EPTPoll: Agree?
(Vote): 1
(Vote): 2
(Vote): 3
(Vote): 4
(Vote): 5
Thumbs up / Thumbs down is better than 1-5 stars
| Blogs > SpiritoftheTuna |
|
SpiritoftheTunA
United States20903 Posts
Poll: Agree? (Vote): 1 (Vote): 2 (Vote): 3 (Vote): 4 (Vote): 5 | ||
|
Nitrogen
United States5345 Posts
| ||
|
H
New Zealand6138 Posts
| ||
|
FragKrag
United States11565 Posts
| ||
|
Raithed
China7078 Posts
On July 15 2008 15:15 H_ wrote: I like the idea of having 0 stars. Giving a blog one star means "There is some merit to this blog". Giving it 0 stars means "This shit is terrible". id rather have 0 stars than 1 stars tbh. i mean, i dont want people giving me ratings on shit that i think has merit/value. | ||
|
evanthebouncy!
United States12796 Posts
Obviously 1 2 3 4 5 gives you a range of flexibilities that up/down simply won't cut it. Some people take long time to make their blogs and I'm sure they want it rated carefully. | ||
|
geometryb
United States1249 Posts
| ||
micronesia
United States24775 Posts
On July 15 2008 15:15 Nitrogen23 wrote: wat If I see this exact post in another thread, I'm going to demand for auto-ban to be implemented for posting 'wat' exclusively. | ||
|
paper
13196 Posts
On July 15 2008 15:24 evanthebouncy! wrote: Yeah and tests should be graded on either 100 or 0. Obviously 1 2 3 4 5 gives you a range of flexibilities that up/down simply won't cut it. Some people take long time to make their blogs and I'm sure they want it rated carefully. people have different rating systems. that's why the thumbs up/down system shines here. isn't rottentomatoes a thumbs up/down system, too? | ||
|
Nitrogen
United States5345 Posts
On July 15 2008 16:17 micronesia wrote: If I see this exact post in another thread, I'm going to demand for auto-ban to be implemented for posting 'wat' exclusively. I had no idea what was going on. I'll start saying "wut" though, just for you. | ||
|
BottleAbuser
Korea (South)1888 Posts
| ||
|
useLess
United States4781 Posts
| ||
|
XtaC_hiryu
Philippines125 Posts
EDIT :D | ||
|
QuanticHawk
United States32139 Posts
| ||
|
Goosey
United States695 Posts
It also has the advantage of allowing an unpopular, yet high quality, post to reach the '5 star' status. In a thumbs-up thumbs-down system fewer stories tend to rise to the top due to the phenom I call (no idea if there is a real term for this) 'popularity snowball'. A good post gets a few thumbs up. This shoves it to the top for others to thumb it up. Since it is good it will receive mainly thumbs up and continue to rise. The bad thing is perhaps there are 10 other quality posts that aren't even getting looked at because too much attention is going to the 'stars' of the show. Thumbs Up is roughly the equivilant of: (numberOfViews)*(AverageStar >= 3) Of course this reply puts the assumption that along with thumbs up comes some way to filter/sort by rating, which the blog section badly needs anyway IMHO. Without filter/sorting or at least showing the rating before opening the blog none of these rating systems really matter except for the self-gratification of the author (which I admit, I do feel better about making 5star posts than 1star posts.. This is a good thing since it just makes me put more effort into delivering quality rather than trash). | ||
|
KOFgokuon
United States14911 Posts
| ||
|
GeneralStan
United States4789 Posts
On July 15 2008 15:15 H_ wrote: I like the idea of having 0 stars. Giving a blog one star means "There is some merit to this blog". Giving it 0 stars means "This shit is terrible". I disagree. 0 Stars isn't a real rating, it's just an indication that you haven't yet rated, or odn't plan to. 0 stars is indifference, where as 1 satar is something that's bad enough that you care enough to give it the lowest possible rating you can. | ||
|
MiniRoman
Canada3953 Posts
WHAT ABOUT HALF AND HALF? | ||
|
Yogurt
United States4258 Posts
On July 16 2008 01:58 MiniRoman wrote: How about we give between 1-5 thumbs up or thumbs down! WHAT ABOUT HALF AND HALF? NO ONE HAS THAT MANY THUMBS THIS IS LUDACRACY | ||
|
SK.Testie
Canada11084 Posts
I don't want to stay in a hotel that has, "2 big thumbs way up." | ||
|
SonuvBob
Aiur21550 Posts
On July 16 2008 00:30 Goosey wrote: Of course this reply puts the assumption that along with thumbs up comes some way to filter/sort by rating, which the blog section badly needs anyway IMHO. Without filter/sorting or at least showing the rating before opening the blog none of these rating systems really matter except for the self-gratification of the author (which I admit, I do feel better about making 5star posts than 1star posts.. This is a good thing since it just makes me put more effort into delivering quality rather than trash). http://www.teamliquid.net/blogs/ Nothing per-post yet though. =/ | ||
|
Wizard
Poland5055 Posts
| ||
| ||
