying practical subjects instead of abstract subjects?

In a perfect world, yes. But hands on learners need to know about history, math and other abstractions. Even by brother, who pull engines out of military vehicles needs to know how to make spread sheets. Or how property rights and mortgages work.

History obviously doesn't work in the Socratic format (rather, it works best when delivered as a narrative) and a lot of day-to-day math can be taught as a ritual pragmatic skill analogous to operating the interface of some machine or other. Your brother probably doesn't need to know how a computer works in order to use it, so why does he need to know how a spreadsheet works if he can perform the ritual operations on it neatly? Similarly, property rights and mortgages are basically just technical dos and don'ts. If you know you have to give someone receipts X, Y, and Z after working on their engine or get in trouble with the state, you can certainly figure out that you need to have deeds X, Y, and Z after purchasing property. It's probably not worth it to try and figure out alternate teaching methods intended for advanced math and other similar fields of study if the people they're directed for are likely uninterested and almost certainly won't benefit from them.

I studied history in college and loved the Socratic format. It has always been the best way for me to learn anything. I will listen to a history book over reading it. You're prescribing teaching methods for the advancement of a specific field, which is not the topic at hand. This is about teaching the populous though a variety of methods so they can navigate the modern world.

And my brother does need a computer to do his job. He manages the parts inventory for the base and and needs to create spread sheets and interface with other computer software. He is required to be well rounded and have a variety of skills, including leadership and communication since he is also a Master Sergeant. And property ownership is not that simple and its not a just list of does and don't. And anyone teaching people that property rights and mortgages are that should stop right away, since that is a sure fire way to face litigation.

Wait, what? Are you saying that you had your history professors come up to you and ask "Now, what do you think the mean GDP growth of Italy was between 1850 and 1900?"

I think we either have very different ideas of what the Socratic Method is or what history is.

history can be taught both ways I think. narration is best for getting out the information, but the subject isn't just memorization and regurgitation of facts. implications of past events are far reaching and there's a large spectrum of interpretations that can be challenged and explored; imo this is where questioning and discussion can help students learn a lot.
I didn't study law so that's out of my depth but
I'd imagine that law is a lot of memorization but there are a myriad of ways a case can be presented, so interpretation and questioning is a large part of education. why else would judges have writeups explaining their interpretations of the law and how justice is distributed?
"Zai is legitimately not as good as bulba." | kaipi ti3 champions
SpiritoftheTunA
Profile Blog Joined August 2006
United States20903 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-07-13 18:44:16
July 13 2015 18:41 GMT
#52177
On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
[quote]
are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts?

no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption

No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.

Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there.

yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own

and he'd be wrong in that disagreement

your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something

Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them.

At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas.

i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project

Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies.

can you point out where it was used with that second sense in this discussion aside from your inference of what i meant when i applied the label not-positive to socrates

anyway my whole point is if you're going to criticize the idea of teaching history using the socratic method you shouldn't distort the argument by starting out with the assumption that everyone will use your idea of what 'socratic method' should mean. even if you disagree with the popular definition, you should go along with it because that's not the focal point of the argument in the first place
posting on liquid sites in current year
Acritter
Profile Joined August 2010
Syria7637 Posts
July 13 2015 18:42 GMT
#52178
On July 14 2015 03:41 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
[quote]
No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.

Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there.

yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own

and he'd be wrong in that disagreement

your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something

Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them.

At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas.

i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project

Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies.

can you point out where it was used with that second sense in this discussion aside from your inference of what i meant when i applied the label not-positive to socrates

Then I have to ask how it's possibly a bad thing to explain why people are full of shit.
dont let your memes be dreams - konydora, motivational speaker | not actually living in syria
Plansix
Profile Blog Joined April 2011
United States60190 Posts
July 13 2015 18:43 GMT
#52179
On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:18 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
[quote]
are you implying all there is to learning history is to learn the "objective" facts?

no critical thinking or discussion could possibly be involved? are you really talking from that assumption

No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.

Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there.

yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own

and he'd be wrong in that disagreement

your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something

Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them.

At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas.

i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project

Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies.

I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method".
I have the Honor to be your Obedient Servant, P.6
TL+ Member
Acritter
Profile Joined August 2010
Syria7637 Posts
July 13 2015 18:43 GMT
#52180
On July 14 2015 03:43 Plansix wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 14 2015 03:39 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:35 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:34 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:30 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:28 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:27 Plansix wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:24 Acritter wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:22 SpiritoftheTunA wrote:
On July 14 2015 03:20 Acritter wrote:
[quote]
No, but the Socratic Method is about teaching specific truths via questioning. It's about using questions to lead to specific answers. Read any of the Dialogues, and you'll find that they're always about Socrates trying to drag people along to things he's already fairly certain about with questions. He's not genuinely probing to see what they think or to try and get them to create their own opinion. The specific answers in history are facts, which it is ridiculous to do anything but outright tell people about. The questioning is not about leading people to answers, which means that it is not the Socratic Method. Not even close.

yea i'm not buying into this "the meaning of 'Socratic Method' has to derive exactly from what he did in his dialogues" logic

thats just like originalist semantic bullshit u scalia u

When it's something named after what someone actually did, it makes sense to have the definition be what that person did.

Are you going to say that it's reasonable to call any Protoss FFE the Bisu Build?

Yeah, that may be how you view the Socratic Method, but that's not really how the teaching style is referred to in education. And the view of words and how they are should be used is by nature subjective.

Ironically, or perhaps appropriately, I think Socrates would very much disagree with your last sentence there.

yea but socrates is a pure rationality bully idiot with little positive ideas of his own

and he'd be wrong in that disagreement

your whole "argument from popularity" thing misses the point that i'm just describing how it's used, not positing what it means in some objective fregean 3rd realm or something

Well, I'll admit I don't fully agree with Socrates on that point. I really wouldn't call him an idiot, though. He's many things, but stupid is not one of them.

At the same time, by only describing how something is used, you end up doing the same thing as you criticize Socrates for doing: stating facts without providing positive ideas.

i don't consider trying to get people to conform to my idea of how language should be used by bringing up disagreements on an internet forum a particularly positive project

Man, now you're equivocating by switching between "positive" as "good" and "positive" as "assertion of existence as opposed to nonexistence." Come on, argue without fallacies.

I am still looking for exactly what your argument is. Because its mostly seems like "I don't agree with the use of Socratic method for teaching subjects I assume can't be taught with the Socratic method".

You missed an important post of mine, I think.
dont let your memes be dreams - konydora, motivational speaker | not actually living in syria
Prev 1 2607 2608 2609 2610 2611 10602 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 2h 21m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
ProTech143
StarCraft: Brood War
Zeus 129
Jaedong 88
Larva 78
Shine 40
ToSsGirL 22
Leta 17
ajuk12(nOOB) 13
Force[name] 6
Other Games
summit1g9179
Coldzera 737
JimRising 401
WinterStarcraft397
Happy273
Mew2King83
Trikslyr19
[ Show 12 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• iopq 2
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota2405
League of Legends
• Rush1079
• Lourlo681
Upcoming Events
KCM Race Survival
2h 21m
Ultimate Battle
4h 21m
ZerO vs Bisu
Big Brain Bouts
9h 21m
FoxeR vs Bly
LetaleX vs MilkiCow
Reynor vs Lambo
RSL Revival
1d 3h
AI Arena Tournament
1d 9h
BSL
1d 12h
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
2 days
IPSL
2 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
2 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
2 days
[ Show More ]
WardiTV Weekly
3 days
Kung Fu Cup
4 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
4 days
The PondCast
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.